Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe everyone who says they wish their parents divorced

105 replies

KungBooPanda · 20/03/2024 21:48

For people who grew up in homes that were abusive or toxic or just unhappy, do you truly really wish your parents had split? Even if it meant spending your life between two homes? Even if it meant spending days and days with the abusive/toxic/unhappy parent?

My parents had issues. Im an only child. My dad was an angry and drunk man. Although my childhood was pretty miserable I think I might have been more unhappy being at dad's home by myself for long periods of time.

I'm interested in people's thoughts and reflections.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itsonlymashadow · 21/03/2024 17:36

KungBooPanda · 21/03/2024 15:24

I suspect quite a few people feel like you @dinkydonky Of course all the stories of abuse and violence - its indisputable that its right to leave - but otherwise I think most kids would rather have parents cohabiting without much love, than living in 2 homes.

I think you might be right.

If both parents have made this decision before resentment and bitterness has set in. Most people really try to make a relationship work stay long after it should have ended. By which point living together in a healthy environment is very difficult. Plus at least one will be very hurt about the split.

Relationships usually end when the bad feeling between the 2 is at a high point. At which point people feel shit about all the things that have happened leading up to it. Or there’s one big things that’s so devastating there’s no coming back from it, like cheating. Pretty hard to live together then

If people still like each other, treat eachother well and with respect, mortally supportive (especially over things like childcare) and work like a team so the house is happy, you might have a point.

However, that’s very rare. And in most cases would mean people splitting up earlier and not putting in several years of effort (at least from one person) trying to make it work.

Lemondenim · 21/03/2024 15:45

I had many years of wishing that when they were trying to “stay together for the kids” and the relief and calmness when it happened was amazing, they were toxic together and truelt better apart.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 21/03/2024 15:42

This is of course very subjective. My parents didn't like each other and mostly avoided each other. From about 16 I believed they were waiting until my much younger sister grew up to separate but one sadly died quite young so it never happened. I am very grateful that they were together growing up, I was mostly unaware of the hostility between them as they were always civil to each other and protected us from their issues. Whether they argued in private or not i do not know. I can imagine they were exhausted from putting on a front but it was worth it for the sake of a stable home life for us.

BlingLoving · 21/03/2024 15:34

I used to wish that my parents would divorce. What's interesting though is that while a lot of what was going on was NOT okay, I found as a young adult I was able to process a lot of these issues and actually, come out the other side. My parents also really mellowed as they grew older so in retrospect, I think it's' probably good they didn't split up.

But, having said that, I don't think that's necessarily true for everyone and I think in our case, my dad didn't always behave well. BUT the big difference is that everyone was genuinely trying their best. I can look back now and think, "ok, yes, that specific behaviour wasn't okay" but I can also think, "but on the other hand, I wasn't walking on eggshells all the time, I genuinely felt supported by my parents etc". DH's dad, on the other hand, was largely absent. Both of his parents were harsh, and erratic, disciplinarians and DH's childhood and early teen years were largely him trying to get away from how shit his life at home was. I think, looking back, he would still agree that them divorcing would have been better.

JonVoightBaddyWhoGrowls · 21/03/2024 15:29

Of course people are right it's impossible to know what life would have been like if our parents had separated. It may have been better but I know one friend who persuaded her mum to leave her dad (who was a total arsehole) and her mum had a psychotic breakdown post separation and is still not able to live independently.

I think you're missing the point. Of course a parent having a breakdown and being unable to live independently is not a better choice. But when people say they wish their parents had divorced, what they mean is that they think that things WOULD have been better if they weren't in those toxic environments.

Certainly, I am confident that DH and his siblings would have MUCH better off his parents had divorced much sooner. And certainly, I don't think it's a co-incidence that they've all struggled with relationships. In DH's case, he's managed to get it right with me but honestly, it has been really really hard at times and one of the things I love about him is that he's really put the effort in to unlearn all the lessons he learnt growing up.

KungBooPanda · 21/03/2024 15:24

I suspect quite a few people feel like you @dinkydonky Of course all the stories of abuse and violence - its indisputable that its right to leave - but otherwise I think most kids would rather have parents cohabiting without much love, than living in 2 homes.

OP posts:
dinkydonky · 21/03/2024 13:00

A different perspective, my parents stayed together for the kids and split when we were adults.

In hindsight, I think the relationship was loveless and they might have been happier separately, but it wasn’t toxic/abusive and certainly not to me and my siblings. I often see similar situations described on here and people are often encouraged to leave the relationship.

I am so, so glad my parents stayed. I would have absolutely hated living between two houses, my parents were both very involved in my life day to day and I would certainly have lost out if we were shipped between them instead of them being able to split responsibilities relating to the various kids between them. I’m grateful that they were both able to prioritise us over their own desires and not create a toxic environment for us to grow up in.

Beezknees · 21/03/2024 12:42

KungBooPanda · 21/03/2024 12:09

Thank you for sharing all your stories. Some of them are fucking horrendous and all credit to you for surviving it and also having such insight and perspective on what you went through

Of course people are right it's impossible to know what life would have been like if our parents had separated. It may have been better but I know one friend who persuaded her mum to leave her dad (who was a total arsehole) and her mum had a psychotic breakdown post separation and is still not able to live independently.

I am just interested as people often tell women on here to protect their kids and leave but I think that can feel like the opposite of protection for some women, it can feel like abandonment.

That is not usual. Most women who leave unhappy marriages end up much happier.

Itsonlymashadow · 21/03/2024 12:28

KungBooPanda · 21/03/2024 12:09

Thank you for sharing all your stories. Some of them are fucking horrendous and all credit to you for surviving it and also having such insight and perspective on what you went through

Of course people are right it's impossible to know what life would have been like if our parents had separated. It may have been better but I know one friend who persuaded her mum to leave her dad (who was a total arsehole) and her mum had a psychotic breakdown post separation and is still not able to live independently.

I am just interested as people often tell women on here to protect their kids and leave but I think that can feel like the opposite of protection for some women, it can feel like abandonment.

I very much doubt your mums friends breakdown was simply due to leaving her arse hole husband. That one thing isn’t what triggered it.

I can see why women choose to stay sometimes. But more often than not ‘I am staying with him because of the kids’ is actually ‘I am staying because I am afraid of the alternative and being alone’ and I do get that. It took me 3 years to actually leave.

But it’s not staying for the kids. And very often the kids would be better off if they did split.

Hoplolly · 21/03/2024 12:18

I feel my parents should have divorced. I asked my mum once why they didn't when I was about 16, and she said because she had nowhere to go. What a sad life. I'd have been happier for her to have gone and found her own life, my dad made her live a very sheltered life, away from friends and family which got worse when she had to give up work aged 40 due to ill heath.

I have great parents and no issues between me and them but I am glad they divorced as they are not suited to each other, no issues apart from being incompatible Why they got married I have no idea

I am divorced and my children have said the same! @WandaWonder

GoodbyeErinsborough · 21/03/2024 12:13

My parents separated when I was 18. They had stayed together for us when we were kids.

I absolutely do wish they had divorced earlier. The tension in the house was unbearable at times and I often didn't go home because of it. I understand why they stayed together but feel that they haven't really shown us what a healthy relationship looks like.

KungBooPanda · 21/03/2024 12:09

Thank you for sharing all your stories. Some of them are fucking horrendous and all credit to you for surviving it and also having such insight and perspective on what you went through

Of course people are right it's impossible to know what life would have been like if our parents had separated. It may have been better but I know one friend who persuaded her mum to leave her dad (who was a total arsehole) and her mum had a psychotic breakdown post separation and is still not able to live independently.

I am just interested as people often tell women on here to protect their kids and leave but I think that can feel like the opposite of protection for some women, it can feel like abandonment.

OP posts:
Saymyname28 · 21/03/2024 08:49

My parents split. It was horrible, I barely saw my dad, my mum had loads of boyfirends. They slagged eachother off to me all the time. I cannot imagine the hell it'd have been if they'd stayed together though, mum was really explosive, she'd have been physical alot, dad was cruel and quite frankly a bully. It would have been hell.

Whatonearth2021 · 21/03/2024 08:42

Did anyone here experience their parents divorce come out of the blue? For mine that’s what happened. He left after me being aware of an issue for 6 months and we were careful not to argue in front of the children. They told me they had no idea it was coming. In many ways this worries me as their world fell apart over night. I can see how it might impact their trust in relationships. This is why I’ve worked very hard to coparent well. We still do birthdays / Xmas as a family. But it does worry me a lot.

takemeawayagain · 21/03/2024 08:38

I agree with you OP. My dad wasn't great but I am eternally grateful that my parents stayed together. Having to sell the house, move god know where, see my dad on his own, cope with my parents having other relationships, potentially having step brothers and sisters. That all would have been my worst nightmare.

It's not the case for everyone and of course it depends on just how bad thing are but I'm very glad they stayed together.

MrsDrDear · 21/03/2024 08:32

We divorced our parents. Sat them down (teens) and told them it was time to call it a day.
Knew DM was unhappy and DF was the best dad ever but they argued all the time.
They were a bit stunned I think, it hit home then what an effect it was having on us.

Once they separated, both got on so much better and still see each other every day.

They stayed in their marriage for us, but it was the wrong thing to do. We wanted 2 happy parents growing up, but it took until we were mature enough to make the decision for them.
I wish they'd have done it when we were younger.

Cathbrownlow · 21/03/2024 08:23

Yes, I think social pressures in the past have a lot to answer for. So many unhappy marriages and unhappy children because of the fear of ostracism or disapproval.

Confrontayshunme · 21/03/2024 08:20

My mother stayed with an emotionally abusive, coercive control based relationship. She didn't love him and still doesn't, but she stayed because church told her marriage is through everything, and she would be judged for leaving. Now he has dementia and is in a care home trying to sleep with other women while guilting her constantly for leaving him there and being an all-round awful person. So she is spending her last healthy years trying to care for someone who is even more openly abusive.
I blame church for the ongoing abuse I suffered because she felt unable to divorce.

MissMarplesNiece · 21/03/2024 08:15

When I was 12 my dad started to see other women. He'd disappear for hours, coming home in the early hours or being out all weekend. It took until I was 15 for them to divorce. That was 3 years of them arguing & fighting.

They then took a further 4 years (until I was 19) for them to come to a final settlement. All that time we lived in the same house - my dad had some rooms, we had others. When DM & DF were even within a few yards of each other they argued & fought. It was like those two bits of an atom bomb that come together to cause an explosion. It happened every day from breakfast to bed. I don't think I ever fell asleep before one or two am because I'd be waiting for DF to come home and the rows to start. I never asked friends round.

All during that time they played childish games & my siblings & I were pawns. My brother recently told me he was so scared & anxious he used to wet the bed when they were fighting (he's a lot younger than me).

So, I really wish they'd separated properly when I was 12. Me, my DSis & my DB all have life long mental health problems.

Cathbrownlow · 21/03/2024 08:13

I remember sitting in my room aged 13 listening to my dad screaming at my mum, and wishing that my mum would leave my dad and take me with her. But I knew she wouldn't - they were a different generation and different times. She was a housewife with no income and she was weak and foolish. He was a nasty bully. Plus I had a sibling with SEN who also made everyone's life a misery although obviously not his fault. My mum would never have coped.

bibliomania · 21/03/2024 08:11

Are you afraid of what will happen to your dc if you divorce, op?

I left my ex when dd was 18 months. He was emotionally abusive and it was harmful for her to spend time alone with him. Would it have been better together? No. He was extremely jealous of the relationship between her and me (in his own early childhood, he had been forced to choose his very scary father over his mother). Being in separate homes meant she could cuddle me without him flying into a rage or physically removing her from me. I was able to be my real self again. She spent over half her time in a calm environment.

He was so obviously toxic that the school became concerned. I went back to court and an order was made that he had to have a third party present during his contact. It still wasn't ideal, as he would pile on the charm with them and confuse her by being nasty when he felt he could get away with it.

As soon as she could, she dropped contact. For a teen, it's been infinitely better for her to be able to make that call.

HollyKnight · 21/03/2024 08:01

God, yes. But I do wish the non-abusive parent pushed for more contact rather than just accept EOW. Still, EOW was more peace than I got when they were together.

InWalksBarberalla · 21/03/2024 07:53

My parents did divorce and I think overall it was better. I still had to spend time with an abusive parent but I also got some time in a household without that abusive parent so that was a bonus. And whilst it was generally pretty toxic post divorce (with both parents dragging us kids into their ongoing battles) on balance it was more toxic when they lived together.

ZipZapZoom · 21/03/2024 07:52

WishesPromised · 21/03/2024 07:47

My parents did divorce and then get back together.

What I wish is that they sorted themselves out because it's hard to say which was worse - when they were together. Each circumstance was utterly dreadful for my sibling and me.

Mine did the same. Only in my case it was complete with getting married again to each other and finally more than a decade later they got divorced again when all their children were adults.

The divorced periods were indefinitely better than the together periods.

WishesPromised · 21/03/2024 07:47

My parents did divorce and then get back together.

What I wish is that they sorted themselves out because it's hard to say which was worse - when they were together. Each circumstance was utterly dreadful for my sibling and me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread