Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
crikesdostop · 21/03/2024 06:21

VashtaNerada · 21/03/2024 03:04

Glad to see some PP have noted that the original message of Easter has nothing to do with Christ! I’m surprised how many people didn’t know that.

I think most people are aware of the pagan roots but in this instance the kid was being taught about the Christian festival of Easter. Which centres around Jesus' death.

Secnarf · 21/03/2024 06:17

I’m another one who wasn’t harmed by learning the Easter story young.

i went to a catholic primary school. There was a regular little yellow magazine called Crusader. I remember us all eagerly looking in it when it arrived as it would describe various martyrs’ death, some of which were very inventively gruesome.

Unfortunately, Jesus being nailed to the cross and being speared in the side to are key points of the Easter story, as this was not done routinely during crucifixion. They were so worried about the power/following of this individual, that they were making absolutely sure he could not be switched with another, and that he was definitely dead.

And when he rises again, Thomas asks to put his fingers in the holes as proof of the resurrection.

Children learn about gruesome real and made-up things at school from an early age. Tudor beheading and Egyptian mummification have been mentioned upthread. I remember in year 1, there were a couple of reading scheme books about Greek myths. Classical myths are also sometimes pretty graphic.

I think it is rare at that age to fully appreciate exactly the suffering involved in these processes, and they tend to just accept the facts of the stories.

ASighMadeOfStone · 21/03/2024 06:16

Moonfishstar · 21/03/2024 05:57

I agree. I don’t think a teacher needs to say any more than “Jesus died on a cross” for Year 1 children; and only go into the specifics if asked, and then only sensitively, and moving the lesson on if any children’s questions get too lurid for the sake of the others.

There’s no reason this can’t go at the kids pace, especially given they are 5 or 6. They don’t need to know the specifics of death by crucifixion at that age, the nailing to the cross being only the start of it!

Willing to bet it went like this:

Teacher: Jesus died on the cross
Children: how did they get him up there?
Teacher: well, actually, in those days, people were very cruel and used nails.
Children: Ewwwww.

And thus the lesson very probably endeth.

ConJob · 21/03/2024 06:15

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

I'm an atheist and I know that easter was originally about bunnies and eggs as they are symbols of spring equinox which the Pagans celebrated. We should leave gruesome fictional stories out of it.

Sausage1989 · 21/03/2024 06:12

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:57

We've never been to church so DD has never seen a Jesus on the cross...

Still? That's VERY graphic for a young child!

I agree with PPs that it's so horrible that they have to be told young when they don't filly grasp the whole thing.

I would bet my life that your daughter isn't actually upset about it..she's just intrigued and talking about what she's learnt. It's you who isn't dealing with it very well. Bizarre 😂do you really tell your daughter the easter bunny leaves chocolate eggs and that's what Easter is about??!?!

Hobbesmanc · 21/03/2024 06:12

I do remember as a child being really distressed at the Passover stories which seemed to overlap the Easter stories at my school. I was the oldest child so the death of the first borne and the daubing of the blood on the doors to warn away the angel of death was traumatising. Don't get me started on Herods slaughter of the innocents.

countvoncount · 21/03/2024 06:11

Problem is.. no more nails hadn't been invented you see, after the gruesome crucifixion I'm sure they all sat down with a buttons egg.
Easter really isn't about bunnies OP, just like Christmas isn't all about presents.
Religious celebrations.

ASighMadeOfStone · 21/03/2024 06:11

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:50

DD knew that Jesus was put on a cross. The nails aspect shocked her to be honest and that's all she was talking about all evening.

The school is not a religion affiliated school but they have RE and learn about all religions.

Talking about it like most small children would, with a bit of glee and fascination at the gore? Or talking and sobbing about never wanting to go to school again talking?

As many many posters have said (because it's the truth) young children mostly have an insatiable appetite for gore. I'd be concerned about the child in my class who was upset about this particularly story, not about the 99.9% who heard it wide-eyed and fascinated and were clearly going to go home and say "did you know THEY NAILED HIM TO THE CROSS WITH NAILS"

Sausage1989 · 21/03/2024 06:08

No. She'll be alright. I've always known about the crucifixion, even before school I'd heard the story. And I'm not from a religious family.

Noicant · 21/03/2024 05:57

I told my 4 yr old how the ancient egyptians removed brains prior to embalming by sticking a hook up your nose and wiggling it around. I had to because we were in a museum. I found it all really fascinating when I was a kid morbid curiosity and all that. She’ll be fine.

Moonfishstar · 21/03/2024 05:57

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:57

We've never been to church so DD has never seen a Jesus on the cross...

Still? That's VERY graphic for a young child!

I agree with PPs that it's so horrible that they have to be told young when they don't filly grasp the whole thing.

I agree. I don’t think a teacher needs to say any more than “Jesus died on a cross” for Year 1 children; and only go into the specifics if asked, and then only sensitively, and moving the lesson on if any children’s questions get too lurid for the sake of the others.

There’s no reason this can’t go at the kids pace, especially given they are 5 or 6. They don’t need to know the specifics of death by crucifixion at that age, the nailing to the cross being only the start of it!

RosesAndHellebores · 21/03/2024 05:54

Thank goodness they've made Mary Poppins PG.

Rosebel · 21/03/2024 05:53

It's fine. I mean if it bothers you ask if she can be removed from RE lessons but it's not really a big thing.
I'm Catholic and heard about it when I was 4 and so did my DDs. Can't say it's affected any of us.
Easter is supposed to be about Jesus.

Devonbabs · 21/03/2024 05:50

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 05:45

Not 'definitely existed' at all, the evidence is pretty sketchy at best.

Whilst not conclusive, most scholars.agree that Jesus existed as a man. I think it’s disingenuous to say the ecvidence is sketchy.

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 05:45

KnickerlessParsons · 21/03/2024 02:52

I dont think it is traumatising at all. Lies and indoctrination yes, but not scary.

I'm not Christian, but I don't think it's lies. Jesus definitely existed, didn't he? Whether he was the "son of God" though is another matter 🤔

Not 'definitely existed' at all, the evidence is pretty sketchy at best.

pinkmushroom5 · 21/03/2024 05:34

user1745 · 20/03/2024 21:52

She probably won't really fully understand how horrible it is to be nailed by your hands at her age. She will understand the words, but not just how gory it would have been, if that makes sense. The same as how we all learnt from a very young age how people were beheaded in the Tudor era, but we probably didn't fully appreciate the details of it (assuming no graphic images are being shown).

It's interesting what people think children will or won't understand.

I remember learning this as a child about 7 years old and being very confused by it. My grandma was very religious. I remember my thought process clearly.

At first, I remember thinking 'well that wouldn't work because you can't put nails through someone's hands' - the idea was simply too gruesome for me to think it could even be possible.

I went through a whole thought process of wondering how they kept him up there and if he had to just somehow hold onto the nails (but why would he do that?), or if the nails were just really thin, or if they put it in his fingers instead of his hands.

I asked my grandma about it and she told me that the nails did go into his hands, but it didn't hurt him because he was Jesus.

I was really confused.

But I definitely knew that putting nails through someone's hands would be bloody and horrible.

The idea of crucifixion itself on the other hand - which is obviously the most gory and horrendous thing - was something that I could not comprehend (hence the nails seemed worse!)

PurpleFlower1983 · 21/03/2024 05:30

We were shown Jesus Christ Superstar and I remember the 39 lashes more clearly than anything. It is a bit traumatising but they do need to learn this stuff.

PurpleFlower1983 · 21/03/2024 05:27

Wait until they teach them about Guy Fawkes!

Ggttl · 21/03/2024 05:18

I found this aspect really horrible as a child but mainly from looking at paintings of it. I always imagined the nails ripping through his hands because of the weight of his body but I didn’t ask further questions. I think it is unavoidable as there are so many depictions of it, so she might as well be told.

TheWelshposter · 21/03/2024 05:16

CryHavoc · 20/03/2024 21:51

I went to a Catholic school and watched the full Robert Powell Jesus of Nazareth films every Easter from being 4. Whipping and nails and crown of thorns and all.

It's the Easter story, far more than bunnies and chicks are.

Me too. This is one of my core memories from primary school as it was so shocking. Some kids cried.

ForestBather · 21/03/2024 05:01

I was just trying to remember when I learned about Jesus dying on the cross. Then I recalled that my mother has always had a crucifix on the wall at home, so it's just been something I took for granted.

TwinklyMintOPmaas · 21/03/2024 04:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DrDavidStarKey · 21/03/2024 04:52

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

Ostara (Easter) was originally about bunnies and eggs. The Christian version came much much later.

JanglingJack · 21/03/2024 04:41

TaFox · 21/03/2024 04:20

I've been to church when I was younger. DD has never been to church.

My DD walked in to the church during a village fete and asked if this was the pub 🤣 she'd been in either. She was taught that Jesus died on the cross though... I soon brought her round to my atheist ways and to know that all religion is evil.

JanglingJack · 21/03/2024 04:38

Floralnomad · 20/03/2024 21:45

Im an atheist but even I know that Easter was originally about Jesus not bunnies and eggs .

This.

Also it would have been through his wrists as the nails would not have been to support a human body.

Swipe left for the next trending thread