Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
crikesdostop · 20/03/2024 23:38

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter

But it's not just in the spirit of Easter, it's literally what Easter is all about. Bunnies and eggs are pagan.

WhatWhereWho · 20/03/2024 23:37

You could tell her it's all bollocks anywhere. Or that he was a magician who was able to dull the pain.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/03/2024 23:37

I remember learning about this as a kid. Blood and gore is pretty par for the course with Christianity 😂

jen337 · 20/03/2024 23:36

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

Is this irony? Easter was originally a pagan festival celebrating spring, fertility and all that, so all about bunnies and eggs! It was hijacked by Christianity and ruined with all this sadomasochistic torture mythology, which actually never happened allegedly occurred around the Jewish festival of Passover.

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 20/03/2024 23:35

CountryMumof4 · 20/03/2024 22:42

As a daughter of a vicar, who spent her childhood largely in churches, I can categorically say that I wasn't traumatised by this. Even after the reading of the Passion on Palm Sunday, and the (quite frankly, very depressing and sad) services on Maundy Thursday and Good Friday). Easter is a huge event in the Christian calendar. Children will learn about it from a very early age, as will they learn about mummification and Mayan history (which includes sacrificing children). It's not pleasant, but I don't know any children who have been actually traumatised by it. Perhaps upsetting and conversations needing to be had with parents about it, but it is part of culture - even if not a religion that someone is actively involved in. Children are resilient - far more than adults, sometimes.

That said, it's hard for a parent to see their child upset, and I'm sorry if yours has been. I'm certainly not disputing that children (and adults) could have a very real human reaction to learning about it, because it's hard to hear.

I can assure you my son was deeply upset by the idea that god could bring Jesus back from the dead but wasn’t prepared to do the same for his loved one. Not an easy thing to explain to a very sad 5 yr old 🙄

AlltheFs · 20/03/2024 23:33

NoMoreLifts · 20/03/2024 23:28

70s Catholic schoolgirl here. Whole class made to feel stupid in RE cos 'of course he wasn't nailed through the palms? How do you think that would hold up a whole body?'
We were 7 or 8. Prob none of us were psychopaths who'f ever thought about the practicalities of crucifixion.

I can confirm I am no psychopath and I very much did ponder the practicalities as a little person!

Our village does a cross walk thingy between 2 churches at Easter, half tempted to go along and ask if they will be demonstrating the actual method including the nail placement.

Sillypede · 20/03/2024 23:29

Mum2jenny · 20/03/2024 21:48

It’s religion, get over it. It’s good that kids get taught about Christianity and the key facts relating to it. Easter is not all about bunnies and Easter eggs.

Facts?

EverybodyIsFantastic · 20/03/2024 23:29

AlltheFs · 20/03/2024 23:21

Interesting- I always wondered about this as a young child, I couldn’t fathom how nails through the hands would work but it wasn’t something you could really ask!
Wrists make sense.

I think it’s ok @TaFox , DD will start at a CofE school this year and it’s what I expect her to be told.

Which does also mean, awkwardly, that stigmatics typically get their stigmata in the wrong spots…

Fact fans, crucifixion is mostly likely to kill you via suffocation. If dehydration didn’t get you first.

NoMoreLifts · 20/03/2024 23:28

EverybodyIsFantastic · 20/03/2024 21:55

Jesus was mildly tickled on the cross?

(In fact, he wasn’t nailed through his hands. The Romans almost certainly crucified through the wrists. Hands wouldn’t have supported the body’s weight.)

70s Catholic schoolgirl here. Whole class made to feel stupid in RE cos 'of course he wasn't nailed through the palms? How do you think that would hold up a whole body?'
We were 7 or 8. Prob none of us were psychopaths who'f ever thought about the practicalities of crucifixion.

Greenbike · 20/03/2024 23:27

Flandango · 20/03/2024 22:53

Jesus of Nazareth as a real person is very much in dispute among historians. There is no primary evidence of his existence. That doesn't mean he didn't exist but it is not correct to say it is not in dispute

I am unaware of any professional historians of the ancient world who dispute the overwhelming likelihood of Jesus’s existence. There is no primary evidence of almost anybody in the ancient world other than emperors, kings, generals etc (and a few famous writers of course). A figure called Jesus who was executed is as well attested as any figure in Palestine at the time, in fact remarkably so given his low status.

See this article from the Guardian, written by a professional historian, for a helpful overview.

Guardian article

What is the historical evidence that Jesus Christ lived and died? | Christianity | The Guardian

Today some claim that Jesus is just an idea, rather than a real historical figure, but there is a good deal of written evidence for his existence 2,000 years ago

https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2017/apr/14/what-is-the-historical-evidence-that-jesus-christ-lived-and-died

BlueEyesBrownHair · 20/03/2024 23:25

Easters about a fluffy happy bunny spreading cheer to people with chocolate easter eggs! Were athiest in our house

AlltheFs · 20/03/2024 23:21

EverybodyIsFantastic · 20/03/2024 21:55

Jesus was mildly tickled on the cross?

(In fact, he wasn’t nailed through his hands. The Romans almost certainly crucified through the wrists. Hands wouldn’t have supported the body’s weight.)

Interesting- I always wondered about this as a young child, I couldn’t fathom how nails through the hands would work but it wasn’t something you could really ask!
Wrists make sense.

I think it’s ok @TaFox , DD will start at a CofE school this year and it’s what I expect her to be told.

BobbyBiscuits · 20/03/2024 23:16

If you don't want her to be Christian just say the Jesus thing is just a story, and of course noone gets nailed to crosses and dies and come back to life. But some people believe it, just like the Easter bunny. It's all nonsense and the main crux is you get chocolate.

mynameiscalypso · 20/03/2024 23:14

They have a special assembly for stations of the cross at my DS' school where they tie a Year 5/6 child to a cross.

I remember being fascinated by the idea of crucifixion when I was in Reception nearly 40 years ago. It's actually the only bit of Reception I can remember at all.

110APiccadilly · 20/03/2024 23:13

Dogdilemma2000 · 20/03/2024 21:55

I mean it’s right central to the mainstream religion of this county - it’s what the whole religion revolves around.

I assume the teacher missed out the bit where the guy on the next cross got his eyes plucked out by crows?

As that (the crows bit) isn't in the Bible, I'd be surprised if it were included. I think it was made up for the Passion film, though it might have come from some traditional (but non-Bible) source.

AntonFeckoff · 20/03/2024 23:08

I learnt about this in Sunday school and I actually did lose sleep over it. I was quite traumatised. I kept imaging how it would feel to have nails hammered through your hands, and the image of him on the cross dripping with blood still disturbs me to be honest. I don’t like seeing crucifixes.

Koulibiak · 20/03/2024 23:07

GetWhatYouWant · 20/03/2024 22:53

Even if you don't believe it( I am an atheist and brought my children up as atheists), don't you think that as Christianity is the majority religion in this country and has had a huge and fundamental impact on our history over the past two millennia, that you should explain the basics of it to your children, in terms of general knowledge? Even if you just stick to explaining about Christmas and Easter, and say that while many people believe it, you don't, you're helping to give your children a more rounded view.

I agree with this. I’m also an atheist. My children have a lot of curiosity over religions, in fact DS is RS captain at his school despite being a non believer.

As an aside, there are lovely children’s books that give children a counterpoint to the “foundation myth” of Adam and Eve. One is called “Older than the stars”, and explains to children in a very lovely way that they are made of stardust.

NamelessNancy · 20/03/2024 23:05

EverybodyIsFantastic · 20/03/2024 21:55

Jesus was mildly tickled on the cross?

(In fact, he wasn’t nailed through his hands. The Romans almost certainly crucified through the wrists. Hands wouldn’t have supported the body’s weight.)

I genuinely thought, having read the title, that the OP was bothered by the error re hands vs wrists! Nails would just rip through the hands.

Edit: looks like I'm not alone!

Viviennemary · 20/03/2024 23:03

Easter isn't about chocolate eggs and bunnies. But I suppose a sensitive child could find details of the crucifixion scarey. I remember clearly being told in quite graphic detail the nails were likely through the wrists. Never forgot that.

CurrentlyChipped · 20/03/2024 23:01

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

Well. 'The word Easter' comes from the spring goddess Eostre and there was a pagan spring festival on the equinox long before Christianity. According to the site I'm linking to, celebrating with coloured eggs date back to at least 580 BCE in Persia. In Ukraine, Pysanka eggs historically honored the sun god father of Eostre's child until Christianity came to Ukraine. Rabbits and hares have also been traditionally associated with the spring fertility festival

https://eu.sctimes.com/story/opinion/2022/04/16/traditions-easter-and-cultural-appropriation-eostre/7317930001/

Traditions of Easter and cultural appropriation of Eostre

Eostre is the pagan fertility goddess of humans and crops

https://eu.sctimes.com/story/opinion/2022/04/16/traditions-easter-and-cultural-appropriation-eostre/7317930001

BumpyaDaisyevna · 20/03/2024 22:59

I think the point of the crucifixion was that it was quite ... horrible.

I dont think it would be appropriate to give a small child a blow by blow account of exactly how crucifixion kills you and how Jesus would have felt and how long it would have taken him to die would be appropriate.

But the basic element of the story - that he was nailed to the cross - I think that's fine if horrible. Four year olds aren't wallflowers they can cope.

Parker231 · 20/03/2024 22:59

GetWhatYouWant · 20/03/2024 22:53

Even if you don't believe it( I am an atheist and brought my children up as atheists), don't you think that as Christianity is the majority religion in this country and has had a huge and fundamental impact on our history over the past two millennia, that you should explain the basics of it to your children, in terms of general knowledge? Even if you just stick to explaining about Christmas and Easter, and say that while many people believe it, you don't, you're helping to give your children a more rounded view.

DT’s didn’t go to a British school so didn’t have religious education. We have told them stories of different cultures and they have friends of many different backgrounds and beliefs.
We don’t lie to them so they have grown up being able to make their own decisions about faiths. They are also atheists.

Koulibiak · 20/03/2024 22:58

KnickerlessParsons · 20/03/2024 22:30

Lots of people were nailed to the cross, not just Jesus. It was a fairly common punishment.

I was taught that most convicts were merely tied to the cross, but that Pontius Pilatus (sp?) had ordered a harsher punishment for Jesus as he was subverting authority?

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 22:56

EverybodyIsFantastic · 20/03/2024 21:55

Jesus was mildly tickled on the cross?

(In fact, he wasn’t nailed through his hands. The Romans almost certainly crucified through the wrists. Hands wouldn’t have supported the body’s weight.)

Genuinely thought this was going to be a thread about the weird idea that you could hang someone on a cross by nailing their hands to it. Anatomically implausible.

Alas, it is not.

WinterMorn · 20/03/2024 22:56

Come on OP, you can’t seriously have an issue with this but still want to celebrate Easter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread