Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the current A&E wait times are mad

111 replies

Iamunsure · 19/03/2024 09:15

I live in west Midlands and the current wait times in our area's A&E is currently 9 hours to be seen for general and 6-7 hours for children A&E. We took our DC to A&E as asked by 111 triage. It's absolutely mad with people sitting on floor for hours to be seen.
How are the waiting times in your area and how's your experience been. I think it's absolutely mad and gone massively downhill for NHS.

OP posts:
Thriving30 · 19/03/2024 16:22

MrTiddlesTheCat · 19/03/2024 09:27

They're not just mad, they're barbaric. I fell down some stairs, shattering my shoulder. Thankfully I'm in Sweden so was seen and given morphine within half an hour an hour. The thought of being left on the floor, in agony, for hours on end absolutely horrifies me.

Does Sweden have a similar healthcare system to us?

Fixerupper77 · 19/03/2024 15:25

BeaRF75 · 19/03/2024 14:50

Well, so many visits to A&E are inappropriate or unnecessary, so it's hardly surprising.
Heard about a person in a minor car accident the other day who went to A&E for cuts and bruises - I mean, where is people's common sense? Yes, they'd had an accident, but what exactly did they expect A&E to do, apart from send them home? Which is exactly what happened!

The amount of people who were in A and E at my last visit because they had a cough despite being well enough to talk outside frequently to SMOKE was infuriating.

There should be a quicker triage where staff are given more autonomy to send people away.

Like the guy who had a sore finger after doing DIY that morning!

ArchesOfWisteria · 19/03/2024 15:18

Judging from my GP- impossible to get an appointment. No option?

BeaRF75 · 19/03/2024 14:50

Well, so many visits to A&E are inappropriate or unnecessary, so it's hardly surprising.
Heard about a person in a minor car accident the other day who went to A&E for cuts and bruises - I mean, where is people's common sense? Yes, they'd had an accident, but what exactly did they expect A&E to do, apart from send them home? Which is exactly what happened!

BobbyBiscuits · 19/03/2024 14:37

@anonhop oh god I know. I was more talking from statistics and reports about how many go for stuff that's better dealt with elsewhere. I was also thinking of one specific person who was so annoying, harassing staff moaning about the wait, and healthy looking, young, while all around were grey, collapsed, sobbing, vomming into sick bowls, unconscious, bleeding etc. I should not judge. I was in resus last time and there was a lady with half her face fallen off staggering about begging for meds. They treat everyone badly.

MaloneMeadow · 19/03/2024 14:29

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:54

Reference poster malonemeadow your comment re my bizarre love for nhs rude. Just sticking up for an institution that has done a lot for me and family throughout various illnesses and am incredibly grateful we have the nhs in this country.
Also your initial post didn't say your dd had tonsillitis. We had part of the story.

Your attitude re: the NHS is part of the problem. People treat it as some sort of sacred cow that is immune to criticism and get offended when anybody dares to talk about the many serious issues it has. Patient care and safety is being seriously compromised and it needs to be addressed and spoken about

Fixerupper77 · 19/03/2024 14:25

I had 13 hours with an infected gallbladder. After I almost passed out, they started sending out a man to shoot liquid morphine into my mouth.

anonhop · 19/03/2024 14:09

BobbyBiscuits · 19/03/2024 11:59

9 hours is not bad for my area. I've been there for 12 with my mum who had a life threatening condition. Even with a severe trauma, you get to resus quickly but then after x-ray you're left for 15 hours without a word, any meds, peeing in a cup..(this was a guy)
Yeah, it sucks really bad. There are some people who clearly are not suffering either an accident or an emergency. This is frustrating to say the least but when someone can't see a GP that's where they try and go.

Edited

Totally agree some people do take the mickey & go to A&E for minor problems, but you can't tell by looking.

Yesterday I was sent to A&E because I'm pregnant & I collapsed. I was absolutely fine, tried GP & midwife, who sent me to 111, who sent me to urgent care, who sent me to A&E. was happily sitting there snacking, knitting, chatting etc. I'm sure it looked like I didn't need to be there.
I also didn't want to be there as felt fine & felt awful for taking up resources, but I'd been sent. So you can't tell by looking who should & shouldn't be there. But 100% agree, some people go for minor things & should be at GP.

Noseyoldcow · 19/03/2024 14:03

We all agree that healthcare in this country is pants, and that shortfalls in one area (e.g. lack of gps) causes problems in other areas. Why aren't other countries' health services in such as mess? Or are they? What are they doing that is so different to us?
I know that not everything is free, but how do they collect money without it being self defeating? It costs money to collect money, so any payments would have to be more than token amounts. And what do they do that could we apply to our health system to make it work better?
I cannot see that the problems we have of an aging population and immigration etc etc being much different in European countries at least, can someone enlighten me?

neilyoungismyhero · 19/03/2024 14:03

A customer of mine who is an elderly lady relying on a shopping trolley/ walker mentioned she used to walk with a stick before her accident. Asked her what had happened and she advised she had been pushed over at a pedestrian crossing. She landed on her bottom. She was in a lot of pain so was taken to hospital and waited for 9 hours in A & E. In the end she couldn't cope and caught the last bus home. She was in desperate pain for 18 months, put down to sciatica but pain killers did no good. Eventually she was found to have suffered 2 untreated back fractures..this has resulted in limited mobility and a lot of chronic pain.
Yes it was her fault for leaving hospital untreated and unseen but she is an old lady and couldn't cope any longer bless her.
Her pain and discomfort could and should have been avoided.
Unless it's a life threatening issue the system is absolutely broken.

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:54

Reference poster malonemeadow your comment re my bizarre love for nhs rude. Just sticking up for an institution that has done a lot for me and family throughout various illnesses and am incredibly grateful we have the nhs in this country.
Also your initial post didn't say your dd had tonsillitis. We had part of the story.

RadFs · 19/03/2024 13:53

Is this sandwell hospital?

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:45

I did not say doctors don't read notes
Of course they read notes that goes without saying but they can't read four folders full so it's good if pt can help and fill in blanks quickly too. All helps too make things smoother for both pt/dr

Tagyoureit · 19/03/2024 13:34

Because people mis-use A&E instead of going to a pharmacy or their gp.

But GPs need to stop fucking about and bring back booked appointments instead of all this call on the day for an appointment.

People want to see a doctor so they go to A&E.

I also think triage could do with telling people to go home rather than admitted them.

I last went to A&E for myself 5 years ago because I was pregnant and bleeding, triage should have just told me what I waited 6 hours for a doctor to tell me, we won't scan you now, here's a letter, go to maternity services in the morning. During my wait, there was 1 lady with heavy periods who should have gone to her gp. 1 guy moaning about his wait but was in and out within 3 minutes of seeing the doctor so not whatever his issue was could clearly have been dealt with by a gp.

catmomma67 · 19/03/2024 13:30

we live in yorkshire.. i recently went to a&e with a suspected stroke... it took them 6 hours to simply speak to someone... i was in a&e a total of 29.5 hours before they finally admitted me and kept me in for 5 days! while we sat there, we saw people come who had come to a&e because they couldn't get to their GP..

MaloneMeadow · 19/03/2024 13:27

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:12

My friends say patients complain that dr didn't know something about them.
Typical comment
'Have they not read my notes'

Remember the size of your notes !!!!and amount of time dr got.
Highlight main illnesses to dr, bring medicine with you etc etc, do something yourself. Don't expect to be spoonfed there is not the staff or time unfortunately. Use your initiative like you do when you are complaining about the nhs.

Properly reading notes is not only
a) their job
b) essential for clinical safety

There is no excuse

Source: worked as an AHP in the NHS for 20 years (before it went down the drain)

MaloneMeadow · 19/03/2024 13:21

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:14

Reference previous poster
Everyone knows tonsillitis can be very serious and some cases are admitted and on iv antibiotics.
Remember sepsis

I think I’d be inclined to side with the actual A&E doctors (rather than a random MN poster with a bizarre love for the NHS) who have told us on multiple occasions that there was absolutely no reason for her to be there, the GP should’ve just properly assessed her. They didn’t do anything on any occasion that a GP couldn’t have done. No red flags, just lazy incompetence

AgnesX · 19/03/2024 13:21

IsadoraQuill · 19/03/2024 11:07

You can always spot the Tories on threads like these. Blaming the astronomical wait times on people using the service unnecessarily when the reality is that they are a small number.

The truth is that GP services are so stretched that people are often getting to crisis point before they can be seen. This is coupled with an ageing population that has increasingly complex care needs, a collapse in social care and mental health services that also lead more people to crisis point, resulting in the perfect storm.

If you want better wait times at A&E, stop focusing on the odd person who turns up at the wrong place, and start demanding accountability from our leaders. Ask why central funding for local government has been decimated, leading to massive cuts in social care which has a knock on effect. Ask why immigration is in the 100000s with no real plan to increase public services accordingly. And ask why once again MPs are getting an above inflation pay rise whilst NHS staff have to beg to be recognised.

Because immigration is the Tories current thing. If they can push the Rwanda bill before the next election they think Rishi and the party will be saved therefore they're throwing money at it left right and centre.

And while we're all focused on those antics the NHS slips ever further out of the limelight.

Haveli · 19/03/2024 13:19

My DD was sent to A&E by the GP last week for suspected meningitis. We were seen within minutes of arriving. I was really surprised having read all about these appalling wait times. However then I heard a nurse tell someone that someone else in the waiting room was kicking off because they'd been there for 19 hours (this was childrens ED). I guess if it's not life threatening you won't be a priority if a continuous stream of emergencies are coming in. I definitely got some angry looks when we were rushed straight though but I can't fault how well they looked after her (it wasn't meningitis fortunately).

Waitingfordoggo · 19/03/2024 13:17

Gastropod · 19/03/2024 12:19

I live in mainland Europe - my local hospital will usually see A&E patients within an hour. More than an hour's wait would be unusual - my partner was there recently and they apologised that the wait would be longer than usual as somebody was in need of more urgent care. I think he waited an hour to be seen, total. Treated and home within 2 hours. Never any feeing that people are "misusing" the system or going there with non A&E-worthy problems.

In fact, when as a worried new parent I took my sick baby daughter to A&E for something that turned out to be pretty minor, and apologised for wasting the doctor's time, I was told "it's our job to decide that there's nothing seriously wrong with your child - and that's why you were right to bring her here, if you were concerned".

It shocks me to read the stories about wait times in the UK, or that people think that this is somehow justified, or normal. It's really not...

I don’t think most of us think it’s ok or normal. But what can we do aside from using the next election to vote for a party we think might do better 🤷🏼‍♀️

I don’t want to emigrate so I stay here, hope things will get better, and just try not to get ill!

I think though that a lot of Brits would say that although the NHS is on its knees, most of the people who work in it are excellent. Most hospital Drs would still tell parents they ‘did the right thing’ in bringing in their poorly child (even if the child turns out not to be very poorly).

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:14

Reference previous poster
Everyone knows tonsillitis can be very serious and some cases are admitted and on iv antibiotics.
Remember sepsis

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:12

My friends say patients complain that dr didn't know something about them.
Typical comment
'Have they not read my notes'

Remember the size of your notes !!!!and amount of time dr got.
Highlight main illnesses to dr, bring medicine with you etc etc, do something yourself. Don't expect to be spoonfed there is not the staff or time unfortunately. Use your initiative like you do when you are complaining about the nhs.

MaloneMeadow · 19/03/2024 13:09

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:07

They can't win though as we've all seen the stories of gp missed something and pt deteriorated. They can't do right from wrong. If they didn't sent pt and there was something more they would be in right s...

You really think that A&E was an appropriate place to go for tonsillitis as our GP couldn’t fit her in an appointment that day?

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:07

MaloneMeadow · 19/03/2024 13:05

GPs are 100% part of the problem - I’ve lost count of the amount of times ours has told us to take DD to A&E, despite her clearly not needing to be there and being told to just go back to the GP🤦‍♀️ I feel embarrassed even turning up as I know we’re wasting their time but what else can you do?

They can't win though as we've all seen the stories of gp missed something and pt deteriorated. They can't do right from wrong. If they didn't sent pt and there was something more they would be in right s...

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 13:05

Wouldn't want to live anywhere else as still think uk best country in world.
Sorry I'm biased but alot of services gone to pot.