Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?

244 replies

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 16:30

Have a fridge, freezer and new double mattress to donate to charity. The mattress is genuinely brand new and has never been slept on because I bought it and then was given a new orthopedic one which was more suitable for my poor bad back! I think I laid on it for less than an hour total.

They've just been and I've never had such an awful experience - they refused the fridge and freezer because "the door seals have gone" (they haven't - I've been using both up until last weekend and never had an issue. The freezer is also missing a couple of drawers (movers dropped and broke them but it's never been an issue)

He then called me a liar over saying the mattress is brand new - because unfortunately I snagged it on the door strip getting it out of the bedroom and it has a few small clicks on the cover.

It has really put me off ever trying to donate anything ever again. I don't have much money and could have sold them in Facebook. The fridge and freezer are a few years old so don't look brand new but do work perfectly well. The way he spoke to me made me feel really small and stupid and I hate being called a liar (I'm ND and not being believed is a massive thing for me.)

If anyone wants to know the charity name I'll share it via PM but it is a big name in the town where I live.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
OP posts:
TheHardScab · 22/03/2024 15:14

is it BHF?

we had the same with a wardrobe and chest of drawers, they would not take them

Iwasafool · 22/03/2024 15:10

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 13:32

I wasn’t really calling them a liar, but yeah sure whatever. OP I think you’re lying.

Actually I would say - exaggerating / embellishing the truth.

just saying that they’re being very defensive and as such I question their posts a little bit. her story does change a bit with the man who came to pick the bits up, and it’s all convenient that they sold OH SO FAST on FB. I’m sure they did sell but I doubt people were rushed off their feet to buy them.

Edited

Whereas you are just making things up because lets face it you weren't there and the OP was.

Iwasafool · 22/03/2024 15:10

SoupDragon · 22/03/2024 10:00

The logic is flawed though. Offering them online via something like Facebook marketplace reached far more people for free than having them in a shop does. It also reaches different people. The charity has overheads to pay and has to factor this into their pricing strategy.

They can either have one freezer in very good condition that is guaranteed to sell for £50 or one damaged freezer that they might get £10 for (random prices!) - which would you choose to stock?

My local charity shop also sells on line. £10 is better than nothing. I don't know when charity shops changed, they used to be of benefit to the charity and people looking for something in their price range now they seem to want to charge high prices. I understand how the OP feels, I took two pairs of leather riding boots to a charity shop, hardly worn (husband was disabled in an accident so could ride) very good quality, they looked down their noses and examined the boots like I was trying to offload rubbish. Never went there again.

Regardless of the economics they should not be rude and calling the OP a liar is disgusting.

KreedKafer · 22/03/2024 15:01

The problem is that a lot of people try and use charity shops as a means of getting rid of old furniture for free instead of having to pay the council to take it away, so they have to be particularly vigilant.

Also, the things you're selling are among the risky things for a charity shop to take. Fridges and freezers require special disposal because of the chemicals they contain, so would be a real ballache for them to get rid of if they can't sell it. Mattresses have to meet fire and safety regulations to be sold on, so again, they have to be extra vigilant about taking them. And I can see why he didn't think it was new, because it does look dirty in the photo.

He shouldn't have been rude to you, of course. But I can see why he didn't take the items. And I also think perhaps the rudeness might have been a case of six of one and half a dozen of the other, because you do seem a lot more angry and worked up than I would be about someone not wanting my old fridge.

slashlover · 22/03/2024 14:50

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 05:40

Do you not think that the fact OP was able to find new homes for her items so quickly shows that there is a demand for such things? UK charities sound like idiots to me.

No, it doesn't show that. The number of people who visit a charity shop is going to be tiny compared to those searching online. We have items we send to our charity's eBay page because we know that it may sell for £200 on eBay but we wouldn't even get £10 for it instore. Believe it or not, UK charities have staff who know their demographic more than people who have never worked or volunteered in one.

A charity shop might 300 customers per day where 10 are looking for a fridge. A FB marketpage might get 300 visitors in an hour, all of whom specifically searched for a fridge.

Trolleysaregoodforemployment · 22/03/2024 14:03

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 22/03/2024 00:55

It's absolutely not dirty! 🤬 Both were cleaned extremely well.

Are you saying it was impossible to clean the black marks near the seal? or in the top left? These marks, along with the missing shelves and the the marks on the metal shelves make it look grubby. Appreciate it may look and smell cleaner than the impression it gives, but it's a fair first reaction to those photos, IMO. I have bought second hand white goods and I swerved any that looked like they came from a house clearance or a HMO. That just my opinion, YMMV.

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 13:32

IroningThrone · 22/03/2024 11:00

So you are calling the op @EmptyTheFrickingBins a liar but aren't honest enough just to say that.

Which bit do you think he's being dishonest about?

I wasn’t really calling them a liar, but yeah sure whatever. OP I think you’re lying.

Actually I would say - exaggerating / embellishing the truth.

just saying that they’re being very defensive and as such I question their posts a little bit. her story does change a bit with the man who came to pick the bits up, and it’s all convenient that they sold OH SO FAST on FB. I’m sure they did sell but I doubt people were rushed off their feet to buy them.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 22/03/2024 13:13

so did the people that bought your 3 items turn up ?
had they turned up in the 15 mins between you posting your thread and selling the items ?

IroningThrone · 22/03/2024 11:00

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 10:50

Didn’t call you anything love. But you are being defensive about it all, like I said in my post.

Just saying that you can’t take everything at face value - it’s an anonymous forum you can say whatever you want to and no one would know what’s the truth 🤷‍♀️

So you are calling the op @EmptyTheFrickingBins a liar but aren't honest enough just to say that.

Which bit do you think he's being dishonest about?

PuddlesPityParty · 22/03/2024 10:50

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 22/03/2024 07:37

So on a thread where I'm upset about being called a liar you've decided to also call me a liar?

Charming.

Which things do you think I'm lying about?

Didn’t call you anything love. But you are being defensive about it all, like I said in my post.

Just saying that you can’t take everything at face value - it’s an anonymous forum you can say whatever you want to and no one would know what’s the truth 🤷‍♀️

Elderflower14 · 22/03/2024 10:20

Apologies.. Your post seemed to fit what I was saying... I understand you don't employ them!!!

toomuchfaff · 22/03/2024 10:18

We have local community pages on Facebook that advertise items for people in need - not sure if you have these but put them on there. There is always someone who could be desperate for the item; if even just to tide them over.

SoupDragon · 22/03/2024 10:00

Iwasafool · 22/03/2024 09:36

Well they were already there so I can't see the pick up cost being an issue, they look clean in the photos and if the OP sold them that quickly it doesn't sound like storage would be an issue.

The logic is flawed though. Offering them online via something like Facebook marketplace reached far more people for free than having them in a shop does. It also reaches different people. The charity has overheads to pay and has to factor this into their pricing strategy.

They can either have one freezer in very good condition that is guaranteed to sell for £50 or one damaged freezer that they might get £10 for (random prices!) - which would you choose to stock?

Iwasafool · 22/03/2024 09:36

Luxell934 · 22/03/2024 09:18

Selling the items for £10 each on Facebook marketplace doesn’t mean there’s a good profitable market for them though does it. It would cost the charity a lot more to pick up, clean, store , etc than it would be worth to them. They would lose money or not make any profit for the charity at all!

OP your being ridiculous, they shouldn’t have been so rude but they clearly did not want the items and probably had to just to honest and tell you. Don’t take it so personally? The items NEED to be profitable for them to make money for the charity, they aren’t taking items out of the goodness of their hearts. If they don’t think it will sell for a GOOD price that they can make a profit off then they won’t accept it. Nothing personal to you or your items.

Edited

Well they were already there so I can't see the pick up cost being an issue, they look clean in the photos and if the OP sold them that quickly it doesn't sound like storage would be an issue.

Isittimeformynapyet · 22/03/2024 09:36

Daffodilsarentfluffy · 21/03/2024 17:29

I actually reported 2 volunteers who conned my SN mate out of £20. Collected 3 units and a table and chairs from her art studio. Flat packed I had built myself. Dismantled and cleaned to perfection.. They were arsey that the table needed 2 of them to carry it... Took her money after saying they wouldn't take it otherwise.. Boss told me future training would be improved.. Didn't get the money back. Won't donate to them again.

What is SN in this context?

Luxell934 · 22/03/2024 09:26

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2024 09:13

Particularly with large items that would be costly to dispose of if they're not able to sell, of course they will only take items they know will sell easily

So many have said this and it's absolutely true

However many have missed that OP's already sold the items straight away on Facebook, which might suggest that the charity have missed an opportunity

DMIL needed to donate a bed with mattress and a coffee table we decided to go with a local charity which puts together furniture packages for people who are being housed by the council and have nothing ... when they went to leave they asked for money which they said was a donation for the charity taking the items. There had been no mention of this on the website or when I'd phoned to arrange collection

I can't pretend to speak for what every charity does, but that has the flavour of a scam with the drivers trying to make a bit for themselves - especially considering she'd already made a donation via what she was giving them

Edited

OP sold them for £10 each though, it’s highly unlikely someone would pay enough for those items to be profitable for the charity. It wouldn’t be worth the charities time to sell them for that. They would be either making no money at all after delivery, cleaning, storing costs etc or actually losing money.

Luxell934 · 22/03/2024 09:18

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 00:25

I agree with you on people who try to dump their rubbish at charity shops, but that is no reason to be rude to others.

Funny how the charity shop didn't want OP's items, but she had no trouble finding homes for them - which surely shows that, despite the charity shop's fussy attitude, there is a market for goods such as hers.

Charity shops here generally take anything which is still useable. Where do people get good but cheap stuff in the UK?

Incidentally I used to work in our local recycling shop, who also weren't fussy and took everything clean and useable, and it's amazing what people will buy.

Edited

Selling the items for £10 each on Facebook marketplace doesn’t mean there’s a good profitable market for them though does it. It would cost the charity a lot more to pick up, clean, store , etc than it would be worth to them. They would lose money or not make any profit for the charity at all!

OP your being ridiculous, they shouldn’t have been so rude but they clearly did not want the items and probably had to just to honest and tell you. Don’t take it so personally? The items NEED to be profitable for them to make money for the charity, they aren’t taking items out of the goodness of their hearts. If they don’t think it will sell for a GOOD price that they can make a profit off then they won’t accept it. Nothing personal to you or your items.

willowthecat · 22/03/2024 09:14

We have a disposable society now and have done for years - you will find stuff like that at your local council dump - I don't mean that as a comment on your stuff OP just that every day reasonable quality usable items are dumped - sometimes taken by those on the look out sometimes not

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/03/2024 09:13

Particularly with large items that would be costly to dispose of if they're not able to sell, of course they will only take items they know will sell easily

So many have said this and it's absolutely true

However many have missed that OP's already sold the items straight away on Facebook, which might suggest that the charity have missed an opportunity

DMIL needed to donate a bed with mattress and a coffee table we decided to go with a local charity which puts together furniture packages for people who are being housed by the council and have nothing ... when they went to leave they asked for money which they said was a donation for the charity taking the items. There had been no mention of this on the website or when I'd phoned to arrange collection

I can't pretend to speak for what every charity does, but that has the flavour of a scam with the drivers trying to make a bit for themselves - especially considering she'd already made a donation via what she was giving them

Misthios · 22/03/2024 09:11

I guess most people wouldn't choose to buy a mattress from a charity, but they do furnish people's homes when they are broke, just released from prison, care leaver's flats etc.

Very true - there are charities which do exactly that, I can think of a couple in the city where I live. But OP does not name the charity. If it was - for example - British Heart Foundation or Cancer Research, that is not their remit, they sell things to raise money for scientific research. It's not their job to then get on the phone to other charities trying to pass on stuff they can't make money on.

BobbyBiscuits · 22/03/2024 09:07

If the guy was just a subcontracted man and van type, then surely he would just unquestioningly take whatever it was he was told to take? It sounds more like he was a representative from the charity itself. I agree it's odd as they look like they do in the photos presumably. Does the charity explicitly say they accept white goods and beds/bedding? I guess most people wouldn't choose to buy a mattress from a charity, but they do furnish people's homes when they are broke, just released from prison, care leaver's flats etc.
I'd make a complaint about the tone of the guy. He's putting the charity in a bad light. Glad you sold the stuff though! Lesson learned I guess.

slippedonabanana · 22/03/2024 09:01

I suppose charities get a lot of people trying to get them to take away subpar items just so they can avoid disposal charges. So they are naturally fussy to prevent having to pay themselves to get rid of them later.

DonnaBanana · 22/03/2024 08:53

In future put them on your towns local for free group, they’ll be gone in no time without questions. People working for charities on minimum wage like that aren’t going to be the best rounded individuals alas

SoupDragon · 22/03/2024 08:46

SableGrape · 22/03/2024 08:33

Are you always so rude, or is it a new thing you're trying out hun? 🤨🙄

Here's a boot so you can really give the op a good kicking 🥾🥾🥾

The person who booked the collection obviously thought the goods were worth taking!

The person who booked the collection obviously thought the goods were worth taking!

Did that person see the items?

There is absolutely nothing rude in that post.

I think the collection people handled it wrongly and should have politely turned the items down but there's nothing wrong with turning down broken items.

SableGrape · 22/03/2024 08:44

Misthios · 22/03/2024 08:40

Rude? OK then.

I think we're seeing why the OP was so offended by the refusal to take her fridge/freezer and mattress. It is NOT RUDE to say that actually, this item is not something we will make money on, and we'll leave it with you.

But that wasn't what they said, was it? If the op was so upset she was shaking then they must have been pretty awful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread