Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Gettingonmygoat · 21/03/2024 10:03

Please, millions of children were told this story when they were 5 and lived to tell the tale. Your child isn't having a fit of the vapours about it but you are, you need to get a grip.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 21/03/2024 09:56

Generations of children have been taught this in infants schools. Never traumatised any that I heard of. Certainly not in my family.

sashh · 21/03/2024 09:56

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 08:54

It's almost as though the whole thing was made up.

Or formed from a different belief system.

Being born of a virgin is not unique to this story. Or being born on Dec 25th.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 21/03/2024 09:54

I think you’d be unreasonable to complain, yes. And I would be very careful to not give your DD the impression that this is something she should be upset about.

Children’s brains tend to process words and stories in a manner they can handle.

That’s one of the differences between “simply” hearing about something and the combination of the visual and auditory (aka films).

Or as a pp put it: she will not properly understand how gory that actually is or what it would truly mean to be nailed to a cross. She’ll “understand” this story in a manner that is based on her current understanding and capabilities.

the fairytales most / many of us grew up with aren’t less gruesome either, tbh.

EverybodyIsFantastic · 21/03/2024 09:51

Mirabai · 21/03/2024 09:42

It’s very much a testament to mankind’s predilection for S&M that the image of divinity in the west is a man being tortured. Of all the things that could have been chosen to symbolise Christianity and sacrifice - it’s graphic crufiction.

Well, that’s the demented gymnastic ‘logic’ of Christianity — that of a supposedly omnipotent, omniscient, benevolent deity who stands by in the face of human suffering, but (in an act you really have to tie yourself in knots to view as in any way compensatory) sends his son/other self to earth to be horribly executed which is somehow redemptive. The gruesome execution is the whole point, rather than the social justice messages of Jesus’ preaching, or the wow factor of multiplying food, rising from the dead, or walking on water.

Waitingforgeorge · 21/03/2024 09:45

TheFancyPoet · 21/03/2024 09:13

I absolutely delighted you made this post. It is a very very tough story, choice to accept what happened to Jesus but may be if you learn why it happened, then it will be a bit easier.

Why did it happen? Given your answer I don't think I have truly understood the why.

Mirabai · 21/03/2024 09:42

It’s very much a testament to mankind’s predilection for S&M that the image of divinity in the west is a man being tortured. Of all the things that could have been chosen to symbolise Christianity and sacrifice - it’s graphic crufiction.

Telomeres · 21/03/2024 09:41

There's not a lot of credit going to the teacher here is there?

There's a big difference between simply telling the 'facts' of the story and a long discussion about the pain and the gore and the process. Which I'm pretty sure she wouldn't contemplate in a class of 5 year olds.

Tlolljs · 21/03/2024 09:31

If we get a bank holiday for all of those I’m in 😀

Mischance · 21/03/2024 09:31

I do not think the issue here is the verity of the gospels, or the history of Easter celebrations.

It is quite simply about what is appropriate to teach young chidlren.

When I was small the chapel at school had the stations of the cross painted around the walls life-size (to a 4 years old). It terrified me and I hated going in there.

Aposterhasnoname · 21/03/2024 09:31

At that age I was far more traumatised at the thought of a six foot rabbit breaking in and sneaking around the house hiding eggs

delapp · 21/03/2024 09:28

takemeawayagain · 21/03/2024 08:50

I'm an atheist and I have no idea why they need to be teaching such graphic details of history in schools at such a young age in the name of religion. I think all schools should be secular and not trying to ram this stuff down kids throats from the minute they start school. They should just learn about all religions in an age appropriate way - and crucifixion isn't age appropriate for 5 year olds.

I don't know what 'worse' things kids are hearing at 5 years old than someone being nailed to a cross.

So I'm with you completely OP.

I agree with the idea of secular schools teaching stuff about religion(s). But not all religions. That would take far too long. Below, just a random few - a few - of the gods, "gods of the highest standing and dignity – gods of civilized peoples – worshiped and believed in by millions", as H.L. Mencken (from whose 'Chrestomathy' I extracted the list) put it.

Of course Jehova and - yes - Christ, and Allah - get just the same number of places on the list as the rest: one. Think about that, RE teachers and others who talk of teaching children about all religions.

A few gods from here and there:

Resheph
Anath
Ashtoreth
El
Nergal
Nebo
Ninib
Melek
Ahijah
Isis
Ptah
Anubis
Baal
Astarte
Hadad
Addu
Shalem
Dagon
Sharrab
Yau
Amon-Re
Osiris
Sebek
Molech
Bilé
Ler
Arianrod
Morrigu
Govannon
Gunfled
Sokk-mimi
Memetona
Dagda
Robigus
Pluto
Ops
Meditrina
Vesta
Tilmun
Ogyrvan
Dea Dia
Ceros
Vaticanus
Edulia
Adeona
Iuno Lucina
Saturn
Furrina
Vediovis
Consus
Cronos
Enki
Engurra
Belus
Dimmer
Mu-ul-lil
Ubargisi
Ubilulu
Gasan lil
U-dimmer-an-kia
Enurestu
U-sab-sib
Kerridwen
Pwyll
Tammuz
Venus
Bau
Mulu-hursang
Anu
Beltis
Nusku
U-Mersi
Beltu
Dumu-zi-abzu
Kuski-banda
Sin
Abil Addu
Apsu
Dagan
Elali
Isum
Mami
Nin-man
Zaraqu
Suqamunu
Zagaga
Gwydion
Manawyddan
Nuada
Argetlam
Tagd
Goibniu
Odin
Llaw Gyffes
Lleu
Ogma
Mider
Rigantona
Marzin
Mars
Kaawanu Ni-zu
Sahi
Aa
Allatu
Jupiter
Cunina
Potina
Statilinus
Diana of Ephesus
Nin-azu
Lugal-Amarada
Zer-panitu
Merodach
U-ki
Dauke
Gasan-abzu
Elum
U-Tin-dir-ki
Marduk
Nin-lil-la
Nin
Persephone
Istar
Lagas
U-urugal
Sirtumu
Ea
Nirig
Nebo
Samas
Ma-banba-anna
En-Mersi
Amurru
Assur
Aku
Qarradu
Ura-gala
Ueras

Stoufer · 21/03/2024 09:23

ConJob · 21/03/2024 08:51

The gospels were not written by Jesus's disciples, none of the gospels were written by eye witnesses.

I also find it really interesting that there were actually lots of gospels written, in the first couple of centuries, and that a conference was held in the 7th century to actually decide which ones should be kept and form the New Testament - those that all told a similar story were kept, those that had different versions were omitted (I think they are in the apocrypha - I think the one about Bel and the Dragon is very intriguing!). It is really interesting as a very early PR exercise. (apologies if I have any of the finer details wrong, esp dates, this is all back in the hazy mists of time for me (I read about it maybe 30 years ago.. But I do still have a copy of the apochrypha).

Telomeres · 21/03/2024 09:22

Jk8 · 21/03/2024 09:09

I also learned this earlier (with "pictures" to see 🤔) & was quite traumatised

This is sort or why I prefer the American "jesus loves you"/ head-to-toe bathrobes / bright halo lights version 😂 to the catholic/prod version

So what does 'quite traumatised' mean then?

You went 'eww' <shudder> then went back to scrolling your phone?

You were not traumatised, don't be stupid.

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 21/03/2024 09:22

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 09:18

Sorry but I don’t think kids need to understand the ins and outs of crucifixion torture to withstand rejection or apply to most jobs.

Don’t be obtuse. I’m talking about the constant need to wrap them in cotton wool

HoppingPavlova · 21/03/2024 09:21

The people who say 'well I went to church and I knew this from 3' - there are shitloads of people like you who went to church and had this dinned into them as children who are really fucked up as a result. It's nothing to boast about, and I feel sorry for your childhood religious experience

That’s then pretty much the entire population over 30 is fucked up? Thats really not true. Why would you feel sorry for everyone’s childhood religious experience when it had no effect on them? It’s really only fairly recently in the scheme of things that some children are disturbed by such facts/story, and it’s probably more appropriate to ask why that is? Why are more kids snowflakes now than ever before as there has been a massive increase in this over time.

I remember all my kids were interested in mummies around 5, and of course asked how/who/what. I had no issues telling them about pulling brains out through noses with long hooks, internal organs put in jars, how they mummified etc. It is what it is. They were all fascinated and it was a ‘good to know’ vibe. Nowadays you’d probably have to line up 10 years worth of counselling for the kids coming through🤦‍♀️.

SlackAlice1 · 21/03/2024 09:20

user1745 · 20/03/2024 21:52

She probably won't really fully understand how horrible it is to be nailed by your hands at her age. She will understand the words, but not just how gory it would have been, if that makes sense. The same as how we all learnt from a very young age how people were beheaded in the Tudor era, but we probably didn't fully appreciate the details of it (assuming no graphic images are being shown).

Largely this.

Although I was a bit disturbed in primary school by a drawing in a history book of a man being beheaded. I remember it making me feel a bit sick.

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 09:18

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 21/03/2024 09:16

You know what I mean. Let’s take out the less palatable facts. The need to mollycoddle kids is off the scale. How will they ever cope in the real world; applying for jobs, rejection etc. Ridiculous.

Sorry but I don’t think kids need to understand the ins and outs of crucifixion torture to withstand rejection or apply to most jobs.

Sweedey · 21/03/2024 09:16

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 20/03/2024 22:00

Well it’s good for her to know the true meaning of Easter and no it’s not all about bunnies and fun.

Well the original meaning comes from the pagan, pre-Christian goddes Eostre and it was a festival of Spring and rebirth, so definitely more fun than nailing people to crosses.

Original meaning of what?

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 21/03/2024 09:16

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 09:12

To be fair it's been rewritten many times already. Some older versions had Jesus slaying dragons, but they had to take that out as people started asking too many questions.

You know what I mean. Let’s take out the less palatable facts. The need to mollycoddle kids is off the scale. How will they ever cope in the real world; applying for jobs, rejection etc. Ridiculous.

MagpiePi · 21/03/2024 09:16

Telomeres · 21/03/2024 07:47

Oh PLEASE! Literally nobody is 'fucked up' as an adult by hearing a story, as a kid, about a guy who died 2000 years previously. Actually nobody.

But millions of people have actually been 'fucked up' by the subsequent religions...

SpringGreensPreens · 21/03/2024 09:13

I have a problem with us teaching all kinds of religious nonsense as if it was facts in schools.

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 09:13

Smashieandnicey · 21/03/2024 09:06

Yep. There is no other context in which anyone would think telling four and five year olds about torture methods is completely fine.

They're not being taught about torture methods. They're being taught the Easter story. Christianity is one of the underpinnings of our society. You may not believe in it but that's just the way it is.

In secular schools they will be teaching about other religious festivals as part of the curriculum too. It is age appropriate to say that Jesus was nailed to the cross and killed in order to tell the story of the resurrection.

At this age children also do harvest topics where they learn where their food comes from. It's also a surprise to many 5 and 6 year olds that their food has been killed for them to eat as their parents shield them from this.

They are literally taught about torture methods, within the gospel Easter story - you must have been taught a sanitised version.

TheFancyPoet · 21/03/2024 09:13

I absolutely delighted you made this post. It is a very very tough story, choice to accept what happened to Jesus but may be if you learn why it happened, then it will be a bit easier.

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 09:12

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 21/03/2024 09:03

Let’s rewrite the Bible so as not to offend young ears. Jeez.

To be fair it's been rewritten many times already. Some older versions had Jesus slaying dragons, but they had to take that out as people started asking too many questions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread