Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
AgnesX · 21/03/2024 16:58

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:39

Not time immemorial. Just since the Romans brought Christianity to our shores and forced it upon us. Before that the British isles has a huge amount of history and ‘religion’ was a more Pagan style tradition that followed the seasons and we worshipped the sun and nature.

So actually Easter IS about bunnies and chicks (ie new life) as the festival of Ostara/Eostre was celebrating new life, springtime, the return of the warmer days and the sunshine for centuries before Christianity arrived here. Christianity appropriated that festival and called it Easter and added a story of new life/being reborn into it (ie Jesus on the cross/resurrection).

Excuse my ignorance for being wrong about pre Christian rituals and Osteria but didn't people also sacrifice to the gods??

Apologies for being wrong there too -- I don't want to start a bun fight.....

Lessstressedhemum · 21/03/2024 16:56

Ostara is the origin of the word Easter in English. But Easter is not an English festival. As I said above, it's probably called Easter here because the pronunciation of the original British/Celtic term was probably already familiar to native speakers, so church fathers decided to keep the name when they introduced Christianity to the people.

OneMoreTime23 · 21/03/2024 16:55

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:49

It’s the same with Xmas. Our ancient ancestors celebrated Yule which was around the winter solstice and celebrated the return of the sun (or son 🤔!).

Also a myth. Quite an outdated one now

https://www.google.com/amp/s/ca.thegospelcoalition.org/article/christmas-isnt-pagan/%3famp

Looks like an unbiased source…….

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:49

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:45

Ostara/Eostre is absolutely the origins of Easter. It’s clear from the wording!
It an old English tradition from LONG before Christianity was brought here by the romans.

It’s the same with Xmas. Our ancient ancestors celebrated Yule which was around the winter solstice and celebrated the return of the sun (or son 🤔!).

It’s the same with Xmas. Our ancient ancestors celebrated Yule which was around the winter solstice and celebrated the return of the sun (or son 🤔!).

Also a myth. Quite an outdated one now

https://www.google.com/amp/s/ca.thegospelcoalition.org/article/christmas-isnt-pagan/%3famp

Christmas Isn’t Pagan - The Gospel Coalition | Canada

No modern Christmas tradition can draw a strait line to any clear and decisive pagan origin.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/ca.thegospelcoalition.org/article/christmas-isnt-pagan/%3famp

Lessstressedhemum · 21/03/2024 16:48

delapp · 21/03/2024 16:40

Well, yes, but ... if you're interested, check out How Does the Spring Equinox Relate to the Timing of Passover?

As Rabbi Posner points out, "The primary factor, which overrode all others [for the Sanhedrin deciding this actual date from year-to-year], was the spring equinox."

That is fascinating. I knew about the three year leap year but not the Sanhedral judgement on how when to add an extra month previous to the standardising.

Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix · 21/03/2024 16:48

I haven't read the full thread but you should probably let your daughter know they didn't nail people to the cross by their palms as this wouldn't support the weight.

It's much more likely the nails went through the bones of the forearm.

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:45

BurntOrange · 21/03/2024 15:44

Easter doesn't have origins in a pagan festival - it's a myth that is thrown up every single year. It's just not true. It's in spring because Jesus was crucified at Passover

Ostara/Eostre is absolutely the origins of Easter. It’s clear from the wording!
It an old English tradition from LONG before Christianity was brought here by the romans.

It’s the same with Xmas. Our ancient ancestors celebrated Yule which was around the winter solstice and celebrated the return of the sun (or son 🤔!).

Lessstressedhemum · 21/03/2024 16:45

delapp · 21/03/2024 16:23

@Lessstressedhemum :"The Vernal Equinox is the eggs, bunnies, Eostre one. Easter is based purely on the date of Passover."

... And the date of Passover is based on ... ... full moon ... ... following, ... ...(wait for it!) ... ... Vernal Equinox.

Passover, Schmaschover, Easter, Schmeaschter ... what's it matter so long as you get your bunnies and eggs?

Given that the Hebrew Exodus from Egypt most likely happened in the C13th BCE, I think it's probably unlikely that Passover is based on the Celtic pagan celebration of the Vernal Equinox. It is based on the date of the Paschal moon, the first full moon after the equinox, of course it is, no one would dispute that. It's dating is probably tied to the goddess Ishtar, but I don't know enough about early Sumerian/Mesopotamian/Canaanite religion to be definitive. I expect eggs were involved but I very much doubt bunnies were.

It is untrue, though, to say that Christianity hijacked a pagan festival for Easter. It is based on the date of the Passover, when Jesus was crucified. This is obvious from the name of Easter in many other languages. We used Easter probably because the word would have been somewhat familiar to native people when Christianity was introduced by the Romans and then reintroduced by the Celtic missionaries.

delapp · 21/03/2024 16:40

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:25

The date of Passover marks the actual date in the calendar in which Jews believed God passed over the homes of the Hebrew slaves in Egypt

Well, yes, but ... if you're interested, check out How Does the Spring Equinox Relate to the Timing of Passover?

As Rabbi Posner points out, "The primary factor, which overrode all others [for the Sanhedrin deciding this actual date from year-to-year], was the spring equinox."

TeenLifeMum · 21/03/2024 16:40

@AmethystSparkles you’re right, apologies for mistyping.

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:39

AgnesX · 21/03/2024 14:09

They've been teaching it from time immemorial. Along with the rest of brutal history.

Easter isn't about fluffy bunnies as much as you might like to kid yourself.

Not time immemorial. Just since the Romans brought Christianity to our shores and forced it upon us. Before that the British isles has a huge amount of history and ‘religion’ was a more Pagan style tradition that followed the seasons and we worshipped the sun and nature.

So actually Easter IS about bunnies and chicks (ie new life) as the festival of Ostara/Eostre was celebrating new life, springtime, the return of the warmer days and the sunshine for centuries before Christianity arrived here. Christianity appropriated that festival and called it Easter and added a story of new life/being reborn into it (ie Jesus on the cross/resurrection).

anotherside · 21/03/2024 16:37

It’s ridiculous teaching 5 year olds about religion. They don’t have the concept of myth vs fact vs belief etc. If parents care they can tell their own children themselves. And of course the UK is a country in which a whopping 6% of people are practising Christians. Stick to the eggs and bunnies, at least that part of fun and encapsulates the wider meaning of Easter which predates Christianity.

liverpoolnana · 21/03/2024 16:30

EverybodyIsFantastic · 21/03/2024 13:07

An entire seminar group of my undergraduates didn’t know what the Annunciation was recently, and colleagues teaching Milton have to do a lot more basic prep work now…

And as for the confusion of 'Immaculate Conception' with 'Virgin Birth' .....

Tootsweets84 · 21/03/2024 16:30

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/03/2024 16:15

The Vernal Equinox is the eggs, bunnies, Eostre one. Easter is based purely on the date of Passover.

Why's it called Easter then?

It isn't called 'Easter' in Hebrew. The two dates are close together so I would imagine at some point it was easier to just use the existing Germanic Spring festival name to cover the new Christian festival

OkPedro · 21/03/2024 16:29

Mum2jenny · 20/03/2024 21:48

It’s religion, get over it. It’s good that kids get taught about Christianity and the key facts relating to it. Easter is not all about bunnies and Easter eggs.

Why is it good that children get taught about Christianity? Unless your family are practicing christians then what's the point? Telling someone to just put up and shut up or in your words "get over it" is ridiculous

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:29

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:26

Yeah it’s not fetishly patriarchal at all…. All that whipped and stripped stuff as well….

And what you were told about this form of execution is absolutely true. It was common at the time. It's history. Don't blame Christianity for that.

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:27

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:26

Yeah it’s not fetishly patriarchal at all…. All that whipped and stripped stuff as well….

This capital punishment was administered by Roman pagans, not Christians...

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:26

Jetstream · 21/03/2024 10:49

Christianity has a bit of a fetish when it comes to detailing punishments. They like it gory.
We were told this at a young age too. We were also told that crucifying was a commonly used capital punishment at that time. Also that Jesus got off lightly as people were also crucified upside down.
Oh and that women were treated really badly, often traveled in with the cattle and sheep while the men traveled in comfort on seats.

Yeah it’s not fetishly patriarchal at all…. All that whipped and stripped stuff as well….

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:25

delapp · 21/03/2024 16:23

@Lessstressedhemum :"The Vernal Equinox is the eggs, bunnies, Eostre one. Easter is based purely on the date of Passover."

... And the date of Passover is based on ... ... full moon ... ... following, ... ...(wait for it!) ... ... Vernal Equinox.

Passover, Schmaschover, Easter, Schmeaschter ... what's it matter so long as you get your bunnies and eggs?

The date of Passover marks the actual date in the calendar in which Jews believed God passed over the homes of the Hebrew slaves in Egypt

WitsEnd10 · 21/03/2024 16:25

GetWhatYouWant · 21/03/2024 14:10

So you'd never even been to visit any cathedrals or churches out of interest while on trips or holidays? I find that absolutely astonishing and I'm an atheist.

Never. We didn't go on holiday as children and my parents certainly weren’t interested in visiting churches or cathedrals on days out. To be honest we very rarely went on trips or days out. My first holiday was at 12 to Cornwall for five days.

delapp · 21/03/2024 16:23

@Lessstressedhemum :"The Vernal Equinox is the eggs, bunnies, Eostre one. Easter is based purely on the date of Passover."

... And the date of Passover is based on ... ... full moon ... ... following, ... ...(wait for it!) ... ... Vernal Equinox.

Passover, Schmaschover, Easter, Schmeaschter ... what's it matter so long as you get your bunnies and eggs?

Tootsweets84 · 21/03/2024 16:23

I mean, that is the story of Easter and the UK has been Christianised for a fairly long time so most children in mainstream school will have learned this and not been too traumatised by it.
The Pagan spring festival always falls on the Spring equinox - which was yesterday :) - and that one IS all about bunnies and eggs (a sick bird that was turned into a healthy hare that lays eggs actually). I grew up celebrating 'Easter' on Easter Sunday with my atheist parents and not really understanding why some people went to church and were mildly offended by all the focus on chocolate eggs. My own children (home ed) celebrate the equinox on the correct day (and take advantage of the happy coincidence that there are chocolate eggs in Tesco) and don't really take any notice of Easter because it's not our sacred day.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 21/03/2024 16:20

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/03/2024 16:15

The Vernal Equinox is the eggs, bunnies, Eostre one. Easter is based purely on the date of Passover.

Why's it called Easter then?

Here’s Encyclopaedia Brittanica to explain

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands
Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:18

Fly3344 · 21/03/2024 14:34

My child is reception and was upset about this story , I think it’s unnecessary. I’ve told them it’s not a real story, Jesus isn’t real but some people believe he is when they are religious.

You are lying to your child....

Justpontificating · 21/03/2024 16:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Is the name calling necessary.
You made your point without it