Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not letting my son go on holiday abroad with his best friend and his family?

482 replies

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 11:28

My son (turning 15 in the summer) and this boy have been best friends for almost a year now. I'm talking two peas in a pod best friends. They're in the same school, but the bestie is 2 years older. They hang out and chat every single day. In my opinion, they have a bit of a weird dynamic because my son sees / treats him like a mentor, and the best friend is the one who takes the lead; but that's beside the point.

The best friend is rich. He's going with his family to the Seychelles (2 weeks) for Easter. Surprisingly, he invited my son (who thought he was just joking at first). Either way, the boy's parents contacted me and we met up to talk. They basically told me that they'll pay for everything (accommodation, flights, food, activities, souvenirs, etc.), and they'd love to have my son come along with them. They said that I don't have to worry about safety and such because the boys are well behaved, and they're eagle-eyed. I said I need some time to think it though.

My husband thinks it's a great opportunity since we obviously couldn't afford such a trip, plus the family has a great reputation. I'm not so sure though. Firstly, I feel uncomfortable at the thought of my son becoming a charity case. Secondly, the Seychelles is very far away, and my son has never travelled that far before. My son is very upset with the no answer, and my husband also believes I'm being unreasonable and weird about this.

I still have some time to change my mind though. I do have some doubts about my decision honestly.

OP posts:
RoberttPostesChild · 18/03/2024 13:12

The age gap is irrelevant, if this was an abuse situation it wouldn't make any difference if the boys were the same age.

For the family offering the holiday, it's clearly not a big deal, it's just a nice thing to do. If you have no issues with them as parents and with the boy, why make one?

There are risks in everything but if there is nothing ringing alarms bells, could you live with having refused that lovely opportunity to your DS?
He must be on tenterhooks waiting for your verdict. All very silly.

SlightlyJaded · 18/03/2024 13:12

Let him go OP

It's a chance that won't come again and there doesn't feel to be a real reason to say 'no'.

It's ok - and right - that you should question it. But you've done that and met the parents. It's passed the red flag test I think OP

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 18/03/2024 13:09

As a parent of an only child, l would always try and invite a friend along to keep her company. They would probably see it as an investment taking your son. I would let my dd go if l knew the parents were decent people - it sounds like they are.

BetsyBobbin · 18/03/2024 13:08

Hang on a minute OP, you say he cured your son of an eating disorder? What is he now, a psychiatrist?

This is getting weirder by the minute. Two years is like ten years apart when you're teenagers; the "weird dynamic" (your words, not mine); the whole "this boy is brilliant in every way, no drugs or drinking", and now he apparently "cures" your son of an eating disorder? This is such an odd situation.

People who are saying "Oh yes, send him, yabu!", are only thinking of a holiday in Seychelles and seriously missing some of the points made by the OP herself. I wouldn't send my DS. Parenting is making responsible decisions that may cause your DC to momentarily dislike you but you have to look at the bigger picture here. The people going "Whoo, free holiday!" are being really not intelligent or perceptive about the situation.

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 13:07

tiredandabitfat · 18/03/2024 12:58

From the description of the dynamic I thought you were concerned that they may be romantically involved? And concerned about the dynamic / age difference?

Now that you've mentioned the literature class, maybe the above isn't correct?

If they are both East Asian, are there many East Asian students at the school? If not, I guess that explains why they have formed a bond.

If you trust the parents, and he's a nice boy, hopefully it will all be fine. My concern would be them falling out, but hopefully they will have enough space and be mature enough to just do their own thing and cool off if they find themselves annoying each other.

No, they're both White. It's a club for people who enjoy reading East Asian literature (translated). They read and discuss different books together.

OP posts:
Londonrach1 · 18/03/2024 13:06

Let him go. Can't understand your no reason. The family probably glad their son has a friend who can entertain him whilst away on holiday.

Winnipeggy · 18/03/2024 13:05

I can't see any reason why you wouldn't let him go and if I was your son I'd be fuming.

moonfacer · 18/03/2024 13:04

I’ve been to the Seychelles, it’s very safe and sleepy. A 15yo will be fine.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 18/03/2024 13:03

Imagine not letting him go because of your own strange assumptions about how this family see you. If he was my kid I'd already have his case packed!

Starseeking · 18/03/2024 13:03

Annime · 18/03/2024 12:40

I think you are being reasonable for worrying about distance. If I were in the same place, my concern would be more about the adults rather than the children. And it might be a stretch, but I would worry about my child being abused by his friend or his friend's family.

Personally, I don't think 2 years is a long enough time to quell these worries/concerns.

If they were the same age, I wouldn't worry too much, but the 2 Yr age gap and the fact that the older boy is the leader would concern me. What if my child is coerced into doing something he wouldn't normally do just because he doesn't want to rock the boat? Or just to simply seem grateful for the holiday?

I wouldn't do it.

Bloody hell, I've heard all the reaches now ConfusedBlush

A 15 year old boy is going to be treated to a holiday with a friend AND his parents for 2 weeks, it's not 2 years locked in a sex dungeon!

Even the OP has said that the 17 year old is a decent chap, and has positively influenced her DS; what's not to like?!? Resentment of the family's wealth compared to your own (OP's) is not a valid reason for him not to go.

Yellowbananasarebetterthangreen · 18/03/2024 13:01

I dont get why some people commenting think a two year age gap is weird - it is if your mindset is totally school related. But in the real world no one bats an eye at an age gap. Amongst adults but also with kids. Eg in a home ed context, church social group, dance class, football club etc its totally normal to have friends (including best friends) who are two or three years younger or older.

TakeOnFlea · 18/03/2024 12:58

Wow. Let him go!

tiredandabitfat · 18/03/2024 12:58

From the description of the dynamic I thought you were concerned that they may be romantically involved? And concerned about the dynamic / age difference?

Now that you've mentioned the literature class, maybe the above isn't correct?

If they are both East Asian, are there many East Asian students at the school? If not, I guess that explains why they have formed a bond.

If you trust the parents, and he's a nice boy, hopefully it will all be fine. My concern would be them falling out, but hopefully they will have enough space and be mature enough to just do their own thing and cool off if they find themselves annoying each other.

RhiWrites · 18/03/2024 12:57

Imagine if your son had a friend whose parents were very badly off. You plan a short break to the Lake District and can easily afford to bring the friend, he’d be company for your son, the cost is negligible to you and you’d like to include the boy because he’s pleasant to be around.

That’s basically what this family are doing, just at a higher price bracket. The cost is nothing to them. It’s not charity, it’s planning something that their own son would enjoy.

I think you’re being quite proud about it, because you couldn’t afford the trip your son shouldn’t go. I think there’s some resentment here. Please don’t stand in his way. It’s such a nice thing that’s been offered by a friend you say has been great to him.

BeaLola · 18/03/2024 12:48

I haven't read the whole thread - I'm in the other position sort of in that my DS 16 (only child) has asked if we would take his best friend with us on holiday this year (not Seychelles think Villa in Portugal) as otherwise he would rather stay home and chill with his mates - DH and I discussed it and thought tbf we can afford to pay for his flight and food etc - they've been friends 2-3 years so we said yes if ok with his mum - she said yes (thankfully) - I really hope she didn't think we were asking as a charity case , to groom him or any of the other strange notions on here

TheAvidPlumRobin · 18/03/2024 12:45

RaininSummer · 18/03/2024 12:43

I would let him go. I understand your reservations as if it was a week in skegness etc you wouldn't hesitate I assume. However they are obviously well off enough to do this and must really like your son to offer. Send him with some spending money for activities and tell him to treat the family to icecreams etc a couple of times.

Yeah, this is what I thought as well. If he goes we'll give him some pocket money.

OP posts:
Misthios · 18/03/2024 12:44

@Feelinadequate23 according to @Annime that's not it at all, it's all a plot by the parents AND the son to groom and abuse his friend.

Jeezo. How do people live with such paranoia. And as for "it's SO FAR" - 10 hour flight. It'd take you that to drive to Cornwall from Scotland easily. Or to get a coach to Dover, over the channel by ferry, coach to somewhere in western Europe.

StarDolphins · 18/03/2024 12:43

I 100% would let him go. I would be over the moon happy if my DD got this opportunity. Not the point but he will always remember you taking away this opportunity!

XelaM · 18/03/2024 12:43

Durdledore · 18/03/2024 12:42

He sounds a lovely boy from your description, with great parents.

Let him go - it’s a total no-brainer.

This!!!!

Just let him go.

RaininSummer · 18/03/2024 12:43

I would let him go. I understand your reservations as if it was a week in skegness etc you wouldn't hesitate I assume. However they are obviously well off enough to do this and must really like your son to offer. Send him with some spending money for activities and tell him to treat the family to icecreams etc a couple of times.

gannett · 18/03/2024 12:42

And it might be a stretch, but I would worry about my child being abused by his friend or his friend's family.

Oh my GOD now even the friend's parents are suspected of being potential abusers. Unhinged.

Durdledore · 18/03/2024 12:42

He sounds a lovely boy from your description, with great parents.

Let him go - it’s a total no-brainer.

Hannahoo · 18/03/2024 12:42

My DS has struck up an amazing 2 peas in a pod friendship with someone 2 years difference in age, they met through both sets of parents knowing one another and realised they get on incredibly. I dont see the issue if they've formed a genuine friendship. Not everything has to be about something sinister.

Feelinadequate23 · 18/03/2024 12:41

gannett · 18/03/2024 12:30

There truly is nothing positive that someone on this site can't turn into a negative. This sounds like a great friendship, one that goes beyond their relative social skills. But I suppose many people on MN don't really have much experience of friendships.

This thread feels like the one about the OP who didn't want grandparents to pay for her daughter's gap year in Colombia. Just this suffocating, anxiety-fuelled need to keep their children's worlds as tiny as possible. It's awful parenting.

Like... in this case what is the worst that will happen? OP feels a bit patronised (even though nothing suggests the friend's parents intend it like this)? The friendship doesn't last? It's a bit awkward in some indefinable way? All of that pales in comparison to the potential (and likelier) benefits.

the "worst that could happen" could be that the friend sees this as more than a friendship and pressures DS to do things he doesn't want to. DS feels he can't say no as he's trapped on the other side of the world with someone else's family, who have paid for him to be there. Far too much pressure for a 15 year old. But only the OP would know if this feels likely, based on her interactions with the boy.

gannett · 18/03/2024 12:41

NotGoingToLie · 18/03/2024 12:33

I’ve oodles of friends and many years of parenting experience. The OP has concerns for many valid reasons. I am very firmly in the ‘don’t let him go’ camp but clearly in the minority. I can’t get past the two year age gap here. It is not a common occurrence. Two years is a lot in these teenage years. Tread cautiously.

The age gap is negligible. Maturity levels in teenagers are all over the place so it's not something you can impose a one-size-fits-all guideline on anyway. And what do you specifically think the danger will be, anyway?

At my school friendships between older kids in different years was perfectly normal. Most of us got to know each other through extracurricular activities etc. By sixth form I don't think anyone socialised exclusively in their year group.

Swipe left for the next trending thread