Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
KomodoOhno · 21/03/2024 01:29

GoodnightAdeline · 20/03/2024 21:45

I was brought up Catholic and learned this at age 4. Never lost any sleep over it. She will be fine.

Me too. My dd is in catholic school let me tell you. This is tame compared to the stories of how some saints died. Everytime she has to pick a saint to dress as I say please pick someone who didn't die too horribly.

BashfulClam · 21/03/2024 01:26

Easter (Ostera/Oestre) was originally a pagan celebration of spring and fertility and not about Jesus at all. Point out to me where the word ‘Easter’ is used in the bible. Easter was hijacked by Christianity to celebrate the resurrection so Bunnies are probably more apt.

Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 01:19

@BoohooWoohoo , yes I agree that kids are naturally attracted to scary and disgusting things. I don’t think we’re doing children a great service by shielding them from narratives that strike their imagination. It can all be counterbalanced at home.

I’m pretty sure my DCs were more scared of the Easter bunny. Perhaps because I told them he would steal any toys that had not been tidied away 😂On the upside, we had a tidy living room for one night a year.

Ausish · 21/03/2024 01:17

That’s the Jesus story. No point in sugar coating it. She’s going to come across lots of stuff about religion that’s far more damaging than that little fairy tale.

Tomatina · 21/03/2024 01:12

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 21:51

It's such a shocking story that you have to start young so that you're desensitised. Hearing it for the first time as an adult would be worse

I think this is true. As a child I just sort of accepted the crucifixion story, it was only much later that the horror of it hit me.

BoohooWoohoo · 21/03/2024 01:06

My kids went to a community school and learned that at the same age too.
Tbh they enjoyed Horrible Histories type information so it didn’t bother them.

Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 01:02

GlomOfNit · 21/03/2024 00:42

Oh FFS. She is SIX. You make a lovely grown-up point about the symbolism and nature of the sacrifice that some people believe someone called Jesus made.

So what? The child is six. And I doubt very much that she'd be capable of appreciating the 'potency of the symbol', I think it would just be shock-horror. You could equally say, well it's absolutely right and proper that people know exactly what happened to millions of Jews (and other persecuted groups) during the Nazi holocaust (and so it is) - but would you sit a six year old down and tell them in detail? Bloody hell, I hope you wouldn't.

Er, I’m an atheist. But that’s what the religion is about. 🤷🏼‍♀️

As an aside - have you ever heard of Godwin’s law? Because you sort of lost the argument there, I’m afraid.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 01:02

This is basic RE stuff for Easter.
Kids have always been taught this from a young age in a country that is Christian.
Every image of Jesus on the cross shows the nails and the cut in his lower abdomen from the Roman centurions sword.

I was taught all this from a very young age as I went to church on Sundays and Holy days where a huge cross hung behind the alter with Jesus in colour, blood and all.
Its part of his sacrifice and has never affected me negatively.

Cailleach1 · 21/03/2024 00:59

What Christians call Easter in the UK is a moveable feast, because the Jewish Passover is a moveable feast (both based on full moons). The full moon which determines when Easter Sunday occurs, is even called the ‘Paschal’ full moon. JC’s death and resurrection was supposed to have occurred around the Jewish Passover which is determined by the full moon.

The Christian Easter doesn’t always coincide exactly with the Jewish Passover as the Jewish year has leap years which throw it off, and I think Christian churches made some other adjustments later on as well. Orthodox Christians still follow the Julian calendar, whereas western churches follow the Gregorian calendar. So, if your dates are different, that can affect which full moon is your Paschal full moon.

RobertaFirmino · 21/03/2024 00:56

I've more of an issue with children being told Jesus died for their sins than the actual nailing. For a start, what sins do children have? In any case, he was put to death by the government because he presented a challenge. One of the first political prisoners and people are still killed by governments today for daring to challenge corruption.

There will be much worse to learn at school than the crucifixion.

DarcyJames3 · 21/03/2024 00:49

I grew up Catholic and this was just a part of the deal. I am not raising my kid Catholic, but one day I decided to take him to sunday school (when he was a toddler) just to view different points of view. And oh my lanta. It was near Easter, and they gave him an advent calendar that they had made using an egg carton. One of the days had ACTUAL NAILS in it!!!

GlomOfNit · 21/03/2024 00:42

Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 00:06

I think the horror of it is a key plank of Christianity: here is a man who agreed to be tortured and humiliated to redeem your sins. He gave up his life so you can go to heaven. The torture is an intrinsic part of the story. The shocking gruesomeness can’t be evacuated from it without losing the potency of the symbol.

Oh FFS. She is SIX. You make a lovely grown-up point about the symbolism and nature of the sacrifice that some people believe someone called Jesus made.

So what? The child is six. And I doubt very much that she'd be capable of appreciating the 'potency of the symbol', I think it would just be shock-horror. You could equally say, well it's absolutely right and proper that people know exactly what happened to millions of Jews (and other persecuted groups) during the Nazi holocaust (and so it is) - but would you sit a six year old down and tell them in detail? Bloody hell, I hope you wouldn't.

viques · 21/03/2024 00:39

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

The word Easter in English derives from the pagan goddess Oestre , who was celebrated in spring. Most European countries use a name possibly derived from the Jewish festival of Passover, which was also not about Jesus but about the Israelites in Egypt.

TommyJoesMummy · 21/03/2024 00:39

He WAS nailed to the cross.
It was an extra harsh crucifixion including insults pinned above his head and a crown of thorns.
He wasn’t ‘placed’ there and there wasn’t a ledge under his bum for him to take a break on.
It does help to hear certain things as a child because it’s beyond gory to think about it from an adult’s perspective, like pp said about the Egyptians and the Tudors.
It would have been just the basic sentence and then left to be added to over the years with the meaning of Easter. Why it happened, the meaning behind the actions, the sacrifice and the love.

Also, the Maltesers in his hands joke is aimed for primary age! 😂

GlomOfNit · 21/03/2024 00:37

OP, I seem to be massively flying in the face of MN opinion on this one (I'm sort of surprised how your poll went) but yes FFS of COURSE it's far too graphic for a year 1 schoolchild!! Bloody hell. Would you want them to read, outside of a religious context, something of that nature at that age? To see something on a screen that even hinted at that sort of gory violence? The people who say 'well I went to church and I knew this from 3' - there are shitloads of people like you who went to church and had this dinned into them as children who are really fucked up as a result. It's nothing to boast about, and I feel sorry for your childhood religious experience.

There are age-appropriate ways of explaining the Easter Story. I thought hardly any CofE schools went into that sort of detail at that age any more. When my own son was at our village CofE primary, he says (retrospectively) that the actual execution was so glossed over that when they, years later, covered the story of Doubting Thomas, and the holes in Jesus' hands were discussed, he thought 'Jesus has HOLES in his HANDS?! Bloody hell, what happened there?' and was quite disturbed. Grin

Sure, Easter is about Jesus and sacrifice AS WELL as about bunnies and chocolate (things change, and it's disingenuous to say to anyone connecting Easter with chocolate and eggs 'well that's not what the meaning of Easter is'. Also annoyingly smug). But you don't go into gory unnecessary detail, particularly in a school where not all the children come from Christian families, and even then I think it's pretty awful.

Salaaaaaaaah · 21/03/2024 00:35

CryHavoc · 20/03/2024 21:51

I went to a Catholic school and watched the full Robert Powell Jesus of Nazareth films every Easter from being 4. Whipping and nails and crown of thorns and all.

It's the Easter story, far more than bunnies and chicks are.

Saw that series too. He was wonderful in it. The piercing eyes are what stand out.

Catsbreakfast · 21/03/2024 00:33

Grow up. I’m not religious but went to a catholic primary. Jesus was born at Christmas (are you ignoring that too?) and died at Easter for all our sins sinplified in the betrayal by Judas. Nailed to the cross at Friday, resurrected on the Sunday. For catholics easter Sunday is bigger than Christmas Eve. We knew this as kids and quite honestly it doesn’t harm children to know some of the more gruesome bits behind their customs. Btw the bunnies you refer to are a Roman fertility ritual and giving Easter eggs as gift was originally a gift to wish fertility on the receiver. Not kid friendly either. You probably mean. Well shielding your child from gory bits of the world but you do them no favour.

SpidersAreShitheads · 21/03/2024 00:33

The conversation about where the nails went reminded me I had this on my phone 😂

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands
Koulibiak · 21/03/2024 00:31

Frankly if you find that bit too horrifying, wait until you hear about transubstantiation.

delapp · 21/03/2024 00:27

Contrary to what many people here seem to think, Easter wasn't originally a Christian festival at all. The very word 'Easter' sort of gives the game away: it derives from 'Eostre', a pre-Christian pagan goddess.

Or you might think about how the date of Easter is (still) decided: spring equinox ... full moon ... weekend? To do with seasons and the lunar calendar, not really anything to do with good ol' Jesus or the nails.

Of course, like other festivals (why is Christmas at the winter solstice?), early Christians simply tagged their feasts on to already existing ones, mostly celebrating important times of year, planting, or harvest time, whatever.

Christianity is just another religion, nothing really special about it. Just a different set of parochial myths. By all means teach children as part of history and societal origins, along with Jupiter, Huitzilopochtli, perhaps, other gods from elsewhere and elsewhen. (Don't think of trying to teach all religions, as a pp said: there's far too many!) Try not to take it too seriously with them, though. That isn't fair.

Cerealkiller4U · 21/03/2024 00:24

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:50

DD knew that Jesus was put on a cross. The nails aspect shocked her to be honest and that's all she was talking about all evening.

The school is not a religion affiliated school but they have RE and learn about all religions.

Even if it’s not a Christian or religious school. RE is still taught…..

Saschka · 21/03/2024 00:23

NorthCliffs · 20/03/2024 21:50

My 4 year old son carefully examined a particularly gruesome crucifix on a table in a Catholic church. He said 'Where's his socks? Aren't his feet cold?' and moved on.

Mine wanted to know why Baby Jesus was a woman (long hair, no longer a baby). I had to explain that several years had passed between Baby Jesus being born at Christmas and Adult Jesus dying at Easter, the events in the Bible didn’t all take place over a very busy three month period.

He also asked if Jesus really came back to life again three days later, I said probably not, and he said “I knew it! I knew that was so sus!”

SultanOfSwing · 21/03/2024 00:21

If you had sent her to a Catholic school I would have said you were asking for it. But if it is just your local primary school (even if it is a CofE school) I agree with you and I think that is too much information for a 6 year old. There’s time enough to learn about all the horrible things human beings do to each other.

I’m with letting he focus on the bunnies and the eggs for a while longer. I believe that children who learn about love and joy first bring empathy to the terrible stuff they inevitably discover. Brutality lessons come soon enough.

School is wrong. You are right.

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 00:21

JudgeJ · 21/03/2024 00:14

Oh, lucky them!

I see you are being facetious but I think this parent did absolutely the right thing. Not at all appropriate for such young children. We should question weird macabre shit like this. Just because it’s been told for years doesn’t make it right.

WhiteLily1 · 21/03/2024 00:19

I remember as a child it being taught as tied to a cross- there were pictures of white cloths around Jesus wrists and ankles. No need to introduce the nails until a bit later IMO