Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Mischance · 21/03/2024 12:08

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 12:05

Exactly.
I got really upset by stories of animals being killed and sacrificed. Romans killing lions, zoos and animal slaughter and seeing dead animals strung up outside butchers shops or bits of meat packaged and for sale in supermarkets. That felt more real to me.

Unfortunately that’s all part of life and world history or part of some religious traditions. We can’t avoid it being taught.

Kids watch these things all the time, Watership Down, Bambi etc. It can’t all be banned because some find it upsetting.

It is about being age-appropriate. Small children do not need to be subjected to the barbarism.

Mischance · 21/03/2024 12:07

but children definitely need to understand the meaning of Easter. They absolutely must realise that it's not just about chocolate and fluffy chicks. - well, no they don't. For many children fluffy chicks (new life) is indeed what it is all about.

Later when they are older they need some understanding of Christianity (and indeed other religions) in order to make sense of cultural references - art, music etc. Until then, let us spare them this barbaric stuff.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 12:05

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:57

Thank you - exactly what I think. No two kids will have the same reaction so it's wrong to assume all five year olds will be 'fine' about it.

Obviously, some kids are fine - my daughter was completely fine about Horrible Histories type gore from around eight, but wouldn't even watch a Disney Film aged five.

Someone earlier said that they will come across worse in real life or on the news - I really hope not!

Exactly.
I got really upset by stories of animals being killed and sacrificed. Romans killing lions, zoos and animal slaughter and seeing dead animals strung up outside butchers shops or bits of meat packaged and for sale in supermarkets. That felt more real to me.

Unfortunately that’s all part of life and world history or part of some religious traditions. We can’t avoid it being taught.

Kids watch these things all the time, Watership Down, Bambi etc. It can’t all be banned because some find it upsetting.

leafinthewind · 21/03/2024 12:02

purplemonkey12 · 21/03/2024 10:56

I've always thought that if any other religion had as its main symbol a man NAILED TO A CROSS, the Average Brit would be completely and utterly horrified. It's weird the way we all shrug, oh yeah, totes normal.

Exactly!

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 12:00

phauxtox · 21/03/2024 11:57

Is that when you converted to being a self righteous bore? 😂

No, it's when I decided I disagreed with indoctrinating children.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/03/2024 11:59

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 11:45

Not just biblical stories either.
History in general.

Im thinking decapitated body parts on spikes on London Bridge and city entrances
Beheadings
Pirates left to rot in cages strung above streets.
They didn’t have Asbos and tags and a bit of community service in those days

They really took the crime and punishment to the next level so they did.

Don't do the crime if you can't do the time/punishment!!!

Hanged, drawn and quartered is another gory method of punishment.

Something I've wondered ever since I learned about the guillotine. Once the head is removed from the body, can the head still talk? I don't know if it was something I watched in a programme like Horrible Histories and a head was talking from the basket but as the brain is in the head, and there would be blood in the cranial cavity (at least for a very short time) could the head still talk?

phauxtox · 21/03/2024 11:57

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:49

Attitudes like this are is why I am an ex-catholic!

Is that when you converted to being a self righteous bore? 😂

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:57

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 11:51

Appreciate that
Which is why I said ‘I think a lot of people’ ….not all. Any two people will have different thoughts and reactions to a single situation.

Thank you - exactly what I think. No two kids will have the same reaction so it's wrong to assume all five year olds will be 'fine' about it.

Obviously, some kids are fine - my daughter was completely fine about Horrible Histories type gore from around eight, but wouldn't even watch a Disney Film aged five.

Someone earlier said that they will come across worse in real life or on the news - I really hope not!

LookItsMeAgain · 21/03/2024 11:53

Tlolljs · 21/03/2024 09:31

If we get a bank holiday for all of those I’m in 😀

That's one way to get a 4 day working week every week of the year 😆

BeaRF75 · 21/03/2024 11:53

We all learnt this as small children - it's fine. The whole point is that Jesus had to die.
It's also fine not to believe in Christianity, but children definitely need to understand the meaning of Easter. They absolutely must realise that it's not just about chocolate and fluffy chicks. Well done that teacher, for allowing children to learn.

Devonbabs · 21/03/2024 11:51

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 21/03/2024 11:06

"Wholesale lifted" is an oversimplification. The ancient Mediterranean was a melting pot of cultures: Greek, Roman, Jewish, Persian etc. It was a multi-lingual, international context. There was a dense cultural matrix of myths and legends and they influenced each other. From this unique context, Christianity emerges: a particular amalgam of Jewish and Greek/pagan influences. But not unique in that respect; if you look at a Jewish writer from a similar time and place like Philo of Alexandria you'll see that he was also deeply influenced by Greek thought.

Jewish was Jewish and spoke Aramaic. The New Testament is written in Greek. It then gets translated into Latin.

I appreciate people's point that there are clear similarities and influences with other ancient near eastern religions and mythologies, but it's ignorant to just say that Christianity "wholesale lifted" things.

Great post

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 11:51

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:47

A generalisation as per most posts on here- I was at church every Sunday from birth and found it hugely upsetting, I broke down crying in mass once and had nightmares - not all kids are the same.

I chose not to subject my kids to this, and they learned about the Easter tradition in about year 4 - community school not religious - in a much nicer way.

Appreciate that
Which is why I said ‘I think a lot of people’ ….not all. Any two people will have different thoughts and reactions to a single situation.

BIossomtoes · 21/03/2024 11:50

Wait til she hears about Salome asking for John the Baptist’s head on a plate for her birthday.

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:49

phauxtox · 21/03/2024 10:52

Every Catholic on Mumsnet is like, she got to 5 before hearing this? She'll be fine seriously.

Edited

Attitudes like this are is why I am an ex-catholic!

Minymile · 21/03/2024 11:47

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/03/2024 11:17

If I'm being generous, Jesus was a real man, but just a conjurer and good illusionist

He was a rabbi.

Although in those days a rabbi could mean a teacher, non trained, not an official part of the ‘church’ or religious hierarchy.

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 11:47

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 11:43

I’m assuming, as a Christian, you attended a church that did not have Jesus on the cross ie Protestant or similar religion.
I think a lot of people on here saw the image of Jesus on a cross either in church or pictures when they were very young so it wasn’t a shock when they were taught the story in school.

A generalisation as per most posts on here- I was at church every Sunday from birth and found it hugely upsetting, I broke down crying in mass once and had nightmares - not all kids are the same.

I chose not to subject my kids to this, and they learned about the Easter tradition in about year 4 - community school not religious - in a much nicer way.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 11:45

LookItsMeAgain · 21/03/2024 11:42

In Ireland we have St Stephen's Day where in the UK you have Boxing Day. I believe that is because St Stephen is/was the first martyr and we celebrate that in Ireland....apparently....Also his feast day is remembered in Good King Wenceslas (apologies for the spelling there).

Always a school day here 😄

Not just biblical stories either.
History in general.

Im thinking decapitated body parts on spikes on London Bridge and city entrances
Beheadings
Pirates left to rot in cages strung above streets.
They didn’t have Asbos and tags and a bit of community service in those days

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 11:43

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 21/03/2024 11:39

I was about 8 years old and a Christian, when we were taught about the whole Crucifixion Story. I obviously knew before then that a very good man named Jesus had died on a cross, but I had never heard about in detail before. I cried my eyes out, when I found out, and even though I am in my 60's now, I still feel both horrified and nauseous whenever I think about how awful it was to kill someone who was so good, in such a horrific manner.

I am not a member of the Christian Church anymore, my beliefs have changed - except about Jesus - and do not align much with either The Church of England's, or the Roman Catholic Church's teachings. If there is any sort of God, and if Jesus was literally his son, then I am disgusted that he would let his son suffer on the Cross in the way it is reported that Jesus did.

So to the people here who say that they knew the details about Jesus's death since they were about 4 or 5, and it didn't bother them, then fine, but please don't say that it didn't bother any of the other children, because I was very bothered about it, but I did my crying when I was alone. I don't think I even told my mum or my dad...

I’m assuming, as a Christian, you attended a church that did not have Jesus on the cross ie Protestant or similar religion.
I think a lot of people on here saw the image of Jesus on a cross either in church or pictures when they were very young so it wasn’t a shock when they were taught the story in school.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/03/2024 11:42

Mallani · 21/03/2024 08:16

There are tons of horrible stories in the Bible - much worse than this. My dd treated us to a graphic stick-person drawing of the stoning of St Stephen on a restaurant napkin (complete with spurting blood) when she was 6. Lovely! I've still got it :)

In Ireland we have St Stephen's Day where in the UK you have Boxing Day. I believe that is because St Stephen is/was the first martyr and we celebrate that in Ireland....apparently....Also his feast day is remembered in Good King Wenceslas (apologies for the spelling there).

Always a school day here 😄

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 21/03/2024 11:39

I was about 8 years old and a Christian, when we were taught about the whole Crucifixion Story. I obviously knew before then that a very good man named Jesus had died on a cross, but I had never heard about in detail before. I cried my eyes out, when I found out, and even though I am in my 60's now, I still feel both horrified and nauseous whenever I think about how awful it was to kill someone who was so good, in such a horrific manner.

I am not a member of the Christian Church anymore, my beliefs have changed - except about Jesus - and do not align much with either The Church of England's, or the Roman Catholic Church's teachings. If there is any sort of God, and if Jesus was literally his son, then I am disgusted that he would let his son suffer on the Cross in the way it is reported that Jesus did.

So to the people here who say that they knew the details about Jesus's death since they were about 4 or 5, and it didn't bother them, then fine, but please don't say that it didn't bother any of the other children, because I was very bothered about it, but I did my crying when I was alone. I don't think I even told my mum or my dad...

Justpontificating · 21/03/2024 11:24

Luckily Henry viii doesn’t come till KS2 🤣

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 21/03/2024 11:23

It was the same for most of us. She won't be giving it deep thought at that age.

Mischance · 21/03/2024 11:19

So - some small chidlren find it upsetting, some don't it would seem.

But, given that it is wholly unnecessary information for school children, it would be best to leave it out to avoid upsetting some - just as a teacher would do with any other subject.

Personally I would be worried about a child of mine not being upset by it, as it shows a lack of normal human feeling.

NonPlayerCharacter · 21/03/2024 11:17

If I'm being generous, Jesus was a real man, but just a conjurer and good illusionist

He was a rabbi.

Everythinggreen · 21/03/2024 11:17

If I'm being generous, Jesus was a real man, but just a conjurer and good illusionist, like the David Blaine of his time, and Chinese whispers exaggerated the stories before someone wrote them down.

If you delve into mythology and demonology, there's mentions of other powerful forces that could be work as a crossover and attached to a "God" like power, archangels and demonic creatures but never a Jesus 🤷‍♀️