Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
supercalafragilisticexpealidocious · 18/03/2024 16:12

We've got one and we love it. It costs only a few quid to "fill up". We drove it to the north east and back yesterday. Had to stop once to top up the electric but it literally
Took 5 minutes as we only needed a bit of charge to get us home. Even a full tank of charge would have taken 30 minutes to fill.

Having said that I may not buy one unless it was a good price (ours is lease) as I've heard the batteries have a relatively short shelf life.

We do love it though.

GirlMum40 · 18/03/2024 16:12

I would not have anything other than electric now but it depends on what you're using it for.

I am using mine for school runs and very short distances to and from work.

The range I get is less than the advertised range but the accuracy of the miles left on the guage is very accurate. I've never run out of charge and have run it down to 1 mile left!

You cannot rely on there being chargers whilst out and about. They are very commonly out of order or in use (or a petrol car is parked in the charging spots as they are commonly nearer the entrances for places)

If you keep it charged up at home it's fine. I tend to just plug it in whenever I'm at home. I would never drive anywhere assuming I can charge it there because that could be disastrous.

The costs are cheaper than petrol but maybe not by as much as you would think.

I have never had it in the garage in all the years I've had it. There's no real engine so nothing to go wrong. The only thing I top up is the wiper wash.

The main advantage for me is the car is SO pleasurable to drive. It's no harder than driving a dodgem. Foot down to go, foot off to stop. No clutch, no gears, no revs. It's like driving for dummies. So easy. And the drive is so smooth. I get nausea now when I go anywhere in a petrol car.

If I had to rely on it for driving on holidays, long commutes etc I would NOT get one. For short city drives or school runs they're a winner.

Cbljgdpk · 18/03/2024 16:11

We had one as a company car and I found it stressful as it can say you have 30 miles left but you don’t really and it will suddenly change and I never really trusted it. Also stopping to charge it can take ages, more so as electric cars get more popular as the chargers are often taken so you have to wait or they’re broken so you’re looking for somewhere. It’s really not good when you have unexpected trips. I also wouldn’t buy one second hand for the reasons you said.

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 16:09

I'm changing my car and absolutely won't get an electric car for environmental reasons. The lifecycle impact of an electric car and battery is awful for pollution. Plus extra road damage as they're heavier. Plus they're lethal in car parks being so quiet, I've nearly been run over several times by an electric car I couldn't hear.

The impact of all the current electric car batteries needing to be disposed of in a few years will be shocking on the environment. The mining for the components is also terrible, but fine as long as it isn't anywhere geographically near us, right? 🙄

Thatnameistaken · 18/03/2024 16:09

I love my Nissan leaf. It's a 16 plate, 25,000 miles, I bought it in September.
Due to its age fully charged it shows 70 mile range which is more than enough for me.
If I was to primarily charge at a commercial charging point it would cost around the same as a diesel but I plug into a 3 pin socket in the garage once I'm down to 20% and the car charges overnight.
I'm averaging 500 miles per month, comparing bills for the same months 22/23 it's costing on average £25/£30 per 500 miles. It was costing that near enough weekly with my old car.
I pay no road tax.
My insurance is £100 cheaper than the equivalent for my previous diesel car.

As far as repair costs go, there's not a huge amount of things to go wrong bar brakes, suspension etc.
I got the car from an independent specialist who can replace individual cells in the battery if/when they fail rather than the whole battery.
It's an absolute no brainer as our second car and it doesn't mind the short stop/start journeys that caused problems with my diesel.
The key as with any used car is finding a seller that you trust.
If you're in the northeast of England I know just the guy.

Blanketpolicy · 18/03/2024 16:08

We have had an EV since June last year.

Everyone in house prefers it to the ICE car which can go days between uses (but is still needed for those uses) as it is just so easy to drive.

Plug it in overnight and it charges at 7.5p per kwh and we get on average around 3-3.5 miles per kwh depending on time of year and driving style (ds get much less mileage than I do and in the summer it is more).

A £3 overnight charge will give us 120 - 140 miles (we keep charge between 20%-80% so we have a bit more range in there available for longer journeys if we need it). We charge twice a week.

I think your driving needs are important to your decision. We don't do many long journeys, my work is only 20 miles away. Occasionally I go to the office in Edinburgh, 70 miles each way, and that is fine on one 100% charge - with the advantage being if you get stuck in traffic it consumes less power crawling than it does at speed. We would use the ICE car for any rare longer journeys we do as we are not confident with charging away from home at unknown chargers.

Servicing is cheaper £88 for last service. Insurance is higher £275 -> £440 (but insurance prices have also jumped so not sure how much of that is because EV)

Added bonus is we run the dishwasher, washing machine, and ds gaming until 3am(!) overnight too at 7.5p electricity rate.

randombloke15 · 18/03/2024 16:07

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 15:40

DB has an electric Audi.

He was down to 12miles range after Leeds to Birmingham recently, and after going to NINE different charging points on the motorway then at the NEC he couldn't find any fast chargers (several non-functioning, any functioning were all in use) and ended up on a crap trickle charge at the NEC for some exorbitant price and it only gave him about 50miles charge in an afternoon. He had to drive home again that day, so then had to hunt for another fast charge, which still takes 1.5hrs or more, wait for it to charge up then drive home.

They both now take the family diesel car if they travel further than a single charge can do in a return journey. Absolutely pointless - spending all that money on a white elephant.

I'm wait until they've sorted access to proper EV chargers nationally. Not worth it at the moment unless you only do local driving with absolutely zero need to ever go further.

That's off
The NEC has the UK's largest ultra rapid charging hub that can charge 30 cars at the same time

www.bppulse.co.uk/going-electric/the-uks-largest-public-ev-charging-hub-nec-birmingham

I've been driving electric for around 6 yrs now, average around 10'000 miles a year, would never go back

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 16:06

jackstini · 18/03/2024 16:04

Oh - and it takes 15 mins to charge to full at a supercharger - so by the time we've got something to eat and been to the loo it's done, no waiting around

If they are available. A full charge still takes approx an hour for most vehicles as I understand it.

Fine if you're tootling about, useless if you have deadlines / travel times to adhere to / kids to get him to bed or what ever where time is of the essence.

jackstini · 18/03/2024 16:04

Oh - and it takes 15 mins to charge to full at a supercharger - so by the time we've got something to eat and been to the loo it's done, no waiting around

jackstini · 18/03/2024 16:03

I've had mine just under a year and done about 7000 miles

Done a few long trips where I've used Tesla Superchargers (& never had an issue finding one available) but mostly I charge at home as I get 240 miles on a full charge

I've spent £351 on electricity in that time (OVO do a cheap anytime rate)
Petrol would have been £1694

No servicing required at all yet
You can warranty the battery and there is no engine or exhaust system to go wrong. No oil leaks and very easy and quiet to drive

We had a hybrid for 2 years before this one and that made our minds up really

We have our own business and bought it through that, which means you can offset 100% of the cost against corporation tax in the first year too (in case any business owners are considering!)

Motomum23 · 18/03/2024 16:02

I wouldn't touch one - they are mot as environmentally friendly as you think unless you plan on installing solar panels to charge it. Repairs are expensive and depreciation is huge

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 15:58

I'll be sticking to petrol for as long as I possibly can. I don't have a driveway so can't charge at home and wouldn't spend long enough in a shopping centre etc. to charge it.

Time your charges with breaks you’d be taking anyway on proper long road trips and you have no difference in journey duration.

We'd only stop for long enough to grab something to eat and use the loo as we'd just swap drivers rather than taking a long break. I can fill up the car in 5 minutes so I don't want to be sitting around in services waiting for the car to charge.

Bjorkdidit · 18/03/2024 15:53

There's a fuel station near us (not on the motorway, it is a few minutes from a junction but it's not signposted as a service station, so effectively a standard suburban filling station) that sells electricity at 65 p a kWh so about 5 times what people pay at home on a special tariff.

If you bought that, it would probably cost more per mile than petrol/diesel to run the car, so putting electric car drivers at even more of a disadvantage cost wise.

Hoppinggreen · 18/03/2024 15:49

I didnt want one but DH did. I leased one so he could see what a bad idea it was.
Unfortunately I fell in love with it and have now bought one.
I absolutely love driving it, its so smooth and quiet. Costs me very little to run as I charge overnight at home mostly for around 2p per mile, according to my App I save around £250 per month as opposed to petrol.
I ahve never had any issue charging on long jorneys and it hasnt blown up yet.
I cant say I bought it to save the planet or anything but I just enjoy it.
Its not for everyone but its great for us

Bjorkdidit · 18/03/2024 15:47

^Expensive to buy.
Cheap to run and maintain.

You are trading up front purchase cost against future lower petrol, tax and maintenance costs^

Indeed. Always do the maths. I bought a 2 YO small petrol car for £8k. A very slightly newer electric version of the same car would have been more like £18k. It would have taken the best part of a decade to make back the extra upfront cost, even if the electric I charged it with was free.

I'm open to the idea of an electric car for personal use and have a vague plan for one when my current car reaches the end of it's life - I'm hoping there will be some trade in deals that will make it more financially viable.

I wouldn't consider it for business use because I do some very long work days that I have no desire to make longer because I'd likely have to charge up twice and no I wouldn't spend the time hanging round service stations drinking coffee while the car charges.

So while MN loves an electric car, there's still a lot of shortcomings for many and the cost is often too high for those who generally drive low to mid price cars.

MaloneMeadow · 18/03/2024 15:46

YANBU. We had one on a weekend long test drive and were very much put off. A car with a supposed 175 mile range dropped to 99 in the cold! Just not feasible for us, plus mad insurance and maintenance costs made it a no go. Alright if you’ve got a short city commute but not for anything else

inkblackheart · 18/03/2024 15:45

Funny how the guys at your local garage (which presumably doesn’t service electric cars given their comments about how specialists are needed) think petrol and diesel cars are the way to go…

ILoveSalmonSpread · 18/03/2024 15:44

We have a self charging hybrid.
It's 'smart' in that it automatically changes between the two fuels but for short commutes , you can override it to use one more than the other.

jannier · 18/03/2024 15:44

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2024 15:33

But still way greener than the equivalent fossil fuel car.

Ours is super cheap to run. No servicing, clean, smooth, fast - could never go back to oilburners.

Depends if you don't mind lithium lakes and have looked at research into the increased pollution from tyre particles due to excessive waste.
The scrappage of cars that can't be sold because nobody wants to buy a second hand car with a battery that will need replacing at the cost of £000,s next year. Or the ones who run on 3g systems that will no longer work as 3g is scrapped.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2024 15:43

I’ve driven ours to the alps and back on several trips. Never once had an issue with charging, chargers or range. Time your charges with breaks you’d be taking anyway on proper long road trips and you have no difference in journey duration. For day to day use we charge at home. Can’t do that with a petrol pump.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 18/03/2024 15:42

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2024 15:33

But still way greener than the equivalent fossil fuel car.

Ours is super cheap to run. No servicing, clean, smooth, fast - could never go back to oilburners.

Are they?
They are made mostly from plastic (crude oil).

My question is: when will something truly have a positive environmental impact,
If you compare something that is already here: older car, versus something that is specifically produced for you: new electric car.

Bottom line is, we need to consume less not more.

Caspianberg · 18/03/2024 15:42

No problem with ours, had 2 years.
We have done long journeys often, we live where it’s really mountainous and minus temperatures in winter and the range is fine. We have 500km roughly in summer. Winter range still 400km ish.
It’s never just dropped range.

We average around €20-30 a month in charging, which is far less than our older smaller petrol cost in Petrol. This February it cost us €23.40.

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 15:40

DB has an electric Audi.

He was down to 12miles range after Leeds to Birmingham recently, and after going to NINE different charging points on the motorway then at the NEC he couldn't find any fast chargers (several non-functioning, any functioning were all in use) and ended up on a crap trickle charge at the NEC for some exorbitant price and it only gave him about 50miles charge in an afternoon. He had to drive home again that day, so then had to hunt for another fast charge, which still takes 1.5hrs or more, wait for it to charge up then drive home.

They both now take the family diesel car if they travel further than a single charge can do in a return journey. Absolutely pointless - spending all that money on a white elephant.

I'm wait until they've sorted access to proper EV chargers nationally. Not worth it at the moment unless you only do local driving with absolutely zero need to ever go further.

mucky123 · 18/03/2024 15:40

I have an electric car and don't have any of the problems you have been told about. The mileage gauge is pretty accurate, have not needed servicing or anything half as much as petrol car does, electric is super cheap we charge ours with a mix of solar and economy 7 (Octopus do great deals) and its super cheap (would be different if you are charging out and about and not at home). I would really recommend. We also use it now for main car, this weekend we drove from home counties to south wales quite happily, charged there and came back in a oner.

GasPanic · 18/03/2024 15:40

Expensive to buy.
Cheap to run and maintain.

You are trading up front purchase cost against future lower petrol, tax and maintenance costs.

I wouldn't buy one if I couldn't charge at home, because the public chargers are expensive and slow. OK every now and then for long distance but not great if you have to do frequently. If you charge at home you can get an EV tariff you can do better but even on the price cap tariff you will do better than petrol in terms of costs to run - maybe 50% ? Then you have lower maintenance charges to benefit from as well.

They are good to drive and tbh I don't think there is much difference in terms of safety etc cf. a petrol.

The real question is what is your daily mileage ?