Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
ruhroh · 21/03/2024 14:06

housethatbuiltme · 21/03/2024 13:39

TBF its not even 'story book' like the old testament parts. Its one of the most factual bits that in history people genuinely where nailed to the cross for acts of crime or treason and this could take the form of religious persecution.

Is the rest of it not weirder, like teaching them someone magically came back from the dead?

or that bunnies shit out chocolate eggs?

Yeah, I actually grew up thinking nails was a fairytale/legend type thing and was surprised to grow up and learn about the technicalities of crucifixion, eg sponge, organ failure, asphyxiation etc.

Anyway, she'd have heard lots of stories about other traditional forms of punishment like beheading ("off with his head!") in Alice in Wonderland, or fantasy ones like a witch baking and cannibalising children in Hansel and Gretel. Most Disney kids movies contain a fair bit of murder and sick torture actually.

Yellowbananasarebetterthangreen · 21/03/2024 14:04

Id be far more worried about my kid if they believed a rabbit leaves chocolate eggs in the garden tbh.

AInightingale · 21/03/2024 14:03

I was more concerned that my four and five year olds were being told that the 'loving God' of the OT drowned the entire human race and all life on earth bar a handful of people and animals. I wondered what they were actually being asked to believe, it's batshit really.

ruhroh · 21/03/2024 14:00

Did she think it was superglue everytime she saw a crucifix?

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 13:59

IfYouCouldSeeWhatICanSee · 21/03/2024 13:51

Maybe do some of your own, alternative research with her?
It does seem unlikely nails alone would have held any grown man in that position long enough for death to occur.
If schools have to teach religion then all possibilities should be explored? For all religious groups imo.

The nails went through his wrists. The Greek word used can refer to either palms or wrists, and we know Romans executed people on the cross by nailing the wrists.

CurlewKate · 21/03/2024 13:51

@TheGreenManalishiWithTheTwoProngedCrown

I think children should know about the Holocaust too. I don't think 5 year olds need to know the details of the concentration camps, though.

IfYouCouldSeeWhatICanSee · 21/03/2024 13:51

Maybe do some of your own, alternative research with her?
It does seem unlikely nails alone would have held any grown man in that position long enough for death to occur.
If schools have to teach religion then all possibilities should be explored? For all religious groups imo.

housethatbuiltme · 21/03/2024 13:39

TBF its not even 'story book' like the old testament parts. Its one of the most factual bits that in history people genuinely where nailed to the cross for acts of crime or treason and this could take the form of religious persecution.

Is the rest of it not weirder, like teaching them someone magically came back from the dead?

or that bunnies shit out chocolate eggs?

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 13:31

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 13:25

he probably existed but didn’t do anything amazing.

It’s understood he existed as a preacher ( or rabbi if you like ). He had such a huge following the authorities and high priests started to get concerned that he was a bit too radical and a bit too popular so they decided to get rid of him.
It’s worth noting there were lots of preachers at the time as the population was having a sort of slavery / cost of living crisis.

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 13:29

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 13:25

he probably existed but didn’t do anything amazing.

"The historicity of Jesus is the question of whether or not Jesus of Nazareth historically existed (as opposed to being a purely mythical figure). The question of historicity was generally settled in scholarship in the early 20th century,[1][2][3][note 1] and today scholars in the field agree that a Jewish man called Jesus of Nazareth did exist in the Herodian Kingdom of Judea and the subsequent Herodian tetrarchy in the 1st century CE, upon whose life and teachings Christianity was later constructed.[note 1]"

His life and teachings kind of changed the course of human history, whether you like it or not... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 13:27

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 12:05

Exactly.
I got really upset by stories of animals being killed and sacrificed. Romans killing lions, zoos and animal slaughter and seeing dead animals strung up outside butchers shops or bits of meat packaged and for sale in supermarkets. That felt more real to me.

Unfortunately that’s all part of life and world history or part of some religious traditions. We can’t avoid it being taught.

Kids watch these things all the time, Watership Down, Bambi etc. It can’t all be banned because some find it upsetting.

That upset me too, as did the story of Abraham and Isaac - I couldn't get it out of my head. Just my experience.

I agree it shouldn't be avoided at all - history being taught age-appropriately I am fine with.

Don't get me started on Watership Down and Bambi 😂

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 13:25

YankSplaining · 21/03/2024 12:55

Re: history and art: oh God, yes, and add literature to that as well. I graduated from a pretty well-known American college, and it was truly dismal how many people didn’t recognize basic Biblical allusions. The poor English literature professors were like, “Okay, in this chapter, someone falls from grace in a garden. Now, what Biblical story is this referring to?” Silence. I always had to raise my hand because I went to Catholic school. Afterwards, people would come up to me and be impressed that I knew stuff you’d find in a 64-page beginning children’s Bible.

Everybody needs a basic working knowledge of the Bible and Greek mythology if they want to understand western art and literature.

As the only Catholic in my practice as an architect I always did the church designs.
No one seemed to know the very basics of what was required in a church. Such as
the stations of the cross….12 or 13 and where to locate them
a font! and where to locate it.
a sacristy
etc etc.

I does seem amazing how little some people grasp the very basics of the Christian religion in a Christian country especially as many of them studied art or/ and art history to Alevel.

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 13:25

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 13:19

The amount of people claiming that Jesus never existed is just unbelievable.

Dawkins once glibly claimed he probably didn't exist, and he was so embarrassed that he had to backtrack and affirm he "probably" did exist.

No credible historian in the world thinks he didn't exist.

he probably existed but didn’t do anything amazing.

LoreleiG · 21/03/2024 13:21

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 21/03/2024 12:20

They will. Kids need to toughen up or shall we scrub out all the upsetting nasty bits of history?

History of all kinds being taught at an appropriate age I have no problem with. Five year olds being taught about specific crucifixion details I find unnecessary.

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 13:19

The amount of people claiming that Jesus never existed is just unbelievable.

Dawkins once glibly claimed he probably didn't exist, and he was so embarrassed that he had to backtrack and affirm he "probably" did exist.

No credible historian in the world thinks he didn't exist.

TheGreenManalishiWithTheTwoProngedCrown · 21/03/2024 13:15

Everybody needs a basic working knowledge of the Bible and Greek mythology if they want to understand western art and literature.

I agree. But small chidlren do not need to be subjected to details of crucifixion.

You don't agree, then. You either learn about the Bible and Greek myths or you don't. A sanitised version of either doesn't make any sense and doesn't help you understand art/literature/music.

EverybodyIsFantastic · 21/03/2024 13:07

YankSplaining · 21/03/2024 12:55

Re: history and art: oh God, yes, and add literature to that as well. I graduated from a pretty well-known American college, and it was truly dismal how many people didn’t recognize basic Biblical allusions. The poor English literature professors were like, “Okay, in this chapter, someone falls from grace in a garden. Now, what Biblical story is this referring to?” Silence. I always had to raise my hand because I went to Catholic school. Afterwards, people would come up to me and be impressed that I knew stuff you’d find in a 64-page beginning children’s Bible.

Everybody needs a basic working knowledge of the Bible and Greek mythology if they want to understand western art and literature.

An entire seminar group of my undergraduates didn’t know what the Annunciation was recently, and colleagues teaching Milton have to do a lot more basic prep work now…

Mischance · 21/03/2024 13:06

*I'm fascinated by some of the language on this thread. A couple of posters have described crucifixion as "barbaric"/"barbarism".

Just interesting since of course Jesus was crucified by the Romans, who very much identified as explicitly not Barbarians!*

Barbaric has a general meaning as a n adjective - as I am sure you know!

Mischance · 21/03/2024 13:05

Everybody needs a basic working knowledge of the Bible and Greek mythology if they want to understand western art and literature.

I agree. But small chidlren do not need to be subjected to details of crucifixion.

Parker231 · 21/03/2024 13:05

kkloo · 21/03/2024 12:40

It's far more unpleasant that little kids are told that Jesus died for our sins, and that we're all sinners and that they have to tell the priest their confessions 😷

I’d be furious if anyone told my DC’s that they are sinners!

YankSplaining · 21/03/2024 12:55

Devonbabs · 21/03/2024 07:41

Maybe take your child into a church, read the Easter story together and discuss it in any way you like.

I’m surprised your daughter has not seen a crucifix before. Everyone in the West needs a good education in Christianity much of western history and art is very closely intertwined with it.

Re: history and art: oh God, yes, and add literature to that as well. I graduated from a pretty well-known American college, and it was truly dismal how many people didn’t recognize basic Biblical allusions. The poor English literature professors were like, “Okay, in this chapter, someone falls from grace in a garden. Now, what Biblical story is this referring to?” Silence. I always had to raise my hand because I went to Catholic school. Afterwards, people would come up to me and be impressed that I knew stuff you’d find in a 64-page beginning children’s Bible.

Everybody needs a basic working knowledge of the Bible and Greek mythology if they want to understand western art and literature.

thepastinsidethepresent · 21/03/2024 12:53

At my school that was accompanied by a very graphic explanation of what crucifixion did to the body, BUT that was at secondary school. Up until then I think I just assumed he was tied to the cross and died of starvation.

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 21/03/2024 12:52

Mischance · 21/03/2024 12:08

It is about being age-appropriate. Small children do not need to be subjected to the barbarism.

I'm fascinated by some of the language on this thread. A couple of posters have described crucifixion as "barbaric"/"barbarism".

Just interesting since of course Jesus was crucified by the Romans, who very much identified as explicitly not Barbarians!

Moonmelodies · 21/03/2024 12:51

HoppingPavlova · 21/03/2024 12:10

We all learnt this as small children - it's fine. The whole point is that Jesus had to die**

Exactly. And not just ‘die’ but suffer immensely while he died. That’s the point.

Whether you are a Christian, Agnostic, Atheist or any other religion, it’s an historical fact that a dude named Jesus (translated over the ages) did exist and wandered around that area and was crucified. Pretty much everything else is up for debate, from the details of his conception, to certain acts he may have undertaken that are now termed miracles, who his ‘father’ was in an ongoing sense, whether his ‘father’ is ‘real’, what happened after he died etc, but irrespective, the fact is he was a real person who was crucified which involved torture. To pretend otherwise or make out to kids he was some dude who died peacefully while being held by some form of velcro to a cross is really odd.

It is very much not a "historical fact" - there are no contemporary records, and only 'scholars' who accept a few vague letters written decades after the event believe it to be true.

WitsEnd10 · 21/03/2024 12:48

Alconleigh · 20/03/2024 22:24

You've never been in a church? Really?

What’s so unbelievable about that? I’d never been in a church until a few years ago when a friend had their wedding in one, I’m almost 40.