Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
WinterMorn · 21/03/2024 00:18

Nichebitch · 20/03/2024 23:45

Of course Easter is about chocolate and bunnies for a toddler ffs. I grew up in a catholic country with all the gore and I rather keep the fluffy version, thank you very much. The graphic details are unnecessary, even if you want to educate in the religious bit

Since when is a 5yr old attending school a toddler?

Toddlerteaplease · 21/03/2024 00:14

NorthCliffs · 20/03/2024 21:50

My 4 year old son carefully examined a particularly gruesome crucifix on a table in a Catholic church. He said 'Where's his socks? Aren't his feet cold?' and moved on.

Love it!

JudgeJ · 21/03/2024 00:14

cakewitch · 20/03/2024 22:09

My child came home from nursery and asked me why Jesus had got nailed to a cross. Utterly inappropriate thing for preschool children to be learning about, and I made my feelings known very strongly.

Oh, lucky them!

Toddlerteaplease · 21/03/2024 00:13

Well he was nailed to it. Kids at my church and in church schools don't seem particularly bothered by the sight of a crucifix.

SwordToFlamethrower · 21/03/2024 00:10

The Easter Bunny and the eggs stuff has been stolen from pagan Ostara, along with all the good parts of Christmas.

Catsmere · 21/03/2024 00:09

"Easter was a pagan festival taken over for indoctrination" misses the detail that religions absorbing elements of other beliefs is hardly limited to Christianity. The Romans had plenty of temples and blended or rebranded deities on other pagan sites. Other pagan peoples did the same.

ForestBather · 21/03/2024 00:09

Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 00:06

I think the horror of it is a key plank of Christianity: here is a man who agreed to be tortured and humiliated to redeem your sins. He gave up his life so you can go to heaven. The torture is an intrinsic part of the story. The shocking gruesomeness can’t be evacuated from it without losing the potency of the symbol.

It's the whole foundation of Christian guilt!

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 00:08

Easter is technically not about a story of a bloke being murdered on a cross. It’s not the ‘true’ meaning of Easter at all. It’s the Christian take on it.

Easter was appropriated by Christianity from the pagan Anglo-Saxon springtime festival ‘Ostara’ which was all about celebrating the spring equinox, the arrival of new life and ‘resurrection’ happening in nature.

OP @TaFox i don’t think yabu. It’s not really an appropriate story for children when you really stop to think about it more deeply than ‘well I was told the story and I survived’.

Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 00:06

I think the horror of it is a key plank of Christianity: here is a man who agreed to be tortured and humiliated to redeem your sins. He gave up his life so you can go to heaven. The torture is an intrinsic part of the story. The shocking gruesomeness can’t be evacuated from it without losing the potency of the symbol.

SwordToFlamethrower · 21/03/2024 00:06

Happy spring equinox, because that is happening right now. Druids, witches and pagans have been celebrating the balance of the day and night today.

Easter happens at a different date each year because it is calculated by putting it at the first weekend after the spring equinox and full moon, which is in 4 days. So Easter is next weekend, because of the pagan calendar of sabbats.

Pagans honour birth, death and rebirth, female creative power.

Christians are obsessed with malecentric everything, torture, death and mourning. It is front and centre of the whole relogion.

ForestBather · 21/03/2024 00:05

We had to watch a graphic film every year at Easter, do the Stations of the Cross, learn all about it and all the graphic ways the martyrs died. We weren't traumatised. They just felt like stories, even though we knew they were real. I think kids' brains don't make the same connections we do about the brutality and reality of it all.

AliceMcK · 21/03/2024 00:05

So they haven’t gone into the floggings and beatings he took?

The whole thing about Jesus dying at Easter in the Christian religion is that he suffered and died for his people, it’s all about his sacrifices.

My DDs go to a catholic school, I attended a school mass yesterday that the whole school attended and my DDs often talk about RE. Schools (at least my DDs) these days are a lot more careful in their wordings and how they get their story across but they can’t frilly everything up.

JudgeJ · 21/03/2024 00:03

OurfriendsintheNE · 20/03/2024 21:50

Just wait til they do the ancient Egyptians 🪝 👃🏼 🧠

Most children love the gory bits of any story, it's the parents who don't realise this! Even a magical day out, most memorable thing is usually who was sick on the bus back!
I recall being very puzzled about how the baby at Christmas was crucified there months later.

Cailleach1 · 21/03/2024 00:01

German ‘Ostern’

Cailleach1 · 20/03/2024 23:59

Illpickthatup · 20/03/2024 22:03

Easier was originally a pagan festival that celebrated spring and new life. So yes it kinda is about bunnies and eggs.

In most other European languages, the word for Easter is some version of Passover. Paques in French. Pascua in Italian. England didn’t go that route, and seems to have kept the name of the roughly coinciding pre-Christian festival. German also Oestern.

SwordToFlamethrower · 20/03/2024 23:58

It's gross. There is such a grim obsession with torture and death in the church.

nadine90 · 20/03/2024 23:57

I was raised Catholic and it’s very much the norm to include the blood and gore.
Objectively I do find it odd that schools teach kids about the devil and hell and torture, yet send panicked emails about Momo or sinister Peppa pig videos.
But yeah, never traumatised me or my kids. Kids are tougher than we take them for x

Comtesse · 20/03/2024 23:55

MamaCM · 20/03/2024 21:53

I imagine the bunnies and eggs were around a long time before Jesus...

Exactly! The Christian festivals borrowed from much older pagan traditions. Bunnies and spring time renewal aren’t a million miles off.

Halfemptyhalfling · 20/03/2024 23:51

Greenbike · 20/03/2024 23:27

I am unaware of any professional historians of the ancient world who dispute the overwhelming likelihood of Jesus’s existence. There is no primary evidence of almost anybody in the ancient world other than emperors, kings, generals etc (and a few famous writers of course). A figure called Jesus who was executed is as well attested as any figure in Palestine at the time, in fact remarkably so given his low status.

See this article from the Guardian, written by a professional historian, for a helpful overview.

Guardian article

Actually there is very recent evidence that the Josephus text has been altered so it's now a lot more shaky

NoMoreLifts · 20/03/2024 23:50

AlltheFs · 20/03/2024 23:33

I can confirm I am no psychopath and I very much did ponder the practicalities as a little person!

Our village does a cross walk thingy between 2 churches at Easter, half tempted to go along and ask if they will be demonstrating the actual method including the nail placement.

I'm sure you're not a psycho!
The think that definitely didn't make sense to me was '3 days'.
Crucified Fri, up and about Sun, surely 2 days.

Nichebitch · 20/03/2024 23:45

Of course Easter is about chocolate and bunnies for a toddler ffs. I grew up in a catholic country with all the gore and I rather keep the fluffy version, thank you very much. The graphic details are unnecessary, even if you want to educate in the religious bit

Wetblanket78 · 20/03/2024 23:44

Back in the 80's when I was about 6 I remember watching a film about Jesus being crusified. Not at school but at home with my mum and siblings. That was my first education of what people from another religion or culture can do to others. It didn't traumatise me more educated of how evil people can be to others just for existing.

Gagaandgag · 20/03/2024 23:43

*some

Gagaandgag · 20/03/2024 23:43

I think you do you - done children are more sensitive than others. If she wants to talk about it you should just let her lead the conversation and talk about it. Don’t speak to school, chat at home openly. She will move on soon enough

Dryt · 20/03/2024 23:39

She’s obviously actually thought about what that means more than most children. I think it’s weird to teach young children gory stuff as if it’s fun and games before most of them can empathise fully, and when those that can don’t have the emotional maturity to process it. It’s desensitising. I don’t understand parents being proud of their kids finding gruesome books or torture mock ups in museums funny. We should take other people’s pain seriously, including, I’m assuming, Jesus’ pain if you’re a Christian. Finding it funny and fascinating as a gory extravaganza is the opposite of feeling the enormity of someone dying in pain to save others. Age appropriate detail to make it meaningful would be possible, I think it’s cheap and easy to chuck in shocking details to try and grab attention.