Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Laikalaika · 22/03/2024 10:37

ApplePippa · 22/03/2024 10:31

But you can't either just cancel over a thousand years of history and culture either - that's how long we have been culturally christian. It's a very significant chunk of our heritage, whether you like it or not.

I'm not sure harking back to ancient pagan religions is really all that helpful either. I doubt many people (neo pagans aside) really have that much appetite for getting involved in goddess worship, but just use it as an excuse to bash Christianity. I'll stand corrected when I see shrines to Eaostra popping up!

I also find it odd that people believe that just because Paganism is older it has somehow had more of an impact on Western culture as we know it. This really isn't true. So much of what we do, how we think and speak have been conditioned by centuries of Christendom.

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 10:37

Laikalaika · 22/03/2024 10:28

There is 0 doubt that Jesus existed, that he jad a very large following because of his teachings, and that he was executed. No credible historian denies this.

There is very little firm evidence outside Christian references.

ApplePippa · 22/03/2024 10:31

benefitstaxcredithelp · 22/03/2024 09:02

As seen on this thread many people today in Britain do not consider the Christian Easter tale as foundational to our culture anymore. It doesn’t resonate with many people anymore.
That era has moved on in my opinion. Even in a church school most of the parents aren’t actually religious. Hence the OP questioning the story. It’s normal and healthy to question things in this way.

But you can't either just cancel over a thousand years of history and culture either - that's how long we have been culturally christian. It's a very significant chunk of our heritage, whether you like it or not.

I'm not sure harking back to ancient pagan religions is really all that helpful either. I doubt many people (neo pagans aside) really have that much appetite for getting involved in goddess worship, but just use it as an excuse to bash Christianity. I'll stand corrected when I see shrines to Eaostra popping up!

Laikalaika · 22/03/2024 10:28

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 09:48

Yes but Mohammed isnt supposed to be the son of God is he?
I am of no religion but I find the existence of Mohammed easier to believe than that of Jesus, although to me its all rubbish and if a religious person cant deal with me saying that then their Faith must not be very strong.
I support anyones right to their Religion as long as it does no harm (and lets face it most of them do) but I have the right to say I think its all just stories made up by men to control people

There is 0 doubt that Jesus existed, that he jad a very large following because of his teachings, and that he was executed. No credible historian denies this.

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 10:12

She loves it
The Good Place I mean, Quote failed

KT1112 · 22/03/2024 10:12

i seem to be in the minority but I agree its too graphic for young children. I also didn't like my children being taught about the resurrection, which led my little ones to ask if people who we had lost could come back to life. I'm not against religion being taught, but in an age appropriate way. Lots of things might be factual but we have to deliver them in an age appropriate way.

cakeorwine · 22/03/2024 10:11

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 10:07

My DD opines that Religious people who do good things should be celebrated LESS than those of us who do so because its the right thing to do rather than due to being afraid of a mythical being and expecting to be rewarded for it in a made up place after death.
She came to this conclusion during her RS GCSE course.
I think she may have a point

She should watch The Good Place on Netflix. Very much a part of the philosophy - it's a comedy but with philosophy about being good, heaven and morals all thrown in.'

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 10:07

Sallyblackcat · 22/03/2024 07:12

Is it a church school? If so, then followers are expected to understand the sacrifices that Jesus made for us, (If that's what you believe), even from an early age. If anything, it teaches key values as a decent human being for believers and non-believers.

My DD opines that Religious people who do good things should be celebrated LESS than those of us who do so because its the right thing to do rather than due to being afraid of a mythical being and expecting to be rewarded for it in a made up place after death.
She came to this conclusion during her RS GCSE course.
I think she may have a point

KimberleyClark · 22/03/2024 10:00

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 09:48

Yes but Mohammed isnt supposed to be the son of God is he?
I am of no religion but I find the existence of Mohammed easier to believe than that of Jesus, although to me its all rubbish and if a religious person cant deal with me saying that then their Faith must not be very strong.
I support anyones right to their Religion as long as it does no harm (and lets face it most of them do) but I have the right to say I think its all just stories made up by men to control people

Organised religion is very much about controlling women.

Parker231 · 22/03/2024 09:57

cakeorwine · 22/03/2024 09:53

But this is taught in UK schools - and it is compulsory to teach Christianity. We are Christian country apparently.

Surely we have the right under freedom of speech to question it - especially as it's compulsory in our schools.

And the Christian church significantly impacts on our "Constitution" what with Charles and all

Thank goodness for non British schools where there is separation of church and state

Parker231 · 22/03/2024 09:56

Sallyblackcat · 22/03/2024 07:12

Is it a church school? If so, then followers are expected to understand the sacrifices that Jesus made for us, (If that's what you believe), even from an early age. If anything, it teaches key values as a decent human being for believers and non-believers.

A Bible story has zero impact on teaching someone good values.

cakeorwine · 22/03/2024 09:53

Bunnygirl1902 · 22/03/2024 09:42

It amazes me that this thread hasn't been deleted yet. If everyone was referring to Islam and making jokes about Mohammad or saying he was made up and fake or speaking about that religion the way people on this thread are talking about Christianity it would have been taken down instantly.

Everyone has a right to believe in what they want. There is no need to disrespect other peoples faith just because you don't believe in it.

Grow up and learn some respect.

But this is taught in UK schools - and it is compulsory to teach Christianity. We are Christian country apparently.

Surely we have the right under freedom of speech to question it - especially as it's compulsory in our schools.

And the Christian church significantly impacts on our "Constitution" what with Charles and all

Hoppinggreen · 22/03/2024 09:48

Yes but Mohammed isnt supposed to be the son of God is he?
I am of no religion but I find the existence of Mohammed easier to believe than that of Jesus, although to me its all rubbish and if a religious person cant deal with me saying that then their Faith must not be very strong.
I support anyones right to their Religion as long as it does no harm (and lets face it most of them do) but I have the right to say I think its all just stories made up by men to control people

Bunnygirl1902 · 22/03/2024 09:42

It amazes me that this thread hasn't been deleted yet. If everyone was referring to Islam and making jokes about Mohammad or saying he was made up and fake or speaking about that religion the way people on this thread are talking about Christianity it would have been taken down instantly.

Everyone has a right to believe in what they want. There is no need to disrespect other peoples faith just because you don't believe in it.

Grow up and learn some respect.

Parker231 · 22/03/2024 09:21

Nigglenaggle · 22/03/2024 09:08

Surely it's supposed to be horrifying? It's an awful thing to do to someone who is guilty, let alone innocent. It's good that she's horrified. Jesus being crucified, whether you believe he was the son of God or not, is history, not a story. It happened and it's awful and we should remember to be better than that now.

I do get that it stings to see your children come into contact with the horrors of the world, but it has to happen and it's our job to bring them up to be people who rage against it, not wrap them up and pretend it isn't there. 2000 years ago is long enough ago to be a gentle start.

Mind you, I was reading mine Beowulf with monsters and snapping spines in it by that age, so I might not be the best judge 😜

In that era many people were probably killed in horrific circumstances. Jesus was just one of them - no need to focus on one individual case.

Nigglenaggle · 22/03/2024 09:08

Surely it's supposed to be horrifying? It's an awful thing to do to someone who is guilty, let alone innocent. It's good that she's horrified. Jesus being crucified, whether you believe he was the son of God or not, is history, not a story. It happened and it's awful and we should remember to be better than that now.

I do get that it stings to see your children come into contact with the horrors of the world, but it has to happen and it's our job to bring them up to be people who rage against it, not wrap them up and pretend it isn't there. 2000 years ago is long enough ago to be a gentle start.

Mind you, I was reading mine Beowulf with monsters and snapping spines in it by that age, so I might not be the best judge 😜

benefitstaxcredithelp · 22/03/2024 09:02

Laikalaika · 22/03/2024 08:46

Surely it depends on how culturally significant the story is? I wouldn't read a 5 year old a macabre storybook by a random author, but the Easter story is so foundational to Western culture that to not teach it is to leave them embarassingly ignorant.

As seen on this thread many people today in Britain do not consider the Christian Easter tale as foundational to our culture anymore. It doesn’t resonate with many people anymore.
That era has moved on in my opinion. Even in a church school most of the parents aren’t actually religious. Hence the OP questioning the story. It’s normal and healthy to question things in this way.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 22/03/2024 08:48

JanglingJack · 21/03/2024 04:38

This.

Also it would have been through his wrists as the nails would not have been to support a human body.

This did make me laugh. Mumsnet taking it to the next level. 😂

OP - on the same theme presumably the teacher did not mention they stuck a sword in his side to finish him off when he irritatingly did not die?

She’ll have forgotten about it next week especially if you are not churchgoers and she won’t see crucifix’s on a weekly basis.

Brace yourself. She will learn about much worse barbarism as she goes through school.

Laikalaika · 22/03/2024 08:46

jen337 · 21/03/2024 21:28

Most sane people would agree that exposing children to graphic violent imagery is not acceptable. Shows how effective religious indoctrination is that people are queuing up to defend it on here.

Surely it depends on how culturally significant the story is? I wouldn't read a 5 year old a macabre storybook by a random author, but the Easter story is so foundational to Western culture that to not teach it is to leave them embarassingly ignorant.

cakeorwine · 22/03/2024 08:40

I am curious as to why people insist that a 5 year old needs to know the FULL details - and not just that he was left to die on a cross.

And in reality, they aren't told the FULL details - they aren't told that he was whipped so hard that the skin came off his back. They are told that he was whipped but not told exactly what that meant.

Why are people insisting that a 5 year old needs to know the details of the nails? Why not just stick with he was left to die on a cross? They have plenty of time to revisit the story and to be told the full glory details?

Duggeehugs82 · 22/03/2024 08:30

ruhroh · 21/03/2024 23:40

Are you referring to my post? It's rather the opposite isn't it?

Teachers and parents are more cautious than ever. Small children nowadays (not teens though!) live in a far more sterilised, sanitised, censored world than any previous generations. I don't necessarily mean this in a bad way, just an objective way.

What was a "fun fact" for my generation (and I'm only in my 20s) would be labelled "traumatising and inappropriate" today – see OP's and your post!

Anyway, as a child I had an insatiable curiosity for historical facts & general knowledge, and if my child does too I certainly wouldn't say no to developing their intellect.

Edited

Religion is only a 'fun fact' to religious people. People who are Atheist don't belive any religious story is a fact, let alone a 'fun fact'!

Duggeehugs82 · 22/03/2024 08:27

jen337 · 21/03/2024 21:28

Most sane people would agree that exposing children to graphic violent imagery is not acceptable. Shows how effective religious indoctrination is that people are queuing up to defend it on here.

This what confuses me! 90% of people are saying she is unreasonable to not want her child be exposed to torture, and then when children are exposed to torture is other ways by media, film and games it's a massive issue ! Why is religion given a free pass? So bizarre!

GrammarTeacher · 22/03/2024 08:05

It's worse than that though. It was through his wrists. Crucifixion wouldn't work through the hands. The Romans knew what they were doing when it came to brutal killing. It's not nice. It's not meant to be.
Also raised Catholic. I can't remember not knowing this.

timetorefresh · 22/03/2024 07:27

I was told the nails were prob through his forearms as just through his hands prob wouldn't sustain enough weight.

Sallyblackcat · 22/03/2024 07:12

Is it a church school? If so, then followers are expected to understand the sacrifices that Jesus made for us, (If that's what you believe), even from an early age. If anything, it teaches key values as a decent human being for believers and non-believers.