Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
OneMoreTime23 · 19/03/2024 07:57

Daftasabroom · 19/03/2024 07:46

An electric car and an ICE reach parity for their environmental footprint after about 100,000 miles after that the EV wins.

She hasn’t done 100,000 miles yet……. (Highly specialist car.)

But if you consider that most people don’t keep cars this long, and would have had maybe 2, 3 or more cars in 19 years, I’m saving the production and disposal impact 2-3 times over.

Londonrach1 · 19/03/2024 07:55

My friend has one of the cheaper cars. We took an hour trip to my family. Had to leave her car charging in the park all day and it ran out of charge on way back. No way have electric car. The stress on the journey back was awful. I think maybe if you buy one of the expensive ones might be worth it as better range. They not good as you think environmental anyway and the risk of exploding...one exploded outside my mil house...it's a total no. Wait a few more years as think something else will appear...this might be the betamax to the VHS if you know what I mean....

Daftasabroom · 19/03/2024 07:53

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

Could you show me one please?

The Polestar 2 LCA is here https://www.polestar.com/dato-assets/11286/1630409045-polestarlcarapportprintkorr11210831.pdf

https://www.polestar.com/dato-assets/11286/1630409045-polestarlcarapportprintkorr11210831.pdf

Daftasabroom · 19/03/2024 07:46

OneMoreTime23 · 18/03/2024 18:12

Had one of my petrol cars for 19 years. Hope to get it past 30. Not sure your claim sticks in that scenario.

An electric car and an ICE reach parity for their environmental footprint after about 100,000 miles after that the EV wins.

OneMoreTime23 · 19/03/2024 07:05

grinandslothit · 19/03/2024 05:17

I finally got my first one a couple months ago it is a Genesis GV60 and I absolutely love it.

That was the only electric car I tried and liked driving, but the shape was all wrong resulting in a too-small boot. :-/

Randomsabreur · 19/03/2024 06:55

The biggest push for us to get an electric car was local tailpipe emissions - most kids' activities are about 8 miles away but as they're around the wheel rather than radial public transport is not possible - 20 minutes or 2 hours by train/bus.

Same for our commutes, but there's a lot of queueing traffic that the EV likes (get 5 miles per kWh) but is bad for the diesel's DPF.

We've done Glasgow to Glencoe and back without charging which is about the kids' limit for a day trip travel time anyway...

Would I go electric for an only car, probably not yet, but as a second "runaround" absolutely as slow runaround trips are generally the worst for engine wear and emissions in a diesel ICE

grinandslothit · 19/03/2024 05:17

I finally got my first one a couple months ago it is a Genesis GV60 and I absolutely love it.

jackstini · 19/03/2024 04:49

@NCForQuestions - I rarely go anywhere where I'd do over 240 miles in one journey; that's the only time I would need to charge away from home

That's quite a bit further than 'tootling' about though Smile
I keep it charged up all the time so never had any inconvenience

If you were doing a commute of over 100 miles each way daily, then I wouldn't recommend it (unless you can charge it at work)

Springincoming · 18/03/2024 22:29

With an EV octopus tariff you can charge for 2p a mile.There is absolutely no way petrol/diesel will cost that. Yes charging in public chargers can end up costing roughly the same as petrol/diesel prices but assuming you charge at home the bulk of the time it is significantly cheaper. That said, I'm not sure how much of an EV you can buy for 6k

DdraigGoch · 18/03/2024 22:27

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 18/03/2024 22:20

Electric cars are not in fact particularly environmentally friendly. Production creates a lot of bad effects that take several years to "pay off" Don't be misled by hype.

They're less unfriendly than ICE cars. Again, if you are determined to minimise your footprint you'll need to look for ways to not use cars of any description.

ItWasneaMe · 18/03/2024 22:24

I've had a hybrid for 3 years then a fully EV for 3 years (work does a good salary sacrifice scheme). Gave the EV back and am now driving a diesel.

Long journeys were horrible with chargers not available or not working. 45 mins to fully charge is just not acceptable on an already long trip. Driving in winter is ridiculous as the range dropped like a stone, just when you want the heating on. We had several stressful trips where we were virtually out of battery by the time we found a charger we could actually use. Even then you had to download yet another app to use it.

They were both joyous to drive, but with the 2nd hand market being virtually nonexistent, we didnt take up the option to keep the EV for longer. We will wait until the infrastructure improves and maybe try again in a few years time.

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 22:22

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 19:24

But I can't morally support the mining in very poor countries by exploited people, purely so I can drive around in my wealthy and privileged country. For me, and this is my own moral line, it's unacceptable. Plus the environmental impact of end-of-life batteries is a major concern.

Why do you think exploitation is any more severe with ICE propulsion compared to EV?

Fossil fuel production does unimaginable damage to the environment, to societies across the planet.

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 18/03/2024 22:20

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

Electric cars are not in fact particularly environmentally friendly. Production creates a lot of bad effects that take several years to "pay off" Don't be misled by hype.

Daftasabroom · 18/03/2024 22:13

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

Please show me because the ones I have seen have a beak even around 100,000 miles depending on the energy mix.

Waffleson · 18/03/2024 21:30

I love my EV! In the winter I charge it at night and we have a deal where the electric is much cheaper at night. In the summer I charge it from our solar panels. It'such cheaper to run than petrol.

There is much less to go wrong on an EV - no engine, no exhaust ... That makes it generally cheaper.

Yes the range is lower below zero degrees, that's just a fact, as the process in the battery slows down at low temperatures.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 18/03/2024 21:08

PrincessTeaSet · 18/03/2024 19:04

That doesn't include the increased tyre and brake emissions. Not very realistic

I use my brakes once per week tops. On ICE many times on every journey 🤷🏻

Lovelyview · 18/03/2024 20:43

PragmaticWench · 18/03/2024 19:24

But I can't morally support the mining in very poor countries by exploited people, purely so I can drive around in my wealthy and privileged country. For me, and this is my own moral line, it's unacceptable. Plus the environmental impact of end-of-life batteries is a major concern.

Every time you put petrol in your car you are supporting the extraction of oil which has terrible impacts on the direct environment https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/shell-niger-delta-oil-spills-sabotage-equipment-failure/ What comes out of your exhaust pipe causes deaths through small particulate emissions and finally the carbon emitted is causing climate change. Electricity for electric cars does create carbon emissions because the UKs energy mix contains Gas - 38.5% but it also comes from Wind - 26.8% Nuclear - 15.5% (figures from 2022 so should be getting lower carbon each year.)

BrondesburyBelle · 18/03/2024 20:06

Love our EV. Dh understands the costs better but we have an octopus EV tarriff (intelligent I think) which charges it for very little at night. I think about £5 for 250 miles range? So very little indeed. Servicing is v minimal as fewer bits need servicing. Insurance is higher than our last petrol car. You do need more range than you think you need. Ours is 64kwh and has been all over the UK with no problems. Obviously costs quite a bit more to charge at a service station but still less than the equivalent in petrol

Magnastorm · 18/03/2024 20:00

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 18:36

Actually no, electric car cradle is much worse than ICE cradle as many many studies have found.

Not true at all.

EV cars have a higher initial environmental cost to produce but over their lifespan they are significantly greener than ICE cars.

Every credible study you care to look at says the same.

timetochangethering · 18/03/2024 20:00

jannier · 18/03/2024 19:39

So you think someone will buy your second hand car when it's due a replacement battery?
You don't believe a heavier car produces more rubber and carbon on breaking although they do need more frequent replacement tyres?
You don't think lithium batteries that when scrapped cause pollution in the countries they are shipped to, let alone the kids who mining it?
A Tesler battery costs around £8800 and would need replacing from 10 to 20 years ...would you buy a second hand 8 year old one knowing it may have 2 years of battery left?
Read up on early Nissan leaf car apps that run on 2g that can't be upgraded making many functions useless.
I guess you're so rich you don't need to buy second hand but many of us haven't even got £8000 for a car.

  1. Most of them haven't used up their batteries yet with normal use - no sign they will be anything other than longer lasting than petrol. yes I've sold 2 second hand now.
  2. You may want to check the weight of a range rover, Land rover discovery, X 5, x3, ford smax, ford galaxy *(spoiler they all weigh more than the tesla.). They don't need more frequent tyre replacement - I run one and it's pretty much the same as petrol.
  3. The batteries won't be scrapped - they are already using them as electric storage. Also the lithium problem is more to do with laptops, phones, and other rechargeable products than cars.
  4. Tesla's are currently running with 250k miles plus on them, and look like they will have longer lives than petrol (they are simpler to repair and maintain)
  5. Nissan Leaf - I've owned two. Yes they are old tech, not least as they have the older Chademo connectors. I would still buy one.
  6. No, not rich, there are some great deals around if you look. I'm currently leasing on salary sacrifice, but my next one will be a second hand, older car. I would happily buy an older Leaf as a second car or a Zoe.
Pinkfluffypencilcase · 18/03/2024 19:58

Hereyoume · 18/03/2024 16:27

EV enthusiast here. Currently on my third Musk Mobile.

First thing? Please forget the absolute bollocks that an EV is "better for the environment", it isn't. The Carbon footprint of an EV is fucking enormous and none of them will last more than 10 years because nobody is going to pay 10k to replace the battery on an eight year old car. So all the current ones will last half as long as an ICE car. They are apparently designing ones with different batteries, supposedly cheaper, but those new batteries can't be retrofitted to existing EV's. If you like the idea of an EV, go for it, but don't kid yourself that you're saving the Polar Bears by driving one.

I am a tech head so that's why I drive one.

If you don't have a home charger then you won't save any money in "fuel" costs over a regular car, so there's that to think about.

Stated range is just a suggestion, in reality you will reliably get half the range, and maybe a bit more if you're light on the throttle and never carry passengers, luggage, use the heating, Air-Con, or drive against the wind.

Look up Zap Map or similar and map out the chargers in your area, it will help you to decide if an EV is viable without home charging. Most are free late at night so you could just time your charging then if that applies to you.

They are a different league to an ICE car to drive, torque is instant and can catch you out if you're not used to it, especially on wet roads. Braking is mostly just foot off and let the regeneration take over, so you don't really have to use your brake pedal often, almost never in town.

Tyres are EV specific and 30% more expensive than "ordinary" ones.

You will use the heated seats to warm you up, not the cabin heater, even the Tesla heater is a bit pants and the drain on the battery just isn't worth it.

I think they are so much fun to drive though, like being in your own Sci-Fi movie! My car feels like a space ship!

Insurance will be a killer though, MAHUSIVE premiums, so factor that in as well.

I was thinking if getting one to save in petrol commute.

Until I read that Nissan Leaf electric car app is no longer supported. The app controls the heating?!
That put me off.

travellinglighter · 18/03/2024 19:55

SOBplus · 18/03/2024 15:36

They aren't green when you consider cradle to grave. They are expensive unless a business buys them and can write them off. I have the Tesla as with 380 mile range it generally gets me where I want to be without hassle. I find I always have MORE range than it says, which has come in handy twice. Its free to charge at work so its a virtually free means for getting most places. I wouldn't buy the electric mini as it came with 100 mile range which would work only to and from work but not any weekend activities. They are an interesting toy but not going to save the planet or anything but it is economical if you can write it off and use low cost electricity.

Umm, three quarters of the co2 of a conventional car cradle to grave. When the battery is no longer efficient enough to run a car it can be taken out and used as part of a domestic solar set up and when it’s no longer efficient enough to be used in a house it is 97% recyclable. The lithium can be extracted and used to make more batteries. So what issues are you talking about?

DrNo007 · 18/03/2024 19:54

We have a plug-in hybrid so it uses electricity for short trips (which are 90% of our car usage) but for longer journeys when we don’t want to stop for hours to recharge, we can use the petrol engine. We charge it from our solar panels so no electricity cost (though of course there is the upfront cost of the panels). We love it and the first few years of servicing were included in the purchase price.

TheYoungestSibling · 18/03/2024 19:50

I'm in no hurry to change my car because the more environmentally responsible choice is to keep the existing vehicle rather than have a new one made.

That said, husband's EV is brilliant and we use it for most of our social / family life stuff as it is cheaper and greener. Servicing is simpler; less often and considerably fewer moving parts to worry about. No timing belts, spark plugs, oil filters, etc etc.

The batteries do experience some degradation. Ours is averaging about 1% loss a year.

If you can charge at home and are in the market to change your car, I would definitely consider electric.

SiriAlexa · 18/03/2024 19:50

I love my electric car! It’s fantastic for school runs and driving within around an hour or so from home. I don’t use it for longer trips. It’s so much easier charging it at home. It’s quiet and doesn’t pollute the air.

I have also heard anti EV stories and I think there a lot of misinformation about them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread