Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the programme Ambulance doesn't show paramedics in a good light at all?

139 replies

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 14:40

I'm am very grateful for all emergency workers and the difficult pressures they are currently under is awful and it's certainly not a job I could do.

However, I'm shocked at the amount of intrusive questions (Asking elderly people why they never had children?) and the general gossiping about patients. I understand the need to pass on factual updates but some of the story sharing is wholly inappropriate.

I enjoy the programme but it's really opened my eyes, and not in a good way!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spencer0220 · 22/03/2024 03:21

ExtraOnions · 21/03/2024 20:11

Greater Manchester Ambulance Service came last year when mum had a stroke.
They were perfectly informal at the right times, they kept everyone calm, they used “love” because we live in The North and that’s how we talk, they could not have been nicer, and thier friendliness brought much neeeded respite to a difficult situation.

I don’t want a robot turning up

I was about to say this.

My DH almost died 4 years ago. The paramedics came, and after he was stabilised, I was so very grateful they spent just a couple of minutes talking to me before they blue lighted him off.

It meant that the trauma I saw (my DM trying to do cpr), wasn't as bad as it COULD have been.

It also helped them get a picture of who he was.

And honestly, I'd rather a human in my house when I'm sat there bawling.

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 03:12

Well I watch it from the other side of the world, and am always very impressed with how kind and caring the staff are. They strike up a conversation with their patients to try to keep them calm and put them at ease, and add a bit of humour for the same reason. What do you expect them to talk about? They are hardly going to start an argument over politics or religion, they just chat about life in general.

swimlyn · 22/03/2024 01:26

swimlyn · 21/03/2024 19:56

Well, recently I saw one of them call a lady “love” instead of addressing her by her full correct name. I was appalled. Politeness costs nothing.

As for the use of “darling” and “duck”, I can’t believe they keep their jobs when they are so offhand with tax paying customers.

What the hell is going on?

This was an "Angry from Tunbridge Wells" post, meant to lighten the moment.

So much instant hostility... 😊

crumblingschools · 22/03/2024 00:45

I think it is slightly ironic that someone is complaining about paramedics etc gossiping about details of a patient whilst they are watching a programme which gives the viewer all the details about the patient. Why are you watching it if you think personal details shouldn’t be shared?

rainintensity · 22/03/2024 00:41

Nurses glued to screens? Not because they want to be, because senior management have made it mandatory for the nursing workforce to become a junior management workforce, registered nurses aren't allowed to be bedside nurses anymore, we spend our days having to input data by strict timelines to justify having the staff on the floor, otherwise they get pulled away to other areas. EVERYTHING IS COMPUTERISED. I used to love sitting with patients hand writing their notes but now it's all on the computer.

Also OP, YABU.

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 00:26

Interesting opinions on here. I generally take opinions that are formed from watching a television programme with a pinch of salt to be honest. Those programmes are engineered, edited and produced to make what is considered good, interesting tv. Everybody shown in the programme has to give multiple layers of consent for the footage to be shown. Patients and relatives are usually shown the footage very early on in the production process and again when it’s basically complete.

I was actually in a few series of one of these ambulance reality programmes many years ago. It was a strange experience and I didn’t really enjoy it so have declined being in any since. Sometimes, as with all human beings, we read the situation wrong and conversation can end up appearing awkward or somewhat inappropriate. You do need to remember though that television is heavily edited so you don’t really have any idea of the true context of the conversations. You’re really only watching snippets of a job spliced together. It’s difficult to make a true judgement once you realise this.

Having said that, there are some terribly inappropriate and unprofessional people still lurking in the profession sadly, though most of them seem to old stylee rather than newly qualifieds. If a newly qualified is making mistakes in conversations that’s likely down to inexperience, naivety and lack of confidence and will improve fairly rapidly.

purpleme12 · 22/03/2024 00:09

🤣🤣

Gymnopedie · 21/03/2024 23:56

swimlyn · 21/03/2024 19:56

Well, recently I saw one of them call a lady “love” instead of addressing her by her full correct name. I was appalled. Politeness costs nothing.

As for the use of “darling” and “duck”, I can’t believe they keep their jobs when they are so offhand with tax paying customers.

What the hell is going on?

Is that you, Hyacinth?

Go and plan your next candlelit supper and calm down.

margegunderson · 21/03/2024 23:46

Christ. Inappropriate is such a weasel word. I bet you disapprove of anything you regard as a personal question and that your definition of personal or gossip is wider than most people's. They are putting people in scary situations at their ease and probably adding to the medical history, not being nosey. They'll never see those patients again but need to build an instant rapport - of course they chat. And they aren't going to tell the whole world what they learned on each job.

hellywelly3 · 21/03/2024 23:08

I think it’s important to see the patient as a real person with a life (just been on a cruise etc) you have to care about the patient to do the job

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 22:33

Goodnight all, sweet dreams.

OP posts:
HullaBallu · 21/03/2024 22:30

The 'why didn't you have children?' question stuck out to me at the time as an unusually tactless question but it was asked by a very new (and young) paramedic who was trying to find out, not that subtly, if the patient had support or if he was coping alone. Paramedics are human.

NewName24 · 21/03/2024 22:18

Pottedpalm · 21/03/2024 14:46

You are being very unreasonable! I’m amazed by the empathy and kindness shown by the paramedics. Many of the patients are elderly and lonely as well as being ill and they seem to enjoy the distraction of a friendly chat.
The paramedics shown on the program do a simply amazing Job which leaves them physically and mentally drained. For far too low a salary.

This, and so much of what so many others have said.

YABVU

HeadInTheSand0324 · 21/03/2024 21:59

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 21:03

🙄 I'll have any opinion I wish too thanks.

Funny how many childless and child free people in here are offended and hurt when others question why they don't have children but an elderly gentleman is fair game. Are we ageist now?

I cannot actually believe people think this is acceptable. And just because you're insulting me, doesn't mean I will change my mind and agree.

You are clearly annoyed about the fact a man was asked why he didn’t have children. That’s it.

Why you had to turn that one instance in to a thread where you slag off paramedics and accuse them of being unprofessional and gossips I have no idea.

You really need to either lighten up or gain some perspective because this attitude and level of annoyance surrounding a man being asked why he didn’t have children is really strange.

And as I said before, you need to think about why you’re using that annoyance as an excuse to generally be nasty about paramedics. Just bizarre.

Telekoma · 21/03/2024 21:39

A few months ago I was visiting my mum, who has a cat.
My mum tripped over the cats scratch post and knocked herself out on the wall.
I phoned an ambulance and fortunately my mum had regained consciousness before they arrived, but was feeling sick and groggy.
The paramedics asked what had happened and I explained.
The paramedics told my mum that's what happens when you go pole dancing.
My mum laughed so hard that she actually vomited.
Should we have told him off? Reported him? Taken offence?
Of course not. No offence was meant and none was taken.
They do a hard enough job as it is, certainly not one I envy them for.
It's a sad day when you can't have a bit of banter to help lighten the situation.

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 21:26

MaloneMeadow · 21/03/2024 21:18

This. Give it a rest OP, you sound ridiculous and have been told this by 100s of posters

Happy to sound ridiculous if it means I don't blindly love everything that NHS workers say just because.

I have repeatedly said I appreciate and value our emergency workers, but they are not without ethical codes and standards.

OP posts:
Angelik · 21/03/2024 21:21

@LucyLaundry the chit chat is often investigative as well as a way of building trust. And, of course, they share stories with each other. Sometimes it's informal counselling, sometimes they are simply sharing they had a nice conversation with a nice person/family which makes them and others feels good especially when they deal with such awful awful things. And they are allowed to smile. Sometimes they have to see joy somewhere, quickly otherwise they'll crumble.

MaloneMeadow · 21/03/2024 21:18

ElliottFromScrubs · 21/03/2024 21:15

Most people have a sense of perspective. That’s all.

This. Give it a rest OP, you sound ridiculous and have been told this by 100s of posters

ElliottFromScrubs · 21/03/2024 21:15

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 21:03

🙄 I'll have any opinion I wish too thanks.

Funny how many childless and child free people in here are offended and hurt when others question why they don't have children but an elderly gentleman is fair game. Are we ageist now?

I cannot actually believe people think this is acceptable. And just because you're insulting me, doesn't mean I will change my mind and agree.

Most people have a sense of perspective. That’s all.

DrCoconut · 21/03/2024 21:09

I also had them out recently when DS was ill. He was scared and they were really good with him.

DrCoconut · 21/03/2024 21:09

I witnessed paramedics dealing with the aftermath of a horrible accident outside my house where a young man suffered a traumatic amputation of a limb. Obviously I didn't stand and watch but it was literally outside my front window. They were there for ages and I later heard the man survived, albeit with life changes consequences. An amazing job, they must have nerves of steel to go out to something like that.

LucyLaundry · 21/03/2024 21:03

ElliottFromScrubs · 21/03/2024 20:57

Glad this didn’t go well for you, OP.

Dont be slagging off the emergency service workers. Just don’t.

🙄 I'll have any opinion I wish too thanks.

Funny how many childless and child free people in here are offended and hurt when others question why they don't have children but an elderly gentleman is fair game. Are we ageist now?

I cannot actually believe people think this is acceptable. And just because you're insulting me, doesn't mean I will change my mind and agree.

OP posts:
ElliottFromScrubs · 21/03/2024 20:57

Glad this didn’t go well for you, OP.

Dont be slagging off the emergency service workers. Just don’t.

cansu · 21/03/2024 20:54

Every time I have dealt with one they have been kind and professional.

GreekDogRescue · 21/03/2024 20:46

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 21/03/2024 17:56

lol.

Go onto the HCPC tribunal website. Look at how many upcoming tribunals are paramedics.

Theres no excuse for asking people they didn't have kids.

You give no context for this conversation.
I don’t have kids and I couldn’t care less if anyone asks why.
Don’t be so touchy. Paramedics have a very stressful job and are t being paid much. Be a bit more tolerant and understanding