Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sleep training is bad for mental health AIBU?

60 replies

Katbum · 20/03/2024 19:26

I’m starting to think you can trace the emergence of sleep training as a widespread practice in the 90s through the emergence and rise in young adult mental health crises from the 2010s or so on. AIBU? Is there longitudinal research on this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
converseandjeans · 21/03/2024 20:24

Agree with @Myotheripodisayoto

Lack of sleep is causing far more issues. I would say an exhausted parent is far less effective than a fully rested parent. The focus should be on everyone sleeping through.

It seems you have to have them in with you for 6 months & not wean until 6 months. So it's unlikely anyone will sleep solidly.

sunglassesonthetable · 21/03/2024 18:17

Lol. This is brilliant defensive work pps.

OP is clearly on the wind up.

LifeExperience · 21/03/2024 12:28

Sleep training did not "emerge" in the 1990s. It has been used by exhausted parents since time immemorial.

LoftyTurtle · 21/03/2024 12:17

Fwiw I contact napped for the first 4 months of DDd life but it was much more for me than her, I loved having an excuse to cuddle her and sit on the sofa and not do housework!!

PuppetQueen · 21/03/2024 12:09

Gosh OP, back in the 70s my mum was very much of the view that you should put babies in their cot, close the door and leave them until morning. She got this from her own mum, who had done the same thing in the 1940s (lots of kids, so no time to stand around rocking the current baby to sleep). No mental health problems amongst me and my siblings, or my mum and her many sibs.

I did the whole attachment parenting, cosleeping malarky and I do have kids with mental health problems. I have many theories as to why this might be, but sleep training definitely isn't one of them!

LoftyTurtle · 21/03/2024 12:06

I think it largely depends on the type of sleep training. Leaving your baby to cry hysterically? Probably not the best for their development. My baby was a pretty good sleeper (after about 6 months old) feed her, put her down and she'd go straight to sleep. But sometimes she would cry, not a hysterical cry but more whinging - I figured out very quickly that if I went in and fussed about her she would just get more wound up and upset. If I left her for not even a minute, she'd quickly roll over and go straight to sleep. I really don't see how this kind of "sleep training" would damage her tbh. It was very obvious to me the difference between her whinging for 30 seconds and bawling her eyes out inconsolably (in which case obviously I would go comfort her)

arethereanyleftatall · 21/03/2024 12:00

Sorry op, but I'm laughing at the idea that my mother, 4th of 8 born in the 50s, living in a 2 bed house, was rocked to sleep in her parents arms for hours.

Myotheripodisayoto · 21/03/2024 11:50

I know sending babies to nursery at a very young age is an essential for a lot of people but I wonder what effect that may have on future mental wellbeing?

Im not sure about big nurseries for under twos. I think home/family type settings with one main caregiver are better - the government really should encourage childminding as its also possible to provide higher quality care with better ratio via childminder than it is via nursery with high premises costs.

RafaistheKingofClay · 21/03/2024 11:09

I can’t imagine that most babies’ needs are best met by not getting a decent block of sleep overnight and being cared for by exhausted parents whose sleep is being broken.

user1497787065 · 21/03/2024 11:09

I know sending babies to nursery at a very young age is an essential for a lot of people but I wonder what effect that may have on future mental wellbeing?

Just a thought not any kind of accusation.

Halfemptyhalfling · 21/03/2024 11:07

I think the extreme gentle parenting is more likely to lead to mental health problems because tired parents unable to cope and other adults and children having to deal with princes/princesses

ColleenDonaghy · 21/03/2024 11:03

Myotheripodisayoto · 21/03/2024 10:54

I'd say the opposite, a lack of sleep training/good sleep hygiene is worsening things.

Tired children behave worse, struggle more to cope.

I was definitely sleep trained & im very resilient, my children both have been too.

I wonder this too. I didn't particularly sleep train, but my eldest went from waking every two hours in our room to sleeping through most nights from the first night we moved her to her own room at 7 months. There was a huge change in her in the daytime too, she was so much sunnier.

Sleep is good and important, for all of us. I'm not convinced sleep training is a bad thing at all.

KnittedCardi · 21/03/2024 11:00

Katbum · 21/03/2024 10:02

Lol. This is brilliant defensive work pps.

You may call it defensive. We call it fact. You are seeking self confirmation bias.

Myotheripodisayoto · 21/03/2024 10:57

Sleep training does not only mean cry it out.

It can include gradually reducing sleep props at an appropriate age to teach a child to fall asleep easily without being held/rocked/fed to sleep etc. It does usually mean accepting some cries as changes are made. It doesn't mean ignoring cries, but it means knowing and accepting for eg a 1 year old may resist change and cry to communicate that but you may gradually introduce the change anyway.

WhatDoesThisMeanForUs · 21/03/2024 10:56

Neither sleep training nor mental health issues are remotely new. They have both been around as long as humans have.

There are plenty of other modern things to actually be concerned by. Sleep training is not one of them.

Myotheripodisayoto · 21/03/2024 10:54

I'd say the opposite, a lack of sleep training/good sleep hygiene is worsening things.

Tired children behave worse, struggle more to cope.

I was definitely sleep trained & im very resilient, my children both have been too.

Whoknowsohyoudo · 21/03/2024 10:52

Sleep training does have negative effects on babies I believe, as I do agree with Erik Eriksons stages of personality/world view development in children. What he says just makes sense. The first stage an infant goes through is trust vs mistrust and not responding quickly and caringly to a child's cry teaches them that their needs will not be met. They eventually learn crying is futile. That leads to a view of the world where you will not be safe and cared for. Does it impact them throughout their lives? Sure I think so. Is it the cause of the incline of mental health issues lately. I don't think so.

whereswaldoooo · 21/03/2024 10:47

Agree @ColleenDonaghy

We didn't do any sort of crying it out (we did do other "training" like trying to do eat-activity-sleep, but I don't think that's what the Q is aimed at, so am not feeling defensive).

But I know my lovely mum would have let me and my siblings cry a bit (after checking our physical needs were met). I think it was usual in the 80s. That's why responsive parents now complain about older generations not understanding their methods

ColleenDonaghy · 21/03/2024 10:30

Katbum · 21/03/2024 10:02

Lol. This is brilliant defensive work pps.

No one's being defensive. I didn't sleep train and I still think you're wrong! It's just a fact that sleep training used to be the norm, it just wasn't called that, it was called looking after a baby.

whereswaldoooo · 21/03/2024 10:25

I don't think it's sleep training parentdata.org/is-there-a-best-method-for-sleep-training/

It could well be phone use / screens if that fits the timeline?

Katbum · 21/03/2024 10:02

Lol. This is brilliant defensive work pps.

OP posts:
NannyGythaOgg · 20/03/2024 22:09

Pre the 90s(ish) it was called parenting.

Mary7241 · 20/03/2024 21:57

More likely connected to iPhone release date 2007…

DodgeDoggie · 20/03/2024 21:28

Sleep training goes back century’s, it’s not a modern thing. I suspect mental health issues derive from unsuitable agenda driven education, parental absence, too much screen time, social media dynamics, not enough nature and movement, pandemic chaos and the break in societal engagement (particularly difficult for those with adhd/PDA/autism who just about managed ok pre covid).

InTheRainOnATrain · 20/03/2024 21:14

🤣 sleeping training was invented in the 90s. Hilarious. That’s maybe when someone invented the idea of checking in versus full cry it out?!

The only things we know for sure is that sleep is a basic human need and that babies and toddlers cry. It’s literally impossible to avoid them ever being upset, so IDK why some people get so weirdly fixated on bedtime. Mine spent a hell of a lot more time screaming in the car seat than it typically takes Ferber to work. Maybe someone study that 🤷‍♀️

I’d like to think we’re better at recognising and treating mental health issues now but honestly IDK. It’s definitely not the sleep training.