Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I had been able to have my babies come naturalky

59 replies

Wishihaddone · 21/03/2024 13:23

I know people will tell me it doesn’t matter and all that matters is that they are healthy and of course this is true but I’d still appreciate being able to share feelings.

When I had DS, I was induced because of my age. I didn’t really know any better and just went along with what I was told. It was a horrible experience which resulted in an emergency section some 72 hours later. I didn’t act mind the section but I was exhausted and very sick and confused, not the best start.

Two and a half years later I was adamant I wasn’t going to be induced so had a planned section at 39 + 6. Much nicer experience but I still wish I’d been able to experience my watered breaking and going into labour naturally. Does anyone else feel the same?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RaginaPhalange · 21/03/2024 19:42

You're entitled to feel that way however I would pick a csection over vaginally due to my experiences.

Ds1 I was enduced with and gave birth vaginally and almost died. I had lost a lot of blood, needed stitches and had 2 blood transfusions and spent 3 days in the icu and 2 more days on the ward and had to fight to go home as i wasnt sleeping. They let me go due to me being at home all the time with my mum as dh had to go back to work.Ds was thankfully doing well.

Ds2 was a planned csection as I didn't want history to repeat its self though was fully aware of complications that could have arised. I was out hospital within the 24 hrs.

Pickingmyselfup · 21/03/2024 19:38

I had the same situation as you, induced with an emergency c section then a planned c section.

I don't really mind, I mean it would have been nice not to have all the intervention but needs must. I had the opinion of going naturally with #2 but I was so scared of something happening during labour that I opted for an elective c section and don't regret it one bit. It was actually a lovely experience although the recovery pain was worse than the first time!

I'm in awe of people who managed to do it all without any real pain relief, I had everything going and the only thing that helped was an epidural, absolutely lovely that was!

Parkerpenny · 21/03/2024 19:33

I did hypnobirthing and ended up with a section. I had no choice as cervix was blocked.

I felt very sad that after IVF, I couldn't deliver without medical intervention and when BFing didn't work out either, I felt very sad...

I look on it differently now but that is over a decade later.

I did recover and heal very well from my section while other mums still had tears and all sorts from their vaginal births. I felt a bit of relief that it was all intact in that area.

But no, I never experienced labour either. You mustn't blame yourself for the feelings you have. They just are what they are. Xxx

minipie · 21/03/2024 19:21

Well my child has lifelong brain damage from her natural birth.

If someone had said no this baby is distressed we need to intervene, she’d have been a lot better off.

Natural birth really isn’t the be all and end all it’s cracked up to be.

DeniseSecunda · 21/03/2024 19:18

I didn't vote because you're not being unreasonable since these are your sentimental desires, but I don't sympathize with them either. I've always been terrified of labor, of the pain, so I had an elective c-section. If I hadn't had that option, I was either going to get an abortion or commit suicide. I am sorry, though, that you didn't get to have the birth experience you wanted.

Inthewellwithjoseph · 21/03/2024 19:13

OP YANBU at all!! I totally understand how you feel. I had to have an EMCS at 30 weeks with dc1 which saved both of our lives. DC2 was an unnecessary c-section after cascade of interventions and me not knowing that I could say no. With dc3, I had a forceps delivery and learnt to use the BRAIN acronym. Dc4 was my dream water birth but dc5 was another EMCS after a placental abruption, again saving both of our lives.
Each birth was more healing than the previous one and I am so thankful for my two vaginal deliveries. I had no idea that hormones give you such a high afterwards as I hadn't experienced it with my first two deliveries.
I found it easier to accept the two c-sections that were life-saving for both me and baby. It does matter and having had a consultant last time who understood that and honoured as much of my birth plan as he was able to made all the difference.

PurpleChrayn · 21/03/2024 17:35

I had this exact situation.

Sometimes I do feel wistful that I didn't birth them "naturally", but I try to keep things in perspective.

Plus, if I had have laboured naturally, it might not have gone to plan anyway.

110APiccadilly · 21/03/2024 17:01

Another thing I used to think a lot about is women throughout history and elsewhere in the world currently who die in childbirth in shocking numbers. C sections are a life saving miracle and it helped me to reframe my C sections as something we were so, so lucky to have had, as opposed to something that robbed me of a magical experience. The experience they "robbed" me of was likely myself and my child dying. I know this isn't helpful for everyone and some people feel it's invalidating their feelings so apologies if that's how it feels to you. I am just sharing what helped me.

@Fargo79 this is very much how I approach it. I've had two inductions, both ending in a section. I accept that I'll probably never give birth vaginally, and whenever I feel sad about that, which does happen from time to time, I remember that I have two children who were born alive and healthy. Many, many women would have given anything to have had the experiences I had.

Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 21/03/2024 16:57

Jaq27 · 21/03/2024 13:49

I also mourn not having the ‘natural’ birthing experience I wanted.
water birth booked with baby 1 but after 3 day labour, failure to progress, meconium and baby’s heat rate dropping I had an em CS. Traumatic. Terrifying. PTSD. No positive memories of giving birth to my much wanted DD. So sad. Took over a year to bond.
planned CS with baby2 after being advised not to try VBAC. A much more positive experience but still not the Earth mother moment I was hoping for in my silly hippy punk heart.
i comfort myself with the memory that I breastfed them both, even though I was very ill and weak after the births and also got pneumonia.
i know we’re supposed to only remember we got the live baby, but our feelings of regret are valid.
i’m still disappointed for not managing to deliver naturally like ‘a real woman’ 22 years later. 🌷

These narratives about what is a natural birth, what is a good mother, what is a real woman, are so dangerous.

you are a real woman.

FallingDownARabbitHole · 21/03/2024 16:54

I always wanted a natural birth. Was terrified to have a CS. With DD I had a crash CS to save her life after her heartbeat dropped dangerously. I was just greatfull they saved her life.

with DS I was the exact opposite. I was so traumatised with Dds birth I wanted an elected CS. They wanted me to try for a VBAC and tried to pressure me. “Luckily” DS was breech.

I never went into labour with either of mines. Part of me wishes I had experienced it. In theory I could have tried with DS after him being turned but I was so scared of another traumatic birth I refused to have him turned. Now 20 years down the line I get a twinge of jealousy when I see people in labour or giving birth on tv.

gonegrl · 21/03/2024 16:49

I feel exactly the same and I had a forceps delivery. Wish I'd experienced the relief and victory or pushing her out. My whole birth plan was around experiencing it all, I wanted as natural as possible with little intervention or pain relief. Managed to get all the way to the finish line and she ended up being in a "brow" presentation so unassisted delivery was not possible and I felt so cheated. Not sure if I'll have another so I do sometimes feel sad that I didn't get to experience what I really wanted to experience.

blobby10 · 21/03/2024 16:13

@Wishihaddone My youngest is now 24 but I completely understand your feelings! My first was an EMCS after labouring for 36 hours, not really progressing, big (10.5 lbs) baby coming down at an angle - forceps tried but gave up very quickly (luckily) and had a GA. I regret missing his first cry, his first feed, my DH did the first nappy change, first bath etc.
#2 was a different story -- fast 'proper' labour, got fully dilated within 4 hours but he got stuck by his shoulders - another big baby at 10.5lbs. EMCS and I heard his first cry but they took ages to stitch me up and I didn't see him for nearly 2 hours.

#3 I was so determined to have a proper delivery I lied about my dates. Consultant wanted me to have a planned section at 38 weeks but I persuaded him to let me go to 39 weeks (which was actually 41 weeks) but no hint of labour. Resulting baby (same weight as the others) was attached very high up with a very short cord so would never have been born normally without one or both of us dying.
Even though I knew all 3 sections were essential, it took over 10 years for me to accept that I wasn't a failure because I hadn't birthed my babies 'normally'. Being able to breastfeed them all for over a year each helped but it was an overwhelming feeling of perceived failure that I had to find a way to deal with. Time helps.

Newsenmum · 21/03/2024 16:00

Happyinarcon · 21/03/2024 15:26

I had a c section which went fine, and I have to say I didn’t care either way, but I do wish I lived in a country or culture that made me feel more confident and engaged with the birthing experience. My head was filled with a list of things that could go wrong so when after many hours of labor a c section was suggested, I was happy to do anything just so I could get my baby and sod off home.
I would have preferred to have felt less bamboozled and more empowered throughout the journey.

If it helps - I did everything. Yoga, hypnobirthing, so much positive birth prep. Still ended up the same way and I did feel a bit cheated and extra crap that it still didn’t work out

whyismysoupcold · 21/03/2024 15:58

I'd have loved to have gone into labour naturally. Both times I was induced, the first was a 44hr labour (less than an hour away from EMCS due to my waters being broken for too long), and the second was a 25hr labour with ventouse, episiotomy, and a prolapsed vagina. Neither were particularly traumatic (they were just difficult) but seeing my mutilated vulva did bring me to tears.

I'm hoping for a natural labour this time around! We'll see...

sophi1995 · 21/03/2024 15:45

I was induced both times. They were both 14 days overdue so I think I waited as long as I could for things to happen naturally but they didn't.

I would have preferred for my body to do it's own thing but it's in the past now and I never really think about it anymore (although my youngest is only 16 weeks so it's a fairly recent past).

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/03/2024 15:42

I'm glad @DeedlessIndeed

All the very best for it.

MochaLove · 21/03/2024 15:40

I can completely relate to you and don’t think you’re being unreasonable. I ended up with an EMCS after having a very long latent labour followed by induction and whilst I’m so grateful we are both ok, I am sad that I ended up with a c section. My baby had been breech until 37 weeks, and I was so happy when the ECV worked and she was flipped. I didn’t really consider then that I’d end up with a section anyway (how naive). I feel like my body failed to do what it’s meant to do. I am only 15 weeks postpartum though so it’s still quite fresh, and I’m hoping in time I won’t feel that way anymore. Just to be clear, I feel that towards myself but I definitely don’t feel like anyone else is a failure for having or choosing a c section birth. You’re allowed to feel how you feel 💐

Happyinarcon · 21/03/2024 15:26

I had a c section which went fine, and I have to say I didn’t care either way, but I do wish I lived in a country or culture that made me feel more confident and engaged with the birthing experience. My head was filled with a list of things that could go wrong so when after many hours of labor a c section was suggested, I was happy to do anything just so I could get my baby and sod off home.
I would have preferred to have felt less bamboozled and more empowered throughout the journey.

Newsenmum · 21/03/2024 15:03

Wishihaddone · 21/03/2024 14:54

That’s right @Crabble Smile

Weirdly the sections didn’t and don’t bother me. I just wish I’d had that ‘omg this is it!’ moment Smile

Me too. Never got that. But only now I’m realising that maybe not having a messed up vag is probably a good thing! and at least I get that wow now without all those problems.

Wishihaddone · 21/03/2024 14:54

That’s right @Crabble Smile

Weirdly the sections didn’t and don’t bother me. I just wish I’d had that ‘omg this is it!’ moment Smile

OP posts:
Crabble · 21/03/2024 14:51

i have said I understand OP’s perspective but my first birth was an awful forceps birth following induction so I’ve had a vaginal birth. I thought OP was more talking about starting to go into labour spontaneously? The sitting at home monitoring every twinge and wondering if this is it - and then it actually finally being it, rather than having a scheduled appointment for induction/section?

NameName2023 · 21/03/2024 14:32

My c-section was by far the better birth.

DC1 - waters broke, horrendous contractions, literally worst pain I’ve been in. After 6 hours I was given the epidural- which I then stayed on for 20+ hours. Episiotomy then got infected after. Tons of antibiotics that affected bonding.

DC2 - planned c-section to avoid going into labour, which ended up being emergency as my waters broke and contractions started. The contractions again were awful. Birth and recovery were much more straightforward.

cannaecookrisotto · 21/03/2024 14:25

YouJustDoYou · 21/03/2024 14:02

In some ways I feel the same, and in others I'm glad I had c sections. I've heard utter horror stories of women giving birth, holes tearing, collapsed this that and the other, etc, shudder.

I had a "natural" birth that involved an episiotomy and a huge loss of blood. Transfusions, and they have to manually turn her as she was back to back. I was in labour for 4 days.

I had planned for a water birth surrounded by candles and calm. I have no regrets, her heart rate started dipping towards the end of labour and at that point I wouldn't have give a shit whatever they did as long as she came out safe.

mammabing · 21/03/2024 14:20

I had an emergency c-section. At the time I would’ve agreed to anything they said to get him out safely but after I was almost disappointed that I hadn’t had him “naturally”.
I ended up going for a birth review to go through everything that happened. It turns out he was back to back but I was labouring perfectly up until 9cm when he turned his head and got stuck. It was completely unavoidable and I’ll be forever grateful to the hospital staff for keeping him safe.
If we have another I’ll go for a vaginal birth again but won’t feel bad if it doesn’t work out.

Wishihaddone · 21/03/2024 14:19

Some lovely and heartbreaking stories here @Dorriethelittlewitch i am so sorry for your story and hope you are in a better place now Flowers

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread