Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that staying single as a signed Mum is the most sensible option

63 replies

Justkeepswiimming · 19/03/2024 18:32

I've been single for 4 years. I've a 7 year old dd. I've not really been looking for another partner, but the more I see threads on here the more I think that staying single it the most sensible option for me, and particularly my daughter.

From threads about child sex offenders targeting single Mums, to others about the challenges of blending families, introducing partners to children, terrible step parents, or these relationships showing themselves to be as bad as the last and of course cocklodgers. And this if course is AFTER you manage to find someone as a single person. Tinder is awful. Spare time is very limited. Social circle is limited.

I struggle to see many positives, but a fair number of risks. Am I being cynical and negative?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chatonette · 20/03/2024 09:59

I completely agree with you OP. I grew up in a blended family and it was horrible. Never felt 100% welcome at either house. Felt like the ‘new children’ in the new marriage were the priority. When moving house, my bedroom allocation was prioritised last. Holidays were taken without me, when I was at my other parents’ house. I could go on and on. I had a miserable childhood. My own grandparents treated me well, as well as my stepfather’s mother. That woman was a saint—treated me like all of her biological grandchildren, even leaving me some money in her will when she passed away (not much—only a token amount, but it meant a lot to me). She had a portrait of herself from her 20s, which I always loved as a child. When her house was being cleared out, I asked if I could have it to display in my home, but was told I couldn’t have it, as I wasn’t one of her real grandchildren.

Because of my upbringing, I decided that I would never date a man who already had children. And if my husband and I did ever split up, I would remain single until my kids were at uni (or later). Some of the dramas I read here reinforce how I feel—dramas with exes, Mother’s Day, not wanting to be guardians for orphaned stepchildren, etc. I’ve lived through these scenarios as a child and won’t ever put my children through it.

Noseybookworm · 19/03/2024 22:57

I think staying single is absolutely a valid choice but it's not for everyone. I know women who have kept their relationship separate from their children and I know some who have ended up living with a partner who turned out to be a really good stepdad and have a great relationship with their children. It can work out with the right person.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 19/03/2024 22:53

YANBU. My mum remained single until I was an adult and I am SO grateful she did for all the reasons mentioned. A boyfriend would have totally changed the dynamic and I suspect not for the better, one way or another.

Seasonofthesticks · 19/03/2024 22:10

Another single mum (no co parent) here to a 7 year old girl. I agree - I work full time and the little spare time I do have is for my daughter. I’ve tried relationships in the past and it stresses me out trying to spread my time out. Also financially I’m better off alone until she is grown. Quite happy just me, my daughter and our Labrador!

teabooks · 19/03/2024 21:33

I stayed single when my last son was born he`s 19 now.
My children came first that was my choice.
In that time i found out alot about myself.
Now kids are both adults im loving life mainly on holidays as the kids dont come with me anymore i go 5-6 times a year.
Im still single and love it but i have my fun like anyone else i just dont want the drama of a relationship.
As i say its a choice and i like my choice.
I raised my family and now its all about me but no way is a man moving in my home.
And no way i want to settle with a man.
Rather go on my holidays and act like a slag for a week come home no one knows anything.
Other than im very happy and refreshed 😉.
Its not just sand and sun putting a smile on my face lol.
I love life.

bombastix · 19/03/2024 21:31

I agree. I have kept my relationships post divorce apart from my children. It is our house and they did not ask to have this situation so it was the least I could do to make it their place.

People these days want to move in and quickly. That is a no from me however lovely they seem (actually massive red flag).

Ariona · 19/03/2024 21:23

CreateAUsername2024 · 19/03/2024 18:49

Yanbu at all. Good for you for putting your daughter and ultimately yourself first.

I agree. Well done for making sure that your dd comes first.

StarDolphins · 19/03/2024 21:21

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 21:13

I will say one thing to anyone reading. Don't think "oh I'll have a relationship when the DC are adults".

  1. By that point you will struggle to accept the compromises that not only come with living with another person, but even just from dating them. Living on your terms will make you selfish. I don't say that in a negative way, I am single and happily selfish! But it is not conducive to a future partnership.
  1. Life is getting harder and more expensive. DC moving out at 18 is now a distant dream for most! If you think introducing a partner to small children is hard, wait till you try introducing them to adult children, who still live with you! It doesn't work. They will never get on.
  1. You also have to consider the inheritance aspect. If you marry, everything goes to your husband. What you worked years for to build and you want to leave to your children. This means you can't approach the relationship in the "normal" way as you have to keep one eye on protecting your assets. Again its not really conducive to an equal partnership.
  1. Which maybe should have been no1! By your 40's/50s it will be mostly the dregs left. Any decent man will be long married and happy with his wife. It is nigh on impossible to find a good man in your 50s.

If you're happy to never have a relationship, or not a serious one. Fair enough. It's a choice I've made for myself. But my warning is to those who think they can just wait and it will all slot into place. It won't.

I agree with most of this.

But not the one about only dregs once you hit 40’s/50’s - yes it might be harder but still entirely possible. What about the decent guys that are widowed, been cheated on, just fell
out of love? There will still be decent ones.

I think a big problem for women is that it’s much easier for a man to find a decent woman than a woman to find a decent man.

AuntMarch · 19/03/2024 21:18

I'm single. My son goes to his dad EOW.
It would take the world's most amazing man to fall from the sky and land I'm front of me for me to consider giving up that time - whether I spend it with friends or just by myself!

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 21:15

I numbered those 1-4 and have no idea why they changed or why there are such big gaps in between! Sorry.

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 21:13

I will say one thing to anyone reading. Don't think "oh I'll have a relationship when the DC are adults".

  1. By that point you will struggle to accept the compromises that not only come with living with another person, but even just from dating them. Living on your terms will make you selfish. I don't say that in a negative way, I am single and happily selfish! But it is not conducive to a future partnership.
  1. Life is getting harder and more expensive. DC moving out at 18 is now a distant dream for most! If you think introducing a partner to small children is hard, wait till you try introducing them to adult children, who still live with you! It doesn't work. They will never get on.
  1. You also have to consider the inheritance aspect. If you marry, everything goes to your husband. What you worked years for to build and you want to leave to your children. This means you can't approach the relationship in the "normal" way as you have to keep one eye on protecting your assets. Again its not really conducive to an equal partnership.
  1. Which maybe should have been no1! By your 40's/50s it will be mostly the dregs left. Any decent man will be long married and happy with his wife. It is nigh on impossible to find a good man in your 50s.

If you're happy to never have a relationship, or not a serious one. Fair enough. It's a choice I've made for myself. But my warning is to those who think they can just wait and it will all slot into place. It won't.

StarDolphins · 19/03/2024 21:07

I agree. My job is to bring my DD up in a safe, happy & stable home and put her first until she is able to look after herself.

I have my own house, have great friends & my life is very busy & I also like time to myself too. I don’t know where I would fit a relationship in even if I did want one.

I had my life before she was born & I will get it again when she’s older but for now, she comes first.

Cafelattes · 19/03/2024 21:06

I was widowed when my daughter was 2 years old and this approach isn't for me, I actively want to meet someone I can build a life with. I enjoyed being married and I'd like to find that again. I'm sensible but I don't want to wait until she's grown up (I'll be mid-fifties) to start again.

I don't think this is selfish or not putting my daughter first, as some comments have implied.

Dweetfidilove · 19/03/2024 20:59

That's the plan, but not right now.

LordSnot · 19/03/2024 20:55

You are being very reasonable. Blended families are terrible for the poor children forced into them.

IMO fill your boots outside the house but don't ever move someone into your child's home.

FairFuming · 19/03/2024 20:52

I'm a single mother, I have 2 small kids who I have about 95% of the time and a really loving kind and very patient boyfriend who is also a single parent who has his kids half the time. We don't want to live together while the kids are still at home and while we do spend time all together we don't want to parent each other's kids and always try make time just for the 2 of us even if it's just a take away at night when the kids are asleep if I'm struggling for child free time or we go out for breakfast on the day off we share. It's totally different to dating when you are child free but it can be done and can be done safely as long as you set strong and sensible boundaries. You also have to know exactly what you want and what you do not want.
If you'd rather stay single then there's nothing wrong with that either.

Maray1967 · 19/03/2024 20:51

Wherearewe2001 · 19/03/2024 19:42

YANBU. I am not a single parent, but was raised by a single mum and she did exactly what you are doing. She stayed single until her last child had moved out and I am so, so grateful that she did. Growing up, I had so many friends made utterly miserable by stepfathers living in their homes. They were either emotionally abused, ignored, blamed for everything or just made to feel like they weren’t welcome in their own homes.

If I split with DH I’d do the same thing my mum did and never move a man into my family home whilst my children were still there.

Yes, I agree. Mine are well past the vulnerable age - youngest is 16 and into martial arts … - but I would not have moved someone into my house when they were younger if I’d divorced.

Sapphire387 · 19/03/2024 20:51

This has been done to death.

OP, you do you.

I was a single, widowed mum. Got married to a single, widowed dad. So we're blended.

Who's to say whether we, or the kids, would have been better off had we not got married? We love each other, we try to build a nice life for all the kids.

StrawberryTwister · 19/03/2024 20:46

saraclara · 19/03/2024 20:43

And most people equate staying single with not dating

Do they? Most people I know use it when they're dating but not committed.

Don't be ridiculous most people don't equate "staying single" with "not living with someone" 🙄

Cassidyscircus · 19/03/2024 20:44

I understand OP. I wouldn’t mind dating someone but I think it’s likely the other party only being able to see me once or twice a week will get irritating for them (that’s the reason my last relationship ended).
Im completely sure that I won’t live with a man or blend families. My house is dds safe calm space and I am not risking our sanctuary.
I also don’t trust most men not to have attitudes/ be aggressive/ sulk etc and I can’t be arsed with that nonsense

saraclara · 19/03/2024 20:43

And most people equate staying single with not dating

Do they? Most people I know use it when they're dating but not committed.

StrawberryTwister · 19/03/2024 20:38

phoenixrosehere · 19/03/2024 20:29

But you can stay single and date! There are plenty of single people who just date and don’t enter relationships.

Then the thread should be "Aibu to not live with a man again as a single parent" two different things really! And most people equate staying single with not dating

Justkeepswiimming · 19/03/2024 20:36

@StrawberryTwister I'm definitely not saying single Mums shouldn't date. Heck I've tried it myself. Not with any enthusiasm, but thats just me. Its really not meant to be self congratulatory. And actually it's great to see some other perspectives. Because sometimes it does look like staying single is a good option.

OP posts:
Samlewis96 · 19/03/2024 20:31

Dweetfidilove · 19/03/2024 20:00

YANBU - I have remained single too and it’s the best thing emotionally and financially.
I'm neither going to bring a man into her space, nor jeopardise her opportunities for the sake of living with a man.

But you can be with someone and not live with them. I spent 10 years with DSs dad but we never lived together. Ice been with my current partner nearly 8 years and we live 2 mins walk away from each other. And my youngest DC is at uni

phoenixrosehere · 19/03/2024 20:29

StrawberryTwister · 19/03/2024 20:22

And then you inevitably get the posters who "totally agree" yet go on to say there ARE in fact dating but they keep it separate, yeah that's not what the op is saying, the op is saying not dating at all this thread isn't about not moving men in it's about not dating at all so no you don't "totally agree" if you are dating.

But you can stay single and date! There are plenty of single people who just date and don’t enter relationships.