Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this is a prime example of the entitlement from some people in this country?

303 replies

MealDeal1 · 18/03/2024 13:31

Someone on a large FB group that I am on posted yesterday to say that they want to move abroad and gave examples of a couple of countries that they want to go to.

They then said that they live in council housing here so would need to be 'housed' over there and how do they go about getting housed?

Basically they wanted to move abroad and get given that country's equivalent of a council house/social housing on arrival.

AIBU to think this is the absolute height of entitlement?

OP posts:
LauderSyme · 18/03/2024 16:00

Social housing is definitely subsidised. I worked for Local Authorities for years, including collecting rent payments for some of those years. Councils don't charge full market rent or anything like it. They usually charge about half of the Local Housing Allowance, which is the maximum Housing Benefit that private tenants can get.

For example, three years ago in my local area, a three bedroom council house was approx £110 per week. A similar house rented privately at that time was approx £250 per week.

The rents collected cover the costs that the Council incurs by being a landlord so it's not that Council Tax payers are subsidising tenants. But Councils don't seek to make any profit like private asset holders do.

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 18/03/2024 16:00

The thread was started as a goad. Another thread to pick on people by assumptions

Kendodd · 18/03/2024 15:59

Bumpitybumper · 18/03/2024 15:32

You seem to be writing your own narrative here with blatant lies.

A third of households that privately rent claim housing benefit whilst two thirds of those that rent social housing claim. The rent that private renters pay is often taxed as income for those landlords in a way that social housing rent isn't. Social housing is expensive for the country and this is why it is a limited resource. If it genuinely paid its way in all regards then there would be a lot more of it around.

Mortgages have never been subsidised by the government. Mortgage holders benefited for many years from low interest rates in the same way that anyone that took out credit has. Now interest rates are higher they are not being penalised by the government either but simply paying the 'going rate'.

What does taxation of corporation's or rich people have to do with whether social housing is subsidised or not? Why does this have to be mentioned on every thread about someone not paying their way? It's such a lazy argument that nobody has to worry about paying their way unless everybody else is doing this. I wonder if you would teach your children this moral when taking about other aspects of life.

With regard two thirds of people in council/social housing claiming HB. The age profile would be older, so fewer people working than in private rented. Do you really think it would be cheaper for the state if all those people rented privately? HB to council tenants is essentially just a 'money-go-round' from the council to the council. None of it makes its way into private hands.
The reason we don't have more council housing is ideology, and it's costing us all a fortune, we really do need a massive councilhouse building programme similarto post war. And I say this as a private landlord myself, so I suppose you could say, it's not costing me a fortune, I'm making money out of it.

Kinsella1 · 18/03/2024 15:58

Basically they wanted to move abroad and get given that country's equivalent of a council house/social housing on arrival.

AIBU to think this is the absolute height of entitlement?

Well this is goady as fuck considering plople that move to the UK are entitled to exactly what UK people are.

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 18/03/2024 15:58

ntmdino · 18/03/2024 15:46

And yet, it's still not a subsidy.

Yes it is. Mortgages and other dearer loans were subsidised by cheap interest rates. Unless you don’t know what subsidised means?

crockofshite · 18/03/2024 15:58

Redannie118 · 18/03/2024 13:50

It's ironic that entitlement only applies to working classes and not all the previous posters who assume you get handed a council house with a pot of gold and a goat. You need to pay rent. If the person who asked about moving countries was in standard rental property, would you have the same reaction?

...... A pot of gold and a goat....
🤣🤣🤣..

Dearg · 18/03/2024 15:55

Bumpitybumper · 18/03/2024 15:51

Yep I am too young to remember this as it looks like it was abolished 25 years ago and it was being effectively phased out before then. It certainly isn't relevant to anyone of my generation.

I am 62 and too young to have qualified for MIRAS!

Bumpitybumper · 18/03/2024 15:54

Alargeoneplease89 · 18/03/2024 15:49

How is social housing subsidised? I cant understand that.
Maybe they are confused and think that, because we house others from other countries that it is the same for other places? Though the circumstances for housing is very different. I.e. escaping war (though passing several safe countries 😇)

Because the government funds a proportion of the costs associated with social housing, especially when the housing is built. This can be done directly through providing funding, giving land for development or through schemes like forcing housing developers to build some social housing for free as a condition of ascertaining planning permission on a site. Obviously the developer will have to recuperate these costs when selling the other houses on the development.

The subsidy is the reason why building more social housing is difficult.

Treeper22 · 18/03/2024 15:54

JenniferBooth · 18/03/2024 14:49

@Treeper22 Its why i didnt swallow the "all in this together" narrative during Covid and acted accordingly because i knew it would be back to the default setting...........and here we are

Yep and I despair that there are human beings who swallow this narrative without living it.

Speaking of covid, housing benefit got the biggest single boost in years (decades?) at that time due to the government realising that the 'deserving poor' would have nowhere near enough to cover their rent with the previous abysmally low rate. Not that it covered rents after but it was a very telling move.....

I even saw people on here saying that those having to claim benefits due to covid 'weren't the usual benefit claimants'. It actually highlighted people's/government's callousness rather than promote the blitz spirit.

Bumpitybumper · 18/03/2024 15:51

JenniferBooth · 18/03/2024 15:44

@Bumpitybumper You too young to remember MIRAS then

Yep I am too young to remember this as it looks like it was abolished 25 years ago and it was being effectively phased out before then. It certainly isn't relevant to anyone of my generation.

Alargeoneplease89 · 18/03/2024 15:49

MealDeal1 · 18/03/2024 15:17

And yes I agree with those that say social housing is subsidised

How is social housing subsidised? I cant understand that.
Maybe they are confused and think that, because we house others from other countries that it is the same for other places? Though the circumstances for housing is very different. I.e. escaping war (though passing several safe countries 😇)

LauderSyme · 18/03/2024 15:49

Wow, that's clueless. They're liable to come down to earth with a bump!

Despite the Conservative's best efforts, the social safety net in this country is still way better than in many other places.

Kendodd · 18/03/2024 15:48

JenniferBooth · 18/03/2024 15:44

@Bumpitybumper You too young to remember MIRAS then

MIRAS went years ago!

Kendodd · 18/03/2024 15:47

ThisOldThang · 18/03/2024 15:37

If somebody is living in a Council House and the government pays their rent directly to the council, then it is free.

I appreciate that this doesn't apply to all Council House tenants, but getting the hump and claiming 'Council Houses aren't free' simply isn't true for a very large number of tenants.

So that means everyone in receipt of full housing benefit, either private rented or council/HA is getting a free house? I would argue that actually, the only person getting a free house is the landlord of the privately rented place.

ntmdino · 18/03/2024 15:46

DaBlackCatsAreDaBestCats · 18/03/2024 15:27

The Bank of England kept the interest rates artificially low. I’m not talking about other bills etc

And yet, it's still not a subsidy.

JenniferBooth · 18/03/2024 15:44

@Bumpitybumper You too young to remember MIRAS then

vodkaredbullgirl · 18/03/2024 15:44

No right to buy, where I live.

IhateSPSS · 18/03/2024 15:43

What responses did they get on the FB post? I bet it went down well Grin

funinthesun19 · 18/03/2024 15:43

It’s a very extreme example you’ve posted OP and I think you’re really silly if you think this is a common thought that some council tenants have.

You’re obviously annoyed by it though despite knowing deep down this is probably a one off event, so do you just have a gripe against council tenants in general and this is a good excuse to have a go?

JMSA · 18/03/2024 15:43

That is actually embarrassing. YANBU.

Locutus2000 · 18/03/2024 15:41

ntmdino · 18/03/2024 14:31

Well, it depends how you define "subsidised".

Around here, rent on the average 3-bed council house with two gardens and a substantial driveway is around £400/month. A similar house (read: identical, it's an ex-council house that's outside the 10 year post-purchase agreement), privately rented, is around £850-900/month.

Might not be directly subsidised, but it's heavily discounted. On top of that, there's the Right to Buy, which effectively works out as "most of what you pay in rent will go to a discount on the property if you decide to buy".

On top of that, there's the Right to Buy, which effectively works out as "most of what you pay in rent will go to a discount on the property if you decide to buy"

The number of tenants still in true 'council' housing is very limited and the only ones eligible for a substantial discount depending on the area.

Most 'social housing' tenants rent from Housing Associations and the discounts under 'right to acquire' are far, far smaller if available at all.

JenniferBooth · 18/03/2024 15:41

ntmdino · 18/03/2024 15:23

That's daft, and not how the banking system works. There was no subsidy, prices were just low because they were linked to interest rates (which is linked to many things, but not subsidisation).

Unless, of course, you think that everybody's food and utility bills were also being subsidised, since prices were low there too.

MIRAS anyone???!!!

x2boys · 18/03/2024 15:41

Similarly those who have their private rent paid by housing benefit are also getting a "Free " house.

Maverickess · 18/03/2024 15:40

Bumpitybumper · 18/03/2024 15:16

There is a difference between paying your way and something being free. Paying your way implies that you are covering all costs associated with the housing your are living in.

A thread earlier this week proved that social housing is indeed subsidised. The operating costs may often be covered by the rent charged but the state often helps with the capital needed to build the properties. Considering most people with a mortgage know all too well about the cost of capital when they pay the interest each month, it's fair to say that social housing is heavily subsidised and anyone living it isn't quite 'paying their way'.

Indeed, there is a difference, I don't suppose though, that there's an appetite for people using the services and industries they want and need that have traditionally low wages to pay their way by increased taxes and prices so that everyone working in them can afford not to live in social housing and be 'heavily subsidised'? Or just not use them because everyone working in them should just pop off and get a better paying job?

We're going to pay the proper cost for these services, be it private or state, and the people needed to work in them one way or the other really. If it's lower point of use price, that impacts on what they are paid and then they need a subsidy of some description to still be available to work in those services and industries and not living under a bridge somewhere.

What takes the absolute piss is that there's many an industry or service that does charge a higher price point at point of use, and doesn't pay enough for someone working in it to not need subsidy in some form, and pockets the difference.

I've not noticed that the people claiming to be the ones doing the subsidising being reluctant to use the services provided by the people working in them and earning low incomes that mean they need the subsidy. But they do seem to enjoy disapproving of the people in those low income jobs and telling them how entitled they are.

Some people support society by the subsidies they pay, others by the work they do, that's how it works. Only the financial contribution is an esteemed and lofty position and the work, well you're worth very little according to many.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/03/2024 15:40

KreedKafer · 18/03/2024 13:55

I think it's a prime example of someone who is just really fucking thick.

Agreed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread