Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the current A&E wait times are mad

111 replies

Iamunsure · 19/03/2024 09:15

I live in west Midlands and the current wait times in our area's A&E is currently 9 hours to be seen for general and 6-7 hours for children A&E. We took our DC to A&E as asked by 111 triage. It's absolutely mad with people sitting on floor for hours to be seen.
How are the waiting times in your area and how's your experience been. I think it's absolutely mad and gone massively downhill for NHS.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mountainclimber50 · 20/03/2024 20:36

@PrincessTeaSet do you have a link to the data to back up your claims?

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:28

Noseyoldcow · 19/03/2024 14:03

We all agree that healthcare in this country is pants, and that shortfalls in one area (e.g. lack of gps) causes problems in other areas. Why aren't other countries' health services in such as mess? Or are they? What are they doing that is so different to us?
I know that not everything is free, but how do they collect money without it being self defeating? It costs money to collect money, so any payments would have to be more than token amounts. And what do they do that could we apply to our health system to make it work better?
I cannot see that the problems we have of an aging population and immigration etc etc being much different in European countries at least, can someone enlighten me?

They spend a lot more on healthcare in other countries, whether via tax or via patient contributions. The NHS is the cheapest healthcare system in the developed world, more or less.

Lots of countries you pay for appointments or a proportion of other costs, generally you would claim some back via insurance which could be through your workplace or the state of unemployed .

In the UK we have much worse poverty and inequality, people living in poor quality housing, people unable to eat decent diets than in other European countries. Poor people take up a disproportionate amount of healthcare. This would make a system where you had to pay tricky as these poor people would have to be exempt from paying (unless you want an inhuman system like in the us). If we took steps to reduce poverty and spent more on preventive care in these people we could save a lot of money overall.

I'm sure there could also be huge efficiency savings for example community nurses could deal with a lot more than they do, better adult social care, better availability of physio and rehab would help people benefit from their expensive operations, not making people wait months until they deteriorate needing more care, having more support for disabled people in the community etc.

Bpickle1 · 20/03/2024 20:14

Just be grateful that you weren't ill enough to be seen extra sharpish!

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:10

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 20/03/2024 08:47

The biggest problem is that people don't look after themselves well in the UK so healh care is stretched and also people massively misuse all health services.

They go to the GP with every cough and cold ( I remember being told by family members every time one of my children had a viral illness as a baby that they "need antibiotics ") not one of them ever had a course of antibiitics under the age of 2.

A&E is used like a drop in centre. Tonsillitis, sore foot etc. People need to really learn what can be dealt with at home, what a pharmacist can offer (most people think they dispense medicine not are health care professionals ) and when it's A&E.

I think better A&E gate keeping and sending home the walking well would be a good start. In general unless you might not make it through the next 24 hours without intervention or a limb is hanging off and won't repair without a medical professional then you probably don't need A&E.

Edited

Trouble is if your child gets tonsillitis on a Friday night you would have to wait until Monday. I guess they probably won't die but they would suffering, need longer off school, a proportion will get sepsis. It's not really a solution. Plus the GP will send you to a and e if they think you need seen and they have no appointments. Once you have been advised to take a child to a and e you have to go or they call social services. This probably explains many of the vomiting toddlers etc .

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:04

Jeannie88 · 20/03/2024 19:19

Children seem to be treated quickly, as with doctors appointments. I've never had a problem getting my DC to see one one in a short space of time, guess it's the priority the system. Should be the same for older people. Xx

Not always. Last time I was there (with a fitting 1 year old) we waited 5 hours. Everyone else in the waiting room waited a similar time. It was all children including some who were struggling to breathe, and a girl with a broken ankle.

Mountainclimber50 · 20/03/2024 20:02

It’s always been like this from my recollection.

I worked in A&E in the 1990’s.

80% of the patients then should not have been there. I presume that is over 90% now.

Many time wasters clog up the system.

I left after being bitten and spat at one too many times.

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:01

LadyEloise1 · 20/03/2024 19:41

How can Sweden have such a good system ?
What does it do differently (to the UK and Ireland ) that gives it a so much better service

They pay about double what we do

PrincessTeaSet · 20/03/2024 20:01

applepie4u · 19/03/2024 11:58

I have friends nurses who work for nhs and the stories they tell are really sad. They usually work over their shifts, often not having a drink so have one at station that they can pick up and are glared at by pts and relatives about who think they are standing there drinking coffee when they are actually having a drink on shop floor and not going for break as so understaffed.
One of my friends who trained in 80s said pts used to respect nhs staff but now there is a lot of verbal abuse, filming with phones which is illegal in hospitals and complaining about trivia so time is taken up dealing with for example sammy who didn't get their cup of tea (big deal) but had a jug of water because staff were dealing with a heart attack or something else more serious. Selfish and think they are the only ones who are ill.
Also the public have become very selfish and demanding but don't look at the whole picture of the wards/accident service. If they have to wait for their tablets to take home they have no patience and forget that there are many other pts drugs inpt and outpatient to sort out.
Some pts also refuse to go home as their family can't pick up till next day so bed block. My friends say some pts demand ambulance booked which costs nhs a lot because no family when they could have got a taxi. My friends have seen family visiting previously.
Another problem is when doctors visit ward the patients don't ask everything or complain after or want a sick certificate and the nurses then have to call dr back from another area so this is all very time consuming.
A lot of patients and relatives make comments to my friends or at them about when they are on the computer. They see this as not proper nursing and make comments like they're just sitting at the desk doing nothing. My friends hear this all the time.
My best mate is a ward sister and she said admission
Assessments
Discharge planning
Blood results
X-rays
District nurse
Etc etc etc etc loads more things literally everything they do has to go on computer so if they did not sit there to look at blood results or write district nurse letter or request room clean for next pt these things would not get done and pts wouldn't have a clean room to go into.
Also my friends were saying how one pt to feed and wash, log roll can take an hour so think of all the pts they are dealing with, dressings, complicated dressings, intravenous antibiotics, pain relief, setting up pumps, doctors rounds, physio rounds, obtaining drugs, talking to relatives, phone calls, very sick patients who can take up all nurse time as all hands on deck, documentation that if is not done they can in serious trouble, audits.
Most people who complain don't understand any of this and as others have said come in as inappropriate admissions.
A lot of time is spent dealing with pts who will ask you if they can have a cup of tea when nurse doing drug round, or when nurses washing soiled dying pt next door.
So please support your NHS.
The staff overall work very hard and are highly qualified, unappreciated, underpaid and undervalued.
Some of my friends said they are done after many years as just subject to verbal and physical abuse on a daily basis.
Also my friends say when doctors to ward rounds patients are so respectful and smiling and happy to see the big boss but then moan when doctors not there so nurse advocate for everyone but get treated the worst and it's not right.

Obviously abusing staff is never acceptable. However you can see why people do it. They are worried, stressed, tired, in pain, they may have pets or children or jobs or elderly relatives to worry about. They then are expected to sit on the floor for 12 hours or more, with limited access to food or water, in dirty conditions, surrounded by suffering or drunk or infectious people. It's hardly surprising that some people lose their patience. It's not really reasonable to expect people to go on understanding and making allowances. The truth is that any wait over 4 hours is too long. People are dying in hospital while waiting, in ambulances, waiting for ambulances, because they avoid calling an ambulance or going to a and e because of the conditions, or because they can't get a GP appointment so their condition worsens. It's completely unacceptable. This is why people kick off. Not the fault of individual staff but it's an unavoidable consequence of the state the NHS is in.

maplepecan · 20/03/2024 19:45

The whole system is broken and people are undoubtedly ending up in a&e as they don't know where else to turn.

When DD recently got a piece of drinking straw stuck up her nose we ended up in a 5 hour wait in a&e. The GP wanted nothing to do with the issue so I phoned 111 to try to establish if there was any minor injuries type of place to take her. There wasn't and all they could advise was to not try to remove it ourselves and wait for hours for a doctor to call back. The thing just needed carefully fishing out so off we traipsed to a&e to wait until midnight for a doctor with a pair of long handled tweezers to spend 30 seconds pulling it out. DD had her observations taken hourly throughout like a poorly patient and we clogged up the waiting room for 5 hours with a completely healthy but increasingly tired and grumpy toddler.

LadyEloise1 · 20/03/2024 19:41

MrTiddlesTheCat · 19/03/2024 09:27

They're not just mad, they're barbaric. I fell down some stairs, shattering my shoulder. Thankfully I'm in Sweden so was seen and given morphine within half an hour an hour. The thought of being left on the floor, in agony, for hours on end absolutely horrifies me.

How can Sweden have such a good system ?
What does it do differently (to the UK and Ireland ) that gives it a so much better service

Jeannie88 · 20/03/2024 19:19

Allmarbleslost · 19/03/2024 12:12

I was in a&e at our nearest Children's hospital with dc2 last week. We were in and out within 2 hours (including triage, xray and temporary cast applied to wrist)

There were however lots of people in the waiting room who had been waiting for 5 hours plus (and were complaining loudly about it!) I can only assume that triage had decided they didn't need to be seen quickly.

Children seem to be treated quickly, as with doctors appointments. I've never had a problem getting my DC to see one one in a short space of time, guess it's the priority the system. Should be the same for older people. Xx

Longma · 20/03/2024 19:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Jeannie88 · 20/03/2024 19:15

Oh please, my Dad with stage 4 cancer and after a fall was left in a side room for hours, no one allowed to be there even though post covid. Fortunately a member of my family worked there and could check on him. He was in agony, crying out, had a drink next to him but couldn't get it. I was waiting and Fortunately he was being taken for scans etc but meanwhile surely anyone crying out in pain to be ignored? Broke my heart, as did the subsequent treatment, only one designated visitor was allowed, so that was my elderly Mum. Same again, couldn't reach water, wasn't drinking (if he did would be sick after) and she had to tell them this so eventually drip, too late, he had already got a urine infection from being dehydrated on top of no immune system to fight it. Weeks later palliative care.

When he was critical ot was the best care, same for everyone I know, but before that stage it's really not good enough.

We are so lucky to have the NHS, most staff are marvellous, but it seems to take to being critical that the best care is given from my experience. Then of course it really can be too late...

FlissyPaps · 20/03/2024 18:45

You can always spot the Tories on threads like these. Blaming the astronomical wait times on people using the service unnecessarily when the reality is that they are a small number.

I disagree. I was in A&E a few months ago in agony with a suspected blocked bowel. I wasn’t paying much attention to who else was in the waiting room as I was crying in pain but my mum who accompanied me did.

There was a woman (around 40yo) chatting to my mum saying she was there with a chest infection and couldn’t get a GP appointment. A man who stormed out who said he couldn’t be arsed to wait any longer as he had already waited 5 hours to be seen with foot pain. A young couple in their 20’s, not sure who was the patient but they ended up having an argument and both left before seeing a doctor.

Saschka · 20/03/2024 18:35

BeaRF75 · 19/03/2024 14:50

Well, so many visits to A&E are inappropriate or unnecessary, so it's hardly surprising.
Heard about a person in a minor car accident the other day who went to A&E for cuts and bruises - I mean, where is people's common sense? Yes, they'd had an accident, but what exactly did they expect A&E to do, apart from send them home? Which is exactly what happened!

That will be for an insurance claim. They’ll say they have whiplash.

TheChosenTwo · 20/03/2024 17:10

Fil had to go last week and it was a 19 hour wait announced on the screen but he was seen quite a lot quicker than that, within about 2 hours he said.

teacrumpetsandcake · 20/03/2024 17:05

PickledPurplePickle · 19/03/2024 09:18

🙄There are already a million threads about this, do we really need another one?

Yes. When people are being left on the floor in agony for hours, we need as many threads as possible and to be talking about it as much as possible.

Roryhon · 20/03/2024 17:02

I’ve had more than my fair share of A&E waits with relatives who are seriously ill in the past five years. It gets worse and worse. I don’t think it’s due to people going with unnecessary things, it’s because there aren’t any beds on the wards available. Often down to the discharge process. It seems to take 24-48 hours for the appropriate forms to be signed and medication dispensed, so people sit on wards that don’t need to. And if they haven’t done that by 3pm on Friday afternoon you end up staying all weekend. I’ve seen it happen so many times while my relatives were in hospital. Both my parents were on a trolley in A&E for 48 hours plus. When my mother was there the trolleys and corridors had bed numbers. There is such a shortage of staff. Nobody can chase anything up. It’s very scary. Luckily my parents and husband had me to ask for them when they were incredibly ill, but some elderly people were left alone for most of the time and couldn’t move. I’m terrified of how it will be by the time I’m elderly.

rooinspace · 20/03/2024 10:19

I recently had to go to an urgent treatment centre (which is alongside the A&E at our local hospital) in large London hospital during a weekday. In and out within 1.5hours including x ray taken. Couldn’t have been more impressed to be honest, I had taken a bag prepared for a long sit.

Deliaskis · 20/03/2024 10:17

MaloneMeadow · 20/03/2024 09:02

Try being told by your GP to (needlessly) bring your child with tonsillitis to A&E.. All because they couldn’t fit her in for an appointment that day 🤦‍♀️ They even asked me to do it on a second occasion but I point blank refused - genuinely embarrassing having to turn up to A&E knowing full well that there was no reason for us to be there

Your experience sounds similar to ours @MaloneMeadow , it very often isn't the fault of the people waiting there, many of whom would happily and even tried very hard to access healthcare in a number of different ways and got pushed to A&E by other parts of the NHS, despite being fully aware that it makes no sense. If it's truly the only option, and you are told that by other NHS services, then people are forced to take it.

SENlife · 20/03/2024 09:45

My local A&E has reported this week that the longest they have had a patient in A&E waiting recently is 1 week. I was in last year after falling down the stairs and fracturing my lower back, there were elderly people that had been sat in the waiting room for 28 hours. The HCA brought them a hot meal and said as you have now been sat here for more than 24 hours we have to feed you a meal.
The hospital is shockingly bad though and should be investigated for its insane amount of failings

Fast800 · 20/03/2024 09:33

KnittedCardi · 20/03/2024 09:25

5 million more people, and a million more over 65's since 2010, doesn't help. You can argue of course that requires more funding, of course it does, but also looking at the stats, there are more staff, more treatments, more of everything, than ever, but it is never enough. Needs reform, and better focus of where funds are spent.

The biggest problem is not the increased population but an increased aging population.

KnittedCardi · 20/03/2024 09:25

5 million more people, and a million more over 65's since 2010, doesn't help. You can argue of course that requires more funding, of course it does, but also looking at the stats, there are more staff, more treatments, more of everything, than ever, but it is never enough. Needs reform, and better focus of where funds are spent.

LoftyTurtle · 20/03/2024 09:18

A lot of it is chronic underfunding by the Tory government, however there is a small but not insignificant percentage down to how the local hospital/services are run. Some run better than others (although all are in a shit situation due to funding regardless.) My local children's hospital is usually really great. When we took our then 8 month old in when she had bronchiolitis, they immediately triaged her. Realised that while she was sick, she wasn't urgently sick. We were sent to a separate area of A&E staffed by nurse practitioners who directly reported to one overseeing doctor. We were quickly seen, treated, and sent home. Far more efficient than insisting we see/wait for a doctor when realistically baby didn't need that (she just needed someone to suction all the snot out of her nose so she could feed again! The nurse said she was impressed by how much snot she had up there, the most amount of snot she'd ever seen apparently 🤣).

Mischance · 20/03/2024 09:08

We really need a system that monitors your health and so people that don't look after themselves don't get to drain the resources - ah, that sounds nice and cheap to run!!