Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 17:55

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 15:36

They aren't green when you consider cradle to grave. They are expensive unless a business buys them and can write them off. I have the Tesla as with 380 mile range it generally gets me where I want to be without hassle. I find I always have MORE range than it says, which has come in handy twice. Its free to charge at work so its a virtually free means for getting most places. I wouldn't buy the electric mini as it came with 100 mile range which would work only to and from work but not any weekend activities. They are an interesting toy but not going to save the planet or anything but it is economical if you can write it off and use low cost electricity.

They definitely have lower environmental impact over the cradle to cradle lifecycle.

Dogmum45 · 18/03/2024 17:51

Nope, not for me. I’ll be clinging onto my petrol car as long as I can.
The U.K. isn’t anywhere near geared up for EV yet. My car park at work holds 2000 cars. There are 5 EV charging points 🙄

I went out with a friend who has an EV a few weeks ago and we couldn’t find a charge point where we parked for the day. There were 4 but 2 were broken and the other 2 in use. We had to stop to charge the car on the way at some services. Took ages as no Fast chargers available. Ended up having to just charge it as much as we could in the time we had and it went into limp mode on the way back 🫣

There is no second hand market for EV. Dealers don’t want them back as the new battery cost out weighs the resale value.

Aesthetically the Tesla has to be THE most boring car ever invented.

No matter how many people try to tell me they are saving the planet by moving to EV, it’s all a load of 💩

Caspianberg · 18/03/2024 17:51

Electric cars do make a noise, especially at low speeds under 20km. I can always hear when dh arrives home as it makes that slow ‘spaceship whoosh’ noise someone above describes. It mainly makes it slow so you notice when cars slowly pull out of driveways or corners or in car parks etc.

Cocothecoconut · 18/03/2024 17:42

I wouldn’t touch one with a bargepole
i love my fiesta, yells at me when it needs juice 10 mins later I’ve got a tank full. Electric still needs to be produced from something , wind and solar are not truly reliable

moderndilemma · 18/03/2024 17:39

My worry is that we are trying to solve a 'now' problem, but not actually looking at the future. This Harvard Business Review paper talks about all the 'green' products that are now starting to go into landfill: solar panels (replaced early to maximise the individual benefits of newer efficiency); wind turbine blades; electric vehicle batteries - ALL going into landfill.

The potential of electric cars is great, lower costs if linked with a home with solar panels. But what in 10/15/20 years time? Where will all that debris go?

The Dark Side of Solar Power

Solar energy is a rapidly growing market, which should be good news for the environment. Unfortunately there’s a catch. The replacement rate of solar panels is faster than expected and given the current very high recycling costs, there’s a real danger...

https://hbr.org/2021/06/the-dark-side-of-solar-power

TonTonMacoute · 18/03/2024 17:20

I'm absolutely not an EV fan but actually I think that I would consider getting one for what you describe. If you can charge it at home and are using it for for regular local trips I wouldn't worry too much about what your local garage guys say, I think it would be fine.

The main downsides for me are the big question mark over depreciation - they are expensive to buy and it's doesn't seem to be clear how the second hand market works yet. When/if the battery goes that's big money. The green credentials have been overstated.

I get the impression that people who don't really like driving prefer them, but that's just a feeling.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 18/03/2024 17:13

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 15:36

They aren't green when you consider cradle to grave. They are expensive unless a business buys them and can write them off. I have the Tesla as with 380 mile range it generally gets me where I want to be without hassle. I find I always have MORE range than it says, which has come in handy twice. Its free to charge at work so its a virtually free means for getting most places. I wouldn't buy the electric mini as it came with 100 mile range which would work only to and from work but not any weekend activities. They are an interesting toy but not going to save the planet or anything but it is economical if you can write it off and use low cost electricity.

Interestingly Volvo, who sell the XC40 in ICE and electric versions, have commissioned a study on the cradle-to-grave emissions of the two variants. That shows that over the life of the vehicle (defined as 200,000Kms) the EV generates as little as half the emissions of the ICE version.

The Carbon Footprint of a XC40 ICE is 58 tonnes CO2e, whereas the footprint for the XC40 Recharge is between 27–54 tonnes CO2e depending on the source of the electricity (page 4 - executive summary)

volvo-cars-lca-report-xc40.pdf (volvocars.com)

To not get an electric car?
Validus · 18/03/2024 17:13

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 16:53

By law EVS have to make a noise when moving for exactly that reason.

They do. They make a spaceship sort of noise. It’s the only way I can describe it.

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 17:12

..

To not get an electric car?
SOBplus · 18/03/2024 17:09

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2024 17:04

They're greener than an ICE car, even after considering the embodied emissions. It is true though that BEVs weren't developed to save the planet, they were developed to save the car industry. If going green is the priority then the answer is to find a way to do without any car.

not really, green only if you parse when you calculate. All research I've seen says if you consider cradle to grave, a Range Rover is more green. Even Elon Musk says that though they are not green enough ...yet, if we didn't get started we would never get to where they are. Research now says batteries made from soft shell crab and lobster shells are better than lithium. So green may happen though PETA may not like it.

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2024 17:04

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 15:36

They aren't green when you consider cradle to grave. They are expensive unless a business buys them and can write them off. I have the Tesla as with 380 mile range it generally gets me where I want to be without hassle. I find I always have MORE range than it says, which has come in handy twice. Its free to charge at work so its a virtually free means for getting most places. I wouldn't buy the electric mini as it came with 100 mile range which would work only to and from work but not any weekend activities. They are an interesting toy but not going to save the planet or anything but it is economical if you can write it off and use low cost electricity.

They're greener than an ICE car, even after considering the embodied emissions. It is true though that BEVs weren't developed to save the planet, they were developed to save the car industry. If going green is the priority then the answer is to find a way to do without any car.

Chersfrozenface · 18/03/2024 17:01

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 16:56

How come they are pretty much silent? Is it just newer ones that have a sound? According to DH I have hearing like a bat and I've not heard them a few times although I do usually hear the tyre noise. DH is deaf and doesn't hear them at all.

Edited

Since July 2021 it has been UK law that both electric and hybrid vehicles must have sound generators installed, as they can be virtually silent, especially when travelling at low speeds. This poses a risk to pedestrians, cyclists and other drivers, particularly those who may be visually impaired.

Vehicles manufactured before this law came into force may well be quiet or even silent.

They are indeed a menace in car parks when you have a visual impairment, as I know all too well.

Elephantswillnever · 18/03/2024 17:01

I drive a plug in hybrid at work. It gets about half the range it says ( we are pretty hilly, I think it’d do better on the flat).

palmtreesoliveleaves · 18/03/2024 17:00

DH got 1 as a hire car when our own car was in the garage and it was an absolute nightmare. He loved the car but the public charging aspect was horrendous. Chargers didn't work, were much slower than advertised, people left their car plugged into chargers meaning they were out of use to others.. Not worth it imo until the charging network works well.

If you have a charging point at home then I guess it would be different.

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 16:58

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 16:56

How come they are pretty much silent? Is it just newer ones that have a sound? According to DH I have hearing like a bat and I've not heard them a few times although I do usually hear the tyre noise. DH is deaf and doesn't hear them at all.

Edited

I think the law came in during 2019 so any ev made before that may not make a noise, but any EV made after that has to make a noise of a level equivalent to an ICE car, and there will still be tire noise etc on top of that. They aren't silent at all.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 16:56

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 16:53

By law EVS have to make a noise when moving for exactly that reason.

How come they are pretty much silent? Is it just newer ones that have a sound? According to DH I have hearing like a bat and I've not heard them a few times although I do usually hear the tyre noise. DH is deaf and doesn't hear them at all.

Hoppinggreen · 18/03/2024 16:55

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 16:52

if you've nearly been run over by an EV maybe you just need to use your eyes, rather than relying on your ears!!

Tell that to blind or partially sighted people. They need to have some sort of sound to make them safer

They do make a noise. I can hear DH reverse off our driveway from inside the house

KnottyKnitting · 18/03/2024 16:55

We have a Yaris hybrid -no charging needed and we get about 70mpg if it is driven on economy mode( eg no rapid acceleration and careful braking. ) it actually makes you drive more safely IMO. The battery is guaranteed up to 15 years if checked yearly.

JanefromLondon1 · 18/03/2024 16:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

MumMumMumMumMumMumMum · 18/03/2024 16:55

I spend way way less charging than I did on diesel. Do you think perhaps your local mechanics wouldn't make as much money on electric cars hence why they attempt to put people off?

acatcalledjohn · 18/03/2024 16:54

The following points should be considered before deciding on how green an electric car is.

  1. Battery metals mining. Mining generally isn't great for the environment, and most mines are in countries where workers' rights are fairly low on the priority list.
  2. Added step to the supply chain, meaning the battery has to ship from source to wherever the car is assembled.
  3. Tyres: the battery adds significant weight to the car, which in turn results in more tyre wear (which are made of oil) so more polluting particles in the environment. Tyre pollution generally is ignored anyway, but actually quite significant. Not to mention the higher cost of heavier duty tyres, so for some people also cost prohibitive. Tyre pollution article
  4. Unless your electricity source is green you can't claim kudos for that (and no, solar panels aren't ideal because after their 20-odd year life they aren't easy to recycle at all).
  5. Shelf life of batteries is limited, and batteries cannot be recycled easily. Plus replacement, depending on the age and value of the car, can be cost prohibitive.
  6. Risk: if the battery cuts out that is you without power on the road.
  7. Logistically not great for long distance travel given the lack of charging points in this country. The country is desperately trying to catch up on charging points.
  8. There where the charging network is much more in line with the number of EVs on the road, they are finding that the electricity grid is suffering an overload. Grid overload NL

Ultimately speaking, in terms of direct emissions it is a good option. However, all the above points are not considered in the marketing because it doesn't benefit our governments and their targets, so effectively it is a lot of greenwashing.

Yet you pay a premium for these cars, far more than you'll ever save on road tax.

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 16:53

By law EVS have to make a noise when moving for exactly that reason.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 18/03/2024 16:52

if you've nearly been run over by an EV maybe you just need to use your eyes, rather than relying on your ears!!

Tell that to blind or partially sighted people. They need to have some sort of sound to make them safer

Whitesapphire · 18/03/2024 16:49

Its personal preference, I’ve recently got a brand new car but chose a petrol one, I’m just not ready to make the switch to electric at the moment.

snoopyfanaccountant · 18/03/2024 16:49

A friend had an old Leaf with poor range and had a very stressful drive from Fife to Glasgow when she couldn't find a working charger in Kirkcaldy or Dunfermline. She ended up in Edinburgh and still struggled. Her new Leaf broke down last week and the dealership (part of one of the biggest companies in the UK) can't look at it until sometime next month.

I replaced my car last autumn and stuck with petrol because I have a 40 mile round trip to work and there is no charging facility there or roundabout. We plan to replace DH's car later this year and we will look into an EV or hybrid but his mileage is so low that I don't think that the savings in fuel costs will be high enough to compensate for the increased cost of buying the car.

Swipe left for the next trending thread