Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New study: Millions of men ‘would xesually abuse children if secrecy was assured’ — The Times

283 replies

ElatedShark · 19/03/2024 11:35

New study: Millions of men ‘would xesually abuse children if secrecy was assured’ — The Times.

A new study has revealed a shocking proportion of Australian men would abuse children “if no one found out”.

The research, conducted by the University of New South Wales, found “concerning” patterns, including that one in six Australian men said they had feelings for children under the age of 18, with 48 per cent of those answering being aged over 54.

One in 15 men questioned admitted they would have xesual contact with a child under the age of 14 if “no one found out”, while one in 25 said the same about children under 10.

The odds of a respondent saying they would have had xes with someone under the age of 18 was 10 times higher if they were aged over 65.

The survey, which questioned over 1900 men aged between 18 and 65 years old, is the world’s largest child sexual abuse perpetration prevention survey of its kind.

The study was welcomed by those who say that the common nature of xesual violence against women needs to be studied at the perpetrator level as well as with victims.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/millions-of-men-would-sexually-abuse-children-if-secrecy-was-sure-ncf9lx5v7

AIBU to be find it disturbing that these were the men only willing to admit it and its probably alot higher??

Reminds me of that red*it thread about men getting aroused changing their daughters diapers or that other study that showed men would happily commit rape if they were assured to never be revealed/caught.

What can we as women/parents/men that don't fall into the above statistics do to combat this ? How can we ensure our sons are not thinking these thoughts are ok?

Millions of men ‘would sexually abuse children if secrecy was assured’

Millions of men would have sexual contact with a child if they were certain that no one would find out, research has suggested.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/millions-of-men-would-sexually-abuse-children-if-secrecy-was-sure-ncf9lx5v7

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
hotpotlover · 19/03/2024 16:51

CaterhamReconstituted · 19/03/2024 12:56

It’s doesn’t have popular support yet. Thankfully. But there is a reasonable amount of academic interest in it. This is how movements work - they move from esoteric academic and political circles into the mainstream.

I don't think academics are looking to make pedophilia mainstream.

What quite a lot of academics are interested in is examining the brains of pedophiles and also give them safe spaces like therapy where they can speak without shame and learn strategies, so that they won't become an offender.

dottiedodah · 19/03/2024 16:51

I seems sad if this is true .Surely these men have sisters ,friends and so on .Its horrible to think they just think of young girls as sexual fodder

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:48

I agree and I think in the past these men were more likely to go to prison for viewing the worst kinds of child sexual abuse images, I had a neighbour once who got 18 months for viewing photos only. Anecdotally speaking there have been some absolutely shocking cases where men have got away with it recently.

bombastix · 19/03/2024 16:45

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 16:39

As I said in a previous post, I worked in the CJS. For me the big problem is that offending against women and girls is not punished enough. We all know the depressing stats about rape convictions. Men who view child abuse online don't get prison. They get a community sentence, some get a programme (I don't know how effective it is) some just get unpaid work. What kind of punishment is that? To me it doesn't reflect the crime. Every one of those men has contributed to that child being abused because they are the "market" for it.

You can argue that prison doesn't really "rehabilitate" but neither does unpaid work! Or spending half an hour with a probation officer once a month (if that, because the probation service is in crisis too). Every crime has been downgraded due to prison overcrowding. But that shouldn't have included crimes against women and children in my opinion. What message does that send?

I agree with this but I think when you look at the punishment of crime specific to women and children it does not reflect the harm done. It never has. Men who view Chile abuse are sex offenders. They should go to prison and the standard sentence should be a minimum of custody. These men may present as pathetic in court but they are dangerous to children. I hear a lot of excuses made for it; what it tells you is depressing.

Garlicking · 19/03/2024 16:45

CaterhamReconstituted · 19/03/2024 14:07

Indeed. And attempts to popularise terms like MAP and hebephile etc are giving a PR gloss to child abusers. As another poster said, we all know what a nonce is.

Are you sure we all know? If we're talking prison slang, a nonce is any sexual offender.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:43

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 16:39

As I said in a previous post, I worked in the CJS. For me the big problem is that offending against women and girls is not punished enough. We all know the depressing stats about rape convictions. Men who view child abuse online don't get prison. They get a community sentence, some get a programme (I don't know how effective it is) some just get unpaid work. What kind of punishment is that? To me it doesn't reflect the crime. Every one of those men has contributed to that child being abused because they are the "market" for it.

You can argue that prison doesn't really "rehabilitate" but neither does unpaid work! Or spending half an hour with a probation officer once a month (if that, because the probation service is in crisis too). Every crime has been downgraded due to prison overcrowding. But that shouldn't have included crimes against women and children in my opinion. What message does that send?

This.

EmpressSoleil · 19/03/2024 16:39

As I said in a previous post, I worked in the CJS. For me the big problem is that offending against women and girls is not punished enough. We all know the depressing stats about rape convictions. Men who view child abuse online don't get prison. They get a community sentence, some get a programme (I don't know how effective it is) some just get unpaid work. What kind of punishment is that? To me it doesn't reflect the crime. Every one of those men has contributed to that child being abused because they are the "market" for it.

You can argue that prison doesn't really "rehabilitate" but neither does unpaid work! Or spending half an hour with a probation officer once a month (if that, because the probation service is in crisis too). Every crime has been downgraded due to prison overcrowding. But that shouldn't have included crimes against women and children in my opinion. What message does that send?

knittingball · 19/03/2024 16:33

Another thread to hid.

Garlicking · 19/03/2024 16:31

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 12:55

I think most of us know when we realised men's eyes on us changed - for me it was around the 12yo mark I noticed men staring and giving me the once over or double-taking. There was also that study that said 35% of girls found they were sexually harassed more in their uniform than wearing home clothes https://theconversation.com/i-started-walking-the-long-way-many-young-women-first-experience-street-harassment-in-their-school-uniforms-202718

Edited

I underwent my first attempted rape at 12. One perpetrator, five other men watching as if it were a fun circus act or something. Fortunately, another pal of theirs came along and went ballistic. I'm very grateful to him, but wtf the other men??!

StellaAndCrow · 19/03/2024 16:30

HandShoe · 19/03/2024 15:21

Yes. A male friend at Uni declared to me without thought or hesitation that if he found he had 6 months to live he’d ‘steal loads of money and rape as many beautiful women as possible’ To him it was a perfectly reasonable thing to say and think.

Yep, similar studies have shown a worryingly large proportion of men would have sex with women without their consent (i.e. rape) if they could get away with it.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/03/2024 16:29

WeaselCheeks · 19/03/2024 14:04

I'm not surprised that a significant minority of men are nonces. When I was at school, absolutely loads of my classmates from the ages of 13-16 were 'seeing' men in their late-20s to mid-30s. The one's 'boyfriend' was trying to convince her to do a threesome on tape with a friend. She was 14 at the time.

My best mate and her sister were abused from the age of six by a prolific paedophile. He eventually got put away for a couple of different cases of child abuse - they never went to the police, because if their own parents hadn't believed them, why would anyone else?

I worked at a place where two different guys got arrested for owning csa images - completely unrelated cases, ten years apart. The one was caught as part of a joint operation with the FBI as he was part of a big paedophile ring, he was jailed (I think he was also creating the images, as well as distributing them). The other was done for possessing extremely serious images of CSA and bestiality - he got a suspended sentences, because the judge felt that he was remorseful and sending him to prison would be 'counterproductive'.

That's not even getting to the weird creepiness you see online with female child actresses, especially as they go into their teens. Horrendous comments like, "If there's grass on the field", etc.

That is horrible.

I was regularly at the pub by 15. I was kissed by some skanky man, idk how old he was but he was well into his 20s, maybe more. I was so taken by him… except he was apparently seeing another girl in my year and I was horrendously bullied because of the kiss… all (unbeknownst to me) whilst living with a woman, whom he got pregnant around about the same time. He organised to see me several times, mostly standing me up. I didn’t realise why he never came as agreed at the time but it’s obvious, he’d preyed on another teen or was with his partner etc.

My friend was pregnant and married at 16 to a 35 year old. A group of us went to the wedding. We discussed that he was a bit too old and that 30 was our cut off point. 🤬 Unsurprisingly he turned out to be abusive and they divorced.

Snugglemonkey · 19/03/2024 16:29

WeaselCheeks · 19/03/2024 14:04

I'm not surprised that a significant minority of men are nonces. When I was at school, absolutely loads of my classmates from the ages of 13-16 were 'seeing' men in their late-20s to mid-30s. The one's 'boyfriend' was trying to convince her to do a threesome on tape with a friend. She was 14 at the time.

My best mate and her sister were abused from the age of six by a prolific paedophile. He eventually got put away for a couple of different cases of child abuse - they never went to the police, because if their own parents hadn't believed them, why would anyone else?

I worked at a place where two different guys got arrested for owning csa images - completely unrelated cases, ten years apart. The one was caught as part of a joint operation with the FBI as he was part of a big paedophile ring, he was jailed (I think he was also creating the images, as well as distributing them). The other was done for possessing extremely serious images of CSA and bestiality - he got a suspended sentences, because the judge felt that he was remorseful and sending him to prison would be 'counterproductive'.

That's not even getting to the weird creepiness you see online with female child actresses, especially as they go into their teens. Horrendous comments like, "If there's grass on the field", etc.

When we were 14 a girl in my year was pregnant by a 30 year old. He moved in with her and her mother and she had a second child at 16. Then she left school.

Garlicking · 19/03/2024 16:27

Naunet · 19/03/2024 13:18

Doesn’t carry the same stigma does it? I’m sure that makes these men a lot more comfortable.

Not really a fair comment, given that there was no stigma attached to PIE while it was thriving. Most people hadn't even heard the word 'paedophile'. In the present day, few have heard of 'hebephile'. I do think it's more useful to have one term covering both groups - there's a large overlap, in any case.

Tbh, I'd rather the new term were 'kiddy fiddlers' because everyone understands that! But I suppose Minor Attracted will do.

Adhdorlazy · 19/03/2024 16:27

@Hartley99 @Cyclebabble very interesting posts.

I agree that it was rife in the UK, and would like to think it’s less prevalent now, but sadly suspect it isn’t. Would agree it’s probably easier to speak out in UK as opposed to India.

I worked as a local journalist many years ago and often covered local court stories. I’d often suggest we covered the child sex abuse stories, but they’d often not even make the paper as the editor didn’t think they were news! Apparently, ‘it happened all the time’ and people weren’t surprised! Or interested.

Cyclebabble · 19/03/2024 16:26

@Hartley99 I do not disagree. Abusers look for opportunities and come in all shapes, sizes and ethnicities. The issue we have within the Indian community is however acute and women and girls are simply afraid to do anything or report abuse and this is now not 10 or 20 years ago.

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 16:19

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:14

Social mores are important. We shouldn't be trying to get rid of the stigma of men (and a few women) who either sexually abuse children directly or provide a market for that sexual abuse by consuming media of child sexual abuse. I don't believe it is ever a victimless crime.

Just like the racism that the older generation showed in Brexit - these are things they do think should be acceptable because in "their day" there wasn't such a "fuss" about it. They haven't fully accepted why things have changed. Reinforcing the damage done and trying to make them empathise in some way would probably help, although at older ages I suspect it would be harder to change perceptions and their view on societal norms.

Adhdorlazy · 19/03/2024 16:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:14

Social mores are important. We shouldn't be trying to get rid of the stigma of men (and a few women) who either sexually abuse children directly or provide a market for that sexual abuse by consuming media of child sexual abuse. I don't believe it is ever a victimless crime.

pickledandpuzzled · 19/03/2024 16:11

Yeah.

And this really emphasises, imo, the need to retain judgement and shaming.

These men are inhibited by shame- they don’t want to be caught. So we ramp up the shame. Make it unthinkable.

Obviously there will still be those who do it ‘if no one finds out’, but we need to keep up the pressure.

If it becomes ok when people find out then frankly it will be carnage for (mainly) girls and boys.

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 16:07

Cyclebabble · 19/03/2024 13:24

Sexual abuse is much more common in my view than the stats show. My experience will be skewed as I am ethnically Indian, but on my count more than half of friends/relatives my age who I am close enough to have a discussion have been abused ranging from being groped to rape. In Indian communities the problem is worse as men know that women will not speak out for fear of the shame. Even amongst my non Indian friends the rate of assault and rape is far higher than any stats I have seen. Sadly this does point to a large minority of men being capable of abuse. A sobering thought for us as parents.

I agree. But it isn’t just the Indian community. I have known at least six women in my life (all white) who were sexually abused, and none of them went to the police. Even as late as the 1990s people just didn’t talk about it. My friend (who had been a child in the 1970s) was sexually abused by her step grandad. One day, when she was 10, he stuck his tongue down her throat in broad daylight in the middle of a park. A woman was passing and said “you shouldn’t be doing that sort of thing,” as if she’d just caught him peeing in the bushes or allowing his dog to foul the pavement. Unbelievable.

I’m convinced the sexual abuse of young people was absolutely rife in this country until very recently. From what I have read and heard I suspect it went on in orphanages, schools, gymnasiums, etc, but was simply laughed off. I went to a state school in Essex in the 1980s. One of the male teachers set up a girls football team, which he ran on his own. He was a weird little guy. At school assemblies the teacher would say “Mr X has asked me to remind you that places are still available in the girl’s football team” and the whole assembly would start laughing - including the teachers. There was this unspoken agreement that he was a pervert and was running the team for sexual kicks, and it was treated as a joke!!! I mean wtf were those teachers doing smirking and laughing about it?!

Snugglemonkey · 19/03/2024 16:07

Cazpar · 19/03/2024 13:15

Not a clue, but it's more accurate than using the word paedophilia, which is a specific psychosexual disorder manifesting as an attraction to pre-pubertal children.

Minor-attracted persons covers many more people than paedophile does. It's right that we look at those who are attracted to all minors, not just those who have not gone through puberty.

I totally agree. It helps us to protect more children. It is wrong to stress puberty as some kind of threshold beyond which it becomes OK, or somehow less horrific to have sex with a child.

We need to focus both research and treatment toward anyone attracted to minors of any description.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:05

No they're not, they've been latching onto lbgt, and it's not the first time they've tried similar.

You must live under a rock

Quite.

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 16:01

I'm not surprised the over 65's were more likely at all - as previous posters have said in the 70's many older family men were getting teenage girls pregnant. This probably reminds them of their heyday.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/03/2024 16:01

Whenever people chuntering about the pushback about same sex spaces and women’s rights refer to section28 and just like the stigma gay people endured, I think it’s actually more akin to PIE in the 70s. An attempt to legitimise and garner sympathy for something society needs to double down about.

I agree. Some extraordinary naivety on this thread.

AntonFeckoff · 19/03/2024 15:51

Key findings of the study:

Around one in six (15.1%) Australian men reports sexual feelings towards children.
Approximately one third of this group reports sexually offending against children.
Around one in ten (9.4%) Australian men has sexually offended against children. Approximately half of this group (4.9%) reports sexual feelings towards children.

In total, almost one in five (19.6%) Australian men in the study have sexual feelings for children and/or have sexually offended against children. The 4.9% of men with sexual feelings who have sexually offended against children differed from men with no sexual feelings or offending against children on a number of measures:

Relationships
They were more likely to be married and reported higher levels of social support.

Employment and wealth
They were almost three times more likely to be working with children.
They were more likely to earn a higher income

Health and wellbeing
They were more likely to report mild, moderate or severe anxiety and depression.
They were over four times more likely to report weekly binge drinking.

Childhood abuse and neglect
They reported approximately twice the rate of adverse childhood experiences. They were over six times more likely to report being sexually abused as children.

Attitudes to child sexual abuse
They were more than 25 times more likely to hold attitudes conducive to online child sex offending.

Online behaviour
They were more likely to use the internet more frequently and intensively. They were much more active on social media. They were significantly more likely to use encrypted apps and privacy services. They were twice as likely to own cryptocurrency and over five times more likely to use cryptocurrency for online purchasing.

Pornography consumption
They were over eleven times more likely to watch violent pornography and over twenty six times more likely to watch bestiality pornography.
They were over sixteen times more likely to purchase sexual content online. 29.6% of those with sexual feelings towards children want help; this is 4.5% of Australian men. These men were more likely to have sexually offended against children online and offline than men with sexual feelings who did not want help

Swipe left for the next trending thread