Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School lunches - reception - please help!

194 replies

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 12:40

Our DC will start reception in September, currently he is going to the nursery.

I am trying to figure out what is best - school lunches vs packed lunch.

I really don't want to go to the school lunches route (despite them being for free) as the quality won't be as good as a packed lunch. It will be full of sugars, processed bread, meat, fried things, frozen things, ready made chips, pasta and potatoes, puddings etc. which are not the best for a kid to have them every day. Once a while I get it but pudding every day? Why?

On the other hand if I go with the packed lunch I read everywhere that it's such a faff and a huge commitment and it will kill me. However, we all cook for ourselves once a day, don't we? I mean either when we come back home from work, or whenever it suits us. Most adults eat home cooked food every day either for lunch or dinner (some privileged for both). So, why not saving a small portion of whatever we are having for ourselves the day before and make a packed lunch with that plus some salad, fruit on the side? What is the faff about that?

It's an honest question as I think I am missing something!

AIBU - You clearly don't understand how hard that is
AINBU - It's not too hard , I think you are right

OP posts:
NeedthatFridayfeeling · 21/03/2024 13:41

Assuming the school follows the Government standards, ours does, they have a great menu and my daughter loves the lunches, takes pack up very occasionally.
https://www.gov.uk/school-meals-food-standards

School meals - food standards

Find out about the type of healthy food all maintained schools and academies in England have to provide under the school food standards.

https://www.gov.uk/school-meals-food-standards

Hoplolly · 21/03/2024 13:41

You have food issues. Potato and pasta are not the enemy when part of a balanced diet.

WithACatLikeTread · 21/03/2024 13:38

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:35

Also your assumption that things are bought into school is likely to be very wrong- school canteens are run on a shoestring and they can’t afford a lot of pre-made stuff. If they are serving chilli, lasagne, wedges or curry, I’m 99% sure it will be made from scratch. One thing you might want to check is whether there is an on site kitchen as this can be an indicator that the meals will be pretty good.

Again if you’re worried ask the office staff- they might even let you speak to the chef etc. But don’t judge based on a menu.

You can smell it as you walk past the schools. 👍

WithACatLikeTread · 21/03/2024 13:37

uhOhOP · 21/03/2024 13:09

Why is it an obsession to care about what you feed to your children?

By the time they are teenagers they will hopefully have a good understanding of how to eat well, and will understand that they can eat a burger and fries today and there's nothing wrong that, but probably best not to eat it several times a week. But a five-year-old, can't make that judgment and relies on his parents to make decisions about his food.

The worry about mercury for example seems over reacting. Surely he would be needing to eat a portion every day or several tins to get mercury poisoning. Obviously I wouldn't want my kids eating unhealthy all the time. My daughter has an all day breakfast on the menu which is mad but I wouldn't be worrying about emulsifiers and mercury.

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:35

Also your assumption that things are bought into school is likely to be very wrong- school canteens are run on a shoestring and they can’t afford a lot of pre-made stuff. If they are serving chilli, lasagne, wedges or curry, I’m 99% sure it will be made from scratch. One thing you might want to check is whether there is an on site kitchen as this can be an indicator that the meals will be pretty good.

Again if you’re worried ask the office staff- they might even let you speak to the chef etc. But don’t judge based on a menu.

BobbyBiscuits · 21/03/2024 13:35

@Tarmacadamia I personally wouldn't care if my kid had pudding every day. But surely the parents can tell staff what the kid can and can't have. It's not just medical reasons. The kid will see puddings around all the time so if s/he's not allowed every day then I guess it's better to get used to it. Some kids must be diabetic or on special diets where pudding every day isn't the norm.

Octavia64 · 21/03/2024 13:35

I can confirm that the puddings and cakes provided as part of school dinners taste and look absolutely nothing like proper puddings and cake.

Worked in education for many years!

If you do do packed lunches please at least use a way of keeping the food hot. Cold leftovers is not great.

eddiemairswife · 21/03/2024 13:33

What is wrong with a pudding everyday? Many of us have survived into old age having eaten cakes and school puddings The problem is the multitude of children who are driven everywhere and never use their legs to transport them to school.

FranticHare · 21/03/2024 13:31

Don't assume the recipes for the food on the menu. Speak to the providers.

The "cake" (for example) is a very small portion, and will also have very little sugar - normally a fruit or a veg provide the sweetness. They are not sweet cakes like you would buy from a cafe. Plus the kids need some energy! They are growing and running.

Things will not be deep fried on mass, and most things will be made from scratch. Just because some Chilli you buy in the supermarket is full of shite, don't assume the same. That is being very unfair. Get your facts and then make a decision.

And beware of signing your child up for hot lunches, and then imposing restrictions like no dessert. He is getting older, and will notice. As will his peers, who will also comment. It will likely give him food issues. Also the teachers have better things to do then ensure your son doesn't have pudding - there are not the same high ratios as nursery.

bakewellbride · 21/03/2024 13:30

'Nasty food'? You are going to need to relax when your child starts school otherwise it will be really stressful for all. There are play dates and birthday parties - you can't always control what your child eats. Pretty much every week my 5 year old runs out of school excitedly clutching a bag of sweets because it was some kid's birthday. What will you do then, take it off them and say they can't have it? Kids want 'nasty food' even more if you are really strict with it.

InTheRainOnATrain · 21/03/2024 13:30

As for the microwaved lunch - everything is a matter of getting used to it... and if you are hungry you will eat it despite not being served hot.
It’s great that you’re all for healthy eating but why so dismissive of it being pleasant to eat? You can do wraps, sandwiches, pasta salad, hummus with veggies to dip as cold options. Pasta cooked that morning with some previously made sauce and put in a thermos. It’s likely that they could also have a jacket potato with cheese and salad followed by fruit for pudding on school dinners, obviously not great everyday but not processed and fine 1-2 times a week. It doesn’t have to be an all or nothing between processed school dinners or a cold portion of last night’s salmon stir fry or whatever you typically eat of an evening. Find the middle ground!

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 13:30

@cadburyegg A cheese sandwich is 100% better than a tuna if you eat cheese everyday or tuna everyday.

Of course, the one off tuna sandwich is not going to do any harm.

At nursery I can't apply the rule "in moderation" which is the right one. It's either a yes or a no! We have the odd tuna at home, he is not missing out.

This is what nutritionists say, it's not made up.

OP posts:
mynameiscalypso · 21/03/2024 13:28

My DS is in reception and has school lunches because he's very fussy and barely ate for the first few weeks of term. He's 'allowed' a hot lunch too as it's already catered for so sometimes he has chips or whatever with his lunch. He normally has a sandwich or something like cold pizza or a pasta salad. Occasional cous cous and chicken. He's very happy and doesn't want to change to school lunches at the moment although I think he's the only one in his class who takes a packed lunch.

cadburyegg · 21/03/2024 13:27

You think a cheese sandwich is healthier than a tuna one?

Oh dear.

A healthy relationship with food isn't formed by banning items completely from your child's diet. Tbh they're likely to want to eat more of it when they're finally given it if they think it's "forbidden".

bakewellbride · 21/03/2024 13:26

Why don't you look at the school menu first then go from there. You seem convinced it will be full of crap but have you actually seen it. My son attends a state school and the menu is good.

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 13:26

Great advice thanks all! I will have a look at these lunch boxes.

I know kids (my nephew and a couple of others) that don't watch telly everyday and they don't eat desserts every day and they seem happy and healthy... not aliens!

If only the only way to survive would be to copy others' bad habits.... we would all be smokers, drinkers and heavy substance users! z

Judgement and filtering and teaching a child that it's ok not to follow the mass in order to fit in are great life lessons I think and school lunches a good way to start building confidence, self power and independence!

The nasty food that is out there is everywhere. Even the toast bread if you look at the back says "emulsifiers" meaning that it's processed...

OP posts:
Tarmacadamia · 21/03/2024 13:25

BobbyBiscuits · 21/03/2024 12:46

Pack lunch can be pretty simple, filled roll, fruit, carrots/cherry toms/cucumber then maybe raisins or other dried fruit or a small amount of cereal like Cheerios? I'd say if your child is saying they really want dinners and getting kind of jealous of the others then you could switch next term. But tell the staff only fruit or whatever for pudding except once a week. And still give them a snack pack of veg and raisins etc for breaktime.

For real? You'd have a child singled out as not being allowed to eat the same pudding as everyone else?

MyOtherCarisAVauxhallZafira · 21/03/2024 13:25

Packed lunches aren't an option at DS' school but he has a real variety, every day there is a meat/fish option a veggie option, a pasta or jacket option or a choice of two wraps/sandwiches there is also a salad and fruit bar available every day.
Last week he chose veggie chickpea curry one day with brown rice, roast chicken another with veg, hot black bean and vegetable fajita wrap with side salad and corn cob another, it's better than I'd be giving him in a food flask! Also their puddings are tiny contain no sugar and often have hidden veg, eg the chocolate cake is made with beetroot. They do have ice cream on a Friday but it's one small scoop of vanilla.
It's a standard state school in a mixed socioeconomic area. They also have fruit and milk snack in the mornings.

Thewildthingsarewithme · 21/03/2024 13:23

@idontlikealdi he’s three 😂 I think we’re fine. Also, as a teacher, I’ve noticed that children are becoming a lot kinder and certainly aren’t instigating cruel nicknames anymore, maybe a lesson our gen could learn too 😋

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:23

It depends on the school but my kids’ (state) school have an on site kitchen where everything is cooked from scratch. Meat free Monday, roast dinner on one day, occasional treat days like burgers or pizza but not even every week. Salad or veg with meals, always a meat free option and some really nice more adventurous stuff like curry, cannelloni, fish pie etc.

As others have said, puddings are tiny and made to specific healthy recipes, so a school brownie is nothing like you’d get in Costa.

I once had a spinach and ricotta cannelloni as I was in a meeting and it was excellent.

Don’t jump on the bandwagon and start criticising the school before you’re even there- ask about the things you’re worried about and make an informed decision. Personally in your position I would give school meals a try but make the evening choices super healthy if you’re worried.

And not sure what you mean by your alternative but just remember that there’ll be 1-2 supervisors at school lunch and no facilities to reheat food, they won’t be able to do that, so unless your evening dinner leftovers can be eaten cold that’s unlikely to be a good idea to streamline things.

5foot5 · 21/03/2024 13:22

MabelMaybe · 21/03/2024 12:58

Having seen how kids responded to a child who had taken in pasta and pesto for their lunch (Urgh, she's eating green stuff!, what's that green? etc.) I'd let them have school dinners. They can have jacket potato every day and dodge the processed food, but our school only does battered fish / fish fingers on Friday so there may be less than you think.

Too right!

When DD was in reception I used to send in packed lunches because I planned for her to have her main meal with us in the evening. I used to send in a little pot of hummus with carrot and cucumber sticks - a snack she genuinely liked. But apparently, according to the other kids, it looked like poo!

Anyway I soon found in that first year she was too tired and hungry in the evening to eat with us so I put her on school dinners and cooked something else for her as soon as we got in at about 5:30.

BTW all this pudding hate. I went to school in the 1960s/70s when we had proper pudding and custard every day. Didn't see do many overweight children then though!

Blondeshavemorefun · 21/03/2024 13:21

Cold leftovers - really ?

You would eat lasagne or shepherds pie cold

You will if hungry enough

I cba to make packed lunch so mini blondes has school dinners and will when in yr 3 and pay for them

We have a nice menu and some of her fav are lentil pizza / best pizza ever mummy

And their curry - chicken and rice

I think you are being too anal. Most schools make sure have veg and fruit for lunch

idontlikealdi · 21/03/2024 13:20

They will want to do what their friends do. Wait and see which way that goes.

Mine went through phases of wanting school lunch and not.

They IME don't tend to eat that much anyway, they want to go and play which is why they come out of school hungry.

@Thewildthingsarewithme your poor kid will end up being known as fish boy or something equally as daft. We sent left overs in a thermos, or ramen, or pasta but not fish.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 21/03/2024 13:20

This week my child has had:

Chickpea Dahl curry
Chilli chicken with rice
Roast gammon, roast potatoes and veg
Margherita pizza and garlic bread
Fish fingers and chips and peas.

They top up from the salad bar as necessary.

That's a pretty decent mix of food, and doesn't demonise any food groups. It's all cooked on site, and the salt, sugar etc is monitored over the course of the week.

A school "cake" is not the same as a cake you would buy in a shop for sugar levels thanks to Jamie Oliver.

Pretz123 · 21/03/2024 13:19

uhOhOP · 21/03/2024 13:14

You think it's a "drama" to be mindful of what food is fed to a child? The food industry has got most of you where it wants you, it seems. It's fine for adults if that's what they accept, but not really for children who depend on adults to make the right choices for them.

I think all schools have to consult with nutritionists and their food is as balanced as it can be within their huge constraints. I also think teachers have way too much to deal with day to day than to add in additional pet requests from parents. Honestly if it's such an issue go with packed lunches or a mix 🤷‍♀️
Hence, I don't see an issue!