Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DeathStarCanteenGal · 18/03/2024 16:47

@PragmaticWench if you've nearly been run over by an EV maybe you just need to use your eyes, rather than relying on your ears!!
And my EV certainly isn't as heavy as the big 4x4s and SUBs that so many people seem wedded to...
I've had mine for almost a year now. Great to drive, cheap as chips to run, and solar panels mean I effectively charged it for free between May and September. But even then charging it fully at home costs about £3.

Panda89 · 18/03/2024 16:45

We have a Tesla and really love it, had it for just over a year now.
It wasn’t an environmental choice, we chose it as we love gadgets and tech, and also because the supercharger network is very good.
It’s super cheap to charge at home, we have a driveway so have our own charger and use Octopus with 7.5p overnight electricity. I make the most of it like a PP and run the dishwasher, washing machine etc all overnight too.

Never had a problem getting a charge at a supercharger, it takes about 15/20 mins to charge to full.

I have no experience of other EVs and their charging networks though, the non Tesla chargers to tend to look more run down/broken.

HelloSunshine11 · 18/03/2024 16:42

We've got a Tesla through a work lease. We'll never go back to ICE now, we all absolutely love the car and everything about it is super easy. About to drive to mainland Europe from Yorkshire and we'll only need to charge once on the way, probably once while we're there, and once on the way back. There are two banks of Tesla superchargers near where we're staying, so we won't have any issues charging while we're away. We've done Scotland, Northumberland, Wales, London on different trips since we've had it with zero issues. Had to queue for a charger once, in London. You just need to be a bit organised with your journey planning and that's it really.

missshilling · 18/03/2024 16:39

OneMoreTime23 · 18/03/2024 16:21

Replaced the sensible diesel family wagon with a petrol
in December because there wasn’t a single electric alternative that worked for us.

This is our issue. We need a proper 4x4 rather than a car with four wheel drive and there doesn’t appear to be an electric one available.

Hereyoume · 18/03/2024 16:34

By free I meant the charging space, not the actual charge .

Chersfrozenface · 18/03/2024 16:32

We have no off road parking and one car, used almost entirely for long distances.

Not happening.

Validus · 18/03/2024 16:30

Love my Kia Niro. Definitely don’t want to go back to ICE.

I don’t have range issues at all, there are plenty of chargers for everywhere I’ve wanted to go, and servicing is fine at the Kia garage.

It’s very cheap to fill up (esp as I have solar). I find independent mechanics hate them though. I think they love ICE and don’t want change.

Caspianberg · 18/03/2024 16:30

Our insurance on new electric full comp is half the price we paid on old petrol third party.

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 16:29

If an EV suits your lifestyle then they are great.

If you can charge at home on a smart meter they are massively cheaper to run than petrol.

Servicing generally cheaper as there are less bits to service.

Range on them is getting better all the time, and if you are planning to use it as second car runaround it'll be absolutely fine.

And, despite what petrolheads will claim, over the course of the lifecycle of a car EVS are undeniably greener than ICE equivalents.

Sputfink · 18/03/2024 16:28

We got a second-hand e-Golf a couple of years ago as our running around car (and in practice the one we both drive most). It’s brilliant. Very easy to drive; cheap to charge at home on the overnight tariff; range is fine (max 144 miles - down to 90ish if it’s well below freezing - but that’s more than enough for school and office commuting). We’ve got a diesel family car for long distance stuff. The only maintenance issue so far was an intermittent fault on the charging socket, but the local VW garage got that sorted quickly and it wasn’t too expensive.

Big question I guess is when we’ll take the plunge and make our second car electric … feels like the national charging infrastructure probably isn’t quite there yet, but it might be in the next few years when we sell our current diesel.

Hereyoume · 18/03/2024 16:27

EV enthusiast here. Currently on my third Musk Mobile.

First thing? Please forget the absolute bollocks that an EV is "better for the environment", it isn't. The Carbon footprint of an EV is fucking enormous and none of them will last more than 10 years because nobody is going to pay 10k to replace the battery on an eight year old car. So all the current ones will last half as long as an ICE car. They are apparently designing ones with different batteries, supposedly cheaper, but those new batteries can't be retrofitted to existing EV's. If you like the idea of an EV, go for it, but don't kid yourself that you're saving the Polar Bears by driving one.

I am a tech head so that's why I drive one.

If you don't have a home charger then you won't save any money in "fuel" costs over a regular car, so there's that to think about.

Stated range is just a suggestion, in reality you will reliably get half the range, and maybe a bit more if you're light on the throttle and never carry passengers, luggage, use the heating, Air-Con, or drive against the wind.

Look up Zap Map or similar and map out the chargers in your area, it will help you to decide if an EV is viable without home charging. Most are free late at night so you could just time your charging then if that applies to you.

They are a different league to an ICE car to drive, torque is instant and can catch you out if you're not used to it, especially on wet roads. Braking is mostly just foot off and let the regeneration take over, so you don't really have to use your brake pedal often, almost never in town.

Tyres are EV specific and 30% more expensive than "ordinary" ones.

You will use the heated seats to warm you up, not the cabin heater, even the Tesla heater is a bit pants and the drain on the battery just isn't worth it.

I think they are so much fun to drive though, like being in your own Sci-Fi movie! My car feels like a space ship!

Insurance will be a killer though, MAHUSIVE premiums, so factor that in as well.

renthead · 18/03/2024 16:26

Well of course the mechanics don't want you buying one!

We got an EV as our second car and I absolutely love it. So zippy and smooth to drive. Our SUV now feels like a tank by comparison.

I also just leave it plugged in at home on a regular slow charge, and this mostly does the trick for our purposes.

lissie123 · 18/03/2024 16:26

I love my Ioniq 5. Have had it for two years and no issues with charging. Just check on the charging site app when I’m going long distances to know where I can charge quickly. I had a diesel car before and I will never go back to a fossil fuel car unless I absolutely had no other choice.

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 16:25

randombloke15 · 18/03/2024 16:07

That's off
The NEC has the UK's largest ultra rapid charging hub that can charge 30 cars at the same time

www.bppulse.co.uk/going-electric/the-uks-largest-public-ev-charging-hub-nec-birmingham

I've been driving electric for around 6 yrs now, average around 10'000 miles a year, would never go back

As per the PP, that only went live in Sept 23 so is after this trip.

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 16:24

JustFrustrated · 18/03/2024 16:20

Did he not find the massive BP super fast charger bank at the NEC? Where 180 cars can be charged simultaneously?

Or any one of the loads of chargers in and around Birmingham?

We're an entirely EV household and do long drives frequently, and have never had an issue. Even in the far flung areas of Cumbria/the north York moores.

Nope, because that only went live in September 23, so wasn't a thing when we went! There were a handful of chargers around the site, all the speedy ones were either broken or in use.

He had tried NINE places on the journey down from Leeds and had an event to get to. He later found a McDonald's with a charger, but again it wasn't that fast and he eventually made it home very late that night.

Nannyfannybanny · 18/03/2024 16:24

Yes particulates from tyres. Very heavy, ruining the roads. Huge amount of minerals and metals to make. The electricity mostly requires fossil fuel to make. Have a friend with a nissan leaf. He also has a Citroen sitting in the garden where, the batteries went on it. That one used to cost a fortune to charge. He now has solar panels. Hates it for long journeys,chargers broken,big queues. Of course the garages will bring them into line,to make money. DH was a motor vehicle technician. 4 years ago, they had one tech who was trained on the electric vehicles. He said he would never have one. If we could afford it,he said he would go self charging hybrid.

Bluevelvetsofa · 18/03/2024 16:21

They really aren’t expensive now, because the bottom has dropped out of the second hand market for electric cars, so dealers are keen to sell them. Next year, electric car owners will have to pay the equivalent of road fund licence, which they don’t currently.

OneMoreTime23 · 18/03/2024 16:21

Replaced the sensible diesel family wagon with a petrol
in December because there wasn’t a single electric alternative that worked for us.

mafsfan · 18/03/2024 16:20

I don't think this matches what other reports have found.

It's about as much rubbish as them bursting into flames - which as it happens is far more likely to happen to ICE cars. It's just that EVs are more 'newsworthy'.

JustFrustrated · 18/03/2024 16:20

NCForQuestions · 18/03/2024 15:40

DB has an electric Audi.

He was down to 12miles range after Leeds to Birmingham recently, and after going to NINE different charging points on the motorway then at the NEC he couldn't find any fast chargers (several non-functioning, any functioning were all in use) and ended up on a crap trickle charge at the NEC for some exorbitant price and it only gave him about 50miles charge in an afternoon. He had to drive home again that day, so then had to hunt for another fast charge, which still takes 1.5hrs or more, wait for it to charge up then drive home.

They both now take the family diesel car if they travel further than a single charge can do in a return journey. Absolutely pointless - spending all that money on a white elephant.

I'm wait until they've sorted access to proper EV chargers nationally. Not worth it at the moment unless you only do local driving with absolutely zero need to ever go further.

Did he not find the massive BP super fast charger bank at the NEC? Where 180 cars can be charged simultaneously?

Or any one of the loads of chargers in and around Birmingham?

We're an entirely EV household and do long drives frequently, and have never had an issue. Even in the far flung areas of Cumbria/the north York moores.

OneMoreTime23 · 18/03/2024 16:20

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2024 15:43

I’ve driven ours to the alps and back on several trips. Never once had an issue with charging, chargers or range. Time your charges with breaks you’d be taking anyway on proper long road trips and you have no difference in journey duration. For day to day use we charge at home. Can’t do that with a petrol pump.

I often drive the length of the UK or across France. My rest stops are generally less than 10 mins…….

mafsfan · 18/03/2024 16:18

Mechanics aren't massively keen on EVs - they're not very keen on changing their business models and retraining! Also local garages won't have had that much experience of EVs. I wouldn't trust much of what they say and I'd ask people who actually own EVs.

We have two - there's not a chance that we would ever go back to ICE cars.

Katherineryan1986 · 18/03/2024 16:17

Something else to look out for - parking charges while charging the car!

We just got an electric car 3 wks ago and have just been on holiday. We got home to a parking fine as it seems we went in a private car park to charge the car and should have bought a parking ticket too! I’ve checked reviews for the location and loads of people have been caught out with this 😡. It never occurred to us to check parking charges!
The other trouble we had was that at 2 places the charging points had been vandalised and the cables stolen.

However, we have changed our tariff at home with Octopus and now get electricity overnight at 7p / kwh so it’s really cheap to charge the car at home.

Properchips · 18/03/2024 16:16

If the deterioration in the battery life in my mobile phone is anything to go by, there's no way I'd buy a battery car and expensive battery replacements down the line.

Swipe left for the next trending thread