Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Startling to discipline at 10 months?

87 replies

Yesso · 19/03/2024 15:20

DS has hit 10 months and has very suddenly stopped feeling like a baby. He’s on the move now, my husband and I are in disagreement about when to start ‘disciplining’ him.

For instance he kneels against a cabinet with glass doors and bangs on it, likewise with any mirrors in the house. I feel we should be moving him away and saying ‘no’ in a stern voice. My husband is happy to let him do it and stands behind him in case he falls.

Am I crazy to think eventually the penny will drop if I keep saying no and he will stop doing it? Husband thinks he is way too young, but if we don’t start now when do we start?

OP posts:
converseandjeans · 19/03/2024 18:28

We always said 'no' to things like that as soon as they were on the move. We never had anything broken or destroyed & I think they knew it wasn't allowed. We didn't discipline them - more move them away & firmly say no. I think if you wait too long they will start causing mayhem. I don't consider myself to be overly strict.

caringcarer · 19/03/2024 18:06

Now is the time to go around your home and baby proof it before he has an accident.

CloudsUnderwater · 19/03/2024 18:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Samlewis96 · 19/03/2024 17:52

Rosesanddaisies1 · 19/03/2024 15:39

Discipline is a bit silly, as they won't understand. But you can and should move them away from a hazardous situation, just physically move or distract them. babyproofing is stupid, I've never done it - I like my nice house - I just keep them away from stuff.

Same as my mum. She always had glass cabinets displayed ornaments and crockery etc. None of us kids or her grandkids were allowed to touch and we all learned this early on.

Rickrolypoly · 19/03/2024 17:51

I wouldn't put this in the discipline category, rather the "keeping baby safe" category. Discipline is correcting bad behaviours. There is nothing wrong with moving him away and saying "ah-ah dangerous" or simply "no" and distracting him if he is doing something that can hurt him. However, you do need to baby proof your house a bit better too. I certainly wouldn't continue to let him bang on a glass door or mirror while I stood behind him.

Dacadactyl · 19/03/2024 17:50

Yes, of course you start at 10 months.

You start at whatever age they are when they're doing something you don't want them to be doing.

At 10 months, it would be a definite "no" and removing them from the area. And repeat.

SableGrape · 19/03/2024 17:48

You can't "discipline" a ten month old baby. What you can do is move them to a safe spot and redirect their attention to something safe - buy a big plastic mirror and let him play with that.

marmitegirl01 · 19/03/2024 17:47

You are not disciplining him. You are keeping him safe. Of course it's ok to say NO in a firm and different voice than you would usually use. Yes you can baby proof but don't baby proof everything as they need to learn there are just some things they don't do and that helps when you go to other places that they understand NO.

KomodoOhno · 19/03/2024 17:41

Fast800 · 19/03/2024 15:24

Yes you should start now. I’m more worried that you husband it happy to let him to continue to do something which injuries him.

This. My dd put her foot thru a glass cabinet because the sitter didn't think it would break. She was between 11 months and a year.

modgepodge · 19/03/2024 17:19

I definitely started using ‘no’ with my daughter as soon as she was on the move (probably a little older, 12-14 months). Even if it doesn’t work straight away it doesn’t do any harm. Alongside actually moving her away from anything where she actually might hurt herself of course. But if she was then crawling/walking towards something I didn’t want her to Touch I’d say ‘no’ in a specific tone and from very young she’d hesitate/stop as she knew what it meant. My nephew on the other hand not so much 😂 my child is very compliant however.

horseymum · 19/03/2024 17:14

Discipline is training not punishing, the earlier you start the better. Lengthy explanation can come later if at all. Also, you can't baby proof everything - obviously things which are dangerous but what happens when you go other places, they need to learn what no means.

Saymyname28 · 19/03/2024 17:13

Not sternly but "no banging" "no that's dangerous" and move him away. You're not telling him off. You're teaching him.

HelpMeUnpickThis · 19/03/2024 17:08

HighLlamas · 19/03/2024 15:32

Neither. The house needs baby-proofing, so he can’t get at the glass-doored cabinet.

Edited

This

sendismylife · 19/03/2024 17:07

Developmentally, the less language you can use, the better. I used, “not safe”, then picked up and distracted. 10 months is not old enough to understand why, you’re kind of getting in that vocabulary early so that the children have it when they can understand. “Hot”, “sharp”, “dangerous” were also words I used. Ideally building to a positive instruction, e.g. “feet on the grass” rather than “get out of the flower bed!”

tiggersfamily · 19/03/2024 17:04

Saying no isn't disciplining

jannier · 19/03/2024 16:53

Move away and distract give other shiny surfaces like supervised foil blankets play mirrors etc definitely don't let them bang on glass.....would he let lo hit the TV? What if he's holding a brick?

Shiningout · 19/03/2024 16:32

Applesandpears23 · 19/03/2024 15:34

This is a good age to start teaching words that mean no but explain a bit more. I used “hot” whilst moving child away from hot things for example. For banging mirrors/glass it is better to find something similar he can do. We got mirrored stick on tiles for the baby’s bedroom so she could bang, kiss and pose in safety. Can you find something similar to redirect to?

Yes this

TigBitss · 19/03/2024 16:26

I dont think it's discipline, it's just teaching your child basic safety and boundaries.

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 16:10

I'd already agreed with the need for babyproofing. That, in conjunction with positive behaviour management, and some great 'discipline' will make the OP the greatest of mothers 👑
Nothing to do with 'loud' parenting. Everything is a learning opportunity for an infant. Considering I've had DC and done brilliantly at it, and I have a Masters in Education, I think I know what I'm talking about 😁

NavyPeer · 19/03/2024 16:06

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 15:42

I disagree about not being able to reason with a 10 month old.
It's not reasoning in the adult sense, but you can definitely convey a message. If done properly, you can sometimes see the cogs turning too. E.G. Say 'hot? ouch' if little fingers are trying to touch radiators. Done with a bit of over-emphasis, babies will learn from your facial expression, if you model it, they will learn that a hot radiator is definitely something they shouldn't be touching. You will see them pause, like they're considering whether or not to continue with what they're doing! Keep instructions about behaviour you don't want, short. Over-emphasise the behaviour you want to encourage.

i disagree.

all that loud parenting is for the adult

All they are doing is mimicking you. And it’s not a reliable way of ensuring safety.

It may give you an illusion of understanding but a 10 month old, hell even a 18 month old has no concept of what something like ‘hot’ actually means until they burn themselves. And then it’s not necessarily retained for next time.

they might pause on 8/10 occasions because mummy has done wavy hand movements and jumped away, so they mimic. But the understanding of ‘if I touch that I will burn my skin and it will hurt me’ just isn’t there 100% of the time.

and we need to look after them, 100% the time.

OP is clearly describing a situation that needs to be babyproofed.

it’s not a learning opportunity for an infant

AuntMarch · 19/03/2024 15:50

Redirect, distract.
Getting into the habit of "it isn't safe, let's do xyz" is no bad thing but it won't mean anything yet - you both need to find him something else to do instead.

Edit: don't just move him away with a "no", move him TO something else and engage him. You are stopping him because it's unsafe, not because he's being disobedient. He's being a baby.

MintTwirl · 19/03/2024 15:48

Neither, distraction and also acknowledging that he is a baby and cannot help being interested in these things and creating a safe space for him.

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 15:46

There's always an issue with the word 'discipline'. Some people view it as a positive, as in, you have the discipline to go training every day. I think that an awful lot of people hear the word and think it's about telling people off. I think @Yesso you are thinking of the former?

BigButtons · 19/03/2024 15:43

You need to do something about the dangerous, easily accessible objects in your house that could cause serious harm to your baby. You don’t change the baby to suit your house. You change your house to make it safe for the baby. The baby is moving - time to move dangerous stuff out of the way. Your baby has no concept of dangerous stuff . It is up to you to protect them.
As for discipling an infant- no- just no.

Saschka · 19/03/2024 15:43

Yep, it isn’t discipline it is keeping him safe by redirecting. Just as you would if he tried to touch the cooker or run into the road.

No need to shout or impose naughty steps or punishments (which is how I’d define “discipline”). Just “nope that will break if you bang it, come over here and play with your cars” while physically removing them.