Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?

244 replies

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 16:30

Have a fridge, freezer and new double mattress to donate to charity. The mattress is genuinely brand new and has never been slept on because I bought it and then was given a new orthopedic one which was more suitable for my poor bad back! I think I laid on it for less than an hour total.

They've just been and I've never had such an awful experience - they refused the fridge and freezer because "the door seals have gone" (they haven't - I've been using both up until last weekend and never had an issue. The freezer is also missing a couple of drawers (movers dropped and broke them but it's never been an issue)

He then called me a liar over saying the mattress is brand new - because unfortunately I snagged it on the door strip getting it out of the bedroom and it has a few small clicks on the cover.

It has really put me off ever trying to donate anything ever again. I don't have much money and could have sold them in Facebook. The fridge and freezer are a few years old so don't look brand new but do work perfectly well. The way he spoke to me made me feel really small and stupid and I hate being called a liar (I'm ND and not being believed is a massive thing for me.)

If anyone wants to know the charity name I'll share it via PM but it is a big name in the town where I live.

To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
To think this charity shop was ridiculous?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nicklebox · 26/03/2024 10:27

hobbitonthehill · 21/03/2024 16:46

My husband tried to donate a few items from his late mother's flat , the 2 men from the charity who turned up were lucky they weren't thrown out the door ! They left with nothing were incredibly rude ! Perfectly good wardrobes and beds ended up in the dump.

I had this experience too. Perfectly good condition wardrobe dressing table unit in very good condition no scratches but was turned down as being too old fashioned.

TheBerry · 23/03/2024 22:03

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 23/03/2024 21:55

How kind of you to explain that to me.

Funny how the person on the phone had no problem with the items (and yes, I described them accurately, including that the mattress was unwrapped.)

But you obviously know better than I do.

The person on the phone was probably some admin volunteer rando who doesn’t really know (no shade, just they probably don’t really know, and are probably there to just book the collection guys to go out and inspect stuff).

The guys who come to inspect the stuff are the paid ones, as you say, who actually know what will sell.

It’s not personal OP. The charity couldn’t make use of your stuff. That’s all.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 23/03/2024 22:01

did you actually tell the person on the phone that the drawers in the freezer were broken thus missing,
did you actually inform the person on the phone that the mattress had ' clicks ' etc
and a snag on it which happened as you were getting it out of the bedroom ?

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 23/03/2024 21:55

TheBerry · 23/03/2024 21:19

OP the charity isn’t there as your personal removal men.

They are there to sell items for a profit so that (at least some of) the money can help people / animals who really need it.

The reason you donate to charity is to help those people / animals. Not because you want the stuff gone, not because you think the stuff is fine, not because you don’t want to take it to the tip or sell it.

The charity will know what items they can sell. If they can’t make use of your items, it’s not reasonable or particularly rational to get so defensive / upset.

The guy probably meant that the mattress wasn’t brand new in that it wasn’t still wrapped up in plastic. Any unsealed bedding they’re not going to want, I’m sure, no matter how perfect it is. I don’t think he was calling you a liar, he was just saying it’s not brand new as in factory sealed in box.

How kind of you to explain that to me.

Funny how the person on the phone had no problem with the items (and yes, I described them accurately, including that the mattress was unwrapped.)

But you obviously know better than I do.

OP posts:
TheBerry · 23/03/2024 21:19

OP the charity isn’t there as your personal removal men.

They are there to sell items for a profit so that (at least some of) the money can help people / animals who really need it.

The reason you donate to charity is to help those people / animals. Not because you want the stuff gone, not because you think the stuff is fine, not because you don’t want to take it to the tip or sell it.

The charity will know what items they can sell. If they can’t make use of your items, it’s not reasonable or particularly rational to get so defensive / upset.

The guy probably meant that the mattress wasn’t brand new in that it wasn’t still wrapped up in plastic. Any unsealed bedding they’re not going to want, I’m sure, no matter how perfect it is. I don’t think he was calling you a liar, he was just saying it’s not brand new as in factory sealed in box.

ColesCorner7814 · 23/03/2024 19:53

There are other charities out there (ie not ones that sell the stuff on) that take them to give to people who are fleeing domestic violence etc and are starting from scratch. They are always desperate for nearly new/working items.

CelestiaNoctis · 23/03/2024 15:04

Yanbu because if he didn't think they were suitable he should have been more polite. He could have said "unfortunately I don't think these meet our requirements but we appreciate you thinking of our charity". I would message his head office informing them of his behaviour as it sounds inappropriate and borderline aggressive.

SecondStarOnTheRight · 23/03/2024 13:44

Bassetlover · 23/03/2024 13:06

Yes! Same! They obviously have form for this. It's put me off buying large items from them.

We had another item they wouldn't take as they didn't think it was stable enough. It had been stood for five years without issue.

The funny thing is, whenever I've gone into their furniture store, it's either overpriced or dated!

Bassetlover · 23/03/2024 13:06

SecondStarOnTheRight · 23/03/2024 10:32

I wouldn't be surprised! This was the British Heart Foundation.

Yes! Same! They obviously have form for this. It's put me off buying large items from them.

SoupInTheLaundryBag · 23/03/2024 11:13

I recall one November deciding to buy a new Christmas tree. My existing one was a lovely tree so I took it and the box of matching decorations to the charity shop I always supported.
The woman looked at me like I’d got two heads and asked what on earth I’d bought that in for as they’d never sell it.
I took it down to the BHF and the lady there was thrilled. It went straight into their window display.

About a week later original charity were making sad posts on the local Facebook group about how in Christmassy their window was and they were desperate for decorations.

Have to say, the attitude of her resulted in me never donating a thing there again.

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 23/03/2024 10:53

Toptops · 23/03/2024 08:47

I hope your FB buyers turn up. I've met more time wasters through that than anything else.
We have a brilliant Shelter shop on our road. They accept anything and everything. Bedding, baby equipment, electrical stuff (they send away.) And they arrange for collection!
I took them a giant bag of carrier bags, unsure but thinking they might be able to use them. She was lovely and explained that anything they can't sell or use themselves, they leave outside the shop for people to help themselves. And they do.
That's the way to do it!

It's all gone.

Freezer went within half an hour, fridge yesterday morning and the mattress went last night.

OP posts:
SecondStarOnTheRight · 23/03/2024 10:32

Bassetlover · 23/03/2024 00:42

I had the exact same problem! I wonder if it was the same charity?

I wouldn't be surprised! This was the British Heart Foundation.

ScholesPanda · 23/03/2024 09:50

I did donate to my local Sally Ann recently and they took everything I had including some saucepans and kitchen implements I thought they might turn away.
They have multiple channels to use things in though- if something won't sell in the shop they can use it in one of their shelters, or give to someone setting up in a new home, or send overseas.

ScholesPanda · 23/03/2024 09:48

It's a shame they didn't take your fridge OP, someone else could have started a thread about how their local charity shop was selling a Beko fridge for £50 when they only cost £120 new.

The freezer is way too battered to be sold in a charity shop.

Charities are starting to cut the number of shops they have, and are getting fussier about what they take as a result- anyone can sell on Marketplace or Vinted with none of the overheads, so the shops can only make margin from products that can command a premium.

Toptops · 23/03/2024 08:47

I hope your FB buyers turn up. I've met more time wasters through that than anything else.
We have a brilliant Shelter shop on our road. They accept anything and everything. Bedding, baby equipment, electrical stuff (they send away.) And they arrange for collection!
I took them a giant bag of carrier bags, unsure but thinking they might be able to use them. She was lovely and explained that anything they can't sell or use themselves, they leave outside the shop for people to help themselves. And they do.
That's the way to do it!

Jack80 · 23/03/2024 07:55

Charity shops can be fussy, try a homeless shelter

AllHopeandRainbows · 23/03/2024 07:08

The thing is @penjil the people you are spiting from not donating to charity any more are not the rude volunteers, you are spiting the people receiving palliative care and bereavement support from Sue Ryder who rely on donation 🙄

TulipCat · 23/03/2024 00:59

I get that charity shops need to respond to their market and can't take things they can't sell, but they do seem to be very picky these days. This leads to "convenience doners" (I include myself in that description) who are primarily donating to offload their stuff, not bothering and just using Freecycle. I do wonder what their supply chain will look like in a few years.

Bassetlover · 23/03/2024 00:42

SecondStarOnTheRight · 21/03/2024 18:33

We bought some furniture from a charity shop, a year later we attempted to donate it back. No change in the condition etc. The men arrived to collect it and stated within two seconds of seeing it that it was the "wrong kind of wood".

Ended up putting it on Facebook and it was collected in the hour.

I had the exact same problem! I wonder if it was the same charity?

ftp · 23/03/2024 00:27

I had the same experience with a certain hospice charity. They came and picked sniffily over everything in my mother's home. Her clothes were all "old lady designer" like Windsmoor, an collection of "wedding" hats and expensive shoes, and many were worn once or still had new tags in. They took a nearly new electric recliner, but when the gift aid came through, they told me they had made just £25!

A lovely local charity came just after, and I wish they had come first. They took everything else, including the umbrella behind the door, and said thank you. They told me that things would be sold or donated on. That even the old tea towels and bedding would be sold for recycling, but they had washing machines and the sheets and towels would be resold for a few pennies to those in need, and that was a win,win for both.
Guess we just picked the wrong one.

LawfulSearch · 23/03/2024 00:06

penjil · 21/03/2024 19:03

Below is a copy of the review I gave my local Sue Ryder charity shop. The staff were appalling, I dropped plenty of goods off at the back of the shop, and not one of them acknowledged me or even said a quick thank you.

I don't donate at all now, to any charity.
I take everything straight to the tip, regardless of it's new or hardly used condition (as most of my items are.)

"Rude and ignorant staff. I donated many household items this morning: a chair, 2 stools and 2 big boxes of bits. It took several trips back and forth from my car, and I carried them all the way through their shop to their office at the back - and not one member of staff even acknowledged me or said thank you, let alone offered to help! At least 2 staff members saw me (they were just outside their back office where I put the donations.) Total ignorance is a disgraceful way to treat someone who has gone out of their way to donate!"

I think we must frequent the same Sue Ryder shop.

IsThisOneAvailable · 22/03/2024 22:30

EmptyTheFrickingBins · 21/03/2024 19:30

You know you can stack stuff directly on the shelves, right?

Of course you can.

But I wouldn't buy one with two thirds of them missing.

OShoey · 22/03/2024 22:20

As OP found, if you hate tipping things which have life left in them (as I do) it's best to cut out the middle man and sell /give away direct to a person that's looking for that item on FB, local groups, ebay etc.

I think the model charities are using will become obsolete due to this. Online hunting is easier than traipsing around charity shops. You can check out many different sites to find what you want for free or low cost. It's also less stressful for the seller as items are more likely to be taken and you can set a deadline for yourself before deciding to tip things.

I understand the argument being made that charities don't have space to store goods they may not sell easily. Wouldn't they'd be better off buying/renting large warehouses and selling online than having high street shops? Maybe sell some of the eye-wateringly expensive real estate in London, that many seem to have HQs in, to fund it?

No excuse for being rude to a donor, especially after accepting the items over the phone and expecting someone to wait in for the pick up.

ViaMargutta · 22/03/2024 22:12

You're oversensitive. No one called you 'all sorts', it's the internet - people have different opinions and are allowed to express them freely.

Charity workers shouldn't be rude, but hey ho. You meet less than friendly people every day. Irritating sure, but you move on.

When I moved in my current empty house, it was empty. Not much £££, so I sorted out all that I needed on the cheap online. Got myself a fridge/freezer all in one, with all the parts present, clean and in fully working condition for £50. Not a famous brand, but whatever. Worked fine for a long time, and was replaced with bells&whistles one much later. £50 for both fridge and freezer with all the shelves, etc. Clean. So no, I wouldn't buy yours. And it might not be dirty, I don't know what those marks at the bottom are, but they are there, visible in your pics.

Your mattress looks fine though. I'd buy that if I needed one. Charity didn't take it, so you sold it on Facebook. Good. Now time to move on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread