Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School lunches - reception - please help!

194 replies

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 12:40

Our DC will start reception in September, currently he is going to the nursery.

I am trying to figure out what is best - school lunches vs packed lunch.

I really don't want to go to the school lunches route (despite them being for free) as the quality won't be as good as a packed lunch. It will be full of sugars, processed bread, meat, fried things, frozen things, ready made chips, pasta and potatoes, puddings etc. which are not the best for a kid to have them every day. Once a while I get it but pudding every day? Why?

On the other hand if I go with the packed lunch I read everywhere that it's such a faff and a huge commitment and it will kill me. However, we all cook for ourselves once a day, don't we? I mean either when we come back home from work, or whenever it suits us. Most adults eat home cooked food every day either for lunch or dinner (some privileged for both). So, why not saving a small portion of whatever we are having for ourselves the day before and make a packed lunch with that plus some salad, fruit on the side? What is the faff about that?

It's an honest question as I think I am missing something!

AIBU - You clearly don't understand how hard that is
AINBU - It's not too hard , I think you are right

OP posts:
lilsupersparks · 21/03/2024 16:25

The school dinners appear unhealthy but some effort goes into making them balanced. Pizzas will be wholewheat based, sausages will have a certain amount of meat content, puddings are made with very limited sugar etc - and the portions are very small so it’s not like your kid is filling up on junk.

most primaries will use an outside contractor so I’m sure the nutrition info will be available on their website.

as far as packed lunches go - making 5 packed lunches a day is not my favourite tbh. And we never ever have leftovers from dinner.

i advise a bento style box to cut down on packaging too. Mine have 3 pieces of fruit and veg, a carb option (pasta salad, sandwich or ham and cheese croissant) an extra bit of protein (yes, sometimes processed but otherwise cubes of cheese or something similar), a cereal bar (I find the cheapest ones often the best nutritionally!) and a pack of crisps or mini cheddars. Sometimes a sweet treat like a frube or chocolate bar. It’s definitely not much healthier than the school meal option but it’s much cheaper! Of course you will be able to do healthier options if you are just making one lunch, I can only dream!!

potato57 · 21/03/2024 16:19

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 15:45

@PuttingDownRoots I make loafs at home , we have a bread maker. Just flour, water, salt and dry yeast. No emulsifiers!

@KomodoOhno Yes first kid... so I have no clue! It's just the pasta option, potato option every day sounds weird to be a healthy and variable diet for the kids that are picky!

Bread maker bread tastes awful. If you're going to make it from scratch make it properly. I guarantee your kids will be obsessing over non-bread-maker-bread in their adult lives, they'll never want to eat it again.

Emmacb82 · 21/03/2024 16:08

I really miss having the choice of free school dinners now mine is in junior school. My youngest will be starting in reception and I will be encouraging him to have them. The options at his school are mainly healthy, chip day once a week, and a lot of the time the puddings are yoghurt and fruit pots. But to be honest he would have a pudding at home anyway so I don’t see the problem in a tiny cake.
My eldest has packed lunches now and as much as I can send in healthy veg sticks and fruit, he’s much more likely to leave that stuff than he would have done having school dinners. At the moment he’s not cottoned on to the fact he could throw bits in the bin and brings it all home so I can see what he’s eaten but he probably eats less healthier now than he did when dinners were free.

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 15:45

@PuttingDownRoots I make loafs at home , we have a bread maker. Just flour, water, salt and dry yeast. No emulsifiers!

@KomodoOhno Yes first kid... so I have no clue! It's just the pasta option, potato option every day sounds weird to be a healthy and variable diet for the kids that are picky!

OP posts:
nyorksdad · 21/03/2024 15:33

That's ours for first week after the holidays for my reception child - lot healthier than when I was at school! . Packed lunches are an absolute faff and you'll get fed up getting a lunchbox back filled with squashed bits of uneaten food!

School lunches - reception - please help!
KomodoOhno · 21/03/2024 15:30

Is this your first child going to school?

PuttingDownRoots · 21/03/2024 15:25

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 15:14

To be fair at work I never buy lunch, like sandwich or whatever else, I always bring my lunch box when in the office. It's an expensive habit buying lunch every day.

So I bring the food I prepared the night before, which many times I am not bothered to heat in the microwave.

Today for example it was steamed broccoli and cauliflower, two packs of boiled prawns (quite many of them to keep me full), a slice of bread plus some cheese and fruit.

I find the combo sandwich/crisps for lunch a bit unhealthy if it's an every day thing.

Of course, as with everything, in moderation it is ok!

I am not sure what profile I have been given in this thread but I am a normal person!

If that's the sort of thing your child will eat,send that.

But its ironice to say sandwiches ate unhealthy when you had bread with your lunch...

LyricalGangsta · 21/03/2024 15:22

Ok so.... I assist in a school kitchen and I certainly think that maybe your primary school isn't adhering to the guidelines.

We don't have a deep fat fryer - NOTHING is fried, ever.

Frozen chips are oven chips and once a week. Fishfingers are oven baked.

All potatoes ie wedges are cut freshly from baking potatoes

'Roast potatoes' are cut and oven baked with the smallest amount of sunflower oil possible

Pasta sauces and pizza topping sauces are packed full of blitzed vegetables

Chocolate cake is packed full of blitzed pears or apples depending what's there - kids don't even realise they are in there

Jacket potatoes are offered daily as some kids want that every day - the parent pre orders so if you don't want your child to have that every day, don't order it for them

Meat free alternatives like quorn are used as it's not healthy to depend entirely on dairy protein every day for vegetarians

Pizza dough is made from scratch

Carbohydrates are essential for growing kids so meals contain protein with a side of carbs (potato/pasta sometimes/rice) and veg

Fruit, organic yoghurt and salad are available every day to add to plates as the kids wish

The cook actually spends a lot of time and effort to make meals that fit the guidelines, are cost effective and things the kids will actually eat, which is probably the hardest part!

shrodingersvaccine · 21/03/2024 15:18

Yeah, I also always take my lunch but

A. I am an adult who can open tupperwares, and use cutlery, without pouring the food everywhere, or burning myself etc etc

B. If there was a free, nutritionally balanced lunch (because school lunches are balanced) available that everyone else was having and eating round the table together I would always go for that, wouldn't you?

Stickerchart · 21/03/2024 15:14

To be fair at work I never buy lunch, like sandwich or whatever else, I always bring my lunch box when in the office. It's an expensive habit buying lunch every day.

So I bring the food I prepared the night before, which many times I am not bothered to heat in the microwave.

Today for example it was steamed broccoli and cauliflower, two packs of boiled prawns (quite many of them to keep me full), a slice of bread plus some cheese and fruit.

I find the combo sandwich/crisps for lunch a bit unhealthy if it's an every day thing.

Of course, as with everything, in moderation it is ok!

I am not sure what profile I have been given in this thread but I am a normal person!

OP posts:
shrodingersvaccine · 21/03/2024 15:13

No one has yet pointed out that even if you reheat last nights dinner in a thermos and send it in - your kid needs to be able to open it, and pack it back up again themselves.

There's often only 2/3 staff members trying to get 400-odd kids through the lunch hall in max 1.5 hours. If the kid can't open in it they probably won't be able to eat it as staff won't necessarily do it for them, and they'll lose the thermos within a week when they can't get everything back into a lunchbox again. You'll also need to fiddle with temps so it won't be too hot or cold when they do manage to get into it.

Mulhollandmagoo · 21/03/2024 15:13

Username917778 · 21/03/2024 12:50

It might be different in Scotland, but our school dinners are nothing like what you've mentioned. My daughter only goes on the days it is something she likes though. Do you have to commit? Can you not do both?

Same here, the only 'crap' lunch is on a Friday where they have fish fingers and chips! They do dessert though, it's usually a choice between yogurt, jelly a cookie or a piece of cake, it it's not a big hunk of cake with custard it's just a little brownie or something (which baffles me, as these wouldn't be allowed in a packed lunch!) I'm lucky as natural yogurt is a firm favourite for my daughter so she usually picks that!

Packed lunches aren't as complicated as you're worries about to be fair, you will get a list of things not allowed and just work around that, a PP is correct lots of children have packed lunches due to allergies so the list will be non negotiable, but you could definitely have sarnies, fruit, veggies, cheese, yogurt etc.

Goldbar · 21/03/2024 15:07

This is 5 meals out of 21 meals a week. The standards around school meals are quite strict. I really wouldn't give this one headspace. Assuming you spend an average of 10 minutes per day planning/making a packed lunch, that's almost 32 hours over the course of the year that you could spend doing something more enjoyable. And your DC gets to eat with their peers.

ManonDe · 21/03/2024 15:07

I'm obsessed with food (but am sadly saddled with a child who has a range of sensory issues around food and disabilities and who eats next to nothing) so I have just had an enjoyable hour or so pootling around the various primary school menus in our area.

Things like courgette cake; cakes made with a sweet potato base; brownies made with mashed black beans all feature. Plus all the pasta is wholemeal in one school which sounds pretty revolting tbh.

But I've printed out some of the menus with the aim to follow them closely at home in the hope I can pique the interest into DS1. (He's 14, weighs 5 stone and is under a paediatric dietician).

Sweetcorn and courgette fritters served with tzatziki and salad is on the menu at one for Meatfree Monday. That sounds really good to me. Won't pass muster with DS1 but I'd quite like it.

Also all seem to have a roast day.

It's very different from my day in the country where I was brought up(Thank Goodness!)

redalex261 · 21/03/2024 15:05

Oh, and if you go for a thermos style container to attempt to provide something hot - make sure your child can open it successfully unaided. Mine couldn’t get lid unscrewed as it tightened due to heat inside. When eventually she could get it open it took so much wrestling she ended up covered in contents.

The lunch supervisors won’t open anything for them.

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 21/03/2024 15:01

This is an example of our school meals....lots of variety.
She still has her home cooked meal when she gets home.
The portions aren't big either.

A lot of meal times are about socialising etc. the people who eat packed lunch are in a different area...however in reception all children in the year have school meals

School lunches - reception - please help!
Apollo365 · 21/03/2024 14:58

School dinners are great here, the cake isn’t real cake, it’s beetroot etc. and pudding is usually fruit/yogurt. Personally I’d give it a go so your child gets to pick from the menu and go and get their food with friends. It’s a good little bit of independence for them.

Noseybookworm · 21/03/2024 14:58

Beezknees · 21/03/2024 13:01

Why is some form of potato or pasta every day a big deal? That's pretty normal. I eat a portion of carbs like that every day.

Exactly 🙄 carbs are not the enemy - growing kids need carbs! Wholewheat pasta is an option and it's tastier too.

FloofyBird · 21/03/2024 14:51

I doubt they're going to pander to no puddings, or tuna only once. week on their baked spud either. Schools don't have time for that for every child and if they do it for one they'd have to do it for all (allergies and medical reasons excluded obviously)

FloofyBird · 21/03/2024 14:50

If you plan on sending your child with cold leftovers from the night before that aren't usually eaten cold, you'll probably find school calling you with safeguarding concerns.

CactusMactus · 21/03/2024 14:41

Buy a little thermos pot. Then you can do fried rice, pasta, noodles, chunky soups, re-heated left overs.
Or little bento boxes - humus, veg sticks, olives, hallumi.

School dinners are rank at our school. Pizza, fish fingers, beans, chips, baked potato everyday. My kids hate them.

Favouritefruits · 21/03/2024 14:40

Just do what you think is best, both my kids have packed lunches as they’re not really into big gravy meals and pies so it was an easy choice. It would be lovely not having to faff about making lunches though!

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 21/03/2024 14:39

The menu won't be what you think it is.

Pizza will be low salt, with vegetables etc. blended in the sauce.
Chips etc. will be oven cooked, not fried.
Cakes will be low sugar and will have hidden vegetables.

And so on. Yes, it says "pizza" or "cake" or "chips" but it won't be the same as the food you get in supermarkets. The portions are tiny and it's all "healthy" etc.

Crowgirl · 21/03/2024 14:32

Just give your kid a packed lunch until / if a day comes when you can't be arsed then stop.

We largely avoid UPFs at home and have done for decades - much longer than the current new craze for it. But I'm very relaxed out and about / with friends/ play dates whatever. I try to mostly buy organic too - but you cant control every little thing. I get why you care. You just have to do what works your family and not worry about others choices.

I promise you kids tend to eat FA at school anyway so they won't be getting too many emulsifiers in.

Plain potato/ pasta exist because there are plenty of kids who won't eat anything and then the afternoon becomes a write off. My school tried to get rid of them to encourage a more varied diet and had to bring them back.

Pudding is yoghurt and fruit though - except Fridays.

BobbyBiscuits · 21/03/2024 14:30

@PotatoFan that's why I said OR a special diet. I was just giving examples where the parents wouldn't want them to have puddings every day. But there doesn't need to be a medical reason.