Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I thought I was pro-choice, is this judgey?

342 replies

Calmondeck · 18/03/2024 09:23

I always thought I was pro-choice. I know the difficulties that can come with pregnancy, I understand the complexities of becoming a parent. And yet I suddenly find myself frustrated at a woman I know for choosing not to follow-through with her pregnancy. Does that mean deep down I am not pro-choice?

In a nutshell, I am friends with the male partner in a couple together for 1.5yrs. They’ve been having sex without contraception but avoiding her fertile window. Several weeks ago, had sex in the fertile window, discussed whether or not to use the morning after pill, (apparently) mutual decision not to. Now early days pregnant. The woman reached out to me asking to meet for a chat “on all things birth and motherhood”. I told her I’m probably not the best person to speak to since my review of motherhood is somewhat clouded by spending half of my toddler’s life in hospital as he undergoes aggressive chemotherapy for infant cancer.

We met anyway. The first thing she said was “I’m getting cold feet, we decided to throw caution to the wind, I’m 35 so thought it’s unlikely the first time ever I have sex in a fertile window I would get pregnant, but now that I am, I was excited, and now I’m suddenly scared. I follow all of the midwives on Instagram even though I wasn’t actively planning to become pregnant, I just think becoming a mother is fascinating”.

I was sympathetic and honest about all of the pros and cons from my tiny experience.

My friend, the dad-to-be, is shocked but genuinely excited.

The pregnant woman has decided today that she will get an abortion. And suddenly I feel deeply sad for this growing little person. And frustrated that the mum said “I had my year and travels planned. I’ll try again in 2 years”.

OP posts:
ancienticecream · 18/03/2024 14:20

So sometimes, abortion is SAVING the baby from a life of pain and misery
There's saving a baby from a life of pain and misery, and there's almost-parents who do everything right to conceive a child and then think naaah, I'll have a baby after I've been on holiday.

Noseybookworm · 18/03/2024 14:20

It's hard not to be judgey when you don't agree with someone's reasons to terminate. But you can still support the principle that it's a woman's right to choose, regardless of her reasons.

Ohhbaby · 18/03/2024 14:20

britneyisfree · 18/03/2024 14:17

I've recently had a good friend do it pretty much this. Literally held a ceremony saying goodbye to the baby see you in a year or two. Dad was on board etc she'd been planning how things would be but decided 'nah'.

But it won't be the same baby??

Ohhbaby · 18/03/2024 14:19

I think it is because they are using abortion as a contraception method. It is one thing to have an abortion because of rape or if you are 17 and its was unintended. But this woman is 35 and didn't want to take all the necessary precautions because there is an easy out - Abortion. I totally hear you, It's like someone said 'being pro choice doesn't mean you have to like the reasoning.

britneyisfree · 18/03/2024 14:17

Sharptonguedwoman · 18/03/2024 09:25

Oh dear. What a mess. I am absolutely pro-choice but this attitude seems cold. I'll return this baby and look again in a couple of years.

I've recently had a good friend do it pretty much this. Literally held a ceremony saying goodbye to the baby see you in a year or two. Dad was on board etc she'd been planning how things would be but decided 'nah'.

willWillSmithsmith · 18/03/2024 14:08

I am pro choice but that doesn't mean I agree with every reason to have one, but I will always believe in the right to choose. I knew someone once who had one because it interfered with their already booked holiday. She was married so it wasn’t a one night stand etc and it just didn’t sit right with me - none of my business of course but I can’t deny it put me off her (she wasn’t a friend just a colleague).

GelatoPistacchio · 18/03/2024 13:56

Wishing your family all the best OP 💐

I agree with most on here that it is judgy but also natural to judge.

Here is how I would frame it as a pro-choice person: even if I think her reason isn't sound, would I want her or any other woman to die from a back-street abortion? No I wouldn't. For me, it is being pro-choice in totality or face condemning women to this fate if we go further down the path of picking and choosing cases.

KateMiskin · 18/03/2024 13:54

Please do what you can for your own child, OP, and don't worry about this sorry pair. They should have most definitely not come to you. V insensitive. I'd make myself much less available.

Sashamalia · 18/03/2024 13:52

I don't think anyone is "happy" at the idea of abortion.
It is a terribly sad thing.

However the way I look at it, is abortion can be a good thing for the baby.

If the baby is going to be born to a mother that does not want it and is not able to look after it - then bringing that baby into the life is just going to hurt the mother AND the baby.

So sometimes, abortion is SAVING the baby from a life of pain and misery

Calmondeck · 18/03/2024 13:50

Thank you for all these thoughtful responses; they’ve helped me clarify my own thoughts/feelings. I do believe I’m pro-choice, and in this scenario I’m pro her choice of not becoming a parent. I don’t judge her on not wanting to shift her life so dramatically. I fully accept if you’re not ready to be a parent, and even if you feel totally ready, parenting is huge. I just wish she’d been more thoughtful earlier - and definitely not have involved me. I can’t help but question whether what I said about my experiences impacted her decision making. But as others have said, she may have a whole lot more going on than I know about.

I feel for my friend - he’s just called apologising for involving me, if only briefly. He’s gutted to not continue this journey, after several weeks of mentally traveling the path to parenthood.

How complex life is. Here I am, bedside at hospital again, subjecting an infant to more and more treatment to save life, worrying whether I’ve inadvertently influenced an almost stranger to prevent a life.

OP posts:
Rewis · 18/03/2024 13:48

To me being judgy (privately or somewhat privately) and being pro-choise is different.

Do you want to force her to carry the child to term? If no. Then you're pro-choise. Doesn't mean you have to be happy about her abortion.

Dontblameitonsunshine · 18/03/2024 13:46

Being pro choice or not is completely missing the point. This experience has challenged your dearly held beliefs and thankfully you have the honesty to think about this

MarkWithaC · 18/03/2024 13:41

Vistada · 18/03/2024 11:50

You don't get to feel the progressive smugness of being pro choice and then be "pro-choice only actually only in circumstances I on my moral high horse deem appropriate"

You're either pro choice or you're not.

You're not.

Nailed it.

tenoutof10 · 18/03/2024 13:29

Do I think she is unwise and short-sighted to terminate this pregnancy? Yes. Do I think she was very tactless to tell you about it in the way she did, given your circumstances? Yes.

Do I think she should be legally prohibited from making this decision? No, I don't.

Halfemptyhalfling · 18/03/2024 13:21

If she is selfish and insensitive currently then probably better she has an abortion. that is why choice is so important. There's too many humans on the planet so it's more humane not to have them (and better environmentally)

Of course she might be less fertile in two years time but that's her choice.

opentoadvice88 · 18/03/2024 13:20

It is judgey but you’re human & you’ve been pulled into this situation.

I’m very much pro choice (& I’ve had an abortion) and wouldn’t be thrilled for anyone having to choose an abortion but I’m very glad they can access one if they choose to.

Fairyliz · 18/03/2024 13:20

Foxesandsquirrels · 18/03/2024 09:48

Whatever my thoughts on this may be, I think it's extremely insensitive for this "friend" to have this conversation with you, bearing in my your situation.

Yes I agree. If she is this self obsessed probably better she doesn’t become a mother.

bonzaitree · 18/03/2024 13:17

I think your instinct was Bob on. You weren’t in a place to have that chat

trust your gut next time!

BabbleBee · 18/03/2024 13:14

Having been a parent of a child with cancer, I think you should be kind to yourself and not worry if, in this instance, you have been judgey or not. How you’re supposed to have rational thinking over a subject like termination while you are watching your own child fight for life I’m not sure. I think they were insensitive to not listen to your concerns about being a shoulder to cry on in the first place.

Majorsmiler · 18/03/2024 13:09

Hi op, not read all the responses but as her friend,id want her to realise it’s not as easy as getting a chance again in two years.This may be her only chance.
She is not in her 20sin fact edging towards her 40s. Many of us on this board post 30s struggled and have had ivf or losses. She is very naive in this respect. It needs to be carefully thought about to avoid a mistake and regret. An educated decision about fertility post 35

Mnk711 · 18/03/2024 13:04

As a parent/want to be parent I think you know more realistically what a pregnancy is (I know everyone does academically but until you've given birth I think it's easier to be a bit more theoretical about it all). I think you can still be pro-choice but feel sad about someone's decision. Exactly as you can support a friend who makes a choice to go back to an abusive husband whilst also being sad about it. Having a seriously unwell child is also obviously going to make you value life even more.

KateMiskin · 18/03/2024 13:04

Zaxi · 18/03/2024 13:02

thats enough internet for me today

Fucking hell "learning disabled daughter was raped in her sheltered home and they said if she was to get pregnant they would raise the child. And they did, with as much love as they gave to their other nine kids."

Indeed. Just horrifying.

Zaxi · 18/03/2024 13:02

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 18/03/2024 11:31

You respect someone who made their disabled child give birth after being raped?

thats enough internet for me today

Fucking hell "learning disabled daughter was raped in her sheltered home and they said if she was to get pregnant they would raise the child. And they did, with as much love as they gave to their other nine kids."

NortieTortie · 18/03/2024 12:55

Sorry haven't read the full thread but If she was in her fertile window the morning after pill prob wouldn't have worked anyway would it? I thought it just delays ovulation.

Anyway, I don't blame you for judging and I don't blame her for changing her mind. My children were very much wanted but I definitely had moments of 'shit, what have I done'.

If you still think she should be allowed the choice to go through with an abortion despite disagreeing/feeling sad for what could have been, I'd still consider you v much pro choice.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 12:55

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/03/2024 12:44

I think saying 'I'm pro choice, but..' is a slippery slope. Start putting conditions in place and those who look to restirict our rights have an edge to lean on.

Personally I don't think I could have an abortion now I've had a child, but before that I would have had one in a heartbeat if the situation had arose.

'I don't feel ready to bring a baby into the world' is a completely valid reason to have an abortion.

I think this is where I sit too. It's a slippery slope, and as soon as society starts applauding people for putting conditions on it, then it can potentially land itself in very hairy territory. And that's something women can just not afford to have happen.

Hence my advice was to disregard your own feeling about it and swiftly move on.