Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Four children 1-14 years sharing room

331 replies

Parques · 18/03/2024 12:39

AIBU to think it's ridiculous and irresponsible that 4 children (same sex - male) aged from 1-14 are sharing a bedroom? There is a fifth child - a girl - who has her own room. There are no funds to extend/loft conversion etc. The children were all planned. No multiple births.

OP posts:
MonsteraMama · 18/03/2024 14:21

I grew up with six siblings, we had all sorts of bizarre sleeping arrangements including all seven of us in one room at one point.

We all survived! It's not ideal but there are worse things.

MsPloddingBottom · 18/03/2024 14:20

GivingOutYards · 18/03/2024 13:17

My self and my husband grew up like this, it was fine!

60 years ago people didn't have showers, maybe it was fine when everyone was the same, but it's not 'fine' now. Like, at all.

Hereyoume · 18/03/2024 14:19

Probably half this country grew up in similar circumstances OP.

BubziOwl · 18/03/2024 14:17

Needmorelego · 18/03/2024 13:20

I don't quite get this "space to study" argument.
I did my homework either sat at the kitchen table or sat on my bed. How much space do you need?

Yes, not really relevant to this OP but I'm a bit baffled by this when I see it on mumsnet too. We all had our own bedrooms growing up but none of us had desks. Homework and studying was done at the kitchen table.

Thinking back to all my friends' bedrooms, ranging from very working class to very middle class, no one had desks in their bedrooms.

But yes four children in one room does sound less than ideal.

drspouse · 18/03/2024 14:15

This does seem hard on the teenager!
Unless I've skimmed too fast we don't have the other children's ages but if the girl is under 10 she can share with any other under 10s and indeed she can definitely share with the baby once he's 2 (could be with parents now) until the oldest leaves home - though if she's 13 this is also way less than ideal for her.
Is there an option for the two oldest boys to have a bedroom downstairs till the oldest leaves home?

Greenbike · 18/03/2024 14:15

As others have said, it’s not ideal, but used to be the norm not that long ago. I wouldn’t call it neglect. Could be a blended family, unexpected twins, contraception failure. Maybe they have religious reasons for not believing in abortion or even contraception. If you’re an observant Catholic or Orthodox Jewish this is normal. No point in judging.

Are your DC friends with theirs? If so can you help by inviting the siblings who are friends with your DC round for dinner? Maybe suggest they come round every week to do some homework in a quiet room with your DC?

x2boys · 18/03/2024 14:11

It's far from ideal but the five children are here now 🤷

BlueEyesBrownHair · 18/03/2024 14:10

Growing up, i shared a room with four of us girls (80s) we lived in a 3 bed house. 3 boys in the other room and mum and dad in the other room. Its all they could afford to buy.

RampantIvy · 18/03/2024 14:10

I shared a bedroom growing up and hated it. All those justifying the parents' unreasonable choice to have so many children - just why?

Things have changed since we were children. The pressures to do well at school and pass GCSEs and A levels have increased so much. I can't imagine trying to do GCSE revision and homework when you have loads of younger siblings running riot.

And before anyone says "just go to the library" not everyone lives near a library or near one that is open beyond 5pm. Our libraries don't open every day either.

I realise that how many children other people choose to have is none of my business, but do I judge people who have large families without any thought about the logistics? Hell yes.

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 14:08

Well, as it seems extraordinarily common on Mumsnet to get pregnant by accident, I'm not sure what anyone could do about it.....

Emptyheadlock · 18/03/2024 14:07

I grew up in similar circumstances.

I despised it and moved out as soon as possible.

RedToothBrush · 18/03/2024 14:07

Heronwatcher · 18/03/2024 13:37

I cannot get my head around the fact the couple decided to have 5 children in a totally inadequate environment.

Obviously!

But is this really the worst thing a parent can do to their child? Think about

  • parents who work all the hours god sends with kids in after school clubs every day;
  • parents who send kids to boarding school;
  • parents who can’t afford a house at all and end up with black mould, in temporary accommodation or being moved every 6 months to a different school.

Some of these are choices which parents make thinking they are best for their kids but other parents disagree.

Then you have parents who get ill unexpectedly or a manageable condition gets worse and the kids become carers.

Then there are parents who drink, take drugs, drive dangerously or have mental health problems which they can’t/ won’t get treated.

Personally I think that the 4 kids sharing a room might be better off than many of the above.

I think my issue with any of this logic is that, as house prices increase, are people saying that only people who are affluent enough, should even consider having children?

The issue that children NEED to have their own rooms or NEED space to study / have friends around / need to have x amount of extra curricular activities or some how they are being neglected is one that I don't get.

It's not ideal but I think it's better than a lot of other scenarios including ones where parents can afford those things but emotionally aren't available because they are perhaps too busy with work.

This is about what parents choose to prioritise, NOT about what the children NEED.

Children NEED food, shelter, school needs met and a loving and supportive family.

None of these things are materialistic.

I think it says a lot that there are many on this thread who ONLY see value in those materialistic things.

There's definitely a marked decline in birth rates because of this though and that will have long term social consequences too.

WhingeInTheWillows · 18/03/2024 14:06

I was one of four children. Three bed house, one boy in his own room and three girls sharing. I absolutely hated it, no privacy, no room. My parents didn’t have enough money to move because they had so many kids to support. Absolutely irresponsible. I decided I’d never do that to my own children.

GhostFaen · 18/03/2024 14:05

I’m surprised the baby isn’t still with the parents. If they sleep through then it’s no trouble to have them with you, but if they don’t then it’s really not fair on the other children.
What are the middle two ages OP?

Our 3yo has just gone into her own room from sharing with us. Eldest (16) has his own room and middle two (10&12) share. There was definite guilt knowing that we were having another child at the same time as adding an extra bedroom, despite the closeness in age but we do have two sitting rooms and are planning either a loft conversion or garden office (the latter being much cheaper) for as they grow up.

Without that second sitting room (done at the same time as bedroom addition) it wasn’t an option to have our youngest.

I always wanted a big family, but you have to have your existing children’s best interests first and foremost. My youngest is my partner’s only and I’m glad we could make it work bit if it would have impeded the others at all we would have done it. Are they a blended family?

Rosesanddaisies1 · 18/03/2024 14:01

I think the 14 year old needs privacy. And the kids are only going to get bigger. Irresponsible to have that many kids if you can't give them adequate space - it's very easy to avoid pregnancy.

Kalevala · 18/03/2024 14:00

I'd have the toddler in the parents' room and maybe a boy with the girl if they are both under 10. Depends on the size of the third bedroom though, could be a boxroom. The eldest ought to have his own room by 16.

Applescruffle · 18/03/2024 13:59

Persumably they are happy with the arrangement since they planned it and are living with it, so I really don't see the problem.

I also don't really see how we are supposed to have much opinion on people we don't know, children who's personalities/wants/individual needs we have no idea of, and a house none of us have seen. The room could be the size of a ballroom for all we know.

SallyWD · 18/03/2024 13:59

I know a family like this. Yes they're poor but they're a very loving family. I did feel sorry for the boys sharing a room as teenagers. I think they were desperate for their own space and privacy.

Kalevala · 18/03/2024 13:56

Parques · 18/03/2024 13:20

No separate space to study. One bed, one bunk bed and 18 month old in a cot. No further space!

If the younger children play in the sitting room for a period so the eldest can study in the bedroom, or vice versa I mean. Just a quiet space.

hirovian · 18/03/2024 13:54

That's a lot to share in a small house. I don't think it's ideal but it's workable. I'm an ex boarder and shared a room with three others, so the idea doesn't phase me at all. I also had to share a room with my sister for some years even at the point where we had three spare bedrooms.

Needmorelego · 18/03/2024 13:48

@RampantIvy the little children can play in the living room if their older siblings are doing homework in the bedroom (or vice versa with the homework being done downstairs and playing upstairs).
Not that complicated.

Growlybear83 · 18/03/2024 13:45

It's not ideal, but I really don't see a problem if they children are the same sex. my mum was one of five (four girls and one boy) who shared a room, and a bed, as a child because there were only two bedrooms. I saw her childhood home, and it was tiny, but they were a very very happy family.

TotoroElla · 18/03/2024 13:42

How old is the girl?

Is her room tiny so can't fit any more beds? As I find it strange they are strictly segregated by sex even though the youngest is only 1. Mine were still sleeping in bed with me at that age anyway!

My DS and DD shared until DS was 14. They were offered separate rooms when DS was 12 but wanted to stay sharing.

Dweetfidilove · 18/03/2024 13:39

Heronwatcher · 18/03/2024 13:37

I cannot get my head around the fact the couple decided to have 5 children in a totally inadequate environment.

Obviously!

But is this really the worst thing a parent can do to their child? Think about

  • parents who work all the hours god sends with kids in after school clubs every day;
  • parents who send kids to boarding school;
  • parents who can’t afford a house at all and end up with black mould, in temporary accommodation or being moved every 6 months to a different school.

Some of these are choices which parents make thinking they are best for their kids but other parents disagree.

Then you have parents who get ill unexpectedly or a manageable condition gets worse and the kids become carers.

Then there are parents who drink, take drugs, drive dangerously or have mental health problems which they can’t/ won’t get treated.

Personally I think that the 4 kids sharing a room might be better off than many of the above.

Agree.

Dweetfidilove · 18/03/2024 13:38

It is not ideal, but also not irresponsible and ridiculous.

Many people grew up like this and the way things are going, many will again. Needing your own bedroom is a relatively new thing.

Are the children’s NEEDS being satisfied? Are they loved and feel safe in their environment? Is the room tidy or does it look like a war zone due to lack of space? Is there a dining area where the teenager can do his homework/study? What’s the relationship like among the children? These are far more important factors than separate rooms.

Swipe left for the next trending thread