Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New study: Millions of men ‘would xesually abuse children if secrecy was assured’ — The Times

283 replies

ElatedShark · 19/03/2024 11:35

New study: Millions of men ‘would xesually abuse children if secrecy was assured’ — The Times.

A new study has revealed a shocking proportion of Australian men would abuse children “if no one found out”.

The research, conducted by the University of New South Wales, found “concerning” patterns, including that one in six Australian men said they had feelings for children under the age of 18, with 48 per cent of those answering being aged over 54.

One in 15 men questioned admitted they would have xesual contact with a child under the age of 14 if “no one found out”, while one in 25 said the same about children under 10.

The odds of a respondent saying they would have had xes with someone under the age of 18 was 10 times higher if they were aged over 65.

The survey, which questioned over 1900 men aged between 18 and 65 years old, is the world’s largest child sexual abuse perpetration prevention survey of its kind.

The study was welcomed by those who say that the common nature of xesual violence against women needs to be studied at the perpetrator level as well as with victims.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/millions-of-men-would-sexually-abuse-children-if-secrecy-was-sure-ncf9lx5v7

AIBU to be find it disturbing that these were the men only willing to admit it and its probably alot higher??

Reminds me of that red*it thread about men getting aroused changing their daughters diapers or that other study that showed men would happily commit rape if they were assured to never be revealed/caught.

What can we as women/parents/men that don't fall into the above statistics do to combat this ? How can we ensure our sons are not thinking these thoughts are ok?

Millions of men ‘would sexually abuse children if secrecy was assured’

Millions of men would have sexual contact with a child if they were certain that no one would find out, research has suggested.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/millions-of-men-would-sexually-abuse-children-if-secrecy-was-sure-ncf9lx5v7

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 20/03/2024 14:25

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 13:20

For all the ones that would, there's plenty of men who wouldn't.
It's like when people say 1 in 3 marriage fail. That means 2 don't.

Oh good - we can all relax then! Thank you for letting us know.

Hartley99 · 20/03/2024 14:25

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 13:20

For all the ones that would, there's plenty of men who wouldn't.
It's like when people say 1 in 3 marriage fail. That means 2 don't.

But the other two out of three marriages aren't always happy. In many, many cases the couple only stay together because of the kids, the house, the debts, etc. In fact, I would say at least half the married couples I know are unhappy but grinding it out.

It's the same with sexual abuse. Just as unhappy marriages are often hidden behind a mask, so is sexual abuse. The majority of victims never go to the police. And the vast, vast majority of rapists are never convicted or punished. I have often looked at old men and thought "I wonder if you ever abused a young girl when you were in your prime." Until very recently (thanks to DNA testing, security cameras, media coverage, pressure from campaigners, and a greater willingness to confront these issues) sexual abuse was hidden away and accepted. It was very difficult to secure a conviction. Without CCTV footage or DNA evidence it was one word against another. And a confused and frightened 12-year-old isn't the best witness. We will never know, but I have a hunch that the sexual abuse of young people was rife, in both institutions and families. I have known at least six women in my life, possibly more, who were raped or abused in their childhood or teens. None of them ever went to the police. It happened in orphanages, hospitals, schools and families. Jimmy Saville wasn't a freak. He was an extreme example of something that was happening everywhere. That's why he got away with it.

I remember reading a newspaper article about this. The journalist wrote that when she was eight or nine a man had stuck his hand up her dress and tried to kiss her. She'd fought him off and run home in tears. Her mother gave her a cup of tea and told her not to be upset and then carried on making dinner. It was just accepted. I don't mean people approved. But it had probably happened to the girl's mother and grandmother. Women had this attitude of "well, that's just what men are like." If you could go back to, say, 1970, it was common for 13 or 14-year-old girls to be groped, assaulted, pressured into sex, etc. I remember a woman (who would have been a teenager in the early 1980s) saying bitterly to me "I always had a different stepdad coming in to kiss me goodnight." Her mother (an alcoholic) had had numerous boyfriends, and the majority of them had sexually abused the daughter in some way. Again, she never went to the police. She had stayed in touch with a man her mother had dated when she was young, and was sort of taking of him in old age (he'd have been in his 80s). She said "of all my mum's boyfriends, he was the only one who was kind and never tried it on with me."😪

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 20/03/2024 14:21

Xenoi24 · 20/03/2024 13:10

I'd have to find a link to it but I think there is also a body of work that argues, with evidence, that the "worst" traits in males have actually been passed on ... because those males with the worst traits were the most successful in passing on their genes.

In the distant past, the vast minority of males got to reproduce and pass on their genes ...this is apparently seen in DNA. The vast majority of males did not. The ones that did tended to be dominant, ruthless, resource & power amassing (even if it was at a small/local level) avaristic "alpha" males with some traits that might fall under the dark triad trait umbrella. Narcissist, lacking empathy, manipulative, sociopathic, dominant etc.

An example of this on a large scale would be Genghis Khan; it is thought from DNA studies that 1 in 12 men across 8 Asian populations (one in 200 around the world) is descended from him.

This theory just backs up the fact that we attribute the best traits to men automatically, but actually a large proportion of them may have the worst traits, and that puts women and children in an ongoing "at risk" situation.

The only good thing from this post is that thanks to the internet it seems a lot of incels are now single and sitting at home wanking on the net rather than actually breeding and continuing these genetics. Small mercies.

PassingStranger · 20/03/2024 13:20

For all the ones that would, there's plenty of men who wouldn't.
It's like when people say 1 in 3 marriage fail. That means 2 don't.

Xenoi24 · 20/03/2024 13:10

I'd have to find a link to it but I think there is also a body of work that argues, with evidence, that the "worst" traits in males have actually been passed on ... because those males with the worst traits were the most successful in passing on their genes.

In the distant past, the vast minority of males got to reproduce and pass on their genes ...this is apparently seen in DNA. The vast majority of males did not. The ones that did tended to be dominant, ruthless, resource & power amassing (even if it was at a small/local level) avaristic "alpha" males with some traits that might fall under the dark triad trait umbrella. Narcissist, lacking empathy, manipulative, sociopathic, dominant etc.

An example of this on a large scale would be Genghis Khan; it is thought from DNA studies that 1 in 12 men across 8 Asian populations (one in 200 around the world) is descended from him.

This theory just backs up the fact that we attribute the best traits to men automatically, but actually a large proportion of them may have the worst traits, and that puts women and children in an ongoing "at risk" situation.

Xenoi24 · 20/03/2024 12:49

On the main subject of the thread, I think we have lots of ideals about men - as people and as fathers - that are actually just that; ideals and very flawed ideals at that.

We have an ideal that they are wired to be good fathers, wired to be "decent" around children and youths ..... But are they??

A percentage might be, but clearly a very large proportion are not trustworthy or positive around children and young people. They are sexually driven, sexually predatory etc.

Even outside of their sex driven, predatory behaviour; they tend to be much less caring, empathetic, responsible etc. than females on average.

Anytime I see irresponsible behaviour towards children by a parent or adult, it's 9/10 a man, not a woman.

Anytime a parent abandons their children, it's vast majority the male parent.

We think they should have equal access and responsibility for the children they produced (and be caring and empathetic and responsible toward children and young people in general) but isn't that actually just a naive ideal? Look at the nature of the beast.

Look at crime stats - males, at the narrow end of the wedge - are responsible for the vast vast majority - nearly 100% of violent and sex crimes.

At the less narrow end they are responsible for the vast majority of partner and ex partner murders.

At the even less narrow end, they are responsible for the majority of domestic abuse.

The vast vast majority of the sex industry exists to cater to them/with them as customers.

There are so many other examples.

It's sad, but I think we really have the rise tinted glasses on, about what a significant portion of males in any society are like ..and what a risk (from "minor" to major) they are to women and children.

Xenoi24 · 20/03/2024 12:34

I'm no expert but on the few documentaries I have watched on this matter, the abuser when interviewed said that they started watching normal porn, then it progressed and progressed until they needed a bigger "kick" i.e child sexual abuse.

I think this narrative has lots of holes in it.

I think it's child sex offenders trying to blame pornography rather than themselves. They're trying to get lighter sentencing.

Ateotd there is tonnes and tonnes of porn of every imaginable type & extremity online - free. How come their "descent" doesn't go to BDSM or bi or whatever.

You cannot access images of child sex abuse on main stream sites, you have to search hard and long and with the risk of your searches triggering reports to the authorities from ISPs, you have to find your way into the dark web, you have to become involved in rings of child sex abusers.
It is not a natural, easy, or automatic progression from mainstream porn, at all.

They want to depict as as such because it takes away from awkward questions, like why they went looking and persisted in looking for images of child sex abuse ... Why they don't have a line/boundary re child sex abuse that you don't cross, why it's acceptable to them personally to search out and use images of child sex abuse etc.

Not all porn addicts "descend" to using images of child sex abuse. In fact I'd wager most don't. So it's not a porn addiction "thing". It's a child sex abuser thing.

Child sex abusers (direct or not) are hardly relaible honest narrators of why they want to see images of child sex abuse. They are fundamental liars and manipulators who want to shift responsibility, so why believe their "porn slippery slope" excuse??

Almostwelsh · 20/03/2024 12:14

As regards the BMJ figures I am not entirely sure as obviously social constraints will limit the number of pregnancies in outlying age ranges. But ot is clear that women in their late 20s and early 30s usually have good fertility so there is no excuse for going for a teenager.

But I think it's uncontroversial that teenage pregnancies are high risk for things like premature birth and even if that were for social reasons, that's still not a plus in fertility terms, to impregnate a girl so young she won't or can't behave in an optimum way to sustain rhe pregnancy.

I do think it likely that it's more biological in origin though, as anyone who breeds animals knows you don't do it as soon as possible or you risk injury to both the mother and offspring. Humans are mammals and no different in that respect.

Certainly people in the past did recognise this and most very young brides in dynastic arranged marriages were not expected to consumate their marriages until some time after the wedding. There was at the time some criticism that Henry vll's mother had him at 13. She never had another baby and it was debated at the time that her young age at the birth had permanently damaged her.

AntonFeckoff · 20/03/2024 09:15

AllyCart · 20/03/2024 07:09

Does this part refer to fertility in terms of number of women actually giving birth, though, rather than reproductive ability?

"The most fertile years (as in live births) are from 21-early thirties according to the BMJ"

A lot of fertility figures I see are based upon actual births per mother in a given age range, not on whether women in a particular age range are most capable of conceiving.

So for example if more women give birth aged 27 than any other age, the stats will show 27 as most fertile age, at least in some of the data I looked at.

(More than happy to see the idea of old men only being attracted due to fertility dispelled, by the way, but I was also curious when seeing the claims and found some of the data misleading.)

Exactly. I don’t think we know that much about it because it’s not the sort of thing you can easily study, for ethical and practical reasons.

From a biological standpoint, it would be in a species’ interest to reproduce as early in life as possible in order to maximise the number of offspring during the fertile lifespan.

AllyCart · 20/03/2024 07:09

Almostwelsh · 19/03/2024 23:30

The young girls being most fertile thing doesn't wash. Teenage pregnancies are high risk and more likely to end in miscarriage or premature birth as the girls immature body literally struggles to carry the pregnancy to term. The most fertile years (as in live births) are from 21-early thirties according to the BMJ.

If fertility is your ultimate goal the best choice is a woman in that age range who has already had a child. She has proven fertility and is in the prime childbearing years.

Edited

Does this part refer to fertility in terms of number of women actually giving birth, though, rather than reproductive ability?

"The most fertile years (as in live births) are from 21-early thirties according to the BMJ"

A lot of fertility figures I see are based upon actual births per mother in a given age range, not on whether women in a particular age range are most capable of conceiving.

So for example if more women give birth aged 27 than any other age, the stats will show 27 as most fertile age, at least in some of the data I looked at.

(More than happy to see the idea of old men only being attracted due to fertility dispelled, by the way, but I was also curious when seeing the claims and found some of the data misleading.)

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 23:35

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 22:33

Completely agree. These men like to think of themselves as saviours rather than taking advantage though and will argue that with you until they are blue in the face. I know a guy adamant he had to have a girlfriend "need" him rather than want him. He really didn't want anyone who was bright, independent or self sufficient and he has moved his latest girl in to his house after going out for a few months max. It's a power trip and I worry a lot of women even not from war torn countries, don't recognise how trapped they become in these situations. I don't trust men with these god complexes at all. Anyone describing themselves as a knight in shining armour makes me equally suspicious.

If they are saviours, then I assume they don’t have sex with the girls. Or am I being naive? 🙄After all, a true knight in shining armour doesn’t take advantage of girls from poor countries. He just helps them immigrate, let’s them sleep on his couch, and then finds them a flat somewhere, right? No doubt they convince themselves a beautiful young Ukrainian blonde has fallen in love with a chubby, balding 50-year-old short arse from Birmingham.

Thing that baffles me is how these men live with their foreign brides. I mean marrying for sex I understand. I despise them for it, but I understand. But what the hell kind of companionship do they get? How can you sleep together, watch TV together, go for walks along the beach, when you can barely communicate and you know she secretly despises you? And what does it do to a man’s self-respect? I mean you’ve basically bought her, let’s be honest. I’d rather be lonely but keep my pride intact. God, the wedding must be excruciating for the wider family. Just shows you the power of self-delusion. I know a lot abusers convince themselves their victim enjoyed the abuse, just as ugly old men who visit brothels are convinced the girl likes them.

Almostwelsh · 19/03/2024 23:30

The young girls being most fertile thing doesn't wash. Teenage pregnancies are high risk and more likely to end in miscarriage or premature birth as the girls immature body literally struggles to carry the pregnancy to term. The most fertile years (as in live births) are from 21-early thirties according to the BMJ.

If fertility is your ultimate goal the best choice is a woman in that age range who has already had a child. She has proven fertility and is in the prime childbearing years.

labamba007 · 19/03/2024 23:29

@Iftheshoesfit do you have an idea why this seems to increase as men age? I too thought this was a sign that perhaps behaviours were changing between different generations, but you're saying as men age it increases?

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 22:33

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 22:25

I have always despised old men with young Thai brides. And the fact that so many men find it funny makes me furious. For example, there is an ugly little fat guy in my local Tesco. He’s in his 60s, with rotten teeth and lank greasy hair. But he’s got this beautiful young Thai wife. I’ve noticed groups of men whispering and laughing when they walk by. None of them feel a shred of sympathy for the girl. To me it’s a form of abuse. He’s taking advantage of her poverty. Simple as that. No way on this earth would she be with him if she hadn’t grown up in some ghastly tin shack in Bangkok. He knows that.

It’s the same with women from the old Soviet bloc. After the Society Union crashed, Russia was plunged into chaos, and for a decade or so western men took advantage of that. A lot of Russian women are incredibly beautiful, and back in the ‘90s and 2000s you’d see ugly old rich guys with stunning young Russian women who they’d met online or while ‘on business’ in Eastern Europe. I got my first job around 1999/2000, when this was quite common (the Soviet Union had only crashed a decade or so earlier and was still very poor). I remember guys at work making the most disgusting jokes about men they knew going to Russia or Ukraine in search of ‘hotties’. I remember one ugly old lech joking about going to Russia, promising to marry a beautiful young girl, having sex, and then sneaking away to the airport in the morning.

Completely agree. These men like to think of themselves as saviours rather than taking advantage though and will argue that with you until they are blue in the face. I know a guy adamant he had to have a girlfriend "need" him rather than want him. He really didn't want anyone who was bright, independent or self sufficient and he has moved his latest girl in to his house after going out for a few months max. It's a power trip and I worry a lot of women even not from war torn countries, don't recognise how trapped they become in these situations. I don't trust men with these god complexes at all. Anyone describing themselves as a knight in shining armour makes me equally suspicious.

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 22:25

OpalSpirit · 19/03/2024 18:32

Not surprising to me.

I lived in Thailand and went to expat Xmas gathering. At least one hundred people there all sat down together. I was the only western female.
Two appalling men had just returned from Cambodia and were happily and confidently telling everyone about the children they had raped in Cambodia.
Talking about the children being brought into a room and shown to them to pick from.

One man said that vile saying about ‘if there’s grass let’s play’ , both the men looked disgusted and said if ‘there’s grass it’s too old’.
Not one other man said a word, generally laughing along. I refused to sit with any of them and left.

I also think living in Thailand helped to demonstrate how communities make actions seem less ‘wrong’.
I have heard conversations between men about how the teen Thai girls working in brothels actually love giving blowjobs.
Genuinely love it, not like frigid ugly European women.

My presence made them uncomfortable as I broke the spell. I knew them for what they were and so they would react in anger at my being there or ask how much I was.

I think if there is no judgement from other men or no criminal repercussions, men use women and children and actually see them as a lesser life form.

I have always despised old men with young Thai brides. And the fact that so many men find it funny makes me furious. For example, there is an ugly little fat guy in my local Tesco. He’s in his 60s, with rotten teeth and lank greasy hair. But he’s got this beautiful young Thai wife. I’ve noticed groups of men whispering and laughing when they walk by. None of them feel a shred of sympathy for the girl. To me it’s a form of abuse. He’s taking advantage of her poverty. Simple as that. No way on this earth would she be with him if she hadn’t grown up in some ghastly tin shack in Bangkok. He knows that.

It’s the same with women from the old Soviet bloc. After the Society Union crashed, Russia was plunged into chaos, and for a decade or so western men took advantage of that. A lot of Russian women are incredibly beautiful, and back in the ‘90s and 2000s you’d see ugly old rich guys with stunning young Russian women who they’d met online or while ‘on business’ in Eastern Europe. I got my first job around 1999/2000, when this was quite common (the Soviet Union had only crashed a decade or so earlier and was still very poor). I remember guys at work making the most disgusting jokes about men they knew going to Russia or Ukraine in search of ‘hotties’. I remember one ugly old lech joking about going to Russia, promising to marry a beautiful young girl, having sex, and then sneaking away to the airport in the morning.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 19/03/2024 22:18

thatgirlinjapan · 19/03/2024 12:57

I rarely say a sexist thing and am quite supportive of men in general, but when it comes to ANYTHING sexual, you've got to admit, they're an odd lot at best and downright dangerous at their worst

I'm no expert but on the few documentaries I have watched on this matter, the abuser when interviewed said that they started watching normal porn, then it progressed and progressed until they needed a bigger "kick" i.e child sexual abuse. I'm assuming this doesn't make up all paedophiles but I wonder if it is the majority because biologically speaking "fancying" a child literally doesn't make sense! It's fucking ridiculous and stupid and I'm happy that there are plenty of men out there that would still beat the shit out of a paedo.

AntonFeckoff · 19/03/2024 22:17

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 22:13

I think they have less ability to change lived experience - they were around when it was socially acceptable for a man to sleep with teens and just be tutted at. They don't see the issue. I'd suspect it's more likely they are caught because they perhaps aren't as tech savvy as the younger generation and not so aware of how they might be caught and how to cover their tracks.

Deleted post as I hadn't read the quote history.

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 22:15

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 21:14

That’s interesting, though disturbing. I think you’re probably right. I suspect a lot of men over 60 think “what the hell, I’ll be dead soon. I’ve always fantasised about having a young girl and this is my last chance. I’ve had my career, my wife is dead/ill/fed up with me, and if I’m caught, well, they’re not going to lock up a 70-year-old for his first offence, are they.”

Plus if a 20 something man hits on a 13yo she might (at a hard push) be flattered and agree to hide a "relationship". If a 65+ guy does the same she is more likely to run for the hills and call him out as a pervert to anyone who will listen.

Garlicking · 19/03/2024 22:15

ScrollingLeaves · 19/03/2024 21:54

So this was a rate of 6 out of 7 men who were rapists/would be rapists.
86%

Yes ... fortunately, 7 on a single day isn't a good enough sample to extrapolate from! I did meet many other men in the year I was 12, no-one else tried to rape me.

TheGhostOfKatesProlapse · 19/03/2024 22:13

Justsomethoughts · 19/03/2024 21:27

Yes absolutely. Would love to see some brain imaging of these older ones. Wonder if there are any frontal lobe changes/anything indicative of dementia that hasn’t yet manifested in the usual ways.

I think they have less ability to change lived experience - they were around when it was socially acceptable for a man to sleep with teens and just be tutted at. They don't see the issue. I'd suspect it's more likely they are caught because they perhaps aren't as tech savvy as the younger generation and not so aware of how they might be caught and how to cover their tracks.

Pussycat22 · 19/03/2024 22:09

Sick bastards.

AntonFeckoff · 19/03/2024 22:09

Cazpar · 19/03/2024 20:39

Actually I wonder if it's a biological thing. I'm conjecturing here and it would be interesting to dig into properly, but we know that both men and women's gametes lower in quality as we age. For women we cease being viably reproductive in middle age but men don't. They never lose the ability to father children however the older a man is the more likely it is that a child of his will have a congenital disability (this has already been studied). I therefore wonder if there is a biological instinct to seek out the "healthiest" (younger) women to counter this.

This was my hypothesis too, but I wasn't sure whether to say it or not.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/03/2024 21:54

Garlicking · 19/03/2024 16:31

I underwent my first attempted rape at 12. One perpetrator, five other men watching as if it were a fun circus act or something. Fortunately, another pal of theirs came along and went ballistic. I'm very grateful to him, but wtf the other men??!

So this was a rate of 6 out of 7 men who were rapists/would be rapists.
86%

MyLovelyPurse · 19/03/2024 21:52

@BobbyBiscuits @CantDealwithChristmas (and others)
Please don't use terms such as child porn or schoolgirl porn. The correct term is images of child abuse.

CoatRack · 19/03/2024 21:30

Hartley99 · 19/03/2024 21:14

That’s interesting, though disturbing. I think you’re probably right. I suspect a lot of men over 60 think “what the hell, I’ll be dead soon. I’ve always fantasised about having a young girl and this is my last chance. I’ve had my career, my wife is dead/ill/fed up with me, and if I’m caught, well, they’re not going to lock up a 70-year-old for his first offence, are they.”

I'd be surprised if this is something that happens to manifest at late-age.

Could it not be more likely that the older they are the more chances there have been to be caught?