Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been angry at this question from a stranger

138 replies

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 18/03/2024 09:34

Was in a shop buying shoes with youngest child when a random lady came over and said how pretty dd was and what lovely shoes she had chosen. She then said “Is she your only child? To which I said no actually we have six children. She asked what age and I said she was the youngest at 7 and the oldest child is now 30. The lady then said “Oh my you have been busy. Do they all have the same father?”
Was aibu to think this was a bloody rude question to ask a total stranger? (The answer is yes they do all have the same father).

OP posts:
LyricalGangsta · 18/03/2024 16:12

I have 4 and was always asked the same thing -
Yes they all have the same father
Yes we had tv
Hmm

Adhdorlazy · 18/03/2024 16:10

A friend of mine had loads of people asking if her first pregnancy was ‘planned’ !!

can’t believe people asked that!

Devonshiregal · 18/03/2024 16:08

TeabySea · 18/03/2024 10:04

And you don't think the bit about the father is rude/intrusive/unnecessary?

I can make conversation with strangers without asking highly personal questions.

But so many people have kids by more than one person. Is it offensive to be thought of as one of these people? Surely it would be rude, also, to assume the kids all had the same dad as that’s making that “default” option.

also the woman was asking because the woman had such a significant age difference across her children - it is an obvious question to wonder about. It’s not like the op had two kids 6 and 3 and she asked whether they had different dads…because that wouldn’t be the first question that crosses your mind. But yes with a huge age gap people are trying to get a sense of how that came to be.

Was it her business? No. Is it an offensive question? if you’re insulted by the idea of being a person with more than one father to your children maybe.

Reugny · 18/03/2024 16:05

InSpainTheRain · 18/03/2024 14:50

I think that was very rude, and I'd have told her so. It's no business of hers anyway. When I had twins a common question was "oh, are they natural". Initially I didn't know that people meant "did we have IVF". I used to reply "Yeah, we just fucked and they happened".

I had my DD when I was 42. I was asked the same question but I knew what people meant. My response was my mum had me at the same age. If the person was a medical professional they then had to spell it out.

To be fair two of the politest conversations I had with people about being pregnant was one of my opticians and my dentist at the time. My optician's wife was around the same age when she had their child, and my dentist was deciding whether to have a child herself in her 40s. My dentist did so sadly for me she is no longer my dentist.

In regards to twins as there are many twins in my family the normal way to approach it is to ask if twins run in the family. Even then it doesn't mean you will get told they are IVF as it is no-ones business. Also funnily the couples who I do know did have IVF aren't generally asked due to people's biases over who normally has IVF.

InSpainTheRain · 18/03/2024 14:50

I think that was very rude, and I'd have told her so. It's no business of hers anyway. When I had twins a common question was "oh, are they natural". Initially I didn't know that people meant "did we have IVF". I used to reply "Yeah, we just fucked and they happened".

fatphalange · 18/03/2024 14:35

How bizarre! My children have different fathers but I've sadly never been asked. I'd love to know how the conversation follows from that 😂

RainingCatsandfrogs · 18/03/2024 14:31

I would have said "Possibly, not sure."

KAT0779 · 18/03/2024 14:31

So fucking rude! What difference would it make to her anyway especially as a stranger. When I was pregnant I was asked "was it planned or a surprise" by someone new at work whose name I didn't even know so basically a stranger. Maybe some people just don't think before they speak or are that nosey that they don't care how rude their question is!

Peonyrosemary · 18/03/2024 14:30

swiveleyedconspiracyloon · 18/03/2024 14:05

mm, see, I did not think so, it was me who wanted to be sterilised, I was done having babies, my body, my choice, not sure who the father was should have a bearing. what if they had all had different dads?🤔

I agree your body, your choice ...but there's no harm a medical professional taking the time to make sure you had thought through your decision fully. That would include thinking about any implications the decision had for your current relationship and it's stability. Getting sterilised isn't usually a decision one parther makes on their own?

ASighMadeOfStone · 18/03/2024 14:28

@Justleaveitblankthen

Why do you think the rude woman was over the age of menopause? The OP didn't mention her age.

DrJoanAllenby · 18/03/2024 14:28

'They all have the same father except for one, but you'll have to ask your husband about that one!' Wink.

INeedToClingToSomething · 18/03/2024 14:22

Some people don't have any filter. Unless she says it with a tone or came across as judgy then I would try not to take offence.

WigglyVonWaggly · 18/03/2024 14:17

I’d answer ‘That’s a very personal question to ask someone you don’t know’ And that would be that. What a nosey question to ask!

TealPoet · 18/03/2024 14:11

Yes it was rude! Whether she meant to be/knew she was being rude is another matter and we can’t know. But as a pp said, that’s not curiosity or making conversation, that’s nosey and really inappropriate.

swiveleyedconspiracyloon · 18/03/2024 14:05

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 13:26

A perfectly reasonable question in that context.

mm, see, I did not think so, it was me who wanted to be sterilised, I was done having babies, my body, my choice, not sure who the father was should have a bearing. what if they had all had different dads?🤔

RoberttPostesChild · 18/03/2024 14:05

This is very rude. For some reason some people think it's ok to ask this question if more than 2 DCs and/or large age gaps between them. I just say 'I'm not sure, who knows?'🤔

Reugny · 18/03/2024 14:01

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 13:23

ND is more common than we tend to assume.

There are lots of women in their forties+ who are ND who would have been diagnosed had they been born later.

Stop digging.

My DP, a couple of my neighbours and a few other people we know are ND. (And yes some of them are women.) They never asked these sort of questions when we first met them.

In fact I've been asked inappropriate and inquisitive questions by ND teens but even they have seen and talked to me more than once before they do so.

Topseyt123 · 18/03/2024 13:47

Well, perhaps she did think that she was just making conversation, but that doesn't make what she said OK or any less rude.

It was very rude. I'd have been tempted to say so.

Sunnytomorrow · 18/03/2024 13:33

I do understand why you felt aggrieved but personally I’d give the lady the benefit of the doubt and move on.

There are a bunch of scenarios that don’t involve intentional rudeness:

  • It may have been just curiosity on the lady’s part rather than intentional rudeness (ie she may have simply found you wonderful and fascinating)!
  • Perhaps she was trying (misguidedly) to show you that she was ‘modern’ and had an open attitude to mixed families? After all, if she’s old then she’s probably seen a lot of changing attitudes over the decades.
  • Perhaps she or her daughter has a blended family herself and wondered (incorrectly, as it turned out) if you were the same?
  • Perhaps the lady spends a lot of time on her own and was desperate for a chat but rusty at conversation?
  • Maybe her family tend to be more outspoken about stuff like that and she doesn’t realise it’s not the done thing.
  • Maybe she’s just a klutz and blurts out things but means no harm by it.

It can be tempting to assume someone was trying to be rude but generally I’ve learned (at a cost!) that if someone says something that could be taken a number of ways, it’s nearly always better to assume they meant the nicer or neutral meaning. The bonus is that this approach completely de-arms the power of passive-aggressive or rude people to ruin your day!

Iwant2beJessicaFletcher · 18/03/2024 13:30

Ive got 3DC (big gap between 2 & 3) and get this question all the time. When I was telling people, especially at work, I was pregnant so many asked if it was an accident. People are so rude but Im used to it now.

Now we're back at the school gates with DC3, when his friends parent find out we've got adult kids, the questions start again.

I often feel like having a sign that says 'yes all DC have the same parents & no, DC3 was NOT an accident'.

Microdisney · 18/03/2024 13:26

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 13:23

ND is more common than we tend to assume.

There are lots of women in their forties+ who are ND who would have been diagnosed had they been born later.

Not on Mn. Every rude person is immediately armchair diagnosed.

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 13:26

swiveleyedconspiracyloon · 18/03/2024 11:26

I got asked this after I had just given birth to my 3rd baby by the MIDWIFE, we were discussing contraception and I wanted to be sterilised and she asked if the kids were all "his" (DH)🙄

A perfectly reasonable question in that context.

Pirelli · 18/03/2024 13:23

ND is more common than we tend to assume.

There are lots of women in their forties+ who are ND who would have been diagnosed had they been born later.

Sharontheodopolodous · 18/03/2024 13:18

I remember years ago,my father reeeaaallllllyyy wanted to go and see jurassic Park

He hadn't been to a cinema in years and he felt it would be a bit odd to go on his own,so looked round and remembered he had 4 kids of his own

We where rounded up and word soon got out in our close knit street that we where going

So of course other kids where asking if they could come too-to which mums and my dad said yes-we made up a group of about 15 kids

Off we went,watched it and we where all trailing out,when a bloke saw us-'mate!are they all yours?'

My dry witted father-'nah,I found that one,and that one,those two-maybe even that one in the local car park and asked if they wanted to come to the cinema with me-i bribed them with sweets'

The poor bloke just backed off slowly

I have been asked if mine have the same father,did I own a TV and have I never heard of condoms?

I find a dark stare and silence worked-they soon backed up

Fucking rude-although the time my (then 17 year old) dd took her siblings to the shop to buy me a mothers day present,and was stopped and then poked in the chest by a an older lady who told her 'it's fucking disgusting-having so many kids at your age'

Dd told her that 'its fucking disgusting that your judging me for being with my brothers and sisters and not my own kids as I don't have any-keep your nasty beak out!' (I wish I was that blunt)

I used to see that woman out and about and she avoided me for years

Peonyrosemary · 18/03/2024 13:17

swiveleyedconspiracyloon · 18/03/2024 11:26

I got asked this after I had just given birth to my 3rd baby by the MIDWIFE, we were discussing contraception and I wanted to be sterilised and she asked if the kids were all "his" (DH)🙄

I don't know about this one.
Extremely rude in general, but might be relevant in a medical setting where the talk was about contraception?