Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the current A&E wait times are mad

111 replies

Iamunsure · 19/03/2024 09:15

I live in west Midlands and the current wait times in our area's A&E is currently 9 hours to be seen for general and 6-7 hours for children A&E. We took our DC to A&E as asked by 111 triage. It's absolutely mad with people sitting on floor for hours to be seen.
How are the waiting times in your area and how's your experience been. I think it's absolutely mad and gone massively downhill for NHS.

OP posts:
Auntieobem · 20/03/2024 09:05

Our a&e performance figures are generally good. Elderly patients aren't admitted through a&e, unless traumatic injury or similar. We've got a service which can provide rapid assessment at home for over 65's to assess and treat at home as far as possible.

I called 111 after dd had partially dislocated her kneecap at school. Previously we'd have been sent straight to a&e, where we'd have waited and waited and probably have needed to return once swelling down etc. Instead I got a call from an a&e doctor who triaged over the phone, arranged an appointment for the next day (with plans that if things got worse I could bring her straight in), by the next morning DD's knee was much better, so I called to cancel appointment.

Need to think system wide to solve system wide issues.

MaloneMeadow · 20/03/2024 09:02

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 20/03/2024 08:47

The biggest problem is that people don't look after themselves well in the UK so healh care is stretched and also people massively misuse all health services.

They go to the GP with every cough and cold ( I remember being told by family members every time one of my children had a viral illness as a baby that they "need antibiotics ") not one of them ever had a course of antibiitics under the age of 2.

A&E is used like a drop in centre. Tonsillitis, sore foot etc. People need to really learn what can be dealt with at home, what a pharmacist can offer (most people think they dispense medicine not are health care professionals ) and when it's A&E.

I think better A&E gate keeping and sending home the walking well would be a good start. In general unless you might not make it through the next 24 hours without intervention or a limb is hanging off and won't repair without a medical professional then you probably don't need A&E.

Edited

Try being told by your GP to (needlessly) bring your child with tonsillitis to A&E.. All because they couldn’t fit her in for an appointment that day 🤦‍♀️ They even asked me to do it on a second occasion but I point blank refused - genuinely embarrassing having to turn up to A&E knowing full well that there was no reason for us to be there

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 20/03/2024 08:56

We really need a system that monitors your health and so people that don't look after themselves don't get to drain the resources and also we need a system based on you getting out of the system what you put in. I.e. at least semi privatised.

Because people think of it as "free" they think they may as well just hop on down and get seen.

It's a ridiculous system really having a completely free at the point of entry system regardless of how you look after yourself and what you have paid in.

Whiskyfromsmallglasses · 20/03/2024 08:49

When my ds 12 had a scooter accident this is time last week I dreaded the wait after everything I've read about. He basically went over the handle bars and took the fall full on his face. No skin on one side of his face, cuts, massive egg and missing three front teeth. We arrived at 4.30pm seen the first nurse at 6.00pm and we're out with painkillers and head injury leaflets just after 7pm that was him being seen my a Dr and a consultant aswell. I can't say we were rushed out the door and I feel his injuries were investigated fully. We are in Scotland

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 20/03/2024 08:47

The biggest problem is that people don't look after themselves well in the UK so healh care is stretched and also people massively misuse all health services.

They go to the GP with every cough and cold ( I remember being told by family members every time one of my children had a viral illness as a baby that they "need antibiotics ") not one of them ever had a course of antibiitics under the age of 2.

A&E is used like a drop in centre. Tonsillitis, sore foot etc. People need to really learn what can be dealt with at home, what a pharmacist can offer (most people think they dispense medicine not are health care professionals ) and when it's A&E.

I think better A&E gate keeping and sending home the walking well would be a good start. In general unless you might not make it through the next 24 hours without intervention or a limb is hanging off and won't repair without a medical professional then you probably don't need A&E.

Deliaskis · 20/03/2024 08:44

People go to A&E, sometimes unnecessarily, because there is no other way to access care. My MIL (who admittedly has a series of complex needs) spent 27 hours waiting in A&E last week with what turned out to be a UTI. We tried everything to get a GP visit for her, but they actually said if it's an infection it needs testing to know which antibiotic to give, and for that she needs to go to A&E. I found this completely astounding but they refused to set her. Whilst waiting in. A&E for the results they put her on penicillin anyway (which surely the GP could have done). I really can't believe that A&E was the best and most sensible route for her to be treated for a UTI, but the GP told us that was the only way. It isn't always the fault of the people showing up there.

Similarly when DD was a baby screaming in pain with acid reflux, the GP said go to A&E there was nothing they could do. We were eventually admitted to paediatrics and she was started on ranitidine (zantac). Again.... Surely A&E shouldn't be the only way to get that, but we were told it was. Again, it isn't always the fault if the people showing up there.

I don't understand what is going wrong in this part of the system, but urgent care needs of this kind are being shunted to A&E, and it's not clear why.

Where I am, other parts of the system are fortunately working well. Both my parents and in laws have had a range of treatments and surgeries recently, some planned some not, and received excellent care.

MumofCrohnie · 20/03/2024 08:38

My DD has Crohn's and yes, admission is via (planned) A and E at the children's hospital, so we spend quite a bit of time there.

I would say most of the time 50 percent of people in peads A and E are babies and small children with nasty coughs, a further 10 percent are vomiting toddlers. I expect a good half of them could and should be GP assessment. For some reason some patients seem to make a family day out of it, with brother and sister, mum and dad as well as the patient. I think it should be one person plus the patient except in exceptional circs (eg nursing baby as an extra).

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 20/03/2024 08:31

people are dreadful at actually knowing where to go and when. GP appointments are almost impossible to get, so people go to hospital when they really don’t need to. People call ambulances instead of taxis so they don’t have to pay, PEOPLE make bad choices.

doctors and nurses do their best in utter shit conditions surrounded by these PEOPLE who do nothing but complain.

orangeleopard · 20/03/2024 08:28

Honestly, it’s always been like this, or at least always has been where I’m from. I was a severely sick child, I have a chronic illness that causes severe pain and weakens my immune system. I got an ear infection that went septic and almost went to my brain, among other things that are ‘normal’ that go away itself, it would always be severe for me that I’d almost end up dying (and that’s not even being dramatic). Anyway, this resulted me being in a&e very often as a child. Still; even with severe conditions, the wait times were horrendous. And this was 15+ years ago. I remember one time having to lay on the floor due to the lack of seats and me crying in agony and no one would come and medicate me and help me I just had to ‘wait’. Children’s a&e is just the same as adult a&e with the wait, if not likely worse as children are more prone to getting injured, illnesses and overall overly worried parents/carers.

On the other hand, I have a wonderful emergency centre for breaks and burns near me who see you instantly. I broke my thumb, got checked in, scanned and seen all within 20 minutes. It’s just a shame that the genuine life or death emergencies are not like this.

barleycorn · 20/03/2024 08:14

Noseyoldcow · 19/03/2024 14:03

We all agree that healthcare in this country is pants, and that shortfalls in one area (e.g. lack of gps) causes problems in other areas. Why aren't other countries' health services in such as mess? Or are they? What are they doing that is so different to us?
I know that not everything is free, but how do they collect money without it being self defeating? It costs money to collect money, so any payments would have to be more than token amounts. And what do they do that could we apply to our health system to make it work better?
I cannot see that the problems we have of an aging population and immigration etc etc being much different in European countries at least, can someone enlighten me?

We don’t spend as much on healthcare as other countries. Here’s an image from the BMA, and the article it was taken from.

https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-support/nhs-delivery-and-workforce/funding/health-funding-data-analysis#:~:text=Prior%20to%20the%20pandemic%2C%20healthcare,EU14%20average%20of%20%C2%A33%2C655.

To think the current A&E wait times are mad
Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 19/03/2024 23:24

My parent ended up at A&E as instructed by their GP recently and whilst bloods were taken after 3+ hours they finally saw a doctor after 7 hours. The staff were great but whilst my elderly parent had a seat, as the patient, I had to stand for 3 hours as it was rammed. I will definitely take a folding chair in future!

Northernsouloldies · 19/03/2024 23:22

It's not just the NHS the whole country is falling apart,housing,roads, education, policing,and you want to try Scotland for nutty SNP policies they unfortunately never cease to amaze.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 19/03/2024 23:09

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 12:08

I think what everyone has got to remember is the nurses and doctors aren't standing in a room rubbing their hands together laughing saying let's see how many more hours we can keep them waiting. Ridiculous I think some people think that.
I wouldn't be in their profession for all the money in the world.
They are doing their best in very difficult situations.

I really don’t think people think that. What they do see is the horrific waiting times and, sometimes, when you’ve not slept and you’re worried about your child or relative and you just want some answers or some help, it’s the staff that get the flack. It shouldn’t be, but equally, who else do those patients turn to? There’s a lack of early intervention (gp appointments, referral waiting lists etc) and people with serious symptoms being told to wait for over a year. My relative just got told by one doctor that they don’t know what’s wrong, so that’s it, discharged. Luckily they have a good GP monitoring them, but there are a lot of very obvious signs something is very wrong. That relative now has to go private. They’ve been very patient and understanding, but when people are put through symptoms that take your ability to live life away and literally cannot access help after years and years of trying, there will be short fuses.

Equally, some staff can be quite tricky. I was once yelled at by a GP receptionist when my son’s urine culture results were three weeks late and he was risking another hospital admission - turned out they were in the wrong folder on the computer and yes, he needed a different antibiotic. A urine culture takes 3 days and she accused me of ‘wasting their time’. I had to phone the lab to find out it had been sent and was in the wrong folder. In reality, no one is perfect and the current way the system works is rubbish.

If we’re going to talk about staff doing their best, we also need to talk about patients and patients’ families doing their best.

The fault belongs to neither the patients nor the staff broadly. I don’t think either the patients or the staff broadly blame each other. It’s the Government and their fun narrative about no money for anyone (except them).

ArchesOfWisteria · 19/03/2024 22:53

Bringonchristmas36 · 19/03/2024 22:45

Sorry but with my daughter who had a life threatening condition she was seen straight away. If you can wait 100 hours it’s not life threatening

That’s silly. Something non-life threatening can become life threatening if you wait long enough. It can be urgent to prevent deterioration. A mild asthma attack can progress, an infection in the tonsils can become sepsis or a deep tissue infection, a broken bone can become septic or become something that requires an operation instead of manipulation. It’s not a black and white situation.
For example a child with a feeding tube can have an easily treatable local infection at the entry point that if left without care can quickly travel into a major infection that’s hard to treat.
Theres this silly idea that GP= I can wait 2 week and A&E= life threatening. Care needs to include a middle ground for urgent, but not an emergency.

waitingforthedrain · 19/03/2024 22:53

I had a recent experience of a&e. Interesting god forsaken place. Absolutely stunk. From the smell of weed/cigarettes that drifted inside from the entranceway ( why can't they had dedicated smoking zones rather than just accepting folk smoking at the door.
Someone vomitted but there was no staff to clean it up, so a hospital blanket was thrown over the offending puke and left to stagnate all day.
Then there was the lad sitting next to me eating an egg sandwich.
And the police turned up, sad, carnage, road traffic accident.

I was there 12 hours before I was admitted to the emergency surgical ward, however it didn't feel that long. I was called and triaged, then sent back out, then called again to get assessed by an AMP, then sent somewhere else for bloods, then a scan, then called back in to see the surgeon eventually.

So I met a lot of folk, lovely, resorting and overworked, at different parts of the day, which helped pass the time. But I will do everything in my power to avoid going back to that hellhole again.

Bringonchristmas36 · 19/03/2024 22:45

Sorry but with my daughter who had a life threatening condition she was seen straight away. If you can wait 100 hours it’s not life threatening

ArchesOfWisteria · 19/03/2024 22:37

This is the timeline I had getting dd seen for something that need antibiotics, a repeated issue she has that is clearly seen and flares up really fast but is the major if she gets medication.
-8am rung GP, no appts told to ring 111
-rung 111, 111 gave me an appt at my Gp who’d said they were too busy (spoke to call handler and clinical staff)
-patient liaison manager called from Gp, half hour later- does dd need an appt
-doc ring, asked to bring dd in
-doc2 saw dd and prescribed at 6pm,

So I spoke to 6 people to repeatedly clearly explain the obvious medical reason she had over and over.
Firstly it if was me I’d not have been capable of going through it all, I’d have been too ill. Or if I didn’t speak English etc I’d give up and go to A&E. I had to be so persistent with recorded messages and people trying to get me to go away. It takes resilience.
Secondly, dd has deteriorated over the day. I should have just gone to A&E as we’d have had a chance of starting the medicine sooner. She ended up not getting medicine for 14 hours (needed out of hours pharmacy trip) and staying overnight in hospital
Thirdly, can it really be efficient I speak to 5 people? Receptionist, patient manager for Gp call handler, doc for 111, doc for telephone appt, doc in face to face appt? It’s far far more time than talking to the one doctor. The system seemed mad. All that to get one of the appts that they apparently reserve for 111? Some common sense would have said just see the person we know we’ll be seeing anyway. Maybe just put a flag on peoples notes if they have a particular issue?

MrTiddlesTheCat · 19/03/2024 18:26

Thriving30 · 19/03/2024 16:22

Does Sweden have a similar healthcare system to us?

Yes it does. We get billed a token amount but otherwise it's very similar. I think the A&E change is around £20.

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 17:34

Reference malonemeadow's last comment to me.
I am not part of the problem as you wrongly put it. What a cheek and how rude to say that.
I am fully aware that the nhs has big problems that need sorting quickly.
My original thread if you had taken the time to read properly was just explaining some of the problems from a different viewpoint. I have alot of friends and relatives who work for tthe nhs so hear things from them.
No one minds 'constructive' criticism about the situation and it is needed as you rightly said. All I was trying to get across is some patients (not all) abuse the system and staff and it doesn't help things to improve.
You seemed to get uptight because I defended GPs saying they can't do right from wrong. No one was having a personal attack at you and your dd and their tonsillitis condition but you have got very rattled for some reason?
We are allowed to have views that are different to you without getting insulted or posters being snidey.
I was trying to explain abit about what it's like for some of the nurses as we do seem to get a lot of threads about how bad the nhs is and how long the A /E waits are so was just trying to give background on what things staff do that some of the public don't realise.
Believe me as I am currently a nhs pt and also got relatives working in it I know how much help is needed to improve things.
But I will put this back on you rather than me as you said earlier i was part of the problem! Why am I part of the problem explaining what the staff do.
You are a big part of the problem as not interested in looking at the full picture.
I haven't got some weird infatuation with the nhs either as you so nicely put it
Just a patient there every week seeing how hard the staff work.

Hettie24 · 19/03/2024 17:20

Patients who turn up at A&E are triaged. The most critical are seen first and that’s how it should be.

If a patient can walk out of A&E because they CBA to wait any longer then they shouldn’t have been in A&E in the first place 🤷‍♀️

Themadcleaner · 19/03/2024 16:56

Some shocking times! I feel so fortunate that our local hospital wasnt anything like that, 20 mins for triage nurse, 1 hour for dr expected wait time, admittedly it was early and quiet on sunday morning and definitely was filling rapidly as the morning went on!

Superscientist · 19/03/2024 16:46

My dad went to a and e a couple of weeks ago having hit his thumb with an axe. He was in X rayed, vaccinated, dressed, given antibiotics and back home in an hour.

Saschka · 19/03/2024 16:43

IsadoraQuill · 19/03/2024 11:07

You can always spot the Tories on threads like these. Blaming the astronomical wait times on people using the service unnecessarily when the reality is that they are a small number.

The truth is that GP services are so stretched that people are often getting to crisis point before they can be seen. This is coupled with an ageing population that has increasingly complex care needs, a collapse in social care and mental health services that also lead more people to crisis point, resulting in the perfect storm.

If you want better wait times at A&E, stop focusing on the odd person who turns up at the wrong place, and start demanding accountability from our leaders. Ask why central funding for local government has been decimated, leading to massive cuts in social care which has a knock on effect. Ask why immigration is in the 100000s with no real plan to increase public services accordingly. And ask why once again MPs are getting an above inflation pay rise whilst NHS staff have to beg to be recognised.

There are three issues, none of which are the patients’ fault (or the A&E staff’s fault):

Collapse of social care - this means that patients who are fit to be discharged experience long delays waiting for a package of care or nursing home placement. This means beds are not freed up for patients in A&E. This is what is leading to longer trolley waits.

Backlogs of care due to Covid - there has been a massive increase in work to try to clear this, again leading to fewer beds available for people in A&E, and also sicker patients in the community (who wouldn’t have been this sick if they’d had their heart failure or diabetic foot treatment in 2020) requiring more frequent admission via A&E.

Collapse of GP services - people really do attend A&E because they can’t see their GP. Sometimes that is reasonable (ie if their condition worsens), sometimes it isn’t. The majority of those patients will be seen in minors, which is generally a different workstream to majors, so those patients don’t influence the patients on trolleys.

All of this could be fixed with more beds and more staff, but the Tories would rather give their cash to people like Frank Hester.

Floralnomad · 19/03/2024 16:29

It depends what you go in with . I’ve been in A&E twice in the last 3 months with my daughter ( adult ) , first time with shortness of breath and we were seen ECG , chest X-ray and out in 3 hours and the second time with urine retention and she was catheterised / de catheterised ( her choice) and out in a couple of hours . On both occasions people were coming in and being referred to the GP and being told it was several hours wait .

Soubriquet · 19/03/2024 16:25

Last time I was in A&E, it took me 18 hours to get a bed. Our local hospital has turned the waiting room into a sitting A&E room. Nurses come out, do your obs etc and will give you painkillers if you need them but otherwise you’re sat in a chair unless the doctor calls you into a room to do the examination. But yeah 18 hours….

Swipe left for the next trending thread