Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my body just wants to hold on to weight !

94 replies

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 06:47

I've been eating so well and exercising so much over the last week- ten days.

I have a good amount of weight to lose, so it should start working reasonably quickly.

I've also done a lot of exercise and I've had a stomach bug. Would you believe it I still have lost no weight ? It's ridiculous !

I've also been exercising most days. I play tennis around 4 times a week and lift weights / gym cardio once a week or so.

Why can't I shift weight !! I've been eating a lot of chicken breast and broccoli and salads, these are my go to foods when trying to lose weight as they're super filling and really filling. Trying to avoid any sweet / starchy / processed foods as they just make me more hungry.

I weight all my food, except vegetables.

OP posts:
MsRinky · 21/03/2024 11:25

I say this with love, but 10 days is nothing. You need to let go of the idea that you need to see quick results for motivation - the time will pass anyway and the alternative to slow progress is no progress or further gain. Work out what you can do sustainably, week in, week out (this is unlikely to be less than an average of about 1800 calories at your weight and activity level) and then do it and keep doing it.

I'm 51, and was also 100kg+. 10 days of diet and exercise did nothing. 10 weeks, I felt different but no-one else noticed. 10 months and I'm 25kg down and people literally don't recognise me. If you want to drop 30 kilos, this is going to take at least a year, probably more, and then you have to maintain it. Consistency is literally everything, so start with what you can sustain. Wish it hadn't taken me so long to work this out, but hey...

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 21/03/2024 10:44

@cushioncovere definitely wouldn't be that then.

Have you thought about possibly trying a personal trainer with a nutrition plan for a month to see if that helps. They might be able to pin point the issue.

I can see your train of thought about starting smaller but for context I was 10 stone 7 starting (slightly overweight according to BMI) and now I am 8 stone 12lbs. I am only 5ft 4 though.

Before anyone shoots me down I don't think 10 stone 7 is in anyway big but after having my second baby I couldn't fit in any of my clothes.

Maybe give it another few weeks as others have said but your definitely doing all the right things so I think there is likely something contributing to you holding on to the weight.

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 10:34

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 21/03/2024 10:25

Do you think you could have a thyroid problem that's affecting your weight?

Between boxing day and early march I lost 24lbs by going to circuit training for 40 mins 3 times a week, walking as much as I could (on mat leave), drinking at least 2.5 litres of water a day and following a diet set out by the gym which is essentially very low carb and high protein.

By doing what your doing I would have thought you would have lost something in 10 days - lots of exercise and low calorie. The first 2 weeks I lost 6lbs and was only slightly overweight starting x

I have quite regular blood test. The last being done in December and it didn't show any issues.

I agree with you, I would expect to have seen some movement.

It's always been an extremely difficult process for me. But I thought because I was smaller and didn't have as much to lose, it was kind of normal.

I only ever lose weight fast if I'm literally starving myself. Think, one meal a day.

When I was on my wedding diet, I used to eat no breakfast and just cucumbers for lunch.

Then at night I would eat chicken and broccoli. I was starving constantly. That's the only way I've ever been able to shift weight. It's really sad and I actually hate calorie counting so much. It makes me feel really sad and obsessive.

OP posts:
Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 21/03/2024 10:26

Should have said I am also similar age. 37 x

Tryingtoconceivenumber2 · 21/03/2024 10:25

Do you think you could have a thyroid problem that's affecting your weight?

Between boxing day and early march I lost 24lbs by going to circuit training for 40 mins 3 times a week, walking as much as I could (on mat leave), drinking at least 2.5 litres of water a day and following a diet set out by the gym which is essentially very low carb and high protein.

By doing what your doing I would have thought you would have lost something in 10 days - lots of exercise and low calorie. The first 2 weeks I lost 6lbs and was only slightly overweight starting x

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 10:20

@crepedechine thanks. That post was so patronising indeed.

OP posts:
crepedechine · 21/03/2024 10:07

strawberryandtomato · 21/03/2024 07:03

If you're eating 2500 calories worth of chicken and broccoli, it's too much.
If you're eating 1500 calories of chicken and broccoli, you'll lose weight.

Which one is it?
Healthy doesn't mean you'll lose weight. Are you weighing and tracking your food?

Who the fuck eats 2500 calories worth of chicken and broccoli? I’m sure op isn’t an idiot.

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 09:54

4timesthefun · 21/03/2024 09:16

My guess is insulin resistance, which would be aggravated by your insomnia. I needed medication to correct my insulin resistance (metformin) but there are tonnes of alternatives. I tried everything else before this and had 0 success. On metformin I’ve been able to eat very normally and lose weight gradually.

Oh really. Ok. I'll look into it. It's always been painfully slow for me and unless I'm literally starving myself, it does not shift. My fear is that I need to be eating around 1000, otherwise it happens too slowly to keep me motivated.

OP posts:
LolaJ87 · 21/03/2024 09:53

Definitely dont cut your calories too low, it has to be sustainable over the long term.

This is so important!

Yes you'll lose weight quickly if you are severely restricting, but if you want steady and sustainable weight loss, then it isn't the way. Trust me, I've done it enough times. Then when you fall off the wagon from over-restricting, the weight just shoots back up.

OP we are similar in profile (I'm 36, have a 15 month old, 5'7'' and over 100kg). I am eating 2,300 calories a day on average and losing an average of 1kg per week, but it took 3 weeks for the scales to start moving. If you're active, you're not going to lose weight as fast. This might seem a bit shit on the scales, but it means you're keeping your muscle while losing actual fat. Crash dieting or other forms of rapid weightloss mean you lose both muscle and fat, which is pleasing on the scale but less sustainable and not as healthy. When I lose weight, I can slowly decrease my calorie intake to keep losses steady and sustainable.

You're going to get lots of recommendations for ways to get that scale moving, but if you stay consistent, it will (provided there's nothing hormonal going on, if you don't see movement on the scales in 4 weeks, it might be worth getting some bloods done).

fishonabicycle · 21/03/2024 09:50

Keep Going - all that exercise will mean your muscles retain extra water for a while. Weight is not just fat, so keep going and it will happen. You didn't gain weight in a week, so you won't lose it either. Be patient x

bettybyebye · 21/03/2024 09:46

I also think you probably need to up your cals slightly, try 1700 instead and that will be more sustainable longer term.
How much water are you drinking? Aim for at least 2l a day
Are you tracking protein as well as cals? Try for at least 100g/day initially, then up to 0.8g per lb body weight.
Lack of sleep can be a factor - difficult with small kids but aim for 7-9 hours per night.
I would up the weights to 3x week if possible as increasing muscle will increase your metabolism.
You sound active in terms of exercise but remember that planned exercise only burns 5% of our daily cals and your NEAT is more important so just increasing steps can be beneficial.
As well as weighing yourself try measurements and progress photos as well.
Would recommend following Sean Casey and the Fitness Chef on instagram. Good luck!

FlabMonsterIsDietingAgain · 21/03/2024 09:37

Definitely dont cut your calories too low, it has to be sustainable over the long term.

I started as 225lb, 5ft 8, 40 yrs old and MyFitnessPal calculated I need to stay under 1670 calories a day. I've stuck to that and lost 21lbs in 12 weeks. Some days I'm a bit under, some days a bit over but over the week it averages out.

I don't eat back exercise calories because I don't fully trust that they're accurate and by reducing carbs and increasing protein and fat I don't often feel hungry enough to need to.

KimberleyClark · 21/03/2024 09:34

Have you had your thyroid checked?

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/03/2024 09:33

I found that when I was on WeightWatchers last year, for a while it went really well. Then I used water rather than skimmed milk on my porridge and it seemed like my body was protesting as the weight I'd lost (almost a stone) didn't want to shift after that.

CrotchetyQuaver · 21/03/2024 09:31

I'm the same height as you and was also pushing 100kg once. I'm 77kg now and still working on it.
It was hard losing the weight but what worked for me was putting all food/drink into my Fitbit app so I could log it accurately. I aimed for 2,000 calories a day in, 2,500 cals "out" and it did work. Agonisingly slowly at a 1lb a week but I had lost a stone after 3 months. Never used to be that hard when I was younger lol.

I really doubt you're burning 3000+ cals a day unless you're cycling miles to work?

waistchallenge · 21/03/2024 09:23

I'd consider doing a bit of intermittent fasting, OP. 16/8 or 18/6. Not necessarily long-term, but just to kick start things a bit, which it is great for.

gettingbackonit23 · 21/03/2024 09:20

Also at 100 kilos and 5’6 there is no way you should do 1200 cals or a 1000 a day deficit. You can probably eat about 1800 and still lose at a good rate. If you go too low you will give up - stick to about 500 cal deficit, lots of walking, strength training 3 days a week and you should get really good results.

Laiste · 21/03/2024 09:20

I know how you feel OP.

I feel that weight which has crept on realllllly slowly (over years) seems to be the hardest to shift.

I have to almost live on nothing but air and be faint with hunger for a week before my body will relinquish a bit of fat 🙄

Once it starts shifting though, it does carry on ...

APART from the week before my period (when i feel like a balloon) and the week i'm on my period when i eat everything not nailed down. I spend the next 2 weeks trying to make up for it before it starts again🙄

4timesthefun · 21/03/2024 09:16

My guess is insulin resistance, which would be aggravated by your insomnia. I needed medication to correct my insulin resistance (metformin) but there are tonnes of alternatives. I tried everything else before this and had 0 success. On metformin I’ve been able to eat very normally and lose weight gradually.

gettingbackonit23 · 21/03/2024 09:16

I am doing something called 30HD which I heard about from a PT podcast I listen to. You set a calorie allowance and exercise etc but you don’t weigh yourself for 30 days and just focus on sticking to the plan (the HD stands for Head Down). Then after 30 days you can weigh and by then you will have already formed healthy habits and there will definitely be some loss if you have stuck to the plan, so you won’t then lose motivation and throw in the towel. I find weighing myself depressing if I haven’t done as well as I hoped.

MiltonNorthern · 21/03/2024 09:14

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 09:12

I do think the calories seem high. But I'm a lot heavier than I was when I last used it.

It worked for me last time. So I guess it's probably more or less ok now. I'll be using a lot more energy doing things than I used to.

I replaced my Fitbit with an Apple Watch and found it was giving me 10-20% higher than the Fitbit was in calorie usage. I sold it after a while and replaced with a Fitbit again. The Apple Watch app is so much less user friendly than the Fitbit one too.

Vanessasbag · 21/03/2024 09:14

LaWench · 21/03/2024 06:50

IMO a week isn't long enough, my body takes around 2 weeks to adjust to healthy changes. Keep going , drink water and it will drop.

This is correct (according to a PT I know). Things you do now, you will see the benefit in two weeks time.

cushioncovere · 21/03/2024 09:12

I do think the calories seem high. But I'm a lot heavier than I was when I last used it.

It worked for me last time. So I guess it's probably more or less ok now. I'll be using a lot more energy doing things than I used to.

OP posts:
MiltonNorthern · 21/03/2024 09:08

Minikievs · 21/03/2024 08:01

@MiltonNorthern I don't think it does include base calories. OP said her apple watch says she burns 3000-3500 a day. Mine says I burn approx 500-800 a day (depending on activity). So that's what I'd use in a post to explain my calorie burn, not the full daily calories (including base). Maybe I've misunderstood 🤷‍♀️
It's a moot point though I guess as OP isn't eating those calories back anyway from the sounds of it.
I agree with your later post regarding her TDEE, and I think OP is probably not eating enough if the exercise has been upped.

Yes you've misunderstood. The calories given by an apple watch always include base calories.

Curlygirli · 21/03/2024 09:01

Have you tried getting a Lympathic massage? They are incredible for getting rid of toxins, decreasing water retention, and increasing the blood circulation.

And to echo what other posters have said, getting lots of fluids (water) is really beneficial for weight loss. Try to only weigh yourself once a month, usually after your period as you can gain anything up to 7lb leading up to your period.

If you’re not getting much sleep either your body could be in survival mode and holding on to weight to protect you. I remember when my DS wasn’t sleeping well for months and i just couldn’t budge the weight.