Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
takemeawayagain · 21/03/2024 08:50

I'm an atheist and I have no idea why they need to be teaching such graphic details of history in schools at such a young age in the name of religion. I think all schools should be secular and not trying to ram this stuff down kids throats from the minute they start school. They should just learn about all religions in an age appropriate way - and crucifixion isn't age appropriate for 5 year olds.

I don't know what 'worse' things kids are hearing at 5 years old than someone being nailed to a cross.

So I'm with you completely OP.

leafinthewind · 21/03/2024 08:50

My then five year old was horrified by the Easter story. It came hard on the heels of Christmas and I remember her asking me: "Did they really nail baby Jesus to a cross? Really? With nails?" She hadn't understood that the story involved an adult. I explained, but it made me want to weep that we think it's fine to tell tiny children about torture like this. Still, since we do, I felt free to use the story for my own propaganda.

In the story, a man is tortured and killed by an occupying army. His own religious leaders help the army, because they are angry that the man says what he thinks, and not what they want him to say. The religious part is the miracle of the resurrection - I explained that some people believe it, but it happened a long time ago and we now know that people cannot come back to life after dying. I choose instead to tell the kids about free societies, the rule of law, free speech and freedom of belief.

Before her first Easter in school, I was much more gentle and only told her 'some people believe'. I didn't tell her they were wrong. When they taught my five year old about torture, in such a careless way that she thought they were talking about nailing a baby to a plank, it freed me up to tell her that religion is a lie, made up to keep the people in line - and that she should just ignore it.

StopStartStop · 21/03/2024 08:49

So were the gospels. The disciples expected the second coming to be in their lifetimes, didn't write anything down for ages.

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 08:47

StopStartStop · 21/03/2024 08:43

Look up 'Josephus, Flavius'. First century Roman historian (pseudo-historian, some would say) refers to Jesus and crucifixion.

Edited

Written decades after Jesus supposedly lived though, right?

ConJob · 21/03/2024 08:46

StopStartStop · 21/03/2024 08:43

Look up 'Josephus, Flavius'. First century Roman historian (pseudo-historian, some would say) refers to Jesus and crucifixion.

Edited

And look up when Josephus was born.

Katiesaidthat · 21/03/2024 08:46

OurfriendsintheNE · 20/03/2024 21:50

Just wait til they do the ancient Egyptians 🪝 👃🏼 🧠

My 5 year old did ancient Egyptians and her little project was a bout momified cats. We put photos of them, the kids loved it.
OP Easter is definitely not about bunnies, it is the most important festivity on the Christian calendar, where those who believe commemorate the crucifixion of Christ and his resurrection on the third day. No idea where bunnies come in.
My daughter attends a Catholic school and her take from this story is that his mum Mary was crying a lot and she (and her friends) were very sorry for her. Kids are weird little things, they have their own points of view.

Tattletwat · 21/03/2024 08:44

SignoraVolpe · 21/03/2024 08:03

The evidence is not sketchy.
The Romans kept very good records.
And the four gospels give details of Jesus life and death.
Jesus baptism and crucifixion are considered to be historical facts.

There is no evidence of Jesus in Roman records.

One of the first mentions of him by Jewish Roman historian is wrote in 93 AD by Flavius Josephus and is wrote that differently to the rest of his work is suspected to be a fake inserted by the church.

The gospels don't really prove anything and are likely a work of fiction.

A lot of people will say historians agree Jesus existed is isn't strictly true as most historians and scholars who are employed to look into Jesus are funded by the church and aren't impartial.

sashh · 21/03/2024 08:44

Smashieandnicey · 21/03/2024 08:10

I'm a sign language interpreter and have interpreted for deaf children of all ages in schools.

If you think it's graphic, picture what it looks like in sign language. Sex ed lessons are always fun too.

You're definitely overreacting and your daughter will be fine. She'll be learning about the Egyptians pulling brains out with hooks soon enough. Kids love all this stuff.

Off topic but I was once (on uni placement) asked to interpret 'felch'.

I find it interesting that people on here get upset about some Bible stories but then suggest a 'Noah's Ark' toy as a christening present.

I mean it's a toy based on a genocide.

Also anyone with kids in RC schools, there is likely to be a 3D depiction on the wall of their classroom.

StopStartStop · 21/03/2024 08:43

Look up 'Josephus, Flavius'. First century Roman historian (pseudo-historian, some would say) refers to Jesus and crucifixion.

EverybodyIsFantastic · 21/03/2024 08:42

Mischance · 21/03/2024 08:26

Crucifixion was (possibly is) a fact of life. That is a given.
But there are facts that we do not detail to children when they are small and quite rightly.
Let's have a lesson for 5 year olds on electric chairs, hanging, guillotines ... I don't think so.
Religion should not override basic principles of making learning age appropriate.

Catholic schools are likely to have crucifixes depicting a naked, bleeding man nailed to a cross in all classrooms. As one of the former Catholic schoolchildren in question, I didn’t even register it. None of us did. It was essentially wallpaper.

It was only when a C of E friend was contemplating sending her child to a Catholic primary after a move, went to visit one, and came out blanched, saying ‘There was a crucifix on the Reception classroom wall!” that I registered it as in any way unusual or that could be considered as liable to appall small children.

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 08:42

sanityisamyth · 21/03/2024 08:39

This.

We don’t believe in Christ so will stick to our Easter bunnies and chocolate eggs.

ConJob · 21/03/2024 08:41

KimberleyClark · 21/03/2024 08:27

The Romans DID keep very good records, you're right, and they have no record of him or any man vaguely fitting his description.

I thought the Romans did have a record of a Joshua Ben Joseph being crucified, but he didn’t fit the classical description of Jesus as depicted in renaissance paintings, being about 5ft 3in tall and dark skinned.

I may be wrong but I don't think so and certainly not during Passover!

sanityisamyth · 21/03/2024 08:39

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/03/2024 21:50

I'm an atheist but come on the Easter story is about the crucifixion of Christ - not magic bunnies.

😳

This.

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 08:38

TheBeeb · 21/03/2024 08:37

Some children who's parents go to church will have heard this from they were babies though, church doesn't give out a content warning for sermons!

The whole point of Easter is to celebrate Jesus death, burial and resurrection. Kids see and hear far worse through normal every day life nowadays sadly.

We celebrate Easter our way but it’s nothing to do with religion.

TheBeeb · 21/03/2024 08:37

Some children who's parents go to church will have heard this from they were babies though, church doesn't give out a content warning for sermons!

The whole point of Easter is to celebrate Jesus death, burial and resurrection. Kids see and hear far worse through normal every day life nowadays sadly.

Beekeepingmum · 21/03/2024 08:37

I'm not sure the nails through the wrists are the worst bit of crucifixion - the slow death bit is probably worse.

I've never quite worked out why some forms of execution are considered more child friendly than others. On Cbeebies they react walking the plank everyday in a way in which they just wouldn't do for a hanging or other forms of pirate execution.... Or at the pantomine it is for the audience to short walk the plank for Captain Hook but if you called for him to be stoned to death you would probably be kicked out the theatre

Thistooshallpass. · 21/03/2024 08:36

I learnt this in reception - didn't give it a second thought . My brother on the other hand got the wrong end of the stick and thought we had got cross buns because Jesus died on a big hot cross bun Smile

StopStartStop · 21/03/2024 08:32

Just don't read her the biblical account in the Gospel of Matthew. Reduces teenagers to tears.

About the nails... usually people were fastened to their crucifix (which wasn't necessarily a cross) by ropes round the wrists. If you try to support the weight of the body with nails through the hands, the hands tear and the body slumps or falls - inefficient. Romans crucified many people, they knew how to do it.

cakeorwine · 21/03/2024 08:32

I suppose it's what level they need to know at that age.

Jesus was killed by being attached to a cross.
Jesus was nailed to a cross.
Jesus was flailed, had his skin taken from his back, had a crown of thorns put in his head, nailed to a cross and left in the sun to die.

How much detail do you need to get into to get over the key details. That he was executed on a cross?

I am sure that if the entire details about the flagellation were taught to a 5 year old, then there would be complaints on here.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands
Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands
Tdcp · 21/03/2024 08:31

When DD was 5 she was taught about the gunpowder plot including quite graphic details about being hanged drawn and quartered😫she's fine though even if though it was a shock for her!

Didimum · 21/03/2024 08:30

Boomer55 · 21/03/2024 08:18

For those of us sent to Sunday school, years ago, and those that attended school, this was taught to everyone. We all survived, no one appeared to be traumatised.

Easter isn’t really based on chocolate and fluffy bunnies.😗. It’s, for believers, our most religious time - which is why all shops must shut on Easter Sunday.

It’s not about “surviving” or “trauma”, it’s about age-appropriate material. They could describe the plot to Nightmare on Elm Street to a bunch of 5yr olds and have them “survive”, but it doesn’t mean it’s age appropriate.

ConJob · 21/03/2024 08:28

Devonbabs · 21/03/2024 08:07

I don’t really agree. Pagan temples as they are are generally nothing to do with our history, it’s generally neo paganism which is practised today.

I think it’s important to discuss the Jewish faith as to give context to Christianity. But the Jewish faith in isolation has had very little influence in our culture.

I would suggest it’s important to give a good grounding in Greek philosophy and the philosophical schools which came after as this had a big impact also.

I don’t think understanding Islam, Buddhism and other religions is that important except to understand some world events and to be tolerant of those with other beliefs. They are pretty irrelevant to understanding western history and culture before the late 19th and 20th century, even then it’s fairly fringe.

Our history and the Christian festivals are all rooted in Paganism and if Christianity shaped our culture and Judaism shaped Christianity, then both had a lot of influence. It would be hard to find a traditional Pagan Temple though I agree!

But if you think a child should attend church just in case they get invited to a Christian wedding, funeral or baptism as the person I was replying to stated, then you should really cover all religions just in case.

Didimum · 21/03/2024 08:27

Stormbornform · 21/03/2024 08:19

Horrible histories is much worse. Should kids also not be taught about the reality of the world wars etc? I don't see the problem.

Horrible Histories age range is established by the publisher as appropriate for 7-9. Not 5yr olds.

KimberleyClark · 21/03/2024 08:27

The Romans DID keep very good records, you're right, and they have no record of him or any man vaguely fitting his description.

I thought the Romans did have a record of a Joshua Ben Joseph being crucified, but he didn’t fit the classical description of Jesus as depicted in renaissance paintings, being about 5ft 3in tall and dark skinned.

Mischance · 21/03/2024 08:26

Crucifixion was (possibly is) a fact of life. That is a given.
But there are facts that we do not detail to children when they are small and quite rightly.
Let's have a lesson for 5 year olds on electric chairs, hanging, guillotines ... I don't think so.
Religion should not override basic principles of making learning age appropriate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread