Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been angry at this question from a stranger

138 replies

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 18/03/2024 09:34

Was in a shop buying shoes with youngest child when a random lady came over and said how pretty dd was and what lovely shoes she had chosen. She then said “Is she your only child? To which I said no actually we have six children. She asked what age and I said she was the youngest at 7 and the oldest child is now 30. The lady then said “Oh my you have been busy. Do they all have the same father?”
Was aibu to think this was a bloody rude question to ask a total stranger? (The answer is yes they do all have the same father).

OP posts:
Hadjab · 18/03/2024 13:10

I had similar from an ex-manager's wife. We went out to dinner, she was sitting between me and another (female) colleague. She asked colleague how many kids she had. She responded "four." She then asked me how many I had, to which I replied "three." She then asks me if mine all had the same dad.

I'm pretty sure there was an element of unconscious bias at best, and out and out racism at worst, as she didn't ask my white colleague if the kids all had the same father...

CactusMactus · 18/03/2024 13:07

I talk shit when I am nervous and have said the most cringeworthy things to people.
I apologies on her behalf... I doubt very much her intention was to be a dick.

Reugny · 18/03/2024 13:05

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 12:53

This woman might be on the autistic spectrum. Neuro-typical people will have all sorts of thoughts (like, 'I wonder if this woman has had more than one relationship to have seven children') but will have learned about social filters. Often, people on the spectrum will learn by observing how NT behave so they can fit in/mask, however you like to view it. But they must continually be aware of what the rules for mimicking are - it won't be a naturally inherent mode for them. Occasionally, especially in social situations that are stressful, these 'rude' comments/questions can be blurted out.
I would assume that to have been the case in your situation @Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 and it's probably best to laugh it off.

Gosh there are loads and loads of ND people around due to the number of people who report such incidents.

More likely there are loads of nosey people around who are puzzled when people don't fit into their biases.

(Should add I've had crap about my daughter from such idiots.)

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 12:58

Justleaveitblankthen · 18/03/2024 10:03

These threads are useful for when these rude people inevitably come across our own paths.

I would have a stock passive aggressive answer:
Smile sweetly, "Ah bless you! Have you always had no filter or has it just come about as you hit the menopause/aged?"

Yes it's judgy, but it's matching like with like.

Referencing the menopause in this way is not only misogynistic, it also displays your level of ignorance about the menopause. I would re-think your technique to avoid being thought of as a bigot.

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 12:53

This woman might be on the autistic spectrum. Neuro-typical people will have all sorts of thoughts (like, 'I wonder if this woman has had more than one relationship to have seven children') but will have learned about social filters. Often, people on the spectrum will learn by observing how NT behave so they can fit in/mask, however you like to view it. But they must continually be aware of what the rules for mimicking are - it won't be a naturally inherent mode for them. Occasionally, especially in social situations that are stressful, these 'rude' comments/questions can be blurted out.
I would assume that to have been the case in your situation @Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 and it's probably best to laugh it off.

SherrieElmer · 18/03/2024 12:43

Yes, bloody rude from this person. Don't waste too much time thinking about it. Some people are just cunts.

MrsClatterbuck · 18/03/2024 12:24

SpaDaysAreMyFave · 18/03/2024 11:30

Yes, all different fathers, from different countries. I’ve been in a world tour.

😂😂😂

Bumply · 18/03/2024 12:22

My sister has six kids and used to be asked "are you catholic?"
My sister would respond that she'd have had twice as many if she were, but hers were all planned at 2-3 years apart.

Showing an interest is one thing. Making assumptions is quite another

RhubarbGingerJam · 18/03/2024 12:22

It is rude.

With three it people said they assumed childminder - though our three could not look more a like - never sure how to respond and why they felt necessary to inform me of it.

Rudest was when I ended up doing house selling tour of our last house- did I mean to have three children. It was a large family house - 3 bed but we were moving on to a 4 and the shared bed room was quite large. They were also miffed I wouldn't let their one child steal one of my DC toys and leave the house with it.

DSD9472 · 18/03/2024 12:11

'I go to lots of orgies, so the kids could be anyones! In fact, I'm not even sure if I'm the mother of half of them 🤔!'

This thread has given me some quick replies to use, so thank you. I get this all the time, but from a childless perspective. A random walked past my house and asked where all the kids were? Are they inside somewhere then??? She was adamant she'd seen a push chair the week prior- she hadn't! Unknown to her, I'd had my 3rd MC a week prior, so I was a bit taken aback.

Mairzydotes · 18/03/2024 12:00

And when there's a large age gap , they ask if the youngest was a surprise.

MikeRafone · 18/03/2024 11:56

The chap looked appalled and said “Does he know?”

why did he think your dh was a bit thick and wouldn't have noticed the bump?

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 18/03/2024 11:56

No idea, waiting on DNA results (you nosey impertinent cow).

EveryKneeShallBow · 18/03/2024 11:52

When I was pregnant with my first I worked at one office and my husband worked at another office of the same company. A chap I didn’t know well came to our office and was chatting to my manager, and commented on my obvious condition. Manager said yes, it’s (dh name’s). The chap looked appalled and said “Does he know?”

VesperLind · 18/03/2024 11:52

I used to get asked similarly rude questions about my DSs when they were little. Big age gap, DS2 is a flaming ginger. Always questions about their paternity from strangers. Very very rude.

MikeRafone · 18/03/2024 11:51

Where you were brought up was it not considered rude to ask such impertinent questions?

pizzaHeart · 18/03/2024 11:49

She was very rude.
To be honest I think even her question about age was inappropriate. What this to do with her?
We can offer a lot of sarcastic answers to that ( e.g I don’t know. Yes, we do love sex etc) but the point is that people shouldn’t be so rude.
By the way I have one child and she is disabled so I usually receive a different set of questions but it’s so annoying.

MadDogMama · 18/03/2024 11:48

It is rude. I have one DD8, and she is an only child by choice.
I was once told, by a colleague, that I am being unfair to her for not giving her a sibling.

whatsitcalledwhen · 18/03/2024 11:48

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 18/03/2024 11:32

A bit torn. Obviously some are jumping to conclusions that she meant that there have been a lot of different dads but she might not have meant that. Being as there are a quite a few she might have thought 2 separate dads and by extension some were step-kids? It could be innocent. Otherwise if not, obviously that's rude.

But why does she need to know? It's absolutely none of her business. And especially rude to ask this in front of a child.

CaramelMac · 18/03/2024 11:48

I really hate it when people come up to me and start telling me how pretty my children are, like that’s some kind of achievement?! And then they keep asking questions, I just smile and walk away or ignore them, I’m not interested in chatting to strangers or giving out my personal information.

The worst was when a foreign tourist grabbed my 2 year old and started touching her face and talking in another language to her, it really shook dd up she kept saying ‘my face, my face’ for days afterwards.

krustykittens · 18/03/2024 11:42

"I'm a tantric sex instructor so their dads could be anyone of my clients. It's just a side effect of the job, really." That should shut her up.

I once had a twat of a colleague congratulate me on my pregnancy and then ask me if my husband was the father. He was shocked at my fury (hormonal, very tetchy, not that that I need to explain myself in the face of such rudeness) and said it was just 'bants'.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 18/03/2024 11:37

What a cheek to say that to you OP.
Way back, I was standing in a group at a wedding. Unknown Rando asked me if I had children, if it was it a difficult birth etc in a persistent way which got more and more uncomfortable and personal. Looking back, I think it must have been his party piece. Disgusting Creep.

Bluescissorsbluepen · 18/03/2024 11:35

First time I met my now friend I was politely saying omg because her daughter was at uni and I’d thought my friend was in her 20’s, we had kids in the same nursery. Anyway she straight away blurted out that she had 5 and they all had the same father but they had the first very young. I was a bit ok, over share I was just being polite about how young you look. But over the years it’s because she knows what’s coming which is horrible. Her oldest used to get crap when they were out as a family assuming she was the mother of the youngest - which is weird too when they were just shopping or whatever.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 18/03/2024 11:34

Another thought that that amount of kids by the same dad is rare these days and actually nice to see! My dad was one of 8 but you don't get it much these days so she was probably genuinely interested!

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 18/03/2024 11:34

Rude and weird. Why does she need to know that information about a complete stranger?