Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why don't people just stop drinking?

139 replies

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 19:44

Just read two crimes that were caused by alcohol.
One a speeding drunk driver, took a car and smashed Into another car on the road killing people.

Did they really think they were going to be able to negotiate the roads properly while drunk and speeding?

Another one a vile bully of a man attacked and killed his wife while he'd been drinking and she died.😱
Now two children have been left without their mum and dads in prison.
I'm sure we can all think of other crimes where drink was involved.

When are people going to stop?
Why do they need to drink all the time (sake).🙄

OP posts:
WhatWhereWho · 20/03/2024 23:46

My goodness why has no one thought of this before. Have you contacted the press, police of perhaps even the government? How did you come up with such a good plan? Have you thought of a solution to the climate issue, bet you could if you tried.

Shakespeareandi · 20/03/2024 23:42

Why are so many people assuming OP is talking about alcoholics?
I wouldn't assume drink drivers are alcoholics. I think the UK should have 0 tolerance, like so many other countries, so you couldn't even have half a lager and drive.

MissingMoominMamma · 20/03/2024 23:30

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 20:11

Be better for them if they did stop?

Of course it would. I suspect most people who drink to excess wish that they had never started.

SuperstarDeejay · 20/03/2024 23:28

PostItInABook · 20/03/2024 21:10

The people in the OPs initial aren’t alcoholics. Being drunk and a twat doesn’t make you an alcoholic. Being drunk and breaking the law doesn’t make you an alcoholic. These are just arseholes who choose to get drunk and then choose to do evil and stupid things whilst drunk and refuse to take any responsibility for it. They do not deserve any sympathy and they do not deserve to be medicalised as having an addiction.

Exactly. The glib 'it's an addiction!' posts are a ridiculous simplification of the issue.

Lots of people aren't alcoholics but change when they drink too much, and not for the better. How many times have you heard people described as 'gets a bit XXX when they've had a few.'

If that XXX is not a positive thing, they just need to cut it out instead of continuing to drink knowing they'll be problematic. It's not like drinking is compulsory! Zero proof drinks and teetotallers are everywhere these days, there's never been a better time to just walk away from it - while you still can - if it doesn't agree with you.

FunkyPenguin · 20/03/2024 23:16

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 20/03/2024 23:11

Why are the first few posts assuming these are alcoholics?

Plenty of people aren't, but drink too much and then behave badly (to say the least, obvs) because their judgement is impaired.

Yes they do think they can navigate the roads drunk, because their judgement is impaired.

No they don't think they're going to kill someone, because their judgement is impaired.

No an alcoholic can't 'just stop'. And a person who is not an alcoholic but is drunk won't just stop being drunk, or doing daft things, because their judgement is impaired.

This is so true, I didn't mention in my previous post that I crashed a friend's car while I was;

  1. Uninsured
  2. Drunk
  3. Under the influence of drugs

I was 17 and didn't even have a license to drive, alcohol and drugs impair your judgement and you make apocalitically stupid decisions, fortunately nobody was hurt or killed or I wouldn't be able to live with myself.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 20/03/2024 23:11

Why are the first few posts assuming these are alcoholics?

Plenty of people aren't, but drink too much and then behave badly (to say the least, obvs) because their judgement is impaired.

Yes they do think they can navigate the roads drunk, because their judgement is impaired.

No they don't think they're going to kill someone, because their judgement is impaired.

No an alcoholic can't 'just stop'. And a person who is not an alcoholic but is drunk won't just stop being drunk, or doing daft things, because their judgement is impaired.

FunkyPenguin · 20/03/2024 23:07

It's not as simple as you think OP, I spent much of my youth in the Middle East and the "Expat" culture was rather toxic at the time.

Despite the strict Islamic laws, drugs and alcohol were readily available in certain circles. We felt as though we were in a bubble which was immune to the laws of the country, a common expat trap to fall into.

I became addicted to drugs and alcohol in one of the most strict jurisdictions in the world, we felt we were above the law and partied all the time.

It's not something that happens to you overnight, you don't realise it, and it creeps up on you very quickly and before you know, it's taken hold.

Panpastels · 20/03/2024 23:01

It's a socially accepted addictive substance. That's why I don't do it anymore.

VampireWeekday · 20/03/2024 22:53

I mean, those people drink to excess. Most of us manage to drink without ever endangering other people.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 20/03/2024 22:17

Most people who drink alcohol are not addicts, don't drink and drive and do not commit crimes or engage in anti-social behaviour. You won't read about them in the news because 'person has a couple of drinks and walks home from the pub' does not have much impact as a headline, but you must know some such people surely?

Bluegray2 · 20/03/2024 22:02

You sound very naive

easilydistracted1 · 20/03/2024 21:42

Being drunk even an alcoholic doesn't make you murder women so YABU. If I get very drunk I talk shite cuddle my wife and go to sleep. I don't know many other women who would do any murdering in response to too many cocktails either

Waitingfordoggo · 20/03/2024 21:39

I think the main ‘reason’ people drink and drive is that they mistakenly think they are more in control than they actually are. They don’t feel that drunk and so surely their driving won’t be affected. Most of us who have been very drunk at some point in our lives will find this familiar because most of us at some point have woken up with an Armageddon of a hangover and thought ‘blimey, I didn’t realise I was that drunk last night’. Or we realise we can’t remember portions of the night before, even though at the time we only thought we were ‘tipsy’ rather than drunk. Most of us of course won’t drive after drinking because it’s a hard line that we won’t cross. But it is one of the tricks of alcohol that we often don’t realise how drunk we are, and I assume this is how most drunk drivers end up in that situation. (That or outright arrogance- yes, I’m pissed but I’m an excellent driver and it’s only a short distance and I probably won’t get caught…)

I know a few people who will drive after one drink but I think the majority of my friends and family members don’t drink anything at all if they know they’re driving later (or early the next day).

I don’t think you’ve said anything particularly groundbreaking by posting a thread saying that drunk drivers are terrible people- we pretty much all feel like that; and it is of course illegal. As to why it happens and how to make it stop- if we had the answer to that, we’d be able to solve the problem. I daresay governments and lawmakers have been puzzling over this particular conundrum for quite some time. If MN can come up with an answer, we should get some sort of prize.

I think alcoholism is a different matter and agree with PPs that most of those who drink drive probably aren’t alcoholics. I’ve known a few alcoholics and most of them didn’t drive at all- or even leave their house other than to walk to the shop for booze.

But I expect there are also some ‘functioning’ alcoholics who manage to hold down a job and then get stuck into the wine every night. They’ll be driving their kids to school in the morning and driving themselves to work and a proportion will be over the limit.

PostItInABook · 20/03/2024 21:22

Resilience · 20/03/2024 20:55

I wish it were this simple.

IME alcohol is too readily used as an excuse. Most people who intentionally seriously hurt someone when drunk (e.g. abusers) are the kind of people who think it's ok to hurt others anyway. They just hide it better or control it more easily when sober. Most people who drink drive choose to do so long before they become over the limit.

All alcohol does is lower inhibitions. With some rare exceptions it doesn't fundamentally alter personality or moral code.

Agree with this post.

Cantrushart · 20/03/2024 21:16

Or, the violent, drunk attackers should just calm down. Aggression is never the solution.

PostItInABook · 20/03/2024 21:16

drspouse · 20/03/2024 21:06

I understand it's an addiction and that some men are just violent anyway but I don't really get why people drink and drive. Do they think they aren't affected even though everyone else is? Or is it when they are so far gone they think the rules are stupid/they no longer care if they hurt someone?

It’s not an addiction. It is breathtaking arrogance. I attended an incident many years ago where one such scumbag killed two teenage girls and seriously injured a third. Of course he was fine. He was laughing and joking on scene whilst the bodies of the two girls lay in some poor persons front garden. That’s just one of the ones I’ve unfortunately had to attend. There are many more. Drink and drug drivers make me sick.

PostItInABook · 20/03/2024 21:10

The people in the OPs initial aren’t alcoholics. Being drunk and a twat doesn’t make you an alcoholic. Being drunk and breaking the law doesn’t make you an alcoholic. These are just arseholes who choose to get drunk and then choose to do evil and stupid things whilst drunk and refuse to take any responsibility for it. They do not deserve any sympathy and they do not deserve to be medicalised as having an addiction.

Helpisso · 20/03/2024 21:07

TimetoPour · 20/03/2024 20:31

What a short sighted view OP.

Drink drivers are not alcoholics, they are the ignorant scum of the earth who think, “it will never happen to me”

Those who get drunk and hurt their spouse are not alcoholics, they are violent criminals who prey on the weak.

Bad people make bad decisions. Whilst alcohol makes these situations worse, it is not necessarily the root of the problem.

Alcoholism is a secret illness. You are more likely to find they have an excuse not to drive. They are more reclusive as they don’t want their illness pointed out.

This in spades . I have friend who I even went on holiday with for a week. She never drank alcohol in front of me . I was chucking the wines down my neck in the evenings and never realised that every time she went to the loo frequently, she was drinking .
it is a horrible way to live and these people do not drink and drive,they avoid driving!
Friend hasn’t driven for years because she has a painful elbow!
Rather that ,than the idiots who go out ,get pissed and drive home because they think they can !

drspouse · 20/03/2024 21:06

I understand it's an addiction and that some men are just violent anyway but I don't really get why people drink and drive. Do they think they aren't affected even though everyone else is? Or is it when they are so far gone they think the rules are stupid/they no longer care if they hurt someone?

Yourethebeerthief · 20/03/2024 21:06

@PassingStranger

You think it's OK then to cause such misery and devastation then to others lives just because you want to get drunk?

Want to get drunk?

OP, you don't understand what alcoholism is. You think you do, but you don't. I've lost a loved one to alcoholism. You simply don't know what you're talking about and your post is naive in the extreme. Like a schoolchild's understanding of a very complex issue.

I sincerely hope you find out more about alcoholism and addiction so that you can understand it better.

There is no excuse for drunk driving, but you would do well to learn more about how alcoholics suffer. Louis Theroux made a good documentary about the subject if you're interested.

opentoadvice88 · 20/03/2024 21:03

Because I love wine.

ButtockUp · 20/03/2024 21:02

'It's not impossible to give up addictions, when it comes to the point your addiction is ruining your life and others it definitely is time to give up.
I'm sure alcohol plays a part in alot of horrible things.'

Does light bend round you?

Do you have any insight into addictions?

Do you actually understand the definition of 'addiction?'

LadyWiddiothethird · 20/03/2024 21:01

I have been sober nearly 21years.Does the OP think people want to be alcoholic? When asked at school what a child wants to be when they grow up,do you think some of them say,oh I want to be an alcoholic?

You sound a bit thick to be honest @PassingStranger,go and do some research on addiction and stop posting shite.

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 21:01

tillyandmilly · 20/03/2024 20:52

I hate the drinking culture in the UK - I have always been treated differently because I chose not to drink alcohol - I can still enjoy myself without alcohol - but apparently I am boring ?

No your the sensible one.

OP posts:
abominablesnowman · 20/03/2024 20:59

Alcohol addiction is so severe that in some cases, stopping drinking can actually kill you. This thread is incredibly ignorant and the idea that people just need 'willpower' is horrible naiive and rather offensive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread