Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not allowing my daughter to bring her boyfriend home for Easter?

190 replies

SparklyTealPanda · 21/03/2024 11:51

My daughter (born 2003) has spring break from 29 March to 26 April. She's currently studying in London. She said she wants to come home starting with next Friday for an extended visit (around a week). That part is wonderful. Now here's what the problem is: she's been dating a man born in 1982 since early 2023 (met in late 2022). That's a 21-year age gap. I ABSOLUTELY HATE IT. Obviously my husband and I let her know that we disagree with their relationship multiple times, but she's an adult and can do whatever she wants at the end of the day. We're just making sure that she remains financially independent and doesn't isolate herself from us.

Well, remember that extended visit I mentioned? Yeah, she wants to bring him along too. I said bloody hell NO. I don't support her relationship, I don't want to meet her boyfriend, and especially don't want him in my house; neither does my husband. So we told her, if you're coming, you're coming alone. Or you're coming with your boyfriend, but he's staying at a hotel and we don't meet eye to eye. She said no, if he's not coming, she's not coming either, it's simple. Said she really wanted to spend some time with us and the family, but if we're being this unreasonable, then she'll just go to his country house in Surrey and spend Easter / the break there with him and his family.

When my husband heard that she's not coming at all, he told me to call her and tell her that fine, she can bring the boyfriend; he really wants to see his daughter, misses her. I, on the other hand, don't think that we should back down so easily.

OP posts:
Rosindub · 21/03/2024 16:38

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:47

You are going about this ALL WRONG!

Invite him to stay and get the measure of him, show your daughter that you accept her choices. See how they are together.

If you think he’s a dick, be nice to him, flirt with him, but subtly draw attention to his age- “oh it’s lovely to be someone who knows good music, what was at no 1 when you were 16 Colin? Oh how much that we have so much in common! Oh look at you tidying up, so nice how someone slightly older doesn’t need telling what to do in the house. You’ll make someone a lovely husband (nudge nudge). How big your little Johnny is getting, he’s a great kid, must be so nice to have the baby years out of the way. Grandad next huh!!”

I can guarantee that your daughter will be 🤮

Unless it is genuine true love. In which case better get used to it!

Her daughter will be 🤮 because her mother will be making a fool of herself with such obvious tactics.

Nanny0gg · 21/03/2024 15:08

HussellRobbs · 21/03/2024 13:28

OP, let me guess, you’ll be expected to cook and host for the week?

Isn't that normal when your children come back to visit briefly?

Nanny0gg · 21/03/2024 15:05

Peekaboobo · 21/03/2024 11:56

I never allowed boyfriends/girlfriends over - just had a blanket rule about it.

Could you do that?

Even if they're serious?

DilemmaDelilah · 21/03/2024 15:03

I would say that he can come, but separate bedrooms please and you want her to pull her weight with the hosting. So it is obvious that he is a guest (welcome or not) and she is family so has to muck in. Who knows - you may like him! Regardless of your feelings about the age gap. We can't pick who our children call in love with, unfortunately, and you are running the risk of driving her away. It sounds like she really wants to introduce him to you - you should give him a chance.

Toomuch44 · 21/03/2024 14:55

I'd let him stay, that way I'd be able to get a feel for the chap - might turn out he proves you wrong. Also, if the relationship ends up being serious long-term, him not being welcome is one way of pushing your DD away.

When I was 17, I went out with a chap who was 38. He was a perfect gentleman and treated me well. The first couple of times he came to pick me up, my parents were at the door obviously to vet him, but he said he totally understood why and they actually found they liked him. Give the chap a chance.

Pottedpalm · 21/03/2024 14:53

supermamio · 21/03/2024 12:05

Is the age gap your only issue with him?

Yes its a huge age gap and i understand that its hard to understand what a man his age sees in a much younger girl, but shes old enough to make up her own mind. A family member of mine has a 31 year age gap, he has kids older than her and they got together when she was 18, no one approved but theyre still together 19 years later and now no one even notices the age gap. As long as he treats her right, id accept her choices.

So she’s 37 and he’s 68 and no-one notices the age gap??😮

2Rebecca · 21/03/2024 14:43

Some people on here do love a bit of doom mongering. We must all be people pleasers and put on our smiley faces as saying no even once leads to eternal damnation!

2Rebecca · 21/03/2024 14:42

I agree I'd say I'm happy to meet him but a week is a long time to inflict a house guest on someone for. Why does he want to come for that long? I don't think I ever stayed with any of my boyfriend or husbands' parents for as long as a week.

Azandme · 21/03/2024 14:42

SparklyTealPanda · 21/03/2024 13:25

No, I'm British, my daughter uses spring break to refer to the Easter holiday since that's how it's written on the LSE academic calendar; so it stuck with me. One week is an extended visit for us 'cause ever since she started uni she has only visited for like a weekend at a time during holidays; she has other things to do in her free time I guess.

And the ONE time she actually wants to, you shut her down...

You really are screwing up your relationship.

She won't bother even coming for weekends if you carry on - and even if this relationship ends, she won't forget. The choices you make now will have consequences for years, possibly forever. So even if this relationship DOES end, and she winds up with someone you deem more suitable, it doesn't mean they'll visit. Or bring any children to see you.

LondonerCalling · 21/03/2024 14:36

GR8GAL · 21/03/2024 13:31

"...she is an adult...".

Don't need to read any more. You are being unreasonable. At least give the guy a chance and count your lucky stars she's not with some 20 something year old empty-headed waster!

There is nothing here that would make me want to thank my lucky stars. A 20-year-old dating anybody over 30 is concerning to me and over 35 is downright creepy. Nothing will change my mind on that. Age gap relationships are deeply
concerning to me and turn my stomach.

BashfulClam · 21/03/2024 14:12

I’d want to see what he was about so I’d ‘welcome’ her bringing him.

KreedKafer · 21/03/2024 14:08

I think you need to ask yourself what's more important to you. Is it:

a) your disapproval of your daughter's choice of partner, or
b) your relationship with your daughter?

I completely understand why you think your daughter's partner is bad news. I think most people would. But I think that by being this rigid about it, you will simply drive your daughter away and will actually make her more likely to stick with him. I know this because my own family's disapproval of a much older boyfriend (I was 22, he was 42) was what made it a lot more difficult for me to dump him when I should have done, because I couldn't bear the thought of proving them right.

It's also worth noting that in my case, the man was wrong for me because he was an arsehole, not because he was 20 years older than me. If my family had said 'He isn't making you happy' or 'It's not OK for him to treat you like this and we're really worried about you because you don't seem well' then I actually might have listened. But instead they said 'He's too old for you', which was absolutely focusing on the wrong thing. In fact, the age gap was literally the one thing in the relationship that wasn't a problem.

My advice would be that you don't have to have this man staying under your roof, but that you should at least agree to meet him and be civil and get to know him and see how he is with your daughter. You don't have to like him or approve, but you do need to know more about him beyond 'He is old and his situation seems off' if you are to be able to have rational conversations with your daughter about this.

GR8GAL · 21/03/2024 14:04

HussellRobbs · 21/03/2024 13:50

Stop being ageist and there's no need for a next time.

I made the choice to share my opinion. You made the choice to be offended, and chose to accuse me of being ageist. My choice now is to ignore you :)

TempleOfBloom · 21/03/2024 14:00

We're just making sure that she remains financially independent and doesn't isolate herself from us.

But you are hell bent on making sure she isolated herself from you!!!

Why do you think she hasn’t been to stay for longer than a weekend? Because you have made your disapproval clear. Now she is giving you the chance to wave an olive branch and you are throwing it in her face.

Keep your mind open, make your home welcoming.

Of you will lose her, and understandably.

VivaDixie · 21/03/2024 13:58

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:47

You are going about this ALL WRONG!

Invite him to stay and get the measure of him, show your daughter that you accept her choices. See how they are together.

If you think he’s a dick, be nice to him, flirt with him, but subtly draw attention to his age- “oh it’s lovely to be someone who knows good music, what was at no 1 when you were 16 Colin? Oh how much that we have so much in common! Oh look at you tidying up, so nice how someone slightly older doesn’t need telling what to do in the house. You’ll make someone a lovely husband (nudge nudge). How big your little Johnny is getting, he’s a great kid, must be so nice to have the baby years out of the way. Grandad next huh!!”

I can guarantee that your daughter will be 🤮

Unless it is genuine true love. In which case better get used to it!

Please don't take this advice OP

Medschoolmum · 21/03/2024 13:55

OP, yanbu to be less than thrilled about your dd's relationship with a much older man. I wouldn't like it either.

But you're being very unreasonable not to respect her choices as an adult, and in the long term, you will just end up driving her away. Is that what you want?

HussellRobbs · 21/03/2024 13:50

GR8GAL · 21/03/2024 13:49

Doesn't change my opinion. Better luck next time.

Stop being ageist and there's no need for a next time.

GR8GAL · 21/03/2024 13:49

HussellRobbs · 21/03/2024 13:39

Your age doesn't excuse you from making ageist comments. Duh.

And I didn't assume your age so your ASS joke makes no sense.

Edited

Doesn't change my opinion. Better luck next time.

Spirallingdownwards · 21/03/2024 13:48

@HussellRobbs At no point has even the OP suggested that the DD and her bf want waiting on hand and foot at all. You seem to have your own little narrative running on to.

OP -how would you feel if the bf was say 26 with a child? Is it the child that is the issue (as well as the age gap) because you suggested this was another reason. Nowadays there are all sorts of blended families and people with a child or children from previous relationships. They can't just be "diaappeared". I think its lovely that your DD gets on well with his son and vice versa. It would be very easy for the son to be the one putting a spanner in the works.

So you say your DD only generally comes home for a couple of days at a time even during unk holidays. Why is that? Does she have work commitments in the holidays or have you previous exerted over controlling traits that has led to her not wanting to come home.

Maybe as someone says she wants an extended visit so she can show him off and you get to know him properly because she is ready to take the next step with a man who at the age of 42 has a country house in Surrey and can afford boarding school fees for his son.

JustTalkToThem · 21/03/2024 13:48

HussellRobbs · 21/03/2024 13:36

What are the odds that OP will be expected to do the hosting though?

Why should she have to cook and clean up after a random man for a week?

Don't project your own relationship onto OP. Many couples share hosting duties - there's nothing here to suggest the OP's DH won't do what's necessary.

Also when my DH and I used to stay at my parents home, it was barely "hosted". It was my family home, so we still did all the normal things like make our own breakfasts, lunches, help with or cook the dinners and offer to make it for my parents, clean, do the shopping, wash-up, all the normal stuff.

chippylips · 21/03/2024 13:47

The most sad part about this is that it probably took OP's dd a lot to even ask. OP if I were you, I'd be on the phone apologising and offering a compromise. That you'd love to meet him but a week is perhaps too long. Otherwise you risk losing her altogether

Topseyt123 · 21/03/2024 13:47

I understand why aspects of this make you uncomfortable, but you are in serious danger of destroying your relationship with your DD here and surely that isn't what you really want to do!!??

I agree with the way your husband is going about this. His approach is much more likely to keep the lines of communication open between himself and DD.

I guess you have now backed yourself into a corner here, from which the only exit is to back down, which you will probably see as humiliation even though it doesn't need to be (just say that you got it wrong and overreacted).

Your options are probably:

  1. dig your heels in as you are and fall out with DD for a long time, possibly for good.

  2. go along with your husband's approach (infinitely more sensible and measured really) and be less rigid. Maybe they could stay at your house, or maybe in a local hotel or Airbnb. I would let them be at your house to be honest but that's something you'd have to iron out.

  3. book yourself a weekend or a week away on your own and let them come to visit your husband without you there. Then you can continue to ignore them, trash your own relationship with your DD but let your husband maintain his.

There was a case in my own wider family where a parent disapproved of a relationship their adult son had forged with a girl. The reasons weren't age gap related but the parent still tried to interfere and dictate. That was over 30 years ago now. The son and the girl got married and are still very happily together. His parent was told to accept it or lose him because this relationship was non-negotiable. The parent was forced to back down as they wanted badly to keep in communication with their own adult child and family relationships did largely recover over time, thankfully. Lessons were learnt - namely that parents cannot dictate this sort of thing. The parent backed down soon enough to even go to the wedding, where I saw them.

That's what you need to do.

Heronwatcher · 21/03/2024 13:47

You are going about this ALL WRONG!

Invite him to stay and get the measure of him, show your daughter that you accept her choices. See how they are together.

If you think he’s a dick, be nice to him, flirt with him, but subtly draw attention to his age- “oh it’s lovely to be someone who knows good music, what was at no 1 when you were 16 Colin? Oh how much that we have so much in common! Oh look at you tidying up, so nice how someone slightly older doesn’t need telling what to do in the house. You’ll make someone a lovely husband (nudge nudge). How big your little Johnny is getting, he’s a great kid, must be so nice to have the baby years out of the way. Grandad next huh!!”

I can guarantee that your daughter will be 🤮

Unless it is genuine true love. In which case better get used to it!

IggOrEgg · 21/03/2024 13:44

BobbyBiscuits · 21/03/2024 13:42

@HussellRobbs that sounds weird for a man in his 40s to want/need to be hosted for free for a week? Does he work?
Is it just her saying this stuff? Is there a chance if you spoke to him he'd be totally reasonable and immediately agree to the hotel, and be surprised she's making these demands on you? I think you maybe should try and speak to him...she's not acting very adult so maybe he's the best port of call? Or if he acts an arse then you'll know you were right about him.

OP has actually said it’s not just about not wanting him to stay at their home though, she’s said she has no interest in meeting him at all and if they stay in a hotel nearby rather than at OPs home then the daughter is to visit without him. Or that’s certainly how the op reads to me anyway.

VivaDixie · 21/03/2024 13:42

OP have you ever asked yourself why your DD only stays for the odd weekend since starting Uni?

I suspect you were already driving her away before this. The fact that you won't even entertain meeting him face to face is appalling.

FWIW my bestie met her DH when she was 25, he was a 45 yo divorcee with two teenage children. 25 years later they are still together with a teenager. Bestie gets on really well with her DHs now adult kids. They are one big extended family. The DH has a fantastic relationship with his ILs, who are naturally only a couple of years older than him. Oh and the 70 year old guy is one of my best friends.

Get a grip OP