Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sleep training is bad for mental health AIBU?

60 replies

Katbum · 20/03/2024 19:26

I’m starting to think you can trace the emergence of sleep training as a widespread practice in the 90s through the emergence and rise in young adult mental health crises from the 2010s or so on. AIBU? Is there longitudinal research on this?

OP posts:
WolfFoxHare · 20/03/2024 21:00

VivaVivaa · 20/03/2024 20:35

You are confusing causation and correlation. I think there is a rise in mental health diagnosis because we are much better and quicker at recognising mental health problems. And that’s from someone who chose not to sleep train.

She’s not even confusing correlation - parenting has become more attachment based since at least the 70s, not less. She’s just confused.

VioletMoonGirl · 20/03/2024 20:50

Try reading The Nurture Revolution by Greer Kirshenbaum, PhD.

TheKeatingFive · 20/03/2024 20:49

I believe sleep training was most prevalent in the 70s. You might want to compare that generation with the ones that came after it?

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 20/03/2024 20:45

My DH's grandma visited the other day, and she was saying how she was told to put her son (my FIL) in the pram at the bottom of the garden for naps and just leave him there.

It wasn't called "sleep training" but it's no different to cry it out. And is far harsher than something like Ferber.

Just because it wasn't called sleep training, I think you're wrong if you think that everyone pre the 90s was cuddling their children to sleep and never leaving them to cry for a minute.

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:41

EasterBunnny · 20/03/2024 20:24

If only all babies came with that setting!

I got lucky all three times.

I got lucky with the first and smugly assumed it was due to my excellent parenting instincts. My second one revealed to me that it had been purely pot luck! He woke screaming every 45 minutes for 6 months no matter what I did and I nearly died of exhaustion. Sleep trained him over 3 nights at 6 months and thereafter he woke only once or twice per night.

VivaVivaa · 20/03/2024 20:35

You are confusing causation and correlation. I think there is a rise in mental health diagnosis because we are much better and quicker at recognising mental health problems. And that’s from someone who chose not to sleep train.

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:33

Mental health issues largely due to screens and social media and too much traffic meaning kids can't play out

User8646382 · 20/03/2024 20:32

It makes you wonder how many comments on forums like this, conditioning people to believe that (1) children should never be disciplined (2) ‘contact napping’ is best for babies and (3) anyone who tells you otherwise is ‘toxic’ and should be ignored or banished, are actually written by the Therapy Industry. 85% of them, I would imagine.

The internet is a powerful tool and most people are pretty gullible.

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:32

There is longitudinal research and it shows no effect on child mental health from sleep training. It shows a beneficial effect on parents mental health.

Easy to find on Google scholar if you want to read it.

All the negative stuff is from Romanian orphanages - hardly comparable to a loving home environment

WolfFoxHare · 20/03/2024 20:32

Pissing myself at this. You know sleep training existed before the 90s, right? My MIL left DH to cry himself to sleep and he’s about the most stable well-adjusted person I know. Meanwhile I have anxiety and a billion hang-ups, and slept through happily from six weeks with never any need for my parents to do anything except pop me down sleepy but awake. I even used to burp myself!

converseandjeans · 20/03/2024 20:29

I think it's the opposite actually. Parents refusing to put a baby into a routine, patting & shushing & co sleeping have made children far less resilient. I would imagine most of us born in the 70s & 80s were in a routine very early on & weaned at 3 months. I don't think Mums fretted as much either. I imagine the strict routine & early weaning avoided lots of sleepless nights! Or they just pushed the pram to the end of the garden where they couldn't hear it!

Octavia64 · 20/03/2024 20:29

Sleep training has been a thing much further back than the 90s.

This link seems biased but it mentions books from over 100 years ago.

intuitiveparentingdc.com/blog/history-of-sleep-training

ColleenDonaghy · 20/03/2024 20:28

EasterBunnny · 20/03/2024 20:24

If only all babies came with that setting!

I got lucky all three times.

Frankly, that's not fair. Grin

I got lucky once and I'll take it. She's making up for it as a threenager though.

Wheresthescissors · 20/03/2024 20:28

User8646382 · 20/03/2024 20:10

It’s more like the lack of sleep training causing the mental health problems. I bet at least 50% of diagnosed SEN conditions would miraculously disappear if kids started getting a proper night’s sleep.

Edited

Yeah, sleep away the autism.
😡

SilverGlitterBaubles · 20/03/2024 20:25

That is quite a leap OP. I think quite a lot has happened in society that has had a bigger impact on the mental health of young people than whether or not they were left to cry for a short time as a baby.

EasterBunnny · 20/03/2024 20:24

If only all babies came with that setting!

I got lucky all three times.

ColleenDonaghy · 20/03/2024 20:23

EasterBunnny · 20/03/2024 20:17

I didn’t sleep train my DC, I put them
in their cots awake and they went to sleep, there was no crying involved.
They stopped waking for a feed at 8 weeks and slept 12 hours at 12 weeks. No laying with them for hours getting them to go to sleep or up every hour or so.

If only all babies came with that setting!

RheaRend · 20/03/2024 20:23

NO the current issues are down to lack of resilience and not making kids deal with small issues and always having to be happy etc. So when they get bigger they have no coping strategies. Then even a minor thing is a huge issue when they have no way of dealing with it.

ColleenDonaghy · 20/03/2024 20:22

Dishwashersaurous · 20/03/2024 19:41

Perhaps it's the opposite. The more recent child centred child rearing having the negative long term impact, rather than child simply slotting into life.

Eg babies being put in prams in the garden for hours in all weathers

I think this is more likely than sleep training being an issue, sleep training has been around forever.

The emergence of the internet and then social media are surely the biggest influences on generational differences though.

TobKat · 20/03/2024 20:17

I did quite a bit of research about sleep training (the 'controlled crying' method that I think you're probably referring to) and there's no evidence that it causes psychological damage. The advice is to wait until a baby is at least 6 months old. It took 3 nights to sleep train my DS (at 10 months) and since then he's always slept through the night without any problem. I've got many friends who decided not to sleep train and their now 7 year olds are still struggling to sleep and coming in to their bed every night. I find it difficult to function with broken sleep & could never cope with that!

EasterBunnny · 20/03/2024 20:17

I didn’t sleep train my DC, I put them
in their cots awake and they went to sleep, there was no crying involved.
They stopped waking for a feed at 8 weeks and slept 12 hours at 12 weeks. No laying with them for hours getting them to go to sleep or up every hour or so.

User8646382 · 20/03/2024 20:10

VenusClapTrap · 20/03/2024 19:59

I think there are many factors behind the mental health crises in young people, but sleep training isn’t one of them.

It’s more like the lack of sleep training causing the mental health problems. I bet at least 50% of diagnosed SEN conditions would miraculously disappear if kids started getting a proper night’s sleep.

VenusClapTrap · 20/03/2024 19:59

I think there are many factors behind the mental health crises in young people, but sleep training isn’t one of them.

Shetlands · 20/03/2024 19:50

It wasn't called sleep training in the 80s but I don't remember any of my friends doing co-sleeping and all the night time palaver expected of parents these days. Unless they were teething or ill, babies and toddlers were put to bed and left there. I remember the advice was to go in after a few minutes crying (no lights on) and stroke them back to sleep (no talking, no picking up). Once they were weaned (4 months back then), we only offered water if they kept up the crying.

I'm not saying we had it right - it was just different and from my perspective now, less stressful than what I read on here.

fluffycatkins · 20/03/2024 19:44

I don't think sleep training has any impact either way but as a society we have been progressively moving away from sleep training well before the 90's.