Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of AMA high earner threads where the poster is not actually the high earner?

107 replies

Evilcountspatula · 21/03/2024 22:48

Please can we hear from a female (single, married, with kids, whatever) who earns enormous sums rather than someone who has married a rich husband. No jealousy, I’d have loved to have married a rich husband myself, but genuinely interested to have a thread from a woman at the top of the money earning tree. Is that too much to ask?
edited for typos

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pippa246 · 22/03/2024 21:51

pinkdelight · 21/03/2024 23:41

I avoid the whole AMA topic like the plague. Just the titles make it sound like the most self-absorbed wankerdom. Obviously many topics are self-absorbed but to actually think "I'm so fascinating I'll start a thread saying Ask About Meeee!" Is too much. And when it's "Ask Meeee About How Rich I Am", eeesh. End times!

self-absorbed wankerdom.

This is my new bestest phrase ever!

And @pinkdelight - 💯 agree - I steer well clear of these posts

GRex · 22/03/2024 21:43

Evilcountspatula · 21/03/2024 23:24

Not career moves, I’m more interested in the juggling act that so many women sadly still end up doing no matter what their earning potential. It’s frequently the default that “it makes no sense” for a woman to go back to work/ work full time post kids because their partner is the higher earner. I’m particularly interested in hearing from women who have pushed past that mindset, got to the top of their game, and reaped the financial rewards.

The difficult thing is wanting to be with your child. I took an unusual route in being self-employed, so I reduce hours and do fewer in holidays, because I want to see DS. Not exactly only possible because DH does 95% drop-offs, any short notice pick-up and evening when I'm suddenly needed in the office - and lower earning accordingly. Not exactly only possible because at school now his breakfast club and after school club options are pretty good. Actually, I would say it is only possible because my hourly rate is enough to mean we can take each hit. I have a couple of colleague friends who have done similar, it is just switching DH for DW in someone giving up a bit. There are some others who did nannies for a few years but got annoyed by it and wanted to be back with their kids more so went part time. Any option at all is a compromise somewhere really with little ones, higher rate just changes the options you have for where you place the choice.

Evilcountspatula · 22/03/2024 10:47

LipstickLil · 22/03/2024 08:00

The high earner is presumably too busy working hard to maintain the high salary to spend all day posting shit on MN!

Yep you’ve probably nailed it 😂

OP posts:
Ludobik · 22/03/2024 09:35

Beezknees · 22/03/2024 08:38

Of course it doesn't.

But personally I, as a single parent with career ambition, don't want to hear about how much someone's DH earns when looking for career advice.

Then don't read those threads, surely? I find those threads interesting, much as I find plenty of other threads interesting that I'm sure others don't. I just scroll past threads I have no interest in reading.

Mumtoaswiftie31 · 22/03/2024 09:10

I am now a single mum but have always been the higher earner and DP earned around half of what I do.
( 3 children ) I have been called out many times on mumsnet because it must not be true.
I have never understood why people don’t believe a woman is genuine If they earn good money.

SlipperyLizard · 22/03/2024 09:10

Evilcountspatula · 21/03/2024 23:58

Not surprised at all. As I say, just interested to hear from women who’ve overcome the societal barriers.

I saw what divorce did to my mum financially (who was forced to give up work when she got married, and had left school with no qualifications) and was determined that I would never be reliant on a man for money.

That drove me to prioritise my career from an early stage and through a decent amount of luck and some hard work I’ve always earned more than DH. Mostly I have made what have been, with hindsight, good career choices that have led me to a highly paid role.

When childcare became an issue, it was DH who took a step back for over a decade for the same reasons many women do - he was the lower earner and it made no sense for it to be me. He’s now back in a reasonably well paid role.

Whether it is societal conditioning or maternal instinct or something else, many women simply don’t prioritise their career while men do. Women go part time and take responsibility for nursery drop off/pick ups while their DH changes nothing (or from watching men I’ve worked with, start working longer hours to avoid being at home for bedtime!). DH and I both worked 4 day weeks before he stepped back, and he worked from home so was on drop off duty. There’s nothing wrong with women doing that, but it shouldn’t surprise anyone when they then earn less, have less in their pension etc.

But the real problem is, I think, the idea that having two adults out of the house all day is a recipe for happiness once kids come along. It isn’t, even now my kids are teens family life is easier because I’m fully remote - if I had to commute each day like before Covid then DH likely wouldn’t have gone back to work. Someone usually has to take a step back, and it would be great if more men did it, but they would suffer the same penalty women currently do.

ShowerEasy · 22/03/2024 09:05

@FusionChefGeoff My DH is in that category but I’m afraid our answers would be incredibly boring, that’s how you can tell the AMA ones are nonsense 😂

FilthyforFirth · 22/03/2024 09:00

LorlieS · 21/03/2024 23:28

Taking a step back from this...how many women are earning more than their husbands?
I'd be interested to know stats on this and reasons behind it.

I earn the same as my husband currently, normal salaries, we are both mid 50sk but my next promotion will see me rise to £75-80k and his similar so depending on who gets there first, I could potentially earn more than him.

Until we had kids I out earned him by approx £10k. I do think having two mat leaves and changing career has meant I will always be roughly the same, even though I started higher.

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 08:57

Tbf I'm also drawing that conclusion from the fact that virtually all the women I know who talk about being company directors are non or low rate tax payers themselves and do a bit of admin for the company, although an accountant does the payroll and tax returns. Their husbands do the invoicable work of being plumbers, electricians, financial advisers, mortgage brokers, IT consultants, personal trainers etc. I can only think of one example (out of 100s of people over the years) of a limited company where the Director is a woman and the husband/partner works for the company, and both invoice, and that is my own.

I do know quite a few women who are high earners or run limited companies on their own though. It's this particular setup of putting the wife on the company as a tax efficiency or to avoid paying full accountancy fees that irritates me when they claim to be equal partners/high earners themselves

Evilcountspatula · 22/03/2024 08:54

NChighearner · 22/03/2024 07:41

I’ve NCed for this. I earn just over £1M a year - I run a technology business. I am not like the high earning DHs you hear about on here in that I’m not on the 630 train, leaving everything to my spouse (who also works FT) or others. I am a present parent for my kids, I turn up to assemblies etc because I’m senior and (mostly) in control of my schedule. I wfh 2 days a week.

The way I did it was to simply keep working and play the long game. I’ve worked in industries where presenteeism isn’t the name of the game. had kids late enough (34 and 36) that we had good household income and hired a wonderful nanny who is still with us even though both kids are at school. I went back to work after 4 months with both, which was tough. When I had 2 under 2 it was really tough. But I forged through because I could see it would benefit us all in the long run. Everything has a price though, like a PP said I don’t do much other than work and spend time with my kids. But work is stimulating, interesting and (gasp) fun. So it’s not drudgery. I do almost nothing around the house, I don’t even know where most of the cleaning products are - I don’t consider chores to be a necessary component of mothering and I am happy to pay our housekeeper (she is paid well, before anyone accuses me of getting rich of the exploited labour of other women) to take that on.

I would never do an AMA because once you get to my level to answer anything would be very outing!

This is really interesting, thank you for taking the time to post and wishing you continued success. Agree that choice of industry is important , there are many where presenteeism is a must - it goes without saying that it holds women back no end.

OP posts:
TheDarkHouse · 22/03/2024 08:49

ArrestHer · 22/03/2024 07:27

There are a lot of assumptions about women directors here. I’m a director in our business. Yes it’s my husbands day today work that is the function of the business, but, alongside my own existing employment, I do all of the business administration. I deal with the finance, the website, any tax, compliance with HMRC rules and those of companies house.

without those parts of the business we would not be earning and so damn right I “earn” my share of the income. But for me he’d have to pay someone else to do it as it’s not his forte at all. Just because it’s not producing product doesn’t mean I don’t earn.

same in my job. I don’t deliver the service we sell, but with out me the team that do couldn’t either.

It’s not an assumption about directors - it’s the conclusion we’ve drawn from the OP on the thread discussed, not a blanket statement re directors.

Beezknees · 22/03/2024 08:38

Yulona · 22/03/2024 08:25

In any case I like threads written by SAHMs, as a SAHM myself who doesn't know many IRL. Sorry if that makes me a betrayer of the sisterhood or whatever.

Of course it doesn't.

But personally I, as a single parent with career ambition, don't want to hear about how much someone's DH earns when looking for career advice.

chickenpieandchips · 22/03/2024 08:33

@Yulona
Welcome to the sisterhood of SAHM!
As for the topic, all the women I know who earn more than my high earning DH don't have children or have nannies and housekeepers or a SAHD.
Our friend is a divorce lawyer and made my husband very aware that as I gave up my career (I earned more than him once) I would take a lot in a divorce.
One of my high earning friends wishes she was the SAHM as she would see her child grow up and not have to cancel holidays and weekends.

HeadNorth · 22/03/2024 08:28

Alcyoneus · 22/03/2024 07:24

It’s not just the high earning threads. Anything professional related, some women come on to give advice in a really learned way and then say that this is what their ‘DH’ tells them. A but like kids saying ‘my mum said’.

Just let the women who know, share their experience, rather than shoe horning what your husband says or does.

Those are so annoying. Even worse when someone chips in with their husband's opinion - when he has absolutely no specialist expertise beyond being a bloke. On a recent film discussion someone chipped in with their husband's view of the film, which was especially significant as he only liked clever women, not silly ones, apparantly. These women are so deeply conditioned that men's opinions just matter more, it is depressing.

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 08:27

I don't really get the alternative pov I'm afraid. The majority of people in this setup are doing it to take advantage of the woman's tax allowance I think. If you're not, because you have your own job, why are you doing his company admin? Why doesn't he just use an accountant? Ok maybe there's some benefits to being able to spread dividends across 2 directors and 2 tax returns, even if both are 40% tax payers, but it's still not the same as a company with 2 directors who are also both employees and both invoicing through the company. I don't get what makes this an 'actual partnership' if you aren't actually contributing to the profits of the company.

Yulona · 22/03/2024 08:25

In any case I like threads written by SAHMs, as a SAHM myself who doesn't know many IRL. Sorry if that makes me a betrayer of the sisterhood or whatever.

ArrestHer · 22/03/2024 08:13

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 07:33

I do all that for my limited company that I am sole diretcor of as well as doing the actual work that I invoice for. Lots of women do. I pay an accountant to do my tax returns. Many men that get the women to do this and make them directors do so so they can take advantage of the woman's tax allowance to pay less dividend tax, not because they need them do the monthly admin that they could easily pay an accountant to do.

Not saying that this is the case for you as you also work, but for most men that have limited companies this is about the wife being a non or 20% tax payer and it's a way to pay less tax.

I don’t deny that what you talk about happens. Or that there are women like you who do it all. I was just pointing out an alternative if an actual partnership as very few people seem to Consider it possible.

i have also had my own business previously but a client persuaded me to work with them as an employee and here I am.

I just get frustrated at women assuming that because you’re a director in a business with your H you’re only on the paperwork for “tax purposes”.

bombastix · 22/03/2024 08:11

Yes v boring. It is not 1950.

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 08:07

Another mis-conception. You can actually work less hard once you become quite senior and lots of more 'in the trenches' jobs like mine involve short bursts of working hard and plenty of time to piss about on the Internet if I want to. I also wfh most days and am posting at 8am before I start work as I'm not getting on and off trains today.

LipstickLil · 22/03/2024 08:00

The high earner is presumably too busy working hard to maintain the high salary to spend all day posting shit on MN!

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/03/2024 07:57

pinkdelight · 21/03/2024 23:41

I avoid the whole AMA topic like the plague. Just the titles make it sound like the most self-absorbed wankerdom. Obviously many topics are self-absorbed but to actually think "I'm so fascinating I'll start a thread saying Ask About Meeee!" Is too much. And when it's "Ask Meeee About How Rich I Am", eeesh. End times!

Also this absolutely. It’s one thing if the AMA is genuinely fascinating (ie I was an ISIS bride).

Starting a thread inviting people to ask envious questions about your beautifully appointed townhouse and four children at Eton is embarrassing.

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/03/2024 07:54

To be fair whenever people post on Mumsnet that they earn over £100k per annum they are invariably told by most poster that they must be lying (because everyone knows women don’t earn that much is the implication). Lots of people on here struggle with the idea that women can be mothers and earn high salaries.

Or alternatively they are accused of bragging.

I’m a single mother and high earner but I don’t talk about my salary on here, partly because it is a bit tacky but also because people have previously told me I am making it up.

CharlieDickens · 22/03/2024 07:49

I'm a high earner but not through fancy jobs.

My pay before children was quite good and I was good at saving. Over the years I paid off my mortgage, invested in the stock market (with help and guidance), took out an ISA and took out a SIPP. Now post-divorce I have a reasonable standard of living.

Most of my income is generated through investments (about £60k pa), the rest is from work (£30k pa). I'm not sure that's what people think about when they hear high earner but the question is what is it you are trying to achieve? So few people are able to get those kinds of jobs isn't it better to learn how to optimise what you have?

Lampslights · 22/03/2024 07:46

I read the other thread and also found it odd, the poster appeared to wish to talk about lifestyle, ovens, horses, handbags stuff, and seemed irate and uncertain when it came to business.

having a business where you take a salary of over a million a year (before tax) but still run around in a works van doing the quotes seemed highly unusual as the running of such a large scale operation would be highly complex. She also unwittingly indicated it was small, as they have so few employees and have to sometimes hire poles.

whuch made me think she was confused on 780 was annual revenue not net salary. if you look at the largest scaffolding companies in the uk, where this company would have to be positioned, they all have full board of directors running it , inc financial, marketing, operational, strategy directors etc, but this was being run by one bloke who did the quotes in his van, had ten employees in total, inc the cleaner.

WhatDoesThisMeanForUs · 22/03/2024 07:42

I think it depends on the questions being asked OP. I don't know the thread being referenced on here, but if the questions were about balancing high earnings jobs and kids, or what career paths or qualifications lead to high incomes, or investments, or outgoings v income, or sharing finances in a high income marriage, or how everyone in the North is poor as a church mouse, I might respond on the thread.

That's despite me being a middle/high earner and DH being the 6 figure earner. I feel like I might have something to contribute.

If the question was about how as a single mother you earn 6 figures, no - I wouldn't contribute.

Swipe left for the next trending thread