Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the programme Ambulance doesn't show paramedics in a good light at all?

139 replies

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 14:40

I'm am very grateful for all emergency workers and the difficult pressures they are currently under is awful and it's certainly not a job I could do.

However, I'm shocked at the amount of intrusive questions (Asking elderly people why they never had children?) and the general gossiping about patients. I understand the need to pass on factual updates but some of the story sharing is wholly inappropriate.

I enjoy the programme but it's really opened my eyes, and not in a good way!

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 21/03/2024 17:27

I love watching this. They.must witness some terrible things
Many of their patients are elderly and live alone. A friendly chat and some care and kindness can llift the spirits of an old lady who may have not seen or spoken to another human for days/weeks .
I fail to see how that is inappropriate

FrancisSeaton · 21/03/2024 17:23

Here we go. All health care professionals should just not talk at all- they just should hand out an information leaflet and not converse at all. They also shouldn't be allowed to smile now apparently as that's inappropriate 🙄

PocketSand · 21/03/2024 17:17

Flagged!

PocketSand · 21/03/2024 17:15

I understand that chit chat and banter is partially diagnostic and to provide a wider picture but in my experience can be quite misleading where undiagnosed ND may be in play. I have 2 autistic DC and am probably autistic myself and didn't appreciate my response to ambulance transfer to hospital for one of them being questioned as abnormal. It was normal masking for me. But not emotional enough for them. Hence they fagged it.

the80sweregreat · 21/03/2024 17:01

The paramedics I've had dealings with were far superior to the Doctors with their bedside manner and dealt with my late dad with dignity and humour
They are great and do a tough job really well

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/03/2024 16:48

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 15:41

I haven't said they don't do a good job, they absolutely do!

And completely agree that they aren't paid enough. None of our public sector workers ate and I fully support a raise for them all.

They have some extremely difficult cases to deal with and its frustrating to see the lack of resources they have.

I still think some of the 'chit chat' is inappropriate. I've seen a young female paramedic embarrass an older gentleman who had to be helped off the floor by suggesting he was cuddling her.

As I said in my OP, asking people why they didn't have children, reporting back to the dispatcher the patients anecdotes and personal situation (Oooh Barry and Helen have just celebrated their anniversary and had just come back from a cruise). Unnecessary.

I'm not criticising their dedication to the job, I'm saying they need extra training on appropriate small talk and passing on gossip.

How I think of this is that some jobs are 'inside' people's lives. I have one of those jobs. We see the terrible, gritty reality of everyone's lives. Inside people's homes when they aren't ready for visitors, when they are vulnerable and weak. We end up, just because of the job, seeing and hearing things no one typically would. Which breeds a kind of immediate intimacy that no one with an 'outside' job understands.

I have to ask questions about sex, violence, drugs and all sorts within ten minutes of meeting someone, sometimes. It is a strange and special place of privilege. But we aren't strange or special. So we have to talk things through, and we sometimes get the level of intimacy wrong.

But 'outside' people will never really understand what it's like for 'inside' people.

BeyondMyWits · 21/03/2024 16:46

Stuff like "they've been on a cruise" isn't gossip... it is useful... was there a norovirus outbreak, did it visit a mosquito area... did they just overindulge in the buffet.. I work in a pharmacy and we do directed small talk - someone comes in with an infected bite, you try to work out if it was in the UK or abroad etc. Sometimes we must seem nosey... and ours is rarely life or death like the paramedics deal with all the time.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/03/2024 16:43

The 'inappropriate chit-chat' actually has a purpose (well most of the time).

It helps you monitor how someones doing, if they start out able to witter away with you and that starts to fade, thats a sign things are going downhill.. and of course vice versa.

It can also really help to take peoples minds off whats going on - the last thing you want when lying on the ground with a broken hip, or gasping in your bed, not knowing when you can get in the ambulance, is someone silently working away or sat there doing nothing, or worse... just focusing on discussing the relevant details of how bloody ill/injured you are.

It may even help the paramedic to block out the rest of the awfulness and get on with the specifically necessary stuff.

SO it may seem inane, it might seem mindless, and because you're talking to strangers in awkward situations, sometimes it might pitch things wrong (in which case you back out and change the subject quickly) for that patient... but it is not without purpose at all!

likepebblesonabeach · 21/03/2024 16:40

Op - AIBU?
Everyone - yes
OP - no I'm not.
Why bother asking the question if you think you are right op, just a waste of everyone's time

Hettie24 · 21/03/2024 16:40

I guess you won’t be calling on the paramedics in your hour of need then?

I’ve had to call them, twice. They were bloody outstanding both times. They saved my 18 month old grandsons life. Enough said!

What’s your job OP?

Thekormachameleon · 21/03/2024 16:36

Op, with respect, get a grip

If you had to listen to or witness half the things we do you'd probably end up rocking in a corner

If we want to wear fun earrings or chit chat to put a frightened pt at ease then we will

Mama2many73 · 21/03/2024 16:32

MaloneMeadow · 21/03/2024 15:51

Appalling in what way?

My cousin works in our local hospital, visits all wards doing her job.
Twice she has put in offical complaints regarding 2 higher level nursing staff due to their behaviour/attitude/manners .
The first she witnessed while visiting her DM who was on a ward (behaviour was toward another patient and family).
The second was when she herself was in urgent care from the nurse practitioner. My cousin spoke to her at the time and told her an official complaint was going in. She mentioned this to colleagues after and before she mentioned who it was 3 of her colleagues named her!!
Most staff are amazing but others shouldn't be allowed near a patient but when retention and staffing is so bad what choice do you have?

Pingu18764 · 21/03/2024 16:30

Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix · 21/03/2024 15:17

I haven't seen the latest few series but it really opened my eyes to the sort of things they deal with.

I remember the episode where the female paramedic had to do a welfare check and she discovered the man's body after he hung himself.

Then the same paramedic had to deal with a young woman who was sadly killed by strong winds. On her next job she went to a patient who brought that up in conversation, and she just nodded.

I think the paramedics have to ask questions about their private life to build a connection and put them at ease. It makes the patient think of happier times.

I think the show is cheapened by the sob stories, and it infuriates me when they're called to a drunkard and they have to wait there for hours with them because they can't leave them alone.

I saw last night's and I although I appreciate its a nervous response, I thought it was unpleasant to see the female call handler smiling after taking the call from the women who was hiding from her abusive boyfriend. I also didn't like the rubber duck earring the male call handler was wearing - I think its in slightly bad taste to be wearing novelty clothing while dealing with people who are in life or death situations.

Ok so I’m going to flip this,

I deal with this stuff, my name badge is a unicorn. Do you want to know why? Because I need something to remind me that while my work is horrific some days it’s also lovely, and that at the end of the horrible shifts it’s ok for me to let it go, go back to my family and enjoy life with them. You think it’s distasteful, for me it’s how I get through the shift.

And as for smiling, I smile so I don’t cry. I don’t cry at work because if I do I can’t do the next job. I have to smile, it’s how I make sure I can continue and only have my break downs when I am ready for them. That may not be when you think it’s appropriate but I have to look after my own mental health first.

So before you judge my unicorn badge, my fun pens and earrings and my smiling, imagine how it feels to deal with someone who’s escaping domestic violence and their story reminds you of your past. Or how you cope when a child has died and you know you have to carry on and the next job may be a waste of your time.

Polominty · 21/03/2024 16:23

Feel free to never call an ambulance OP, no matter how life threatening your situation is, for fear of being asked chatty personal questions by the paramedics. I couldn’t care less if the call handlers wore full on fancy dress never mind a cheerful ear ring, thank goodness they are there to get help to desperate patients. I wouldn’t last a day, I’m sure I’d be sobbing in the toilets by lunchtime and I work in social work so I’ve heard some challenging things over the years.

helpfulperson · 21/03/2024 16:23

I imagine some of the 'chit chat' is aimed at gently prompting people on bits of their medical history they wouldn't mention otherwise. And banter trying to relax patients to reveal important things.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 21/03/2024 16:18

I felt nothing but gratitude for the paramedics who turned up and blue-lighted me to hospital after I was hit like an express train with pneumonia last year.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 21/03/2024 16:18

I watch the show and have never taken that from it at all, so I don’t agree OP.

Silverumbrella · 21/03/2024 16:14

I watch Ambulance and I’d rather have any of the lovely paramedics on there attend a loved one than the two who came to us when my poor MIL was terminally ill with cancer and came to transfer her from her home to the hospice.

They hardly spoke a word to us, no small talk or made us feel at ease at all despite dh and I trying to instigate some kind of conversation, it was very uncomfortable.

They still do a very difficult job and I dare say most are brilliant with people but as I say, the ones we got were not the friendliest of folk. Give me any off the Ambulance program anytime.

Minimink · 21/03/2024 16:14

I don't understand why you think it doesn't show Paramedics in a good way. They're human beings dealing with extremely scary situations at times. They deserve so much more credit than they get.

Last year I had to call for Paramedics a lot over the space of a few weeks for a poorly relative. Every single time they turned up they were amazing, even the ones that were about to finish their 12 hour shift when another job had come in!

I cannot praise the Ambulance service enough.

Now I'm going to watch last nights episode because I forgot it was on!

Toddlerteaplease · 21/03/2024 16:12

@Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix I remember that one. She visibly flinched when the next patient mentioned it. I'm
Not sure I'd have been able to just carry on like she did. Hats off to her.

ArcticOwl · 21/03/2024 16:12

my partner is a paramedic tech, and honestly, you have NO fucking idea.

Before we were together we were at an event he was working as medical volunteer, and i was in another role, i fell quite ill (near collapse due to an emergency that meant i missed important meds) and he switched from 'friend' to 'medic' and i've never felt so safe and reassured than when he slid into his work patter to keep me from panicking and making things worse, all while arranging for friends to get my meds from my hotel room, someone else to get me food, even helping me back to my room and contacting my team to let them know i was being taken off shift.

It might not be 'appropriate' to you, but when you're in that situation, sick, and scared, having someone be personable, funny, and kind can make the world of difference.

Toddlerteaplease · 21/03/2024 16:11

The ambulance program is very scripted, according to ex dispatchers on here. Apparently it's not usual to give a full update to control after every call. Only if something bad has happened. So I wouldn't worry about it.

tuvamoodyson · 21/03/2024 16:09

I was a nurse for many years, you know the ones who will enjoy a joke and those who you take a different approach too…paramedics do a fabulous job, could you do their job OP?

DojaPhat · 21/03/2024 16:08

I don't really like these types of shows but what I like about the ambulance one is it does show the paramedics in a very human way - they become likeable and I find myself empathising a great deal. Wholly unlike the police ones which couldn't scream propaganda louder if there was a UK-wide law that we all be seated by 8pm ready to watch the latest instalment of the very nice police officer arresting the very bad lollipop lady.

IkaBaar · 21/03/2024 16:08

The poor paramedics have a few moments to develop a rapport with a patient. Some of the questions e.g. what do you do for a living are about developing that rapport but also about how to explain things, because asking what level of education do you have wouldn’t come across well!

Of course sometimes healthcare professionals get it wrong, they are only human. At the moment they are doing an incredibly stressful busy job.

I’ve been most surprised by what people call an ambulance for, when other services would have been more appropriate.