Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not letting my son go on holiday abroad with his best friend and his family?

482 replies

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 11:28

My son (turning 15 in the summer) and this boy have been best friends for almost a year now. I'm talking two peas in a pod best friends. They're in the same school, but the bestie is 2 years older. They hang out and chat every single day. In my opinion, they have a bit of a weird dynamic because my son sees / treats him like a mentor, and the best friend is the one who takes the lead; but that's beside the point.

The best friend is rich. He's going with his family to the Seychelles (2 weeks) for Easter. Surprisingly, he invited my son (who thought he was just joking at first). Either way, the boy's parents contacted me and we met up to talk. They basically told me that they'll pay for everything (accommodation, flights, food, activities, souvenirs, etc.), and they'd love to have my son come along with them. They said that I don't have to worry about safety and such because the boys are well behaved, and they're eagle-eyed. I said I need some time to think it though.

My husband thinks it's a great opportunity since we obviously couldn't afford such a trip, plus the family has a great reputation. I'm not so sure though. Firstly, I feel uncomfortable at the thought of my son becoming a charity case. Secondly, the Seychelles is very far away, and my son has never travelled that far before. My son is very upset with the no answer, and my husband also believes I'm being unreasonable and weird about this.

I still have some time to change my mind though. I do have some doubts about my decision honestly.

OP posts:
Definitelylivedin · 18/03/2024 12:27

Let him go. We take a friend of Dad's on holiday with us. Nothing to do with charity, she just doesn't want to hang out with us all the time. As long as you trust the family let him go.

As an aside, it is worth writing a letter to say that the other family are responsible for him just in case of accident etc.

TotoroElla · 18/03/2024 12:26

Let him go! He's not a charity case. Have you never treated your DS's friends to anything? Taken them to the cinema, got them a takeaway pizza? It's the same thing.

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 12:26

Sweetheart7 · 18/03/2024 12:18

You are doing the right thing to think about this OP. Do you know the boys parents? You say both boys have been best friends for 1 year and attend the same school. What about prior how friendly were they?

It's no doubt a good opportunity but I don't believe in just accepting anything just because someone has offered you!.

I'm not sure what I would do it would depend if I knew the parents. 2 weeks is a long water. Water can be dangerous also... you just don't know. On the other hand it would be a shame for DS to miss out!

I do. Met them a few times, they seem like nice, respectable people. They didn't know each other prior to that, only in passing. They were not running in the same circles. They met in an East Asian lit club, and bonded over common hobbies / interests.

OP posts:
Platedshoes · 18/03/2024 12:25

This is interesting because I don't think the OPs reasons for nit wanting him to go matter at all, if that was all, I'd definitely say yes.

However, a confident, socially accomplished 17yo wanting to take a 15 yo, who has issues the older teen supports with, on holiday does ring some alarms for me.

rookiemere · 18/03/2024 12:25

We have an only and it was much easier to bring a pal along for DS than going just the three of us.

You could reciprocate in kind so if you go on UK holiday invite their DS along. At that age Whitby is just as exciting as the Seychelles.

The only thing I'd say is from never going away with them a two week holiday is quite a big leap.

ecoeva · 18/03/2024 12:25

If the 17 year-old friend is quite 'socially accomplished' (as you describe it), you might think he'd have a friend in his own year to invite?

The age gap at that age is unusual OP. Fair enough if they were neighbours or family friends who had grown up together. But I've never come across this within a school.

NotGoingToLie · 18/03/2024 12:24

Are they two years apart school wise? I can’t quite figure out the friendship here. I’d be saying no to the holiday and encouraging your DS to explore other friendships.

RandomMess · 18/03/2024 12:24

Are you sure they aren't in a relationship?

Or want to be in a relationship or one of them wants it to be a relationship?

Nevermind31 · 18/03/2024 12:24

My parents always took a friend for my brother once I wasn’t going on holiday with them anymore (brother is much younger). It meant my brother had a much better time, and by extension, my parents too.
why wouldn’t you let your son experience what might be the trip of a lifetime?

KreedKafer · 18/03/2024 12:23

YABVU.

Longma · 18/03/2024 12:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Starseeking · 18/03/2024 12:22

I can't see anything in your OP which suggests you should say no, unless there's a massive dripfeed coming.

Your DS looking up to someone older than him (Yr 10/11 vs Yr 12/13) doesn't sound like a big issue to me, although for you to mention it, it must be to you. I'd reflect on why you think that is.

Also lots of people invite their DC friends on holiday with them and pay for it; for the holidaying family it means their DC has someone their age to spend time with and something to do, so are less likely to sit around whining that they're bored! I'd certainly do the same in future years, and wouldn't see the other DC as a charity case; this speaks to your insecurities, rather than being a reality.

NotGoingToLie · 18/03/2024 12:22

Gosh I think you’re perfectly reasonable to say no. The dynamic sounds a bit odd - two years apart is quite a lot in the teenage years. Also, I wouldn’t want to be without my only DC for two weeks at Easter - nothing unreasonable about that. Go with your gut OP.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 18/03/2024 12:21

Your son is not going as a charity case but to keep their son company so I would change your thinking there.

i would find it difficult to stand in the way of giving my son this opportunity and can understand of he feels resentful.

as long as you trust the family, I would let your son go.

holjam · 18/03/2024 12:20

Why would you say your son is a charity case? You sound like you have a chip on your shoulder to be honest.
This is an amazing opportunity for your son.

WotNoUserName · 18/03/2024 12:20

I went on holiday with my best friend and her family when I was 15. They paid for everything, I just had to take spending money. It was the first time I'd been on a plane.

It's one of my best memories, and she's still my best friend all these years later.

The age gap isn't weird to me, my son's best friend is 2 years younger than him - my DS is 16. Wtf is wrong with that? I'm quite sure his mum wouldn't have a problem with him coming away with us if I was to ask. Why do people think kids can only be friends with those in the same school year as them? Are all your friends the same age as you?

Bumply · 18/03/2024 12:19

Admittedly not abroad, but I've taken a friend of Ds1 on holiday with me and my boys.

I didn't ask any payment, just that the friend have spending money to buy treats/souvenirs.

I was certainly not treating him as a charity case. It was for selfish reasons if anything as it made my life easier to have Ds1 and his friend occupied with each other and me and ds2 (4 years younger and not into the same things) could chill out without the usual sibling rivalry.

Sweetheart7 · 18/03/2024 12:18

You are doing the right thing to think about this OP. Do you know the boys parents? You say both boys have been best friends for 1 year and attend the same school. What about prior how friendly were they?

It's no doubt a good opportunity but I don't believe in just accepting anything just because someone has offered you!.

I'm not sure what I would do it would depend if I knew the parents. 2 weeks is a long water. Water can be dangerous also... you just don't know. On the other hand it would be a shame for DS to miss out!

PerceptionIsReality · 18/03/2024 12:15

We used to regularly take friends on holiday when I was a teenager. I was an only child and because of that we had a bit more money, more space in the car, hotel rooms etc and my parents were also conscious of me being a bit lonely. We never considered our offer as charity and I don't think any of my friends or their parents did either. It's nice to have company - both for the kids and the parents and once you hit mid to late teens it gets harder to actually make friends on a brief holiday than it perhaps is for younger kids who can go to animation activities etc and are a bit less self conscious about chatting to new people.

Platedshoes · 18/03/2024 12:14

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 12:06

Yes, I do. He's a good influence: against smoking, drinking, drugs, studies hard, is active, etc. He also basically cured my son of a disordered eating problem he had (couldn't eat in public or among people he doesn't feel comfortable around). It's just that he's a way more proactive social participant than my son is; actually more proactive in general really. But to be fair that's probably why they're such good friends, their personalities don't clash; 2 headstrong people don't typically make a great duo.

Hmm. I might change my view. A socially accomplished 17 yo wanting to spend lots of time with a quiet and possibly vulnerable (the disordered eating?) younger teen does raise some warning bells.

Noshowlomo · 18/03/2024 12:13

Im not an only child but my sister is 16 years older than me and moved out when I was 4, so I was an only child in that respect. My friend came to Spain with us when we were 14 and I went to America for 2 weeks with my then best friend when I was 16. Both great, although we then weren’t as close afterwards, think 2 weeks was overkill, but a great holiday and all was fine and safe with both.

MissFizzyPop · 18/03/2024 12:13

I was in a similar situation last year - my teen was invited to Florida for 3 weeks with the family of best friend. They offered to pay for everything but I wasn't comfortable with that so I paid for her flight and gave the family some money for food etc plus spending money. Might be an option if that makes you feel more comfortable? My daughter had an amazing trip so it was worth it!

Capmagturk · 18/03/2024 12:12

I'd never ever forgive my parent for depriving me of such an amazing opportunity.

Hedgerow2 · 18/03/2024 12:10

Your 2 reasons for not letting him go -

  1. It's charity. This is ridiculous and inverted snobbery. If they weren't so well off would you let him go? You can repay their generosity by having the friend over to stay, taking him with you on days out etc.
  1. He's never been that far. So what? How far is acceptable? He's 15 fgs. One of my dcs went on a 3 week sports trip to New Zealand when he was 13.

You are being very very very unreasonable in denying your son this opportunity.

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 12:06

Feelinadequate23 · 18/03/2024 11:55

Hmm, surprised more people haven't picked up on the age gap here. Very unusual/strange for a 17 year old to want to be best friends with a 15 year old. Wonder if there's an alternative motive here? OP, do you like the boy?

Yes, I do. He's a good influence: against smoking, drinking, drugs, studies hard, is active, etc. He also basically cured my son of a disordered eating problem he had (couldn't eat in public or among people he doesn't feel comfortable around). It's just that he's a way more proactive social participant than my son is; actually more proactive in general really. But to be fair that's probably why they're such good friends, their personalities don't clash; 2 headstrong people don't typically make a great duo.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread