Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jesus held on the cross with nails in his hands

839 replies

TaFox · 20/03/2024 21:43

DD5 is in year 1 and has been learning about Jesus at school. Great stuff in the spirit of Easter.

The RE teacher told the class how Jesus was NAILED to the cross.

This is quite graphic for a little girl who believes that the Easter bunny will leave eggs in our garden.

Should I tell school that this is too much info for little ears?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
celticprincess · 21/03/2024 20:25

Ah yes, mine did it from nursery as they were at a catholic pre school from age 3 and they went to church for mass if there was a school mass on.

I think by y1 she was learning about Louis Braille and the accident that caused him to lose his sight and how the use of braille came about. That was quite a graphic story as well.

But yes, RE is part of the school curriculum and the different religious stories need to be told. They’ll hear a lot worse in history lessons though doing the plague, the Tudors etc. Lots of gruesome tails to be told.

Elly46 · 21/03/2024 20:24

I’m catholic and was taught in a convent school by nuns from age 3, in the late 70’s. I learned that he was nailed to the cross and it didn’t affect me at all.

Bertielong3 · 21/03/2024 20:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Scottsy200 · 21/03/2024 20:22

Perfect Mumsnet post

maybe they can change it to the fact that he was held on the cross by pretty bows and ribbons just so your little precious doesn’t get upset, what has become of this bloody world

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 20:22

Laikalaika · 21/03/2024 16:49

It’s the same with Xmas. Our ancient ancestors celebrated Yule which was around the winter solstice and celebrated the return of the sun (or son 🤔!).

Also a myth. Quite an outdated one now

https://www.google.com/amp/s/ca.thegospelcoalition.org/article/christmas-isnt-pagan/%3famp

That’s hardly an unbiased opinion is it. And for every website that holds this opinion there is another which disputes it. For example https://www.history.co.uk/articles/the-pagan-roots-of-easter

You are entitled to your opinion as I am to mine but you’ll never convince me that Easter doesn’t have its roots in our ancient English/Irish/Celtic/Pagan traditions. Hares/rabbits and eggs have been around as symbols of new life and springtime for centuries longer than the story of Jesus being killed on a cross.

The pagan roots of Easter

Some historians have argued the name derives from a pagan springtime goddess called Ēostre

https://www.history.co.uk/articles/the-pagan-roots-of-easter

Toffifee1 · 21/03/2024 20:21

Can’t believe that she got voted unreasonable. I wouldn’t want my toddler to be told anything involving the torture of a living creature. My DC doesn’t need to know how animals are slaughtered yet or how people were nailed to a cross or other mean things humans do/did to each other.

Emmz1510 · 21/03/2024 20:19

To answer the person who thought it was wrong for this to be taught in schools- I understand your point however im an atheist and I have always taught my daughter that she gets to choose what she believes when she is older and can make the decision for herself. That’s why I don’t have a particular issue with my daughter learning about religion in school and being told these stories.

I agree with user1475. At 4 she won’t fully understand or have an emotional connection to how painful and bloody that would have been and probably have just a superficial, matter of fact understanding of it. They don’t overthink things at that age.
Any distress she does have is likely to be short lived and you can validate her feelings and reassure her in a child friendly way that although it would have been very painful Jesus was very very brave

NoEnemiesManyPatios · 21/03/2024 20:17

NB: not through the hands, but the wrists. So even their Xian iconography gets it right. >smdh<

Wingham · 21/03/2024 20:14

ConsistentlyPeeved · 21/03/2024 19:43

Apologies for pissing on the chips of those who think Easter isnt about chocolate eggs and bunnies.

Read up about how Christian's/ catholics took pagan holidays/ rituals and made them their own.

Yes Jesus story is unique. However the egg representing fertility and new beginnings dates to Babylonian times. A fertility goddess known by Ostara was thought to be able to turn into a hare and lay eggs.

Chocolate ones?

Prunesqualler · 21/03/2024 20:13

Wonder how OP would feel about dc watching their teacher do a rabbit dissection in class at age 9 as my kids did.

ConsistentlyPeeved · 21/03/2024 19:43

Apologies for pissing on the chips of those who think Easter isnt about chocolate eggs and bunnies.

Read up about how Christian's/ catholics took pagan holidays/ rituals and made them their own.

Yes Jesus story is unique. However the egg representing fertility and new beginnings dates to Babylonian times. A fertility goddess known by Ostara was thought to be able to turn into a hare and lay eggs.

Yellowbananasarebetterthangreen · 21/03/2024 19:21

@ConJob oh my goodness my pelvic floor muscles. You've won the internet for me today!

CaliforniaHereWeCome1 · 21/03/2024 19:00

Totally agree it’s inappropriate for that age group. Shame on the people who squeal “but it’s religiiiiooon and it really happened and we should respect beliefs”. Lots of horrible things happen that we don’t tell 5 year olds about because they are not old enough. Religion is all fabricated bullshit so why are we still inflicting this nonsense on children? It should be prohibited.

Graviga · 21/03/2024 18:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

ruhroh · 21/03/2024 18:53

Mischance · 21/03/2024 18:26

Ah that's fine then. Let's give her the detailed facts. Never mind she is in reception!

Honestly, as a child I loved fun facts like these. I loved Horrible History too like most children!

maddiemookins16mum · 21/03/2024 18:52

I was raised Catholic, we’ve heard it all from a very young age. In fact watching any kind of depiction of The Crucifixion was pretty normal for us wains from a young age.
You can’t have a proper Easter without blood, nails and an empty tomb I’m afraid.

ConJob · 21/03/2024 18:49

Yellowbananasarebetterthangreen · 21/03/2024 14:04

Id be far more worried about my kid if they believed a rabbit leaves chocolate eggs in the garden tbh.

I failed to see the 't' on the end of rabbit and considered converting!

swimlyn · 21/03/2024 18:45

Err...

It's all a work of fiction @TaFox .

Tattletwat · 21/03/2024 18:34

OneMoreTime23 · 21/03/2024 16:55

Looks like an unbiased source…….

I tried reading some of it, it's horrendously biased.

BurntOrange · 21/03/2024 18:32

@benefitstaxcredithelp Nope, not true for Christmas either. A lot of these ideas are outdated Victorian scholarship which have since been found to be completely wrong

Mischance · 21/03/2024 18:26

Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix · 21/03/2024 16:48

I haven't read the full thread but you should probably let your daughter know they didn't nail people to the cross by their palms as this wouldn't support the weight.

It's much more likely the nails went through the bones of the forearm.

Ah that's fine then. Let's give her the detailed facts. Never mind she is in reception!

Catsbreakfast · 21/03/2024 18:14

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 09:03

Can’t believe you’re not religious and you believe all this. You call them traditions and customs but they’re not originally our British traditions (see above all the posts about the true origin of ‘Easter/Ostara/Oestra’. Christianity tagged all these fantasy stories onto existing traditions when the Romans brought it with them.

I don’t believe it but that’s what’s in the bible and what was being taught in religious studies. I can’t believe you read all this and can’t comprehend what I said.

ApplePippa · 21/03/2024 17:46

benefitstaxcredithelp · 21/03/2024 16:39

Not time immemorial. Just since the Romans brought Christianity to our shores and forced it upon us. Before that the British isles has a huge amount of history and ‘religion’ was a more Pagan style tradition that followed the seasons and we worshipped the sun and nature.

So actually Easter IS about bunnies and chicks (ie new life) as the festival of Ostara/Eostre was celebrating new life, springtime, the return of the warmer days and the sunshine for centuries before Christianity arrived here. Christianity appropriated that festival and called it Easter and added a story of new life/being reborn into it (ie Jesus on the cross/resurrection).

Did Ostara/Eostre predate Christianity in the British Isles? I'm not sure she did. She arrived with Germanic invaders/settlers (who eventually became the Anglo Saxons) in the post-Roman era. Christianity first arrived in the Roman era.

Cas112 · 21/03/2024 17:45

I literally got taught the same thing

Literally thought nothing of it and can't say I'm scarred for life opConfused

Lidlisthebusiness · 21/03/2024 17:36

@Whereareallthemillionaires that's good to know, mine are home ed, so I cover things from all angles. As an atheist, I think it's how I can give them broadest approach. I know when I was at senior school, I did a project on witchcraft in RE, but I didn't know if things like the Pagan beliefs were looked at.

Swipe left for the next trending thread