Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?

244 replies

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 16:30

Have a fridge, freezer and new double mattress to donate to charity. The mattress is genuinely brand new and has never been slept on because I bought it and then was given a new orthopedic one which was more suitable for my poor bad back! I think I laid on it for less than an hour total.

They've just been and I've never had such an awful experience - they refused the fridge and freezer because "the door seals have gone" (they haven't - I've been using both up until last weekend and never had an issue. The freezer is also missing a couple of drawers (movers dropped and broke them but it's never been an issue)

He then called me a liar over saying the mattress is brand new - because unfortunately I snagged it on the door strip getting it out of the bedroom and it has a few small clicks on the cover.

It has really put me off ever trying to donate anything ever again. I don't have much money and could have sold them in Facebook. The fridge and freezer are a few years old so don't look brand new but do work perfectly well. The way he spoke to me made me feel really small and stupid and I hate being called a liar (I'm ND and not being believed is a massive thing for me.)

If anyone wants to know the charity name I'll share it via PM but it is a big name in the town where I live.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
OP posts:
Misthios · 22/03/2024 08:40

Rude? OK then.

I think we're seeing why the OP was so offended by the refusal to take her fridge/freezer and mattress. It is NOT RUDE to say that actually, this item is not something we will make money on, and we'll leave it with you.

tolerable · 22/03/2024 08:38

@IloveAslan .No- it is fabulous her items were put to use somewhere. Tough as it sounds refusingpotentil "stock"they know isnt at standard required is part of their job.
tough.
Idiot would be to draw aconclusion on entire uk charity based on 1 experience.probably

SableGrape · 22/03/2024 08:33

Misthios · 22/03/2024 08:25

They simply don't have the space to take every single damaged item that people mightwant. It's surely not difficult to understand.

You'd think so, wouldn't you. But ask anyone who volunteers in a charity shop and they will have heard donors making statements about "someone getting use our of it" whether it be a pair of boots with the soles hanging off or chipped mugs and plates. People get emotionally attached to their things and don't like the idea of throwing them in the bin, so kid themselves that there is still life in that old chipped mug from 1999 and "someone" might be able to use it. So they donate it, we take one look, and chuck it in the bin. But that costs money because charity shops pay commercial rates for disposing of waste.

With white goods it's even more expensive because there is a recycling fee for things like fridges and freezers because of the chemicals used in the refrigeration. Mattresses do have to be absolutely pristine because they are bulky and awkward to store and with experience, charities will know that they are a hard sell when they have signs of wear.

OP says she got £10 per item as if this is "proof" that the charities are deluded and have just diddled themselves out of cash by refusing her amazing donation. What she's not thinking about is that in the time/fuel the two people spent coming to her house, they could have been at another house up the road picking up 6 boxes of other goods which were much more valuable. It's a numbers game.

Are you always so rude, or is it a new thing you're trying out hun? 🤨🙄

Here's a boot so you can really give the op a good kicking 🥾🥾🥾

The person who booked the collection obviously thought the goods were worth taking!

Misthios · 22/03/2024 08:25

They simply don't have the space to take every single damaged item that people mightwant. It's surely not difficult to understand.

You'd think so, wouldn't you. But ask anyone who volunteers in a charity shop and they will have heard donors making statements about "someone getting use our of it" whether it be a pair of boots with the soles hanging off or chipped mugs and plates. People get emotionally attached to their things and don't like the idea of throwing them in the bin, so kid themselves that there is still life in that old chipped mug from 1999 and "someone" might be able to use it. So they donate it, we take one look, and chuck it in the bin. But that costs money because charity shops pay commercial rates for disposing of waste.

With white goods it's even more expensive because there is a recycling fee for things like fridges and freezers because of the chemicals used in the refrigeration. Mattresses do have to be absolutely pristine because they are bulky and awkward to store and with experience, charities will know that they are a hard sell when they have signs of wear.

OP says she got £10 per item as if this is "proof" that the charities are deluded and have just diddled themselves out of cash by refusing her amazing donation. What she's not thinking about is that in the time/fuel the two people spent coming to her house, they could have been at another house up the road picking up 6 boxes of other goods which were much more valuable. It's a numbers game.

SoupDragon · 22/03/2024 08:15

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 05:40

Do you not think that the fact OP was able to find new homes for her items so quickly shows that there is a demand for such things? UK charities sound like idiots to me.

They simply don't have the space to take every single damaged item that people might want. It's surely not difficult to understand.

MrsWhattery · 22/03/2024 07:37

I can find absolutely nothing on the wide internet that connects damaging fabric with “click,”

I can’t believe people are telling OP she didn’t mean the regional word she used! It’s hard to google this because so many websites include the word “click’ in its internet meaning but I had a go. If you Google ‘clicked my tights” “clicks in the fabric” and similar in quotes, you’ll find people using it. Often on selling sites to describe items.

Just because a word is onomatopoeic doesn’t mean it can’t have other uses (although I think snagging fabric can make a little clicking sound, especially tights).

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 22/03/2024 07:37

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 07:23

Do you not think the OP is being super duper defensive and to take some of her claims with a pinch of salt?

So on a thread where I'm upset about being called a liar you've decided to also call me a liar?

Charming.

Which things do you think I'm lying about?

OP posts:
MaverickBoon · 22/03/2024 07:30

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 05:40

Do you not think that the fact OP was able to find new homes for her items so quickly shows that there is a demand for such things? UK charities sound like idiots to me.

There might be a demand for these things (however small/niche it is or isn't) but the point is that the charity shop is under no obligation to take the items if their business model doesn't cover them catering to that demand. That is to say, if they don't have the room to store things for when one bloke with low freezer standards eventually comes in with enough cash, then why should they? The person that bought the freezer was probably actively searching online groups so could filter and find it pretty quickly - the shop might not get so lucky with the perfect customer.

Plenty of PPs on this thread have said it more eloquently, but just because charity shops rely on donations, it doesn't mean they don't also have a business model. If they thought they could make more.money taking these kind of items, then they would.

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 07:23

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 05:40

Do you not think that the fact OP was able to find new homes for her items so quickly shows that there is a demand for such things? UK charities sound like idiots to me.

Do you not think the OP is being super duper defensive and to take some of her claims with a pinch of salt?

Hobbesmanc · 22/03/2024 07:10

Off topic I know. But I thought the word click for little snags on fabric or carpets was in common use. I'd use it for example when the cat catches a claw in the duvet cover.

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 05:40

tolerable · 22/03/2024 02:39

ok.so "charity" you OFFER they collect(with plan to sell-support organisation)
THEY know what they deem acceptable.
leave you with original items.
if theyd av went "thhanks love"and landfilled whatchu sold\deem serviceable.would you feel any better?

Do you not think that the fact OP was able to find new homes for her items so quickly shows that there is a demand for such things? UK charities sound like idiots to me.

tolerable · 22/03/2024 02:39

ok.so "charity" you OFFER they collect(with plan to sell-support organisation)
THEY know what they deem acceptable.
leave you with original items.
if theyd av went "thhanks love"and landfilled whatchu sold\deem serviceable.would you feel any better?

mathanxiety · 22/03/2024 01:18

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 21:00

I described them in detail on the phone and the person on the phone didn't seem to have an issue with them!

Again, the mattress has never been used. I tried it for about 30 mins with a mattress protector, mattress topper and sheet before realising it was far too soft. There's not a mark on it.

But it is slightly ripped - it does have signs of wear.

They have to choose between your statement that it hasn't been used, on the one hand, and on the other, the fact that it has some snags.

They don't know you. They do know what they are looking at.

They have very likely seen a hundred other mattresses that nobody has ever slept on.

mathanxiety · 22/03/2024 01:10

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 19:30

You know you can stack stuff directly on the shelves, right?

I think you need to face the fact that this was a subpar freezer.

Yes, you've been using it. Yes, you can stack food on the shelves.

No, that's not great, and there's a risk the charity shop might not be able to sell it.

TheCompactPussycat · 22/03/2024 01:00

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 22/03/2024 00:55

It's absolutely not dirty! 🤬 Both were cleaned extremely well.

Tbf, the photos show that they are both rusty/damaged along the bottom edge which people may be thinking is dirt. That sort of damage/wear will mean that the seals are no longer working to the standard they should be.

mathanxiety · 22/03/2024 00:58

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 17:56

Why though? It's been working perfectly well for me for over a year and the fella who took it didn't seem at all bothered!

Because a freezer missing drawers is a freezer they may eventually have to pay someone to dispose of.

It may end up a net financial loss to them.

They're not a disposal.service.

TheCompactPussycat · 22/03/2024 00:56

@QueenCamilla I guess different charity shops have different requirements. They probably know their customers best.

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 22/03/2024 00:55

Trolleysaregoodforemployment · 21/03/2024 22:25

That freezer is dirty and has missing shelves. Its hardly surprising they would not take that. You haven't photographed the seals so it difficult to tell on the fridge. There is point using floor space for things that will not sell.

It's absolutely not dirty! 🤬 Both were cleaned extremely well.

OP posts:
QueenCamilla · 22/03/2024 00:52

@TheCompactPussycat

I could see myself buying the mattress.
I've owned three charity shop mattresses in my life. All previously used. I had a luxury king size one for years and I've had at least another 2 or 3 for shorter term (whilst moving and renovating house) or occasional use (single guest bed).

I will never, ever spend £1500 on a mattress when I can get the same thing for £150. Each to their own.

MoreRainbowsPlease · 22/03/2024 00:45

I have had a couple of annoying occasions with donating furniture to charity and 2 of them were with BHF who we originally chose to donate to because of a family member who had benefitted from their research.

The first time my Gran was downsizing and had some retro (but very in style and desirable now) items, a table and 4 chairs and a sideboard. When the men came to collect they said the table and 2 sideboards weren't desirable but they might take the chairs. They made my normally very placid and calm Gran so upset (they were very rude and off hand) she told them not to worry. I sold the items for her on ebay and got £270 for it all.

I then wanted to donate 2 solid hardwood sideboards. I filled out the form online, sent photos and then had a phone call from the manager of the shop to arrange a collection time. She said they looked lovely (they were in as new condition). When the men came they refused to take one and begrudgingly said they would take the other. When I asked why they wouldn't take both of them they said it was because it wouldn't sell. When I said I had sent photos and the manager had said they wanted it, they said she had no idea what sold and what didn't! They took one of the sideboards and I decided to keep the other one in the end.

After all this when DMIL needed to donate a bed with mattress and a coffee table we decided to go with a local charity which puts together furniture packages for people who are being housed by the council and have nothing. I agreed to wait in for them to collect. They had said they needed to check the bed and mattress all over to check it was in good enough condition which was fine, but when they went to leave they asked for money which they said was a donation for the charity taking the items. There had been no mention of this on the website or when I'd phoned to arrange collection. DMIL wasn't very well off herself so wouldn't have had money to give and I didn't have any cash on me. I explained I was not aware we were expected to give a donation and I had no cash. They sort of snorted at me and left with out saying a word.

Now I either sell things on facebook marketplace, or if I need something gone quickly Freecycle. The thing that really upset me was when I go in the BHF furniture shop the prices are so high for 2nd hand goods (in some cases they really do sell chipped Ikea things for the same or more than brand new ones), and they have the same things in for months. Also in the case of my Gran's items her things were in really good condition yet quite a bit of the things in the shop are very shabby. I get that the shop workers will know what will and won't sell. But certainly in my shop there is not a very fast turnover, which I think must be to do with price.

QueenCamilla · 22/03/2024 00:42

Maybe depends on the area - but there's quite a few independent junk shops around here (and Emmaus are great) and they'll take anything not broken.

Alternatively, everything (even broken) will be taken from the front of my house in mere hours. I've been surprised by what goes!

And equally, I sometimes root through charity shops for the most obscure items and it is great when I can find just the right pair of deep soup spoons for 50p or the top part of a bureau or broken chest of drawers that I can use the oak from.

Some furniture charities are so bogged down in their own rules, that they look more like a glitter-bombed Chinese ikea than a pre-loved or vintage shop.

TheCompactPussycat · 22/03/2024 00:41

The charity shop is not a free refuse collection service. Looking at those photos @EmptyTheFrickingBins has posted, none of that stuff is good enough to be sold on in a charity shop. The freezer has missing drawers, both the fridge and the freezer have damaged seals (you can see the damage to the painted-coating where the seals should make contact with the frame on the photos), and the mattress has substantial snagging and cannot be described as new, however few minutes you actually lay on it. If they were to take it away, they would be extremely unlikely to sell any of it and would have to pay to dispose of it at the local tip.

5YearsLeft · 22/03/2024 00:38

susey · 21/03/2024 16:58

Glad it is not just me 😂 I think she means "nicks"?

I can find absolutely nothing on the wide internet that connects damaging fabric with “click,” which may be my fault, I admit. So to someone saying they’d heard it or “fabric can be clicked,” could you show me even a single source on that? Because I was almost wondering if this post, especially with the amount of times OP used the word, was just to check how many people would ask what the absolute fuck clicks are. Like the Emperor’s New Clicks.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 22/03/2024 00:32

Let's not forget that one person's idea of rudeness is another person's idea of truth.

None of us were there, we only get to read the Op's version of the conversation.

altho we do have a photo of the freezer, without the broken drawers...

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 00:25

Help221 · 22/03/2024 00:04

To be fair, a lot of people try to donate any old shit to charity shops and get mad when they're anything but thankful. People frequently use charities as dumping grounds because it's the most convenient way for them to get rid of stuff. It's absolutely tiring and can cost a charity a lot of money when they need to dispose of items. People leave bags and bags of stuff on the floor outside under giant signs that ask them not to, and it all ends up costing the charity money to bin after it's been destroyed in the rain or unsellable crap to begin with. I've volunteered for charities before and encountered many volunteers who are rightly sick of people using it as a dumping ground and expected to be thanked for it.

Obviously it's not acceptable for anyone to be rude, but after seeing the cheek of people and what they try to "donate", I'd say try not to take it too personally and cut them some slack.

And with all due respect, a charity doesn't want a freezer with broken drawers. That is not a thoughtful donation.

At least there's a happy ending for everyone where the charity hasn't been lumbered with items they don't work and you have managed to get some money for them.

I agree with you on people who try to dump their rubbish at charity shops, but that is no reason to be rude to others.

Funny how the charity shop didn't want OP's items, but she had no trouble finding homes for them - which surely shows that, despite the charity shop's fussy attitude, there is a market for goods such as hers.

Charity shops here generally take anything which is still useable. Where do people get good but cheap stuff in the UK?

Incidentally I used to work in our local recycling shop, who also weren't fussy and took everything clean and useable, and it's amazing what people will buy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread