Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send college an email after no teacher for a year?

56 replies

Mnetter11 · 19/03/2024 02:39

My DD 17 attends college and will be taking her 3 A levels in 60 days. She is very upset as she is currently getting D’s in one of her subjects (background: she is achieving A’s in her other two and was achieving A’s in this subject last year.) This subject has had no teacher for the whole second year and have had around 10 supply/agency teachers. She is very disheartened as her dream universities and apprenticeships are now out the window.

We’ve both made many complaints throughout the year to the head of year who has promised there would be a permanent teacher soon. I’m not in a financial position to pay for private tutor but feel very sorry for DD and not sure what to do next.

AIBU to contact the college about emailing somebody higher to put in another complaint (I am worried the college will turn on DD if I do this as they’ve been no help previously) ?

Is there any educational boards I can put in a complaint too?

OP posts:
PlumbersWifey · 19/03/2024 07:41

My sons school did this for his Maths GCSE and were adamant that while it wasn't ideal, they were doing nothing wrong.

Phineyj · 19/03/2024 07:38

Yes and the specification! Make sure it's for the right board and course. They're all freely available on the exam board websites.

Phineyj · 19/03/2024 07:31

You and DD are going to have to throw some time and/or money at the problem yourselves.

Forget the teacher situation. It's too late. You need:

A CGP revision guide for the right specification
The exam board endorsed textbook
To say what the subject is either here or on the Staffroom thread so people can point you towards good quality free resources
To download all the past papers and DD needs to start practicing all the different types of questions and then use the resources above to fill any knowledge gaps
(Possibly pull some strategic sickies if the cover teachers are actually confusing her - this is more of an issue than lack of teaching ime)
Change her mindset. She is independent and resilient. She is going to succeed!

Signed, a teacher who taught myself Physics GCSE, Statistics A level and most of an Economics degree in similar circumstances...

Miyagi99 · 19/03/2024 07:26

Ask for them to print out the curriculum for that subject (you can do it yourself too) so she can cover everything herself at home or the library. My son’s A level teachers were woefully poor so we did it ourselves. Not ideal but he did get to uni.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 19/03/2024 07:18

Depending on the subject I know some students have used uplearn to cover the course. Though at this late stage she would have to put serious work in.

It has a cost but it much less than a tutor. If you say the subject someone here might be able to help as well.

Putting in a complaint shouldn’t affect your daughter and with only a couple of months to go they couldn’t disadvantage her now. But what do you hope for an outcome? They can’t change the crap teaching.

Mumoftwo1312 · 19/03/2024 07:10

It is usually much more expensive for the college to pay for supply and agency teachers. They will be very keen to get a permanent teacher if they can. It's not from a lack of will on their part, or stinginess.

I don't think complaining will do any good at all.

As for the suggestion upthread of contacting your mp - I had to laugh, what can they do in this situation?! If no one is applying to teach there, they can't get someone. The best an MP could do is lobby for better working conditions etc to boost retention in general. Not magic up a shortage-subject teacher out of thin air

Mnetcurious · 19/03/2024 07:08

I really sympathise with you, the same has happened in one of my child’s GCSE subjects and they will probably not end up with the 9 they could have got in this subject if there had been a specialist teacher throughout all of year 11 (appreciate its the not the same as A level but it’s my child’s best subject that they also want to continue at A level and beyond).
By all means complain but it’s too late to make much, if any, difference at this stage I’d say.
I’d make sure she has all the revision guides etc and there are also loads of helpful resources on YouTube, like lessons by professional teachers. There are also sites like ‘maths and physics tutor’ (I don’t know what her subject is) which are free and explain all the different topics in videos as well as providing practice questions.

BibbleandSqwauk · 19/03/2024 07:06

OP what subject is it? There's lots of teachers on here who might be able to point you to the best online resources. Lots of teachers recorded themselves presenting their PowerPoints over lockdown and put them YouTube. If it's RS, message me and I'll try to help.

Oblomov24 · 19/03/2024 07:01

Complain to Head. Ask that all her Uni's are contacted. This will achieve little though, and little practical affect. I agree with Lily, why a D? She needs to pull out all resources. And you need to find whatever money you can, club together with other parents to hire a tutor.

Nevermindtheteacaps · 19/03/2024 06:57

You could experiment with perplexity.ai to create structured revision material and exercises for her, tailored to her gaps. It's currently free

MrsMurphyIWish · 19/03/2024 06:51

I’m sorry you’re going through this but there are no teachers. I teach in an Outstanding secondary and even we are 2 English teachers down and thus one of our English Lit A-levels group is being taught by a cover supervisor. We have so many complaints but there’s nothing we can do if no one applies for the position. Emailing will only make you feel worse as you think nothing is being done and will make the institution feel awful too when it’s the Tories who have created this mess.

Tutors are the way to go - group tutoring will be cheaper or asking Uni students to tutor as well.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 19/03/2024 06:45

Yabu as it is not the college's fault.
Huge shortage of teachers. Even with bursaries of up to 30000!

NinetyNineRedBalloonsGoBy · 19/03/2024 06:42

T*HERE ARE NO TEACHERS

IT'S NOT DUE TO THE COLLEGE BEING CRAP, THEY CANNOT RECRUIT! * Trust me, it's MUCH harder work for the college having to set cover --and deal with the constant complaints from parents about the lack of teachers.

No one wants to teach so there's no new staff.

Good, experienced staff are leaving in droves - in part due to the CONSTANT stream of complaints like this one about the lack of resources - which should be going to the government but instead get lobbed into schools.

OP - I'm sorry for your DD but what do you think your complaint will achieve? Do you think they will receive it and the penny will finally drop that they need to put an advert out for the first time?! Confused

RedStripeypillow · 19/03/2024 06:36

I second taking control of the situation yourself. Buy the text book, go onto the Exam website and download past papers, read examiner reports, mark schemes.

Get together with other members of the class ti get a tutor.

Watch videos.

Someone who is capable of getting As should be able to improve this grade.

wagnbobble · 19/03/2024 06:36

Rummikub · 19/03/2024 03:38

Email and ask if your dd’s Ucas reference has stated that there hasn’t been a subject tutor for a year. And to request they take this into account. I’m not sure if it will make a difference but if she’s getting AA and a D and that’s the reason why then that’s the least they can do

If they haven’t then ask them to email admissions of the uni she has applied to.

I would also go higher than head of year to complain. Unfortunately it doesn’t seem like there’s much that can be done in the time that’s left. Are they offering subject specific revision over Easter?

Exactly this - Her UCAS reference should have referred to this and if not each Uni told . You need to send in an official complaint as that way it should be addressed properly rather than covered up at a lower level . May also be worth commenting on local social media updates even if to just let other parents / students know that this is a subject to currently be avoided

Daffodilsdaftie · 19/03/2024 06:35

If this was at the start of her course I’d be straight on to my MP. He has sorted out a similar issue for me, and when he talks people listen.

It’s too late in the day for that though, so it’s a case of buying the revision guide and getting stuck in to self learning.

hopscotcher · 19/03/2024 06:34

These things happen in 6th form unfortunately - it's shit for the students, though. Supply teachers can be good, but a constant stream sounds really difficult for continuity.
I agree with complaining again to someone higher (am sure this won't impact on anyone's treatment of your DD) and with trying to find out whether the lack of teacher can count as a mitigating circumstance for UCAS.
Beyond that, I guess she has to study independently as best she can - use the textbook (if there is one), past papers, model answers etc. There's presumably someone in charge of the subject who could provide, or signpost you, to some of these things.

Embraceit · 19/03/2024 06:30

ArghhWhatNext · 19/03/2024 06:01

10 different cover teachers in a year who are not doing a proper handover one to the next are not going to deliver an effective, structured course. It is only the most independent, self-motivated (and possibly otherwise supported) individuals who will thrive in spite of that. Just as in a workplace with constant leadership change productivity and morale drops - people don’t become bad at their jobs - it’s just very difficult to do them as you ideally would.
Making a complaint won’t change things for your daughter but is essential for future students who might sign up to an unresourced course on the promise that it might be resourced.
I think as others have suggested, I’d see if it’s possible to club together for tutoring.
If her results turn out poor would it be feasible to have a year out and retake the subject elsewhere?

As I said, OP needs to explain why she thinks the two are correlated more clearly to the school.

I’m in my 20s and went through similar and in recent years - and it didn’t impact my a levels. My teacher was present during AS year but then I had an array of supply teachers during her maternity leave in 2nd year. It was slightly disruptive but I came out with the grade anticipated. So that’s why there needs to be more of an explanation as to what the issue is in OP’s circumstances.

A level students are expected to independently study so classroom learning only makes up a % of the overall expected learning time. I’m sure the school will state something similar, and I’m not sure what resolution they can provide here.

lilyathena · 19/03/2024 06:29

Though it's also worth checking what the reasons are for the D. Is this the picture across the group? Does DD know what she needs to do to improve etc. has she had decent feedback on the mock? Can that be organised if not... by someone who knows what they're doing... ?

lilyathena · 19/03/2024 06:01

Maybe look at the complaints policy of the college and try to follow it but escalate as quickly as possible. Supply for a year isn't acceptable though the national picture is not good. They must have data on students' gcse outcomes and targets for what they want them to be achieving now. They should be supporting those students who are below where they should be somehow. Can they bring an external consultant in, who knows the course, to run holiday or in-term intensive crash course? These people do exist though cost of course - what's the subject and where are you? Funding and staffing are in a mess like everywhere I expect but you may be able to pressurise for something like this if enough people make a fuss to a senior decision maker. Are you able to contact other families to try to increase pressure?

I would also go to the exam board website and get marked exemplars in the subject in past papers so DC can see 'what a secure one looks like'. Again whether she can replicate these this may depend on the balance of skills versus knowledge in the subject and what it's possible to do without a skilled teacher.

ArghhWhatNext · 19/03/2024 06:01

Embraceit · 19/03/2024 05:48

To be honest I’m not sure about your approach.

From the school’s pov, they have found cover for the lessons and course material. That there’s been a range of supply teachers doesn’t mean that everyone in the class would automatically get a D grade. There must be something else going on specific to your daughter that would explain going from A to D. I’m not sure that the 2 things are as strongly correlated as you think, but maybe you just need to outline why you think that more clearly to the school.

Edited

10 different cover teachers in a year who are not doing a proper handover one to the next are not going to deliver an effective, structured course. It is only the most independent, self-motivated (and possibly otherwise supported) individuals who will thrive in spite of that. Just as in a workplace with constant leadership change productivity and morale drops - people don’t become bad at their jobs - it’s just very difficult to do them as you ideally would.
Making a complaint won’t change things for your daughter but is essential for future students who might sign up to an unresourced course on the promise that it might be resourced.
I think as others have suggested, I’d see if it’s possible to club together for tutoring.
If her results turn out poor would it be feasible to have a year out and retake the subject elsewhere?

Embraceit · 19/03/2024 05:48

To be honest I’m not sure about your approach.

From the school’s pov, they have found cover for the lessons and course material. That there’s been a range of supply teachers doesn’t mean that everyone in the class would automatically get a D grade. There must be something else going on specific to your daughter that would explain going from A to D. I’m not sure that the 2 things are as strongly correlated as you think, but maybe you just need to outline why you think that more clearly to the school.

DaveWatts · 19/03/2024 05:46

Could you club together with some of the other pupils in her class to share the cost of a tutor for some private lessons? Also if you contact some private tutors and explain your circumstances you may be able to haggle a cheaper rate. What's the subject?

BCBird · 19/03/2024 05:35

The fundamental issue is that no one wants to teach. It is not fair on your daughter I know. Could you ask the school yo psy for a tutor for the group? Even online would be better than nothing?

Octavia64 · 19/03/2024 05:33

You can send in a complaint but if the college are trying to recruit and no one is applying there is little more they can do.

Try posting the subject she needs help with on the secondary education board and asking for free resources.