Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Startling to discipline at 10 months?

87 replies

Yesso · 19/03/2024 15:20

DS has hit 10 months and has very suddenly stopped feeling like a baby. He’s on the move now, my husband and I are in disagreement about when to start ‘disciplining’ him.

For instance he kneels against a cabinet with glass doors and bangs on it, likewise with any mirrors in the house. I feel we should be moving him away and saying ‘no’ in a stern voice. My husband is happy to let him do it and stands behind him in case he falls.

Am I crazy to think eventually the penny will drop if I keep saying no and he will stop doing it? Husband thinks he is way too young, but if we don’t start now when do we start?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
3WildOnes · 20/03/2024 19:30

KeyboardMash · 20/03/2024 09:54

"Discipline" is a bizarre concept to be using in this context. You should definitely remove him from the danger. I would probably say something like "oops, no, not for playing". It's teaching, not 'disciplining".

I see teaching and discipline as the same thing. So when an older baby or young toddler pulls your hair or scratches you might say no and place them down. Maybe there is some misunderstanding over OPs choice of words.

BurbageBrook · 20/03/2024 18:48

@Missamyp I'm not even going to engage with someone who thinks child development is 'pseudoscience' Confused

BogRollBOGOF · 20/03/2024 11:59

10 months is old enough to begin to understand words like "no", "hot" or "sharp" before distracting them and moving on to something more interesting. DS1 would look at me and howl from 10m when I said "no" then headbutt the ground (later diagnosed with autism) so there were foundations of understanding that "no" meant he wasn't getting to do what he wanted unchallenged.

It's a long process with lots of repetition, but getting mobile is a good time to start.

Babyproofing where viable is helpful for everyone's sanity, but not a complete answer. Some hazards can't be removed. Some are harder to anticipate. Sometimes you're in different environments and have to rely on vigilence and modifying/ correcting behaviour at an early stage.

Letting a child bang a glass door is potentially dangerous. They grow stronger, may hit with an object, might encounter an old glass door not up to modern safety standards. Sometimes safety glass such as shower screens can randomly blow. An accident and injury could occur before they grow out of the behaviour.

It's easier to begin managing behaviour (age appropriately) from a young age than to find you've got issues with older children with no boundaries and are unused to managing themselves appropriately to their surroundings.

Missamyp · 20/03/2024 11:45

BurbageBrook · 19/03/2024 15:37

No you don't discipline a 10 month old, that's absolutely ridiculous. They're not old enough to understand and they certainly won't have the impulse control to moderate their behaviour. You baby proof, distract and move baby away where necessary. Do some basic research on child development.
It makes me absolutely cringe when I hear people telling off little babies. Pointless, ineffective and silly.

Discipline isn't telling off or punishing.
Discipline is guidance and instruction.
Personally I'd be using distractions and offering choices and from time to time no.
I'm not a big fan of baby proofing.
Child development is pseudo science.

BertieBotts · 20/03/2024 11:37

Toycull · 20/03/2024 09:22

I honestly wouldn’t expect a ten month old to have a toy brick that could break a TV! Plastic ones maybe 😂

Wooden toys can break glass if thrown with enough force and/or they hit the glass with the wrong point of the toy e.g. a corner. A friend of mine's toddler broke a glass panel (single glazed, likely 1960s, not safety glass) in this way. Luckily nobody was near it at the time as he threw it from across the room!

We also had a glass panel door break, same type/era, when there were windows open on both sides of the house and a gust of wind went through and slammed the door. Again, luckily, nobody was hurt but this was a close shave as DH was actually standing near to the door at the time. DS2 was approximately 2 or so. I don't want to think what could have happened if he had been near the door when it happened. Huge, awful shards of glass got thrown across the room, luckily not too far as it just led into a doorway-width hallway. I had felt anxious about the door and wanted to move/replace it but we never got around to it.

OTOH we had a glass coffee table when DS1 was a toddler. It was perfectly fine, he bashed toys on it all the time, climbed on it, nothing ever happened. It was newer, so it was probably safety glass, but I never though to check this. Maybe we were lucky in that case.

Included a photo of the door. The middle part got completely blown out. The top half of it slid down in the frame to meet the bottom.

Startling to discipline at 10 months?
CloudsUnderwater · 20/03/2024 10:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Stompythedinosaur · 20/03/2024 10:10

A 10 month old is very much a baby still! And obviously too young for "discipline".

Make the environment safe, move them away, distract them.

Bearbookagainandagain · 20/03/2024 10:01

This isn't about discipline, it's about safety so yes you have to remove him from the situation (and safe proof your house).

But "saying no" isn't discipline to me either. It's about setting boundaries and understanding that you can't always do what you want for various reasons. You will be in a world of trouble later if you don't start setting those boundaries now. Stay calm, no shouting or getting stressed/annoyed, firm "no, it's not safe", and create a distraction with another toy.

KeyboardMash · 20/03/2024 09:54

"Discipline" is a bizarre concept to be using in this context. You should definitely remove him from the danger. I would probably say something like "oops, no, not for playing". It's teaching, not 'disciplining".

Toycull · 20/03/2024 09:22

I honestly wouldn’t expect a ten month old to have a toy brick that could break a TV! Plastic ones maybe 😂

jannier · 20/03/2024 09:17

Toycull · 20/03/2024 08:36

Why would a ten month old be holding a brick?

Don't your 10 month olds have wooden bricks? Or many other toys that could break your TV or were you being pedantic and asking me to specify a toy brick?

Toycull · 20/03/2024 08:36

jannier · 19/03/2024 16:53

Move away and distract give other shiny surfaces like supervised foil blankets play mirrors etc definitely don't let them bang on glass.....would he let lo hit the TV? What if he's holding a brick?

Why would a ten month old be holding a brick?

beAsensible1 · 20/03/2024 07:34

Remove any mirrors / glass from toddler height.

he is welding the house needs baby proofing. Some banging is ok because that’s how they learn. However nothing that potentially dangerous should even be within his grasp.

SpeedyDrama · 20/03/2024 07:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Thank you, I don’t if I see him actually climbing. But (luckily I guess?) mine likes to announce he’s about to climb because he knows I’ll pick him up to stop him, it’s a funny game to him. He’s nearly three so coming out of the toddler stage now.

CloudsUnderwater · 20/03/2024 07:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Snugglemonkey · 19/03/2024 23:31

My 2nd dc is 15 months. She will blow and wave if I tell her something is hot (from food to radiators). She will say "no, no" and wave her finger at the fridge (but then sometimes give into temptation and have a wee hoke until I lift her).

I have said no to danger things from she started moving. She understands quite a bit I think, buy that does not mean she pays attention. Sometimes I say no, (always with redirection) and she just chucks stuff and squeals at me. Or actually just roars at me. Hey ho, she is learning, sometimes reluctantly 😂

BertieBotts · 19/03/2024 22:51

Well sure but then why reference falling in relation to glass cabinets and mirrors specifically? The worry isn't falling in that case, is it? The worry is the glass.

If you're hovering at all cruising (e.g. sofa, coffee table) then fine, but that's a separate issue IMO to whether or not an item is safe for a baby to pull up on/bash on.

So if you disagree about whether it's safe or not that's one issue.

If you both agree that it's unsafe but you differ in terms of "we need to teach him not to do it" vs "we need to make sure he's safe around it" that's a different issue.

You might have both disagreements of course which is why I'm confused.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 19/03/2024 21:04

The penny won't drop because he can't understand the concept of "no". Redirect him on every ocassion to a safe space and give eye contact, smile, attention. Each time he goes to glass just silently without eye contact move him and make the positive interactions. You will reinforce positive behaviours. Drawing lots of attention, negative or otherwise just creates a draw and reinforces it's a rewarding behaviour.

Marblessolveeverything · 19/03/2024 20:56

HighLlamas · 19/03/2024 15:32

Neither. The house needs baby-proofing, so he can’t get at the glass-doored cabinet.

Edited

This.

RafaistheKingofClay · 19/03/2024 20:48

I don't really understand what the falling thing is about.

I’m guessing overcaution in a newly mobile/standing baby from a first time parent.

PeloMom · 19/03/2024 20:39

Dude you should be baby proofing and providing your DS with sufficient Yes- space. Not ‘discipline’ 🤦🏻‍♀️

BertieBotts · 19/03/2024 20:37

In terms of this though:

For example, he kneels against a cabinet with glass doors and bangs on it, likewise with any mirrors in the house. I feel we should be moving him away and saying ‘no’ in a stern voice. My husband is happy to let him do it and stands behind him in case he falls.

I think this is probably a difference in risk perception?

I haven't stopped my DC banging on the mirrored doors of our wardrobes because I think they are unlikely to break. Mirror tiles in the bathroom are more precarious as they are attached with double sided sticky tape (Hmm this is DH's idea of DIY) and I don't let them bang on them. The TV screen is more delicate and I don't want them banging on it. So for these two we would say no and move them away. They don't have unsupervised access to the bathroom anyway.

A glass cabinet, maybe more of a hazard and I might move it or try to dissuade them.

I don't really understand what the falling thing is about. For stuff like climbing up on tables where they might fall, I've done a mixture of let them do it and spot them in case they fall, and take them down because it's not appropriate right now. The 5yo and 15yo don't climb on tables, so they must have either exhausted any desire to climb on tables, or they have internalised the rule that it's not socially acceptable to do that. The 2.5yo will sometimes climb on tables but I am not worried about him falling off and he does this much less often than he tried to do it at 1yo. If we're at home and he's not getting in anyone's way - whatever. If we were somewhere else or it's causing a problem (e.g. there is stuff on the table) - not allowed.

Blanketpolicy · 19/03/2024 20:36

You have at least good year or so before you start anything near disciplining!

baby proof, distract, or remove until then.

Eleanorwishes · 19/03/2024 20:34

Our son banged his hands on a glass door and his hand went through it. Twenty years later he still has a big scar on his hands. Clearly you need to stop him doing anything dangerous. Glass and toddlers don’t mix.

mathanxiety · 19/03/2024 20:32

ancientpants · 19/03/2024 19:59

You "babyproof" a house to give small children a safe space to begin to explore the world. You don't train 10 month old babies like they're a naughty dog.

Very well put.

Swipe left for the next trending thread