Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe everyone who says they wish their parents divorced

105 replies

KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 21:48

For people who grew up in homes that were abusive or toxic or just unhappy, do you truly really wish your parents had split? Even if it meant spending your life between two homes? Even if it meant spending days and days with the abusive/toxic/unhappy parent?

My parents had issues. Im an only child. My dad was an angry and drunk man. Although my childhood was pretty miserable I think I might have been more unhappy being at dad's home by myself for long periods of time.

I'm interested in people's thoughts and reflections.

OP posts:
catscalledbeanz · 20/03/2024 23:02

Three days a week living with abuse is better than 7 days a week living with abuse AND having that be your primary example of relationships/ parenthood/ boundaries/ norms.

However in my case- both my parents are bearable, even nice people. Apart. I love spending time with my mother- she's witty and funny and has a dark humour which is. coupled with an understanding of human nature and life. She is a ball.
My dad is gracious, kind and the life and soul of every party. Charming and exuberant. He is one of my favourite men in the world.

Together my parents bring out only the very worst in each other- my mothers dark humour and wit becomes bile and cruel venom. My fathers spirit, that outgoing confidence and natural charm becomes obnoxious, and domineering. Neither are abusive parents directly. By staying together I grew up in an abusive home and it wasn't until adulthood I found out that they are great people who love me. The toxic atmosphere ruined my childhood . They thought they were doing us a favour

HungryBeagle · 20/03/2024 22:46

KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 22:30

This is exactly what I mean. As miserable as the fights or tension were, I always had my mum. I can't imagine being 6 or so and being with my dad without my mum. He wasn't physical but he was furious and intimidating and never had anything to say to me. I would have hated it!

We didn’t all have abusive parents though. Just parents who had a toxic relationship with each other. It was a massive relief when they split and I could spend time with them individually, instead of together in a horrific atmosphere. That’s why I’d rather mine had split earlier.

Foxblue · 20/03/2024 22:45

The thing is, is what you are asking also means 'do I wish my parents stayed together, unhappily for my sake'
I'd be surprised if you could find anyone who would say yes to that.
Look at how many people who now feel like their childhood was a lie because their parents stayed together until they were 18 then split.

Having read probably hundreds of experiences over the years, the discomfort and annoyance of feeling shuttled round in your childhood, while can be anxiety inducing and disturbing for kids, pales in comparison to the long term damage done to kids and their view of relationships when growing up witnessing a dysfunctional relationship, especially one where the parents pretend it's all fine and normal.
Think about it - a feeling of 'not having a place' in childhood is unpleasant, and im sure there are cases where its led to a lot of unrest, but abuse and dysfunction cycles are perpetuated through generations - you see it on posts here, people will say 'that's how my dad was with my mum so I've grown up thinking it was normal' - and that's just one way it perpetuates.

KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 22:30

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 20/03/2024 22:26

Very glad my parents divorced and b) that it happened at an age when contact was led by me.

Had I been say under 10, however, I can't imagine how awful contact weekends would have been.

This is exactly what I mean. As miserable as the fights or tension were, I always had my mum. I can't imagine being 6 or so and being with my dad without my mum. He wasn't physical but he was furious and intimidating and never had anything to say to me. I would have hated it!

OP posts:
KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 22:26

I'm also sorry for all the upsetting childhoods described here. Its heart breaking. I do agree that when there is abuse like that...certainly splitting is the right thing to do of course.

OP posts:
EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 20/03/2024 22:26

Very glad my parents divorced and b) that it happened at an age when contact was led by me.

Had I been say under 10, however, I can't imagine how awful contact weekends would have been.

KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 22:25

@mindutopia and would you have felt this relief if your dad had demanded overnights do you think?

I'm trying to establish if people who say they wish their partners have divorced would feel the same in this 5050 world where kids are forced to spend time equally?

OP posts:
BuzzerCompany · 20/03/2024 22:23

I would have had more sleep at least. Trying to sleep whilst keeping my fingers in my ears to block out the arguing, shouting and screaming as my dad hit my mum, was really difficult.

mindutopia · 20/03/2024 22:22

There is no guarantee of living between two homes even with divorced parents.

Mine had a miserable marriage. It was such a relief when they divorced. I felt free. I was 10. I never spent a single night at my dad’s with the exception of a holiday with him and his partner when I was probably 16/17. He’d come to visit. I might go for Christmas lunch with his side of the family. He’d come see my school play. Never had a single overnight, which was great. I don’t think he had much interest in being that sort of parent. And probably enough sense to realise he was shit and shouldn’t try.

ZipZapZoom · 20/03/2024 22:14

Twolittleloves · 20/03/2024 22:11

This sounds abit 'holier than thou'...tantrums are a normal part of toddler development, and raised voices on occasion don't make someone a bad parent or produce troubled kids :-/ It shows kids that it's normal as a human to feel anger, or get stressed sometimes.
And show me a kid that has never had an episode of 'bad' behaviour ever, and I'll show you a pig that flies 😂

I think you underestimate just how much growing up in a toxic environment where shouting etc was the norm fucks you up.

The poster isn't saying they are perfect or holier than thou they are recognising how their current life is as a direct result of the environment they grew up in.

curlymam · 20/03/2024 22:12

100%, my parents split when I was 13 and it was such a relief. Going between two happier homes was much better than the awful home we were living in before.

Twolittleloves · 20/03/2024 22:11

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 20/03/2024 21:55

@Zanatdy totally agree. 4 kids, never a raised voice, never any tantrums, bad behaviour, no smacking (different generation then), all in good relationships, good jobs and DP and I also never argue.

This sounds abit 'holier than thou'...tantrums are a normal part of toddler development, and raised voices on occasion don't make someone a bad parent or produce troubled kids :-/ It shows kids that it's normal as a human to feel anger, or get stressed sometimes.
And show me a kid that has never had an episode of 'bad' behaviour ever, and I'll show you a pig that flies 😂

Meadowfinch · 20/03/2024 22:02

No-one can understand another's situation.

I wish my dm had found the courage to leave. We wouldn't have had to see f any more because he wouldn't have bothered and we would have been rid of him a lot sooner.

But she didn't - it wasn't the done thing then- and so each of us had 18 miserable years except little sis who jumped ship shortly before her 16th birthday.

WandaWonder · 20/03/2024 22:01

I have great parents and no issues between me and them but I am glad they divorced as they are not suited to each other, no issues apart from being incompatible

Why they got married I have no idea

PlumbersWifey · 20/03/2024 22:01

Better to separate but kids shouldn't be sent with abusive drunk parents anyway.

ZipZapZoom · 20/03/2024 22:01

HungryBeagle · 20/03/2024 21:59

And not all involve a dysfunctional parent. Mine were great parents apart, it was just their relationship that was awful and toxic.

You're right that's very true. Many parents that don't work together are still good parents individually so again it wouldn't be a lonely place to be if the parent was a good parent but a poor partner.

HungryBeagle · 20/03/2024 21:59

ZipZapZoom · 20/03/2024 21:56

Why wouldn't you believe them I thinks it's pretty accurate.

Also realistically in most of these situations the child wouldn't have a lot of contact with the dysfunctional parent so no need to spend long periods of time to be lonely with them

And not all involve a dysfunctional parent. Mine were great parents apart, it was just their relationship that was awful and toxic.

TesticularHeft · 20/03/2024 21:57

I spent years wishing for my parents to separate. When they did it was a huge relief. A big change with its own upheavals but it taught me much healthier things about a relationship than watching them.

MyBreezyPombear · 20/03/2024 21:57

My parents were toxic together which lead to an incredibly traumatic childhood. Seperately though they were decent parents and I was so much happier when they split

ZipZapZoom · 20/03/2024 21:56

Why wouldn't you believe them I thinks it's pretty accurate.

Also realistically in most of these situations the child wouldn't have a lot of contact with the dysfunctional parent so no need to spend long periods of time to be lonely with them

TattiePants · 20/03/2024 21:56

I absolutely wish my parents had divorced many years before they did. They finally separated just before my 16th birthday. The constant arguments, affairs and regular domestic violence has impacted me way more than having divorced parents ever would. Realistically, would your dad have even wanted to have you living with him for part of the time?

PurBal · 20/03/2024 21:55

My parents definitely should have divorced 20 years ago. Not physically abusing but toxic. It’s even worse now I’m an adult and not living at home.

HungryBeagle · 20/03/2024 21:55

Yes I did. Mine split when I was 8 for about a year but got back together. I wish they’d stayed apart. They did eventually split again when I was 18, but that still meant far too long living in a house with 2 people who clearly despised each other. Neither were abusive and I was happy spending time at both houses in the brief period they were apart. Together they were toxic, and home was miserable.

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 20/03/2024 21:55

@Zanatdy totally agree. 4 kids, never a raised voice, never any tantrums, bad behaviour, no smacking (different generation then), all in good relationships, good jobs and DP and I also never argue.

Kinneddar · 20/03/2024 21:54

My friends parents have been married 50 years. She wishes they had split up about 40 years ago.

She'd have far rather lived in 2 houses with parents who would have been happier & might have met & married other people