Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been angry at this question from a stranger

138 replies

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 18/03/2024 09:34

Was in a shop buying shoes with youngest child when a random lady came over and said how pretty dd was and what lovely shoes she had chosen. She then said “Is she your only child? To which I said no actually we have six children. She asked what age and I said she was the youngest at 7 and the oldest child is now 30. The lady then said “Oh my you have been busy. Do they all have the same father?”
Was aibu to think this was a bloody rude question to ask a total stranger? (The answer is yes they do all have the same father).

OP posts:
betterangels · 18/03/2024 19:15

BeaRF75 · 18/03/2024 10:08

Actually, the first question was rude, let alone the subsequent ones and I don't know why OP answered. I would just not have engaged at all.

Same. Why engage with random personal questions? Especially if you find them rude.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 18/03/2024 19:12

I know it's a "rude" question, but somehow, I just don't think I would have been offended, or angry if asked this. She sounds a bit lonely.

dottiedodah · 18/03/2024 19:02

I think some people just dont have a filter TBH.Its well cheeky .

NotQuiteNorma · 18/03/2024 18:39

ThePunchBowl · 18/03/2024 09:49

She was just making conversation.

Wanting to know of the OP has multiple children with different men is not just making conversation.

whatsitcalledwhen · 18/03/2024 18:36

@Devonshiregal

I would not ask someone this and agree it feels intrusive. But objectively it shouldn’t be maybe? If you think about it, if it isn’t a ‘problem’, why would it matter? Iyswim

... because it's intrusive.

That's objectively reason enough not to ask 🤷🏻‍♀️

I'm adopted. I attach no negative feelings to being adopted. I still found it rude and annoying as a child when people who knew I was adopted would say to my mum (in front of me) 'ooh she still looks like you though, doesn't she!' not because I have negative feelings about being adopted but because it feels uncomfortable when people overstep boundaries and say intrusive, inappropriate things.

Bigsigh24 · 18/03/2024 18:30

Of course it’s bloody rude !

TeabySea · 18/03/2024 18:17

Devonshiregal · 18/03/2024 17:55

I would not ask someone this and agree it feels intrusive. But objectively it shouldn’t be maybe? If you think about it, if it isn’t a ‘problem’, why would it matter? Iyswim

It's a "problem" because it's a complete stranger. It's a "problem" because it's a personal question.

I wouldn't go up to someone in the street who was carrying a bag of shopping and start asking them what they were having for their tea, who was coming to tea, and how old they were.
I wouldn't go up to someone with a baby and ask them if it was a boy or a girl and then ask if they were still with the other parent.
I wouldn't go up to someone randomly and ask them what brand of toothpaste or sanitary towels they used.
All personal questions.

I'd happily talk to someone about their coat, or the weather, or what was on TV last night, or that patch of flowers over there, or any one of a hundred other things that are a perfectly easy conversation topic with a stranger.

Devonshiregal · 18/03/2024 17:55

whatsitcalledwhen · 18/03/2024 17:02

@Devonshiregal

But so many people have kids by more than one person. Is it offensive to be thought of as one of these people? Surely it would be rude, also, to assume the kids all had the same dad as that’s making that “default” option.

She didn't say it was offensive.

She said it was 'rude / intrusive / unnecessary'.

Do you not think it was rude, intrusive and unnecessary to ask a complete stranger who fathered their children? Let alone in front of the children?

I would not ask someone this and agree it feels intrusive. But objectively it shouldn’t be maybe? If you think about it, if it isn’t a ‘problem’, why would it matter? Iyswim

brightyellowflower · 18/03/2024 17:21

I wouldn't have given so much detail to her in the first place -! Is she your only child? No she's got siblings.

That's it.

I probably would think wow if I had the info that one 'child' was 30 and another 7. Maybe she had ADHD and literally couldn't help herself asking!! Don't be so quick to give out information that's against the norm and then you might not get rude questions by people blurting shit out!

EightChapters · 18/03/2024 17:08

Yes, it was very rude but it doesn't sound like she meant it to be - just has poor social skills and boundaries. Probably pisses off several people a day...

I wouldn't have given her all the information you did as the warning signs were there before she even asked you that question.

whatsitcalledwhen · 18/03/2024 17:02

@Devonshiregal

But so many people have kids by more than one person. Is it offensive to be thought of as one of these people? Surely it would be rude, also, to assume the kids all had the same dad as that’s making that “default” option.

She didn't say it was offensive.

She said it was 'rude / intrusive / unnecessary'.

Do you not think it was rude, intrusive and unnecessary to ask a complete stranger who fathered their children? Let alone in front of the children?

Smokeysgirl · 18/03/2024 17:02

It's just downright rude to ask such a personal question to a stranger (or anyone)!

TeabySea · 18/03/2024 16:58

Devonshiregal · 18/03/2024 16:08

But so many people have kids by more than one person. Is it offensive to be thought of as one of these people? Surely it would be rude, also, to assume the kids all had the same dad as that’s making that “default” option.

also the woman was asking because the woman had such a significant age difference across her children - it is an obvious question to wonder about. It’s not like the op had two kids 6 and 3 and she asked whether they had different dads…because that wouldn’t be the first question that crosses your mind. But yes with a huge age gap people are trying to get a sense of how that came to be.

Was it her business? No. Is it an offensive question? if you’re insulted by the idea of being a person with more than one father to your children maybe.

I wasn't suggesting it was offensive. I said it was intrusive.
I didn't suggest that the person might be curious about OP's other children. I have a friend who has a significant age gap between her children. When I was getting to know her I didn't ask her whether they had the same father. That's up to her to tell me if she wants to.

I also didn't suggest that the question was insulting.

I suggested that it was not a complete stranger's business. On a first encounter with anyone, in any situation it is unnecessary to ask. Even if curiosity is burning within you.

I maintain that it's perfectly easy to make conversation or small talk without delving into personal questions. I've managed perfectly well to do so for my entire life.

Generally what I do when I'm out and about is mind my own business other than to perhaps tell someone that I like their shoes/hair that their child is behaving beautifully, etc.

YouOKHun · 18/03/2024 16:56

No they’ve all got different fathers; I’m working my way through the Household Cavalry.

I also like @Dearg’s “no, all different Dads, Fathers’ Day is a logistical nightmare”.

I wouldn’t assume some neuro divergence but I wouldn’t feel the need to be aggressive to the woman in case she meant no harm and just didn’t think. She may be crass, nosey, judgy or deliberately rude. Retorting with “are you menopausal” as suggested upthread is shitty. A bit of deadpan humour wouldn’t go amiss, it’s not attacking her but it will shut the conversation down as others have said.

But I am both ND and menopausal so obviously can’t be relied upon to conduct myself properly.

Growlybear83 · 18/03/2024 16:35

Yes it was an odd thing to say and maybe a bit rude, but does it really matter?

RhubarbGingerJam · 18/03/2024 16:32

Adhdorlazy · 18/03/2024 16:10

A friend of mine had loads of people asking if her first pregnancy was ‘planned’ !!

can’t believe people asked that!

I was asked that so often I think I got immune to that one.

Better than MIL who as we hadn't announced tying to family assumed they were all accidents and told people this. DH got fed up of being ribbed by mates and got very blunt in end.

Still DH cousin announced trying as due to medical complications IVF was needed - they had people shouting across roads asking if his wife was pg yet.

WitsEnd10 · 18/03/2024 16:28

Reugny · 18/03/2024 09:47

Next time give an answer that will embarrass her.

Most people in the UK don't like answers that involve death so say "No the older kids father died by a toilet exploding" or some such nonsense.

This. I like to say things that make people regret the rude questions they ask. When I fell pregnant with DS2 when DD was under a year old I was asked frequently if it was planned/did we plan to have them so close together. I just said “no, we usually do it up the bum but one night DH slipped and here we are”. That soon shut them up.

Allfur · 18/03/2024 16:27

It is kinda funny, I'd ask the same of a bloke

Patrickiscrazy · 18/03/2024 16:27

It's laughable, not sure which part 😂🙄

Smokeysgirl · 18/03/2024 16:19

We adopted our ds aged nearly 4. We lived in a small village and, obviously, I couldn't just suddenly pass him off as my own but the amount of people who openly asked why couldn't I have kids "of my own" and whose "fault" was it, mine or dh's? was astonishing. Some (nosy buggers) even asked me what his background was, in a fake sympathetic voice, as if I was about to spill the beans on all his highly confidential early trauma to them!

Allfur · 18/03/2024 16:19

I've been asked that loads, not massively bothered to be honest, and I ask it myself

Viviennemary · 18/03/2024 16:17

That was extremely cheeky. She crossed the line.

Boredandstressed · 18/03/2024 16:17

People ask me this ALL the time I used to get annoyed but still feel like I had to answer and justify it ???? Now I’m older I just say ‘no all different ! I’m a cock connoisseur!’

rooftopbird · 18/03/2024 16:16

I'd have honestly burst out laughing in an assumption she was a bit nutty!

This is where this comes into play.

To have been angry at this question from a stranger
CookieCrumbles23 · 18/03/2024 16:14

Yep, completely rude. I have a mixed heritage and my family all have different skin tones. Have often been asked if we are related, have the same Dad.. adopted??

I don’t really know where people expect the conversation to go. It’s just nosy and ignorant.