Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get an electric car?

158 replies

Jamesblema · 18/03/2024 15:23

I was keen to get one as our second car (small-ish run around mainly for DH to do his 25 min commute every week day - we have a larger family car).

My main reasons were the savings on running costs and the benefit to the environment. I figured we could spend 6-8k on the car and then we would save massively on petrol costs. However, taking to the men at our local garage has put me off- they said that electricity costs are almost as much as petrol and repairs on electric cars require specialist mechanics and can be massively more expensive especially when something goes wrong with the battery. They also said that the estimated remaining mileage is often more than you actually have left and you can easily run out of charge and need to stop for over an hour to charge up. The cost of buying a hybrid is putting me off that option too.

So aibu to keep my petrol car at the cost of the environment? Any positive electric car experiences?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
OneMoreTime23 · 21/03/2024 08:11

Orders76 · 20/03/2024 23:19

If it's a second runaround for his work, buy a tiny second hand 1litre diesel. Reuse etc.
Go vegetarian if worried about the environment.

Don’t buy a diesel for short runs (or long ones, actually.)

Bjorkdidit · 21/03/2024 04:42

Orders76 · 20/03/2024 23:19

If it's a second runaround for his work, buy a tiny second hand 1litre diesel. Reuse etc.
Go vegetarian if worried about the environment.

I assume you mean petrol, which is what I bought.

As for 'misinformation about electric cars' the factor that just about every advocate always fails to account for is the significant extra purchase price. Most people can't or won't just disregard an extra £10/20k in upfront costs which is what you're looking at when comparing like with like.

I worked out it would take about a decade to break even when comparing like for like, ie similar age car in petrol and electric, as the cost of the latter was more than double, so decided that it wasn't justified to me.

They might cost a lot less to run if you can charge at home or otherwise cheaply, eg at work but any time you have to pay commercial rates, which is more likely than with petrol/diesel because the range is so much lower then your cost per mile could easily be more than that for petrol,which puts you on the back foot if you need to justify the higher upfront cost with cheaper running costs.

Orders76 · 20/03/2024 23:19

If it's a second runaround for his work, buy a tiny second hand 1litre diesel. Reuse etc.
Go vegetarian if worried about the environment.

KERALA1 · 20/03/2024 23:17

Keen to stop feeling guilty about driving a polluting diesel car round our ancient small city that is in a dip and has poor air quality.

Telekoma · 20/03/2024 23:16

No thanks. I don't want to plan my journeys around recharging.

Jamesblema · 20/03/2024 23:14

OneMoreTime23 · 19/03/2024 22:45

we should just be avoiding private cars whenever we can, through walking, cycling, public transport or taxis.

This just isn’t practical in large parts of the country. I have to commute to London 3-4 weeks a month. Despite living about 20 miles from Cardiff I’m in a public transport black spot. Have to drive to the bus or train. And then getting back late at night as a lone female I want to get off the London train and into my car, not onto a train (provided it’s not cancelled) which still leaves me 4 miles from home.

Also I just went to book a train for me and my DD. A 4hr 30 min drive is going to take an hour longer, including 2 changes and triple the cost if I go by train. A bus might be cheaper but would take 9 hours. No way am I going to do either of those.

OP posts:
Jamesblema · 20/03/2024 23:10

mafsfan · 19/03/2024 16:51

It's absolutely not conclusive Hmm

Plenty of people who actually own EVs have said overwhelmingly positive things. There has also been a lot of misinformation posted - as there always is with EVs.

It is conclusive for me. Not conclusive for everyone.

OP posts:
Jamesblema · 20/03/2024 23:09

GasPanic · 19/03/2024 16:58

My guess is you will believe what you want to believe.

The maths might tell a different story though.

And as with all of these sorts of things, you need quite a lot of detail in order to establish whether or not electric cars are a good purchase - detail for whatever reason people are often unwilling to provide.

What do you mean detail people are unwilling to provide? 😂

OP posts:
OneMoreTime23 · 19/03/2024 22:45

we should just be avoiding private cars whenever we can, through walking, cycling, public transport or taxis.

This just isn’t practical in large parts of the country. I have to commute to London 3-4 weeks a month. Despite living about 20 miles from Cardiff I’m in a public transport black spot. Have to drive to the bus or train. And then getting back late at night as a lone female I want to get off the London train and into my car, not onto a train (provided it’s not cancelled) which still leaves me 4 miles from home.

Newbalancebeam · 19/03/2024 17:16

Got one of each. Love driving the electric and great to charge at home. Cheap to run too. BUT range anxiety is real, charging in some parts of the country is a joke and for longer journeys on unknown roads, I’d rather take the petrol car. Which rather makes a mockery of the cheaper to run electric car if I don’t use it on long journeys…

loubd · 19/03/2024 17:06

yep, we will see

Daftasabroom · 19/03/2024 17:04

loubd · 19/03/2024 17:01

good decision op.
We recently changed our car and had a good budget for a new one.
We spent weeks researching EVs but all the conversations and internet searches pointed towards not going EV.
I think a better technology is around the corner. I suspect EVs are the new Betamax.

There really aren't any better technologies round the corner. EVs are the future for personal everyday domestic transport.

loubd · 19/03/2024 17:01

good decision op.
We recently changed our car and had a good budget for a new one.
We spent weeks researching EVs but all the conversations and internet searches pointed towards not going EV.
I think a better technology is around the corner. I suspect EVs are the new Betamax.

GasPanic · 19/03/2024 17:00

Fifthtimelucky · 19/03/2024 10:44

I recently bought a new (to me) car. I would have liked an electric but it is our only car and I worried about charging it on long journeys.

I went for a plug in hybrid instead. Best of both worlds in my view. All my local motoring is electric and very cheap (we have solar panels and our own charger) and on long journeys I have the security of being able to stop at a petrol station.

I have a plug in hybrid. It works well for me. A bit too well in the respect I don't use much petrol with it at all.

I am worried though about not running the engine. It only gets fired up once every couple of weeks. Which is not great as engines really do need to be run.

GasPanic · 19/03/2024 16:58

Jamesblema · 19/03/2024 11:32

Thanks all! Seems conclusive that buying a cheaper end electric car would be a disaster. I’ll hold off until my current car packs in and then look at how much money I have for a hybrid

My guess is you will believe what you want to believe.

The maths might tell a different story though.

And as with all of these sorts of things, you need quite a lot of detail in order to establish whether or not electric cars are a good purchase - detail for whatever reason people are often unwilling to provide.

mafsfan · 19/03/2024 16:51

Jamesblema · 19/03/2024 11:32

Thanks all! Seems conclusive that buying a cheaper end electric car would be a disaster. I’ll hold off until my current car packs in and then look at how much money I have for a hybrid

It's absolutely not conclusive Hmm

Plenty of people who actually own EVs have said overwhelmingly positive things. There has also been a lot of misinformation posted - as there always is with EVs.

Jamesblema · 19/03/2024 11:32

Thanks all! Seems conclusive that buying a cheaper end electric car would be a disaster. I’ll hold off until my current car packs in and then look at how much money I have for a hybrid

OP posts:
iwafs · 19/03/2024 10:50

My brother's EV gives him anxiety about the charge situation

personally, if you are are spending 6-8k, I'd go with a petrol car that can get fixed easily by someone local wtih readily available parts if there are problems. id worry that spending that little on an EV means that you are going to get a shit EV. But you can get a decent petrol for the money.

Fifthtimelucky · 19/03/2024 10:44

I recently bought a new (to me) car. I would have liked an electric but it is our only car and I worried about charging it on long journeys.

I went for a plug in hybrid instead. Best of both worlds in my view. All my local motoring is electric and very cheap (we have solar panels and our own charger) and on long journeys I have the security of being able to stop at a petrol station.

AdobeWanKenobi · 19/03/2024 09:32

The angst on here over EVs is always good for a laugh.

if it suits your lifestyle, have one.
if it doesn’t, don’t.

that simple. Bit like having kids really 😂

Fairyliz · 19/03/2024 09:18

I was on the motorway last week and there was mile after mile of flashing messages saying no ev charging at service stations. I’m not sure what had gone wrong.
We then spent an hour in a traffic jam caused by a car running out of electricity in the middle lane.
It really put me off, if this is a regular occurrence what happens if you are going a long way?

Hoppinggreen · 19/03/2024 09:13

Absolutely, I would never recommend one to anyone who cant charge at home

magicmole · 19/03/2024 09:03

It seems that many of the people who love their EVs are able to charge at home. It makes sense. Checking on zap map all the charging points within 15 miles of me cost at least 80p/kWh. There is one that's "only" 55p but it's restricted to customers of a business. Meanwhile the overnight EV tariff with my energy supplier is 7p/kWh!

New cars are carbon intensive to build - all that steel and plastic - whether they're ICE or EV. And batteries are particularly carbon intensive to make so nearly half of the embedded/embodied carbon in the life of an EV is produced before it's even left the factory. And lithium mining is a real issue (although hopefully less environmentally damaging sodium batteries may be on the way).

I was a Green Party member until recently. They do promote zero emission vehicles like battery EVs but many diehard environmentalists say that rather than worry about EV vs ICE we should just be avoiding private cars whenever we can, through walking, cycling, public transport or taxis. A petrol moped is a better option in the transport "hierarchy" than an electric car!

But when this isn't practical - like an unavoidable daily commute which has to be by car - then the "Green" recommendation is sometimes to get the smallest/lightest car for your needs, buy it second hand (but not a banger), use it as little as you can and keep it for as long as it's reasonably efficient rather than changing for new every few years. So for some a second hand EV might fit the bill but then so might a small-engined ICE car.

If our next car ends up being an ICE car we'll keep it for a decade, use it as little as possible and not feel guilty. But then we don't live in an urban area, don't have to commute and don't have access to charging at home.... everyone's situation is different.

Daftasabroom · 19/03/2024 08:30

@SOBplus the link you supports everybody else's view not yours.

SOBplus · 19/03/2024 08:15

Last post on this as you can't force people to see reality.
Electric vehicles are less carbon polluting - yup; electric vehicles are a step in the right direction - yup; but not green considering cradle to grave - every study posted in this thread ONLY talks about carbon and brushes over the rest of the environmental concerns. Even Elon Musk says that EVs needed to get started so there would be investment to one day make them green which is what is happening. Deforestation, habitat destruction and water pollution further exacerbate the ecological toll. The delicate balance of nature is disrupted, which leaves long-lasting damage that takes generations to heal. The carbon dioxide and other greenhouse emissions that come with the process of lithium mining, extraction and overall production are worse for the climate than the production of fossil fuel-powered vehicles. A study from The Wall Street Journal in 2019 revealed that 40% of the total climate impact caused by the production of lithium-ion batteries comes from the mining process itself. And so on!

What is the environmental impact of lithium batteries?

https://changeit.app/blog/2021-03-26-environmental-impact-of-lithium-batteries/