Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DdraigGoch · 18/03/2024 19:49

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

Perhaps you could reference them, given that a couple of us have found lifecycle analyses that contradict your statement.

I'm not an EV supporter. As far as I'm concerned, they are there to fill in the edge cases that public transport (proper public transport, not the underfunded mess we have in the UK) and active travel (ditto) can't manage. Mass private car (of any type of propulsion) ownership and a sustainable future are mutually exclusive aims.

Onthegrid · 18/03/2024 19:45

Only read page 1, you have to love a typical mechanic mansplaining electric cars.
Yes, new ones are expensive, but they are cheap to run and service in general. Our family car has been electric for 5 years, and now I have switched my 10-year-old diesel for another ev.
We love them and have driven as far as London to Edinburgh and regularly do 200-mile round trip days.
We have on-the-drive charging and have been known to push down to the last 5% but only when we are heading home.
There is a good Facebook group Women Drive Electric UK

SqueezedMiddleTummy · 18/03/2024 19:44

MaloneMeadow · 18/03/2024 15:46

YANBU. We had one on a weekend long test drive and were very much put off. A car with a supposed 175 mile range dropped to 99 in the cold! Just not feasible for us, plus mad insurance and maintenance costs made it a no go. Alright if you’ve got a short city commute but not for anything else

Edited

Was it a new car? They take a while to “learn” the true range, my range went up significantly after I’d had it a couple of weeks with no change in weather or driving habits

Tryingtokeepgoing · 18/03/2024 19:44

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 19:24

But I can't morally support the mining in very poor countries by exploited people, purely so I can drive around in my wealthy and privileged country. For me, and this is my own moral line, it's unacceptable. Plus the environmental impact of end-of-life batteries is a major concern.

Though you are happy to consume oil derived products from countries with some of the worst human rights records in the world for their workers…?

In 2022:
14.7% of crude oil came from the US, where almost 1 in 100 of the population are in jail
13.2% came from Saudi Arabia, which is consistently ranked among the "worst of the worst" in Freedom House's annual survey of political and civil rights
12.7% came from Russia, know for its peaceful action in Eastern Europe
5.5% came from Iraq, which still has the death penalty

fortunately in between those is Canada, with 5.5% of world production.

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2024 19:40

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 17:09

not really, green only if you parse when you calculate. All research I've seen says if you consider cradle to grave, a Range Rover is more green. Even Elon Musk says that though they are not green enough ...yet, if we didn't get started we would never get to where they are. Research now says batteries made from soft shell crab and lobster shells are better than lithium. So green may happen though PETA may not like it.

Actually the figures I've seen from Prof. Mike Berners-Lee still put the BEV lifecycle emissions lower than those of ICVs. If I find that book I'll post the figures.

In the meantime, I've found some from the International Energy Agency: https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/comparative-life-cycle-greenhouse-gas-emissions-of-a-mid-size-bev-and-ice-vehicle

Again though, while BEVs are greener than ICVs, in absolute terms they are not "green", the only way to achieve that is to rely primarily on active travel for almost all journeys, with public transport for the occasional longer trip.

Comparative life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions of a mid-size BEV and ICE vehicle – Charts – Data & Statistics - IEA

Comparative life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions of a mid-size BEV and ICE vehicle - Chart and data by the International Energy Agency.

https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/charts/comparative-life-cycle-greenhouse-gas-emissions-of-a-mid-size-bev-and-ice-vehicle

SqueezedMiddleTummy · 18/03/2024 19:39

I love mine. I drive 50 miles round trip to work several times a week and every other weekend drive 150 miles. I trickle charge at home from a three point plug and at my long range destination also on a normal home plug. On my long 150 mile journey I usually stop for a 15 min top up or so on a super fast charger if I haven’t set off with a full charge which is about the time to takes to walk into the services and have a wee and buy a coffee so it doesn’t bother me at all. I know where the nearest fast chargers on the journey and have several options and would never let myself be in an unfamiliar place with barely any charge - best to top up earlier although only occasionally do I have issues with out of service chargers. One bug bear is on a busy day queuing system for electric chargers is not clear who is first in line (you just guess park opposite someone randomly and hope they haven’t just started their charge) which I think is deeply upsetting for English people although I rarely do have to queue. Electricity is cheaper than petrol overall but not hugely so however you can get cheap rates at certain times and if you trickle charge like me not use public (expensive) chargers you will save money. I’m on a forum for people with my electric car and the servicing seems super cheap but I do have a brand new car on lease.

I have an official range of 230 miles but that is significantly reduced in cold weather or if mainly motorway driving but I allow for it. I change my route to be more dual carriageway as that allows regenerative charging and also I prefer it to three hours of motorway! It’s just a different way of thinking. I love not having to go to the petrol station!

jannier · 18/03/2024 19:39

timetochangethering · 18/03/2024 19:18

@jannier unfortunately everything you have written is untrue....

So you think someone will buy your second hand car when it's due a replacement battery?
You don't believe a heavier car produces more rubber and carbon on breaking although they do need more frequent replacement tyres?
You don't think lithium batteries that when scrapped cause pollution in the countries they are shipped to, let alone the kids who mining it?
A Tesler battery costs around £8800 and would need replacing from 10 to 20 years ...would you buy a second hand 8 year old one knowing it may have 2 years of battery left?
Read up on early Nissan leaf car apps that run on 2g that can't be upgraded making many functions useless.
I guess you're so rich you don't need to buy second hand but many of us haven't even got £8000 for a car.

Woodworm2020 · 18/03/2024 19:38

Cocothecoconut · 18/03/2024 17:42

I wouldn’t touch one with a bargepole
i love my fiesta, yells at me when it needs juice 10 mins later I’ve got a tank full. Electric still needs to be produced from something , wind and solar are not truly reliable

LOL - where does the ‘juice’ you fill your car up with come from? Oh yes the finite resources that can’t be renewed. Good one!

SquirrelHash · 18/03/2024 19:37

Men at local garages will always put you off electric cars as they need virtually no maintenance.

I could never go back to an ICE vehicle. Thèrs a lot of bullshit out there about electrics.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 18/03/2024 19:35

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

Though many more studies show the reverse…

DancefloorAcrobatics · 18/03/2024 19:29

@timetochangethering Keep kidding yourself:

https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/06/1067272

The environmental impact is horrendous. Just because its not on our doorstep, doesn't mean we shouldn't care.
But a bit of greenwash is great for the economy.

I'm not entirely against electric cars. They have been a long time in the pipeline but technology isn't there along with the infrastructure.

UN highlights urgent need to tackle impact of likely electric car battery production boom

Demand for raw materials used in the production of electric car batteries is set to soar, prompting the UN trade body, UNCTAD, to call for the social and environmental impacts of the extraction of raw materials, which include human rights abuses, to be...

https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/06/1067272

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 19:24

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 18:00

EVs are more environmentally friendly the ICEs. You're mistaken.

Why do you think the batteries will be disposed of? (Clue = they won't)

But I can't morally support the mining in very poor countries by exploited people, purely so I can drive around in my wealthy and privileged country. For me, and this is my own moral line, it's unacceptable. Plus the environmental impact of end-of-life batteries is a major concern.

nimski · 18/03/2024 19:24

inkblackheart · 18/03/2024 15:45

Funny how the guys at your local garage (which presumably doesn’t service electric cars given their comments about how specialists are needed) think petrol and diesel cars are the way to go…

This! Hardly an unbiased opinion...
We have had one for several years, no problems. About to change our 2nd car (diesel) for a hybrid.

RM2013 · 18/03/2024 19:19

i personally wouldn’t but an electric car. Unfortunately we live in a terraced house and our garage is in a separate block but we aren’t allowed to run electricity in it so we couldn’t charge a car at home. No chargers at my work place so would be logistically tricky for us. I have a hybrid which I love. Friend who has an electric (company car) loves it though

timetochangethering · 18/03/2024 19:18

jannier · 18/03/2024 15:44

Depends if you don't mind lithium lakes and have looked at research into the increased pollution from tyre particles due to excessive waste.
The scrappage of cars that can't be sold because nobody wants to buy a second hand car with a battery that will need replacing at the cost of £000,s next year. Or the ones who run on 3g systems that will no longer work as 3g is scrapped.

@jannier unfortunately everything you have written is untrue....

timetochangethering · 18/03/2024 19:14

They are definitely much cheaper - I would estimate about £5 per 250 miles instead of more like £50.

They are definitely greener - a proper international study has proven it, they are a little less green to make than a petrol car but after about 18 months they overtake petrol and over a lifetime (10-15 years) it's about 1/3 of the pollution of a petrol vehicle.

Pretty much everything you hear in the press is complete bunkum, lithium mining, etc etc.

EV's catch fire 9 times LESS than petrol vehicles.... mile for mile.

They are easier to fix and less likely to go wrong, they are much simpler than petrol engines.

Oh, and the batteries are holding out well, you have Teslas now with 250k miles on them, all good and 2013 leaf's still going strong.

I have driven to the Alps and Scotland (from London) with no issues.

You have to do your research on range but they definitely don't run out of battery "unexpectedly".

I have been driving various EV's since 2015 and we are a total EV family from 2020.

PrincessTeaSet · 18/03/2024 19:04

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 17:12

..

That doesn't include the increased tyre and brake emissions. Not very realistic

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:40

Lovelyview · 18/03/2024 17:58

There's a useful series in the Guardian examining electric car myths and reality https://www.theguardian.com/business/series/ev-mythbusters. Basically they catch fire less than petrol/diesel, over the whole life cycle they produce lower carbon emissions and they do cost less to run if you can charge at home. We own an old Nissan Leaf and rent a Kia inero. Electric cars are fantastic to drive. Charging infrastructure is getting much better. There is less to go wrong with them so generally they are good for servicing/MOT costs. On the minus side if they do go wrong they can be expensive to fix and getting parts can be difficult and the cost to buy or lease one can make them too expensive. We wouldn't go back to petrol/diesel. You do have to decide if it suits your lifestyle as they won't suit everyone at the moment.

Carbon is just one part of environmental cost and not the most significant current one.

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 17:55

They definitely have lower environmental impact over the cradle to cradle lifecycle.

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

surew · 18/03/2024 18:31

Anyone choosing a new car needs to consider what they need from that car.

We chose a low range EV (older Leaf) for my short commute and local journeys. It fulfils the brief perfectly. I've done over 10,000 miles in it, only ever charged it on my own driveway and never run out of power.

1stWorldProblems · 18/03/2024 18:25

We purchased our BMW i3 (fully) electric car 9 years ago (2nd hand) as a second car for school runs & commuting. It has now done over 125,000 miles and the battery is as good as the day we got it - it's a very small battery in comparison with newer models (we get 80 miles in hot weather & about 55 miles in cold, dark weather) so we watch it carefully & regularly arrive home to our charger in the winter with 2-3 miles left.

It has very few moving parts so only needs servicing every 2 years (unlike a hybrid which has both the issues and weight of two engines) & the most we've ever paid for work on it is this year's service as we need a suspension strut replacing (£375 at our local garage incl the service.) Until April we haven't had to pay any car tax - this will rise to £20 pa next month. We (along with Tesla drivers) own our battery as well as the car, so have the option of recycling it as a power wall for home storage should it start to lose efficiency or we could assess the battery and replace any dodgy cells for about £3k each - still cheaper than a new car.

It's a blast to drive when you're not watching the miles and comfortable & economic if you are. And no matter the arguments regarding electric car production green issues vs conventional cars, when sitting in traffic I'm barely using any electricity to keep the car ticking over & not polluting the air around me.

There are a lot of dodgy older EV cars about but if you do your research & buy one with 60-100 mile battery then you'll pick up a cheap to buy & cheap to use 2nd car with enough mileage for your DH's commute and as a run about. Can't recommend my BMW I3 60ah with Rapid Charging.

OneMoreTime23 · 18/03/2024 18:12

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 17:55

They definitely have lower environmental impact over the cradle to cradle lifecycle.

Had one of my petrol cars for 19 years. Hope to get it past 30. Not sure your claim sticks in that scenario.

DottyPencil · 18/03/2024 18:11

Depends.
If you know hat you're getting into, it's OK.
Get as new a version as you can afford for longer range if that's important to you.
DP finds his company car an absolute pain in the arse. It takes ages to charge and barely covers his long commute. In winter, he has to switch the heating in it off some days to get home.
If we go anywhere for the day, I drive in my diesel. He has to always be thinking and planning ahead.
Don't be too put off though if you just want it for short journeys or you can get a newer one.

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 18:00

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 16:09

I'm changing my car and absolutely won't get an electric car for environmental reasons. The lifecycle impact of an electric car and battery is awful for pollution. Plus extra road damage as they're heavier. Plus they're lethal in car parks being so quiet, I've nearly been run over several times by an electric car I couldn't hear.

The impact of all the current electric car batteries needing to be disposed of in a few years will be shocking on the environment. The mining for the components is also terrible, but fine as long as it isn't anywhere geographically near us, right? 🙄

EVs are more environmentally friendly the ICEs. You're mistaken.

Why do you think the batteries will be disposed of? (Clue = they won't)

Lovelyview · 18/03/2024 17:58

There's a useful series in the Guardian examining electric car myths and reality https://www.theguardian.com/business/series/ev-mythbusters. Basically they catch fire less than petrol/diesel, over the whole life cycle they produce lower carbon emissions and they do cost less to run if you can charge at home. We own an old Nissan Leaf and rent a Kia inero. Electric cars are fantastic to drive. Charging infrastructure is getting much better. There is less to go wrong with them so generally they are good for servicing/MOT costs. On the minus side if they do go wrong they can be expensive to fix and getting parts can be difficult and the cost to buy or lease one can make them too expensive. We wouldn't go back to petrol/diesel. You do have to decide if it suits your lifestyle as they won't suit everyone at the moment.

EV mythbusters | Business | The Guardian

A series of articles that explores the myths, the realities and the grey areas surrounding electric vehicles

https://www.theguardian.com/business/series/ev-mythbusters

Swipe left for the next trending thread